```json
{
 "case_id": "wealth-synthesis-01",
 "domain": "wealth",
 "conclusion": "supportive",
 "confidence": 0.75,
 "selected_option_ids": [],
 "factors": [
  {
   "claim": "Strong dhana yoga: Jupiter, lord of the 2nd, conjunct Saturn, lord of the 1st, in the 11th house of gains — a classic 2nd-lord + lagna-lord combination in the house of income.",
   "effect": "supporting",
   "evidence": ["/yogas/3", "/placements/Jupiter/house", "/placements/Saturn/house", "/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse", "/lagna/lordInHouse"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Jupiter is in Moolatrikona in Sagittarius and occupies its own 11th house, strengthening both the 11th (gains) and its 2nd-house ownership.",
   "effect": "supporting",
   "evidence": ["/placements/Jupiter/dignity", "/houses/10/sign"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Raja yoga: Venus rules both the 4th (kendra) and 9th (trikona) and sits in its own sign Libra in the 9th — a powerful Lakshmi-type placement for fortune and assets.",
   "effect": "supporting",
   "evidence": ["/yogas/1", "/placements/Venus/dignity", "/placements/Venus/house"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Additional raja yoga: Venus (4th lord) conjunct Mercury (5th lord) in the 9th supports wealth through education, intellect, speculation and property.",
   "effect": "supporting",
   "evidence": ["/yogas/0", "/placements/Mercury/house"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Mars (10th lord) aspects Saturn (1st lord), forming another raja yoga linking career/status with self-earned position.",
   "effect": "supporting",
   "evidence": ["/yogas/2", "/aspects/Mars"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Adhi Yoga from the Moon (benefics Jupiter, Venus, Mercury in 6th–8th from Moon) indicates prosperity and comfort per classical lunar combinations; Moon itself is exalted in the 4th (assets, home, vehicles).",
   "effect": "supporting",
   "evidence": ["/yogas/5", "/placements/Moon/dignity", "/placements/Moon/house"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "The 11th house (gains) is aspected by Mars and Rahu, adding drive but also volatility, competition and sudden fluctuations to income streams.",
   "effect": "mixed",
   "evidence": ["/houses/10/aspectedBy"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Sun (7th lord) sits in the 8th house aspected by Saturn and Mars: partnership/business income can be unstable or tied to others' resources, inheritance matters are significant.",
   "effect": "challenging",
   "evidence": ["/placements/Sun/house", "/houses/7/aspectedBy"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Current Mercury mahadasha (2018–2035): Mercury is a 5th/8th lord placed in the 9th within the Venus–Mercury raja yoga — dasha lord participates directly in wealth yogas, favorably activating them.",
   "effect": "supporting",
   "evidence": ["/dasha/current/mahadasha", "/placements/Mercury/house", "/yogas/0"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Upcoming Mercury–Saturn antardasha (2032–2035) activates the Jupiter–Saturn dhana yoga again via the 11th house, though Saturn's neutral dignity tempers the pace.",
   "effect": "mixed",
   "evidence": ["/dasha/upcoming/3", "/placements/Saturn/dignity"]
  }
 ],
 "contradictions": [],
 "missing_information": [
  "Exact birth-time rectification confidence (lagna at only 0°19' Aquarius makes house cusps timing-sensitive)",
  "Specific periods for major financial decisions/events to correlate against dasha timeline"
 ],
 "rationale": "The chart carries multiple independent wealth combinations: a direct dhana yoga (Jupiter+Saturn in the 11th with Jupiter in Moolatrikona owning the 2nd and 11th), two raja yogas centered on Venus in own sign in the 9th, and Adhi Yoga from an exalted Moon. The long-running Mercury mahadasha places a participant of the Venus–Mercury yoga in charge until 2035. Offsetting factors are modest: 8th-house Sun as 7th lord complicates partnership income, and malefic aspects on the gains house add volatility, but these qualify rather than negate the overall supportive picture."
}
```


Explanation: The House1LordInHouse11 rule treats the ascendant lord's placement in the 11th house (house of gains) as favorable for income and gains; it does not guarantee enormous profits nor indicate financial loss, so B and C are incorrect.


Dhana Yoga: 11th lord Sun conjunct 9th lord Mercury in the lagna — a strong wealth combination linking gains and fortune to self-effort

Mercury is vargottama, reinforcing the Dhana yoga's durability

Budha-Aditya yoga in the 1st supports intelligence and earning capacity, though Mercury's combustion tempers it

Raja Yoga from Saturn ruling both 4th (kendra) and 5th (trikona); Saturn sits in the 2nd house of accumulated wealth — yogakaraka in the wealth house

Saturn in the 2nd is in an enemy sign (Scorpio) and conjunct debilitated Rahu with Ketu aspecting — savings and family wealth face obstruction, volatility, and shared-resource complications

Lagna lord Venus debilitated in the 12th — but forms Vipareeta Raja Yoga (8th lord in 12th), suggesting gains through adversity, foreign lands, or hidden sources; still, the dispositor of wealth is weak at birth

Jupiter in the 11th house of gains (friendly Leo), aspected by Mars/Saturn but well placed for income and fulfilment of desires; Jupiter also aspects the 5th (speculation)

Current Rahu mahadasha until mid-2026: Rahu is debilitated natally and placed in the 2nd house with Saturn, indicating financial turbulence during this long period; Rahu–Mars antardasha (Mars rules the 7th/2nd lord) keeps pressure on money matters

Jupiter mahadasha begins 2026-07-31; Jupiter is a benefic placed in the 11th house of gains, promising a materially better phase

Exact D1/D9 strength calculations (shadbala) for Venus and Saturn to weigh the Vipareeta yoga against debilitation

Second-house navamsa confirmation of wealth durability

Explanation: The chart carries genuine Dhana and Raja yogas (11th+9th lords in lagna, vargottama Mercury, yogakaraka Saturn in the 2nd) pointing to real wealth capacity. These are offset by a debilitated lagna lord in the 12th, Saturn-Rahu affliction of the 2nd house, and a currently running debilitated-Rahu dasha. The mixed verdict reflects strong underlying potential currently under pressure, with the Jupiter mahadasha starting July 2026 indicating improvement.


```json
{
  "case_id": "wealth-synthesis-02",
  "domain": "wealth",
  "conclusion": "mixed",
  "confidence": 0.7,
  "selected_option_ids": [],
  "factors": [
    {
      "claim": "Dhana yoga: Sun (11th lord of gains) conjunct Mercury (9th lord of fortune) in the lagna — a classic wealth combination, strengthened by Mercury being vargottama.",
      "effect": "supporting",
      "evidence": ["/yogas/2", "/placements/Sun/house", "/placements/Mercury/house", "/vargottama"]
    },
    {
      "claim": "Budha-Aditya yoga in house 1 supports intelligence and earning capacity through self-effort, though Mercury's combustion tempers the result.",
      "effect": "mixed",
      "evidence": ["/yogas/0", "/placements/Mercury/combust"]
    },
    {
      "claim": "Saturn forms a Raja yoga as single lord of kendra (4th) and trikona (5th), placed in the 2nd house of accumulated wealth — wealth via property/assets, but Saturn is in enemy sign Scorpio with debilitated Rahu, indicating slow, obstructed accumulation.",
      "effect": "mixed",
      "evidence": ["/yogas/1", "/placements/Saturn/house", "/placements/Saturn/dignity", "/placements/Rahu/house", "/placements/Rahu/dignity"]
    },
    {
      "claim": "Vipareeta Raja Yoga: Venus, lord of the 8th (sudden events, inheritance), sits in the 12th — potential gains through inheritance or others' resources arising from loss/isolation contexts.",
      "effect": "supporting",
      "evidence": ["/yogas/3", "/placements/Venus/house", "/placements/Venus/dignity"]
    },
    {
      "claim": "Lagna lord Venus debilitated in Virgo in the 12th house: weakened vitality of self-directed wealth; expenses, foreign connections, or isolation drain resources.",
      "effect": "challenging",
      "evidence": ["/lagna/lordInHouse", "/placements/Venus/dignity", "/placements/Venus/house"]
    },
    {
      "claim": "Jupiter in the 11th house of gains (friend's sign) supports income streams and fulfilment of desires, though at the very end of Leo (29°54') — late-degree, and it receives aspects from Mars and Saturn.",
      "effect": "supporting",
      "evidence": ["/placements/Jupiter/house", "/placements/Jupiter/formatted", "/houses/10/aspectedBy"]
    },
    {
      "claim": "2nd lord Mars placed in the 5th house links wealth to speculation/intelligence/creativity; Mars also aspects the 11th and 12th houses — gains mixed with expenditure.",
      "effect": "mixed",
      "evidence": ["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse", "/placements/Mars/house", "/aspects/Mars"]
    },
    {
      "claim": "Current dasha: Rahu–Mars–Saturn (Rahu MD until 2026-07-31). Rahu is debilitated in the 2nd house of wealth with Saturn — financial pressure, volatility, and unexpected obligations during this closing phase of Rahu mahadasha.",
      "effect": "challenging",
      "evidence": ["/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord", "/dasha/current/antardasha/lord", "/dasha/current/pratyantardasha/lord", "/placements/Rahu/house"]
    },
    {
      "claim": "Upcoming Jupiter mahadasha from 2026-07-31: Jupiter is a benefic placed in the 11th house of gains and aspects the 5th house — an improvement in income and accumulation outlook relative to Rahu MD.",
      "effect": "supporting",
      "evidence": ["/dasha/upcoming/0", "/placements/Jupiter/house", "/aspects/Jupiter"]
    }
  ],
  "contradictions": [
    {
      "statement_id": "S1",
      "error_type": "overclaim",
      "correction": "The dhana and Budha-Aditya yogas should not be read as unqualified wealth: Mercury is combust (/placements/Mercury/combust) and the dispositor chain runs through a debilitated lagna lord, so results manifest with delay and leakage rather than straightforward affluence.",
      "evidence": ["/yogas/0", "/placements/Mercury/combust", "/lagna/lordInHouse"]
    }
  ],
  "missing_information": [
    "Exact birth-time rectification confidence (whole-sign houses sensitive to time)",
    "Ashtakavarga bindus for 2nd and 11th houses to grade wealth quantum",
    "Specific life events/financial history for verification"
  ],
  "rationale": "The natal promise of wealth is real but conditional: dhana yoga (Sun+Mercury in lagna), Saturn's kendra-trikona raja yoga landing in the 2nd house, and Jupiter in the 11th give genuine capacity for gains and asset-building. These are counterweighted by a debilitated lagna lord in the 12th (expenditure, leakage), combust Mercury, and a heavy Saturn-Rahu conjunction in the 2nd house making accumulation slow and subject to disruption. The present Rahu–Mars–Saturn period (through mid-2026) is the weakest stretch; the incoming Jupiter mahadasha from July 2026, with Jupiter natally in the 11th aspecting the 5th, indicates a materially improved financial phase thereafter. Overall verdict: mixed — solid long-term wealth structure with significant frictions and timing-dependent outcomes."
}
```


```json
{
  "case_id": "wealth-synthesis-03",
  "domain": "wealth",
  "conclusion": "mixed",
  "confidence": 0.7,
  "selected_option_ids": [],
  "factors": [
    {
      "claim": "Second lord Saturn is exalted in Libra in the 10th house, forming Sasa Yoga — a strong indicator of status-linked wealth through career.",
      "effect": "supporting",
      "evidence": ["/placements/Saturn/dignity", "/placements/Saturn/house", "/yogas"]
    },
    {
      "claim": "Venus rules both the 10th (kendra) and 5th (trikona), a single-lordship Raja Yoga pointing to gains via profession and purva punya.",
      "effect": "supporting",
      "evidence": ["/yogas", "/houses/9", "/houses/4"]
    },
    {
      "claim": "Jupiter as 12th lord placed in the 6th forms Vipareeta Raja Yoga; it also aspects the 2nd and 10th houses, lending protective support to finances.",
      "effect": "supporting",
      "evidence": ["/yogas", "/placements/Jupiter/house", "/aspects/Jupiter"]
    },
    {
      "claim": "Adhi Yoga from the Moon (benefics in 6th/7th/8th from Moon) supports overall prosperity.",
      "effect": "supporting",
      "evidence": ["/yogas"]
    },
    {
      "claim": "Mercury, karaka of commerce and accounts, sits in the 2nd house but is retrograde and combust, weakening the wealth-house occupant.",
      "effect": "challenging",
      "evidence": ["/placements/Mercury/house", "/placements/Mercury/combust", "/placements/Mercury/retrograde"]
    },
    {
      "claim": "Venus, the Raja-yoga lord, occupies the 12th with Rahu, indicating expenditure, foreign links, and leakage alongside earning potential.",
      "effect": "challenging",
      "evidence": ["/placements/Venus/house", "/placements/Rahu/house", "/houses/11/significations"]
    },
    {
      "claim": "Current period is Rahu–Venus (to Dec 2026) with pratyantardasha Saturn: Rahu amplifies, but its dispositor Venus sits in the 12th with Rahu natal, so financial flows are amplified in both directions.",
      "effect": "mixed",
      "evidence": ["/dasha/current", "/placements/Venus/house", "/placements/Rahu/house"]
    }
  ],
  "contradictions": [],
  "missing_information": [
    "No specific option set was provided to select from",
    "Navamsa dignity of the 2nd/11th lords beyond sign placements already given (Saturn and Jupiter share D9 11th house — noted, but no explicit varga-strength judgment supplied)",
    "Question specifics (e.g., investment timing vs. income growth) are not stated"
  ],
  "rationale": "The chart carries genuinely strong wealth-supportive architecture: an exalted second lord in the kendra of career (Sasa Yoga, /placements/Saturn/house, /placements/Saturn/dignity), a Venus Raja Yoga linking 5th and 10th, Vipareeta Raja Yoga via Jupiter, and Adhi Yoga from the Moon. Against this stand real weaknesses: combust-retrograde Mercury occupying the 2nd itself, and the Raja-yoga lord Venus placed in the 12th with Rahu, which doctrine reads as expenditure and dissipation tempering gains. The current Rahu–Venus mahadasha–antardasha activates both sides at once. The represented evidence supports 'mixed' rather than a forced positive or negative verdict; no doctrinal basis exists here to guarantee financial outcomes."
}
```


Sasa Yoga: Saturn exalted in Libra in the 10th (a kendra) — a strong Mahapurusha yoga supporting career status and earned wealth through profession.

Raja Yoga from Venus ruling both the 10th (kendra) and 5th (trikona) — a wealth-and-status combination, though Venus itself sits in the 12th, weakening delivery of its results.

Vipareeta Raja Yoga: Jupiter as 12th lord placed in the 6th — gains arising after difficulty or through others' losses/debt resolution; classically supportive under adversity.

Adhi Yoga from the Moon (benefics in 6/7/8 from Moon) — comfort and prosperity indications.

The 2nd house of accumulated wealth holds Mercury retrograde and combust, with lord Saturn in the 10th — savings fluctuate and depend heavily on career; combust retrograde Mercury suggests irregularity in speech/financial dealings.

11th house of gains is empty with Mars as its lord in the 3rd — gains come through self-effort and initiative rather than passive income; no strong affliction but no amplification either.

12th house contains Venus (5th/10th lord) with Rahu — significant expenditure, foreign-land or speculative outflows tied to status-seeking; Venus in Mula nakshatra adds volatility.

Current Rahu mahadasha / Venus antardasha (2023-12 to 2026-12): Rahu sits in the natal 12th with Venus; this period emphasizes expenditure and foreign/unconventional financial channels, while Venus's yogakaraka-like lordship can still deliver career-linked gains.

Transiting Rahu conjuncts natal Mercury in the 2nd house (as of 2026-01-01), pressuring wealth accumulation, family finances, and speech-related contracts during the current period.

A reading of 'great wealth' cannot rest on Sasa or Adhi Yoga alone while ignoring the combust retrograde Mercury in the 2nd and Venus-Rahu in the 12th, which materially qualify accumulation.

Vipareeta Raja Yoga does not guarantee windfalls; it indicates rise through adverse circumstances, and Jupiter is also retrograde and in enemy sign, weakening the yoga.

Explanation: The chart shows genuine strength for career-derived status and prosperity (exalted Saturn Sasa Yoga in the 10th, Venus kendra-trikona Raja Yoga, Adhi Yoga from the Moon, Vipareeta Raja Yoga). However, direct accumulation is qualified: the 2nd house Mercury is retrograde and combust, the 11th is unoccupied, and the 5th/10th lord Venus sits in the 12th with Rahu — indicating high expenditure and leakage alongside earning power. The current Rahu-Venus period (through Dec 2026) mirrors this duality, with transiting Rahu on natal Mercury in the 2nd adding near-term pressure. Net indication: mixed — strong professional standing and gains-through-effort, but inconsistent savings and elevated expenses; no certain outcome should be stated.


```json
{
  "case_id": "wealth-synthesis-02",
  "domain": "wealth",
  "conclusion": "mixed",
  "confidence": 0.7,
  "selected_option_ids": [],
  "factors": [
    {
      "claim": "Strong Dhana Yoga: Sun (11th lord) conjunct Mercury (9th lord) in the 1st house links gains and fortune to self-effort, with Mercury vargottama strengthening the yoga.",
      "effect": "supporting",
      "evidence": ["/yogas/2", "/placements/Sun/house", "/placements/Mercury/house", "/vargottama"]
    },
    {
      "claim": "Budha-Aditya Yoga in the lagna supports intellect-driven earning, though Mercury's combustion tempers its expression.",
      "effect": "mixed",
      "evidence": ["/yogas/0", "/placements/Mercury/combust"]
    },
    {
      "claim": "Raja Yoga via Saturn ruling both 4th (kendra) and 5th (trikona); Saturn in the 2nd house of accumulated wealth can convert this into assets/savings, but Saturn is in enemy sign Scorpio and sits with debilitated Rahu, indicating gains through persistence with volatility and delays.",
      "effect": "mixed",
      "evidence": ["/yogas/1", "/placements/Saturn/house", "/placements/Saturn/dignity", "/placements/Rahu/house", "/placements/Rahu/dignity"]
    },
    {
      "claim": "2nd lord Mars in the 5th (trikona) aspected by Jupiter from the 11th connects earnings to intelligence/speculation and gives a dhana link between houses 2, 5, and 11.",
      "effect": "supporting",
      "evidence": ["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse", "/placements/Mars/house", "/aspects/Jupiter", "/placements/Jupiter/house"]
    },
    {
      "claim": "Vipareeta Raja Yoga: Venus, 8th lord, in the 12th — sudden/other people's money themes can turn favorable after disruption; Venus is debilitated, so results are modest and tied to expenditure/foreign/isolation matters.",
      "effect": "mixed",
      "evidence": ["/yogas/3", "/placements/Venus/house", "/placements/Venus/dignity"]
    },
    {
      "claim": "Lagna lord Venus in the 12th and debilitated weakens personal retention of resources; income tends to leak into expenses, foreign connections, or isolation-related costs.",
      "effect": "challenging",
      "evidence": ["/lagna/lordInHouse", "/placements/Venus/dignity", "/placements/Venus/house"]
    },
    {
      "claim": "Ketu debilitated in the 8th (Taurus, sign of Venus) with the 8th also aspected by Mars, Saturn, and Rahu indicates instability around inheritance/joint finances and sudden fluctuations in shared resources.",
      "effect": "challenging",
      "evidence": ["/placements/Ketu/sign", "/placements/Ketu/dignity", "/houses/7/aspectedBy"]
    },
    {
      "claim": "Current Rahu mahadasha (to 2026-07-31): Rahu is debilitated in the 2nd house of wealth, so this long period likely brought aggressive but unstable financial pursuits; Rahu–Mars antardasha (Mars = 2nd lord in 5th) keeps focus on earning through initiative/speculation.",
      "effect": "mixed",
      "evidence": ["/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord", "/placements/Rahu/dignity", "/placements/Rahu/house", "/dasha/current/antardasha"]
    },
    {
      "claim": "From 2026-07-31, Jupiter mahadasha begins; natal Jupiter is benefic in the 11th (gains), friend-sign dignity, aspecting the 5th where the 2nd lord sits — a materially more supportive period for income and fulfilment of desires, though Jupiter at ~29°54' Leo is at the very end of the sign (sandhi), weakening it somewhat.",
      "effect": "supporting",
      "evidence": ["/dasha/upcoming/0", "/placements/Jupiter/house", "/placements/Jupiter/dignity", "/placements/Jupiter/degreeInSign"]
    }
  ],
  "contradictions": [
    {
      "statement_id": "S1",
      "error_type": "omission",
      "correction": "The Dhana Yoga (Sun+Mercury in 1st) should not be read as unqualifiedly strong: Sun is debilitated in Libra and Mercury combust, so both participants of the yoga are compromised; the yoga operates with reduced force despite Mercury's vargottama status.",
      "evidence": ["/placements/Sun/dignity", "/placements/Mercury/combust", "/yogas/0", "/vargottama"]
    },
    {
      "statement_id": "S2",
      "error_type": "overclaim",
      "correction": "Saturn's Raja Yoga does not automatically mean wealth: Saturn is in an enemy sign in the 2nd alongside a debilitated Rahu, so the yoga manifests only after effort, delay, and with fluctuation.",
      "evidence": ["/placements/Saturn/dignity", "/placements/Rahu/dignity"]
    }
  ],
  "missing_information": [
    "Exact birth-time rectification confidence (affects lagna degree and house cusps under non-whole-sign systems)",
    "Divisional charts D2 (hora) for wealth-specific assessment",
    "Ashtakavarga bindus for the 2nd and 11th houses to quantify gain strength"
  ],
  "rationale": "The chart carries genuine wealth yogas — Dhana Yoga (9th + 11th lords in lagna), a kendra-trikona Raja Yoga through Saturn, and 2nd-lord-in-trikona with 11th-house Jupiter's aspect — but every participant is weakened: Sun debilitated, Mercury combust (though vargottama), Saturn in enemy sign with debilitated Rahu in the 2nd, and lagna lord Venus debilitated in the 12th. Net reading: capacity to earn through intellect and persistent effort, but chronic leakage of funds and volatility in savings and joint finances. The tail end of the Rahu mahadasha (Rahu debilitated in the 2nd) fits an unsettled financial phase; the incoming Jupiter mahadasha from mid-2026, with natal Jupiter dignified in the 11th aspecting the 2nd lord, indicates a more supportive earning cycle — with proportionate uncertainty, not certainty."
}
```


Saturn occupies the seventh house but rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh house; per the stated rule this is a challenging indication for marital happiness.

Saturn's exaltation in Libra (Sasa Yoga) mitigates the indication, so it remains an adverse marker rather than a deterministic outcome.

A single placement does not guarantee divorce; Saturn's exaltation in Libra in the 7th (Sasa Yoga) actually strengthens the significator of marriage.

The exception cannot apply when its condition (Saturn ruling the ascendant or seventh) is unmet — here Saturn rules houses 10 and 11 only.

Statement A is established by the rule and chart, so D is false.

Explanation: Chart facts show Saturn placed in house 7 (/placements/Saturn/house) with Libra as the 7th sign ruled by Venus (/houses/7/lord) and Aries ascendant ruled by Mars (/lagna/lordInHouse). Saturn rules Capricorn (10th) and Aquarius (11th) (/houses/10/lord, /houses/11/lord), i.e., neither the ascendant nor the seventh, so option A correctly states the challenging indication. B is a deterministic overclaim contradicted by Saturn's exaltation (Sasa Yoga), C misstates the rule's scope, hence D fails.


Sasa Yoga: exalted Saturn in the 10th (kendra) grants career-based authority and sustained earning power

The 2nd lord (Saturn) is placed in the 10th, linking accumulated wealth directly to profession

Raja Yoga from a single-lord Venus ruling both the 10th (kendra) and 5th (trikona)

Adhi Yoga — benefics in the 6th, 7th or 8th from the Moon — classically indicates prosperity

Vipareeta Raja Yoga: Jupiter as 12th lord in the 6th can convert losses/debt into gains after difficulty

Venus, the yoga-forming wealth lord, occupies the 12th house of loss/expenditure conjunct Rahu — earnings leak through expense, foreign/isolation matters, and unconventional channels

Mercury in the 2nd house is retrograde and combust, weakening the karaka of commerce and the 9th lord's fortune-signification in the house of accumulated resources

Current dasha is Rahu–Venus–Saturn (from 2025-11-09): Rahu sits with wealth-lord Venus in the 12th while Saturn is exalted in the 10th — gains through career are supported but expenditure runs high simultaneously

Transit Saturn aspects the natal 12th (where Venus-Rahu sit) from the 3rd house, adding pressure on expenses during this window

Adhi Yoga and Sasa Yoga indicate capacity for prosperity, not guaranteed wealth; the 12th-house Venus-Rahu placement materially qualifies any strong-wealth claim

Explanation: Strong career-linked wealth architecture (exalted 10th-house Saturn forming Sasa Yoga, 2nd lord in the 10th, Venus kendradi-pati Raja Yoga, Adhi Yoga) is offset by the wealth-yoga lord Venus sitting in the 12th with Rahu and a weakened combust-retrograde Mercury in the 2nd. The current Rahu–Venus–Saturn period activates both the gainful 10th and the loss-giving 12th at once. Net indication: solid earning capacity through profession with persistent leakage through expenditure — a genuinely mixed picture rather than a clean verdict.


Saturn occupies the seventh house (Libra), which signifies spouse and partnership.

For this Aries lagna, Saturn rules the 10th and 11th houses (Capricorn, Aquarius) — neither the ascendant nor the seventh.

Since Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh, no ownership exception applies; its placement in the seventh is treated as a challenging indication for marital happiness.

Mitigating context exists but does not negate the indication: Saturn is exalted in Libra forming Sasa Yoga, and Venus, lord of the seventh, sits in the lagna aspecting its own house.

No astrological placement 'guarantees' divorce. Saturn in the seventh is at most an indication of delay, seriousness, or friction in marriage, here softened by exaltation (Sasa Yoga).

This directly contradicts statement A's stated rule: the exception applies only when Saturn rules the ascendant or the seventh, which it does not here (/houses/9/lord, /houses/10/lord).

Explanation: The chart facts show Saturn placed in the seventh house (/placements/Saturn/house) while ruling Capricorn and Aquarius, i.e., the 10th and 11th, not the lagna or seventh (/houses/10/lord, /houses/11/lord). Under the stated rule, the ownership exception therefore does not apply, making option A correct as a challenging (not deterministic) indication. Option B is an overclaim no rule supports, and option C misstates the exception. Exaltation and Sasa Yoga plus the seventh lord Venus in the lagna provide mitigating support but do not change the polarity of the listed indications.


Saturn occupies the seventh house and is a functional neutral/malefic here ruling houses 10 and 11, not the ascendant or the seventh; by the stated rule this counts as a challenging indication for marital happiness.

However, Saturn is exalted in Libra forming Sasa Yoga in a kendra, which mitigates the harshness of the placement.

No astrological placement 'guarantees' divorce; Saturn exalted in the seventh (Sasa Yoga) can indicate delay, maturity, or stability in marriage rather than dissolution.

The exception does not apply when Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh; here Saturn rules the 10th and 11th (/houses/10/lord), so the challenging reading of A stands.

Explanation: Option A correctly states the rule: Saturn sits in house 7 (/placements/Saturn/house) while its lordships are Capricorn (10th) and Aquarius (11th) (/houses/10/lord), not Aries lagna or Libra seventh, so the challenging designation applies. Option B is an overclaim no rule supports, and option C misstates the exception's scope. The exaltation/Sasa Yoga is a mitigating factor but does not negate the listed indication.


Saturn occupies the seventh house (Libra) — a classic placement scrutinized for marital happiness.

Saturn rules Capricorn (10th) and Aquarius (11th), so it rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh; per rule A it is treated as a challenging indication for marriage.

Mitigating: Saturn is exalted in Libra and forms Sasa Yoga in a kendra, softening but not negating the challenge.

Seventh lord Venus placed in the ascendant with mutual aspect to the seventh supports the marriage significator.

Saturn in the seventh does not guarantee divorce; classical doctrine treats it as an affliction whose outcome depends on dignity, aspects, and dasha context.

The exception applies precisely when Saturn DOES rule the ascendant or seventh; here Saturn rules neither (/houses/9/lord = Saturn for 10th... i.e., lords of houses 1 and 7 are Mars and Venus), so no exception arises.

Explanation: Statement A matches the chart exactly: natal Saturn sits in house 7 (/placements/Saturn/house) while ruling houses 10 and 11, not the 1st or 7th, so the stated rule renders it a challenging indication. Statement B is an overclaim (exaltation and Sasa Yoga mitigate). Statement C misstates the exception's condition. The applicable listed statements are negative-polarity, so conclusion = challenging.


```json
{
 "case_id": "marriage-application-01-evidence-order",
 "domain": "marriage",
 "conclusion": "challenging",
 "confidence": 0.85,
 "selected_option_ids": ["A"],
 "factors": [
  {
   "claim": "Saturn occupies the seventh house of marriage",
   "effect": "neutral",
   "evidence": ["/placements/Saturn/house", "/houses/6"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh: lagna is Aries ruled by Mars, and the seventh is Libra ruled by Venus; Saturn rules houses 10-11",
   "effect": "neutral",
   "evidence": ["/lagna/lord", "/houses/6/lord", "/houses/9/lord", "/placements/Saturn/sign"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Therefore the exception for Saturn-as-lagna-or-seventh-lord does not apply, and Saturn's presence in the seventh stands as a challenging indication for marital happiness per statement A",
   "effect": "challenging",
   "evidence": ["/placements/Saturn/house"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Statement B (guarantees divorce) is an overclaim — no rule guarantees divorce; Saturn here is also exalted forming Sasa Yoga, a mitigating dignity",
   "effect": "supporting",
   "evidence": ["/placements/Saturn/dignity", "/yogas/1"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Statement C is factually wrong: the exception requires Saturn to rule the ascendant or seventh, which it does not here",
   "effect": "supporting",
   "evidence": ["/lagna/lord", "/houses/6/lord"]
  }
 ],
 "contradictions": [],
 "missing_information": [],
 "rationale": "The chart has Saturn in house 7 (/placements/Saturn/house), but its lordships are Capricorn (10) and Aquarius (11) (/houses/9/lord, /houses/10/lord) — not the Aries lagna or Libra seventh. So statement A's condition holds and Saturn-in-the-seventh is a challenging indication for marriage; B overclaims a guaranteed outcome (and ignores Saturn's exaltation/Sasa Yoga); C misstates the exception. Only A is applicable, giving a challenging polarity."
}
```


Saturn occupies the seventh house but rules neither the ascendant (Aries/Mars) nor the seventh (Libra/Venus) — its lordships are the 10th and 11th.

Under the stated rule, Saturn in the 7th without lordship of the 1st or 7th is a challenging indication for marital happiness; this matches option A.

The exception clause cannot apply here since Saturn does not rule the lagna or 7th, so option C fails on this chart.

Option B's guarantee of divorce is an overclaim no classical rule supports; Saturn is also dignified (exalted) forming Sasa Yoga in a kendra, which softens any reading.

No rule guarantees divorce from Saturn's presence in the 7th; indications are probabilistic, not deterministic.

The exception to Saturn-in-7th challenging marital happiness applies only when Saturn rules the ascendant or seventh; here it rules the 10th and 11th.

Explanation: Saturn sits in the natal 7th (/placements/Saturn/house) but lords the 10th and 11th houses (/houses/9/lord), not the 1st or 7th. Therefore statement A's rule fires: Saturn in the 7th without lordship of the ascendant or seventh is a challenging indication for marriage. Statement B overclaims certainty, and statement C misstates the exception's condition. Only A is applicable, so the conclusion takes its polarity: challenging. Note mitigating context (exalted Saturn, Sasa Yoga) that tempers but does not negate the listed rule.


7th lord Mercury placed in the 8th house separates the marriage karaka house from its lord, indicating turbulence, secrecy, or sudden disruptions in partnership

Mars sits in the 7th house in an enemy sign, giving Mangal-type friction, assertiveness and conflict potential with the spouse

Sun also occupies the 7th, and Ketu aspects the 7th house — ego dominance and detachment colouring the partnership

Venus (natural marriage karaka) is at the very end of Aries in the 5th, neutral in dignity and ruled by the afflicted Mars, so its capacity to bless marriage is diluted

Raja yoga between 1st lord Jupiter and 7th/10th lord Mercury (mutual aspect) links self and spouse houses, supporting a significant committed union

In D9, Venus is well-placed in Sagittarius in the 5th under Jupiter's dispositorship, strengthening inner marital harmony despite D1 afflictions

Jupiter transits the natal 7th conjunct natal Sun and Mars as of early 2026, activating the marriage house during Ketu–Mercury dasha (Mercury being the 7th lord)

Explanation: The 7th house carries both promise and strain: raja yogas connecting lagna lord Jupiter with 7th lord Mercury and a dignified D9 Venus support a real marriage prospect, while Sun+Mars occupancy of the 7th, the 7th lord's placement in the 8th, Ketu's aspect, and a weak-end Venus indicate conflict, delay or disruption. Overall indication is mixed rather than clearly supportive.

Mercury rules both the 7th (Gemini) and 10th; it is placed in the 8th house Cancer, not in the 7th.

Navamsa 7th house occupants and its lord's strength for fuller D9 assessment

Upapada lagna not provided in chart facts

Exact timing windows would require checking dasha-antardasha periods of Venus/Mercury via timeline tools

Explanation: Marriage indications are genuinely mixed. Supporting: Raja yogas linking 1st lord Jupiter with 7th lord Mercury (/yogas), a strong exalted Saturn aspecting structure, and D9 Venus in a friendly sign (/vargas/D9). Challenging: combust Mars and Sun in the 7th (/placements/Sun/house, /placements/Mars/house), 7th lord Mercury debilitated-context in the 8th (/placements/Mercury/house), Ketu's aspect on the 7th, and natal Moon debilitated in the 12th suggesting emotional withdrawal (/placements/Moon). Current Venus mahadasha beginning 2026-07-29 (/dasha/upcoming/0) is a plausible activation window given Venus's role as karaka, but its D1 weakness tempers expectations.


7th house is heavily occupied and afflicted: Sun (lord of 9) and combust Mars sit in Gemini in the 7th, with Mars in enemy sign and Ketu aspecting the house — classic indicators of friction, ego clashes, or a dominating/dynamic spouse dynamic.

7th lord Mercury is placed in the 8th house in an enemy sign — the karaka of partnership falls into a dusthana, suggesting delays, secrecy, turbulence, or transformation through marriage.

Venus, karaka of marriage and lagna nakshatra lord (Purva Ashadha), sits in the 5th with Rahu — romantic inclination and love-marriage potential, but Rahu's conjunction can bring unconventional choices or infatuation-driven decisions.

Raja yoga between Mercury (7th lord) and Jupiter (1st lord) by mutual aspect links self and partnership; Jupiter also aspects the 10th from the 2nd, lending eventual dignity to married life despite a rocky start.

Debilitated retrograde Jupiter (natural karaka of husband/wisdom) in the 2nd house of family weakens family harmony significations, though its retrogression and the single-lordship raja yoga (4th+1st lord) partially restore strength.

D9 lagna Leo with Moon and Mercury in D9 lagna shows emotional engagement with the partner; however Mars in D9 8th and Jupiter in D9 12th indicate inner strain around intimacy and shared resources.

Exact marriage timing cannot be fixed without checking dasha antardasha sequence against the client's actual marital history; no event dates are supplied.

Upapada lagna / Jaimini marriage factors are not present in the facts.

D9 navamsa dignity of individual grahas (exaltation/debilitation within D9) is not listed.

Explanation: Marriage indications are genuinely two-sided. The supporting side: a mutual-aspect raja yoga joining the 1st lord Jupiter and 7th lord Mercury ties personal identity to partnership constructively; Venus as marriage karaka is unafflicted by combustion in D1 and placed in the 5th (romance) though conjunct Rahu; the native's lagna nakshatra lord is Venus itself, making relationship themes central to life direction. The challenging side dominates structurally: the 7th holds Sun plus a combust, enemy-sign Mars and receives Ketu's aspect, pointing to conflict and heat in partnership; the 7th lord Mercury occupies the 8th (dusthana) in an enemy sign, indicating delay and turbulence; and the natural karaka of the spouse, Jupiter, is debilitated retrograde in the 2nd (family). The Vipareeta Raja Yoga (8th lord Moon in 12th) may convert some adversity into resilience after initial difficulty. Overall verdict: mixed — marriage is indicated and eventually stabilizing, but early friction, delays, or an unconventional path are strongly suggested. Timing would require correlating Venus/Jupiter/Rahu periods with biographical events.


7th lord Mercury is placed in the 8th house, a dusthana, weakening the significations of partnership and suggesting turbulence or secrecy in marriage

Mars sits in the 7th house with the Sun; Mars in the 7th is a classical mangal-dosha-type affliction and its enemy dignity plus combustion further strain marital harmony

Ketu aspects the 7th house, adding detachment or karmic distance to partnerships

A Raja Yoga forms between Mercury (lord of 7) and Jupiter (lagna lord) through mutual aspect, indicating that partnership can still elevate status despite the difficult placement

Jupiter, lagna lord and karaka of wisdom, aspects the 8th and via mutual aspect supports Mercury, offering protective grace to the 7th-lord axis

Venus, karaka of marriage, is a benefic placed in the 5th (a trikona) ruling 6 and 11, linking romance to gains, though at the very last degree of Aries (gandanta-like edge) and aspected by Saturn and Ketu's house

In D9, Venus is well placed in Sagittarius in the 5th from the Navamsa lagna, supporting inner strength of the marriage karaka

D9 lagna lord Sun sits in the D9 7th house in Saturn's sign, and Mars occupies the D9 8th — spouse-related matters carry weight but also friction

Current Ketu–Mercury dasha runs to mid-2026 with Venus mahadasha starting 2026-07-29; Venus as marriage karaka and 11th lord suggests relationship matters become more prominent after mid-2026

Explanation: The chart shows a genuinely mixed marriage picture: heavy affliction of the 7th house itself (Sun+Mars occupation, Ketu aspect, 7th lord in the 8th) is counterbalanced by Raja Yoga links between the 1st, 7th and 10th lords, a decently placed Venus, and reasonable Venus placement in D9. The upcoming Venus mahadasha (from July 2026) makes this domain more active. No death/medical predictions made; indications are probabilistic, not certain.


Explanation: The chart places Saturn in the eighth house (/placements/Saturn/house = 8), not the seventh. Statements A, B, and C all concern Saturn in the seventh, so none of them applies to this chart; D is correct. Conclusion polarity cannot be set from the listed statements since none is applicable.


7th house Gemini occupied by Sun and Mars; Mars is combust and in enemy sign — marital significators under pressure

Venus (karaka of marriage) placed in the 5th with Rahu, at 29°12' — late-degree placement and Rahu conjunction add instability to romance

Mercury, lord of the 7th, sits in the 8th — spouse-significator house lord in a dusthana

Raja Yoga: Mercury (lord of 7) mutually aspects Jupiter (lord of 1), giving partnership a dignified, supportive dimension

D9 lagna Leo with Moon and Mercury in D9 lagna; Venus strong in D9 (Sagittarius, dispositor Jupiter) supports inner strength of the marriage karaka

Ketu aspects the natal 7th house, adding detachment or karmic coloring to partnership

Current Ketu–Mercury dasha (until 2026-07-29): antardasha lord Mercury is the 7th lord but sits in the 8th — relationship matters activated through a dusthana lens

Transit Jupiter retrograde conjunct natal Sun and Mars in the natal 7th house (as of 2026-01-01), aspecting houses 4, 7, 8 — benefic activation of the marriage axis despite retrogression

Upcoming Venus mahadasha from 2026-07-29 (Venus–Venus first): Venus is the marriage karaka and 6th/11th lord placed in the 5th — a period that typically brings relationship developments, though Venus's Rahu conjunction colors it

Mars in the 7th is often read as Kuja/Mangal-type affliction, but its combustion and enemy dignity already limit it; it should not be treated as an outright denial of marriage, only as friction.

A synthesis must weigh the supporting D9 Venus and Mercury–Jupiter Raja Yoga against the challenging 7th-lord-in-8th; neither alone determines outcome.

Exact navamsa strength/bala calculations for Venus and Mercury beyond dignity shown

Whether the native is currently married or seeking marriage (context for timing interpretation)

Specific pratyantardasha-level timing within the upcoming Venus mahadasha for event windows

Explanation: The chart shows a genuinely mixed marriage picture. Challenging factors: Sun+combust Mars in the 7th, 7th lord Mercury in the 8th, Venus conjunct Rahu at a very late degree in Aries, and Ketu's aspect on the 7th — indicating friction, karmic coloring, and delays or intensity in partnership. Supporting factors: Mercury–Jupiter mutual-aspect Raja Yoga linking the 1st and 7th lords, Venus well-placed in D9 Sagittarius, transit Jupiter activating the natal 7th in early 2026, and the Venus mahadasha beginning July 2026 which should foreground relationship matters. Net reading: marriage/partnership themes are strongly activated around the Ketu→Venus dasha transition (mid-2026 onward), but the union carries inherent tension requiring conscious management; outcome quality depends on how the Venus periods unfold rather than being fixed as either clearly favorable or adverse.


Explanation: The chart places Saturn in the 8th house (/placements/Saturn/house), not the seventh. Statements A-C all concern Saturn in the seventh house, so none is applicable to this chart; D is correct.


```json
{
 "case_id": "marriage-synthesis-01-evidence-order",
 "domain": "marriage",
 "conclusion": "mixed",
 "confidence": 0.7,
 "selected_option_ids": [],
 "factors": [
  {
   "claim": "7th house is occupied by Sun and Mars, with Mars combust — a heated, ego-charged 7th house that strains partnership harmony.",
   "effect": "challenging",
   "evidence": ["/houses/6/occupants", "/placements/Mars/combust", "/placements/Mars/house", "/placements/Sun/house"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "7th lord Mercury sits in the 8th house and also rules the 10th — the marriage significator tied to dusthana themes of sudden change and transformation; Mercury in Cancer is also in enemy sign.",
   "effect": "challenging",
   "evidence": ["/placements/Mercury/house", "/placements/Mercury/dignity", "/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse", "/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Ketu aspects the 7th house, adding detachment or unconventional coloring to partnership.",
   "effect": "challenging",
   "evidence": ["/aspects/Ketu"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Venus (marriage karaka) placed in the 5th house of romance, though conjunct Rahu, which can amplify desire but add karmic/unusual elements to love matters.",
   "effect": "mixed",
   "evidence": ["/placements/Venus/house", "/placements/Rahu/sign", "/houses/4/occupants"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Raja yoga between Mercury (lord of 7) and Jupiter (lord of 1) via mutual aspect links self and spouse houses — a strong supporting factor for eventual committed partnership.",
   "effect": "supporting",
   "evidence": ["/yogas"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Navamsa lagna Leo with Moon there; Venus dignified in Sagittarius D9 5th house — inner strength of the Venus karaka is good despite natal 'Neutral' dignity; Sun in D9 7th repeats the solar emphasis on spouse.",
   "effect": "mixed",
   "evidence": ["/vargas/D9/placements", "/vargas/D9/lagnaSign"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Vipareeta Raja Yoga (Moon as 8th lord in 12th) offers resilience through crises but does not directly ease the 7th-house friction.",
   "effect": "neutral",
   "evidence": ["/yogas", "/placements/Moon/house"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Timing: current Ketu mahadasha (to 2026-07-29) is generally detachment-flavored; the incoming Venus mahadasha from mid-2026 (Venus–Venus to Nov 2029) activates the natural marriage karaka sitting in the romantic 5th — a favorable window for marriage or deepened partnership.",
   "effect": "supporting",
   "evidence": ["/dasha/current", "/dasha/upcoming"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Transits as of 2026-01-01: Jupiter transiting natal 7th (Gemini) conjunct natal Sun and Mars while aspecting natal 1st — benefic transit over the marriage house supports union attempts now; Saturn from Pisces (natal 4th) aspects houses 7 and 10, adding pressure/delay flavor.",
   "effect": "mixed",
   "evidence": ["tool:transits_at#transits/contacts/4/inNatalHouse", "/transits/contacts/6/aspectingNatalHouses"]
  }
 ],
 "contradictions": [
  {
   "statement_id": "S1",
   "error_type": "omission",
   "correction": "A reading focusing only on Sun+Mars in the 7th would conclude a difficult marriage outright; it must be reconciled with the Mercury–Jupiter raja yoga linking lords of 1 and 7, and the strong Venus antardasha window ahead, yielding a mixed rather than challenging conclusion.",
   "evidence": ["/yogas", "/dasha/upcoming"]
  }
 ],
 "missing_information": [
  "Exact birth-date confirmation of marital status/history to calibrate timing claims",
  "Navamsa 7th lord strength assessment beyond raw placements (not provided)",
  "Upapada lagna (Jaimini) not available in facts"
 ],
 "rationale": "The 7th house carries clear affliction: Sun and Mars occupy it (Mars combust), its lord Mercury sits in the 8th in an enemy sign, and Ketu aspects it — all pointing to friction, ego clashes, or delay in partnership. This is materially offset by (a) the mutual-aspect raja yoga between Mercury (7th lord) and Jupiter (lagna lord), (b) Venus the karaka well-placed in the 5th, and (c) dignity of Venus in D9. Timing favors movement once Venus mahadasha begins 2026-07-29, reinforced by Jupiter's transit through the natal 7th in early 2026. Net judgment: mixed — marriage/partnership indications are real and supported by dasha and yoga, but quality requires managing heat and instability inherent in the 7th house."
}
```


```json
{
 "case_id":"health-application-01-paraphrase",
 "domain":"health",
 "conclusion":"insufficient",
 "confidence":0.85,
 "selected_option_ids":["D"],
 "factors":[
  {
   "claim":"Second lord Venus is placed in the ninth house (Sagittarius), in neutral dignity",
   "effect":"neutral",
   "evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/sign","/placements/Venus/dignity"]
  },
  {
   "claim":"A single placement of the 2nd lord in the 9th does not, by itself, support a claim of early-life weak health improving later, nor uniformly poor health throughout life",
   "effect":"neutral",
   "evidence":["/placements/Venus/house"]
  },
  {
   "claim":"No chart rule diagnoses a specific illness; health indications would require assessment of lagna, its lord, 6th/8th houses and their occupants (e.g., /houses/8/occupants)",
   "effect":"neutral",
   "evidence":["/houses/6/significations","/houses/8/significations"]
  }
 ],
 "contradictions":[],
 "missing_information":[],
 "rationale":"Options A and B both assert health trajectories ('weaker early/better later' or 'uniformly poor throughout') supposedly flowing from the second lord's placement in the ninth. While the placement itself is factual — Venus is lord of house 2 and sits in house 9 (/placements/Venus/house) — no such time-differentiated or lifelong health rule follows from it as stated, so neither A nor B is established. Option C is doctrinally incorrect on principle: Jyotish placements indicate tendencies, not specific illness diagnoses, and this evaluation must not diagnose medical conditions. Therefore none of A–C holds, making D the only defensible selection."
}
```


The second lord is Venus in the ninth house, a trikona — this placement itself is generally considered auspicious and gives no inherent indication of uniformly poor health.

Statement A asserts an early-poor/later-better timeline for health, but no such temporal split is derivable from the placement /placements/Venus/house = 9 or from any stated doctrine in the chart facts.

Statement B's claim of uniformly poor health contradicts Venus being a natural benefic occupying a trikona (house 9), aspected by its own dispositor Jupiter (/aspects/Jupiter includes house 9).

Statement C claims diagnostic power for a specific illness; no classical rule of 'second lord in ninth' diagnoses named diseases, and the chart facts contain no such attribution.

A benefic second lord in a trikona cannot support a blanket reading of lifelong poor health.

House-placement rules indicate areas of life affected, not specific medical diagnoses.

The exact textual source and wording of the 'stated rule' linking second lord in the ninth to health timing, needed to validate option A

Birth-time rectification quality and any actual health history to corroborate any timing claim

Explanation: Venus (lord of 2) sits in house 9, a trikona, aspected by Jupiter — an ordinarily favorable configuration. Nothing in the chart facts establishes an early-vs-late deterioration/improvement pattern (A), a verdict of lifelong ill health (B, contradicted by the dignified benefic placement), or disease-diagnostic power (C). Without the source text of the rule itself, none of A–C can be confirmed from the computed evidence, so D applies.


7th house occupied by Sun and combust Mars — malefic occupation of the spouse bhava, Mars combustion weakens the karaka of marital drive and indicates friction/assertion issues in partnership

7th lord Mercury placed in the 8th (dusthana) — the karaka-of-spouse-house lord falls into a house of sudden events and transformation, indicating instability or delay themes in marriage

Ketu aspects the 7th house — nodal influence adds detachment or unconventional coloring to partnership

Raja Yoga between Mercury (lord 7 and 10) and Jupiter (lagna lord) by mutual aspect — a strong mitigating factor linking self and partnership, capable of elevating marriage once formed

Venus (natural karaka of marriage) in the 5th with Rahu, aspecting the 11th — romance-oriented placement with amplification/desire via Rahu; Venus aspects gains, supporting fulfillment of relationship desires but Rahu adds volatility

D9 shows Venus in the 5th of Navamsa (Sagittarius, dispositor Jupiter strong in own-sign context) — inner strength of the marriage karaka is good despite D1 complications

D9 lagna Leo with Moon in D9 lagna and Saturn in D9 11th (Gemini) — emotional investment in the marriage sphere is present; Saturn's role suggests maturity/late-blooming tone

Current dasha is Ketu MD–Mercury AD (to 2026-07-29); Ketu is the graha aspecting the 7th natally, while antardasha lord Mercury is the 7th lord in the 8th — an activating but turbulent period for marital matters

Venus–Venus mahadasha begins 2026-07-29 (/dasha/upcoming/0) — Venus as mahadasha lord, being the natural marriage karaka placed in the 5th, marks a distinctly more favorable window for marriage than the closing Ketu period

Transit Jupiter retrograde sits in the natal 7th conjunct natal Sun and Mars (as-of 2026-01-01) — benefic transit through the spouse bhava supports marriage-related developments near this window, though retrogression suggests revisiting/reworking arrangements

Vipareeta Raja Yoga (8th lord Moon in the 12th) — converts a dusthana weakness into resilience; sudden disruptions tend to resolve without lasting damage

Malefic occupation of the 7th (Sun + combust Mars) does not deny marriage; it colors its quality. The Mercury–Jupiter Raja Yoga and dignified D9 Venus counterbalance it.

Any synthesis omitting the dasha sequence is incomplete: Ketu MD ends mid-2026 and Venus MD (karaka of marriage) runs through 2039, materially changing the outlook across time.

Exact timing question (already-married vs. seeking marriage) not specified

Navamsa 7th lord condition and upapada lagna not provided in chart facts

Dignity of Venus in D9 relative to combustion/affliction in navamsa-specific terms

Explanation: Marriage indications are genuinely mixed. The D1 7th house carries real afflictions: Sun and combust Mars occupy it (/houses/6/occupants, /placements/Mars/combust), its lord Mercury sits in the 8th (/placements/Mercury/house), and Ketu aspects it (/aspects/Ketu). Against this stand a Mercury–Jupiter mutual-aspect Raja Yoga directly involving the 7th lord (/yogas/1), Venus the marriage karaka well-placed in the 5th with good D9 strength (/vargas/D9/placements/5), and a Vipareeta Raja Yoga buffering dusthana damage (/yogas/3). Timing favors improvement after Ketu MD closes on 2026-07-29, when Venus–Venus begins (/dasha/upcoming/0), reinforced by transit Jupiter currently in the natal 7th (/transits/contacts/4). Net: marriage/partnership matters are achievable and likely to stabilize from late 2026 onward, but with friction, unconventional elements, and a need for deliberate management during the current Ketu–Mercury window.


Explanation: In this chart the 2nd lord is Venus, placed in the 9th house (/placements/Venus/house = 9; /houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse confirms Venus rules Taurus, the 2nd). However, the placement of the 2nd lord in the 9th is not a recognized standalone diagnostic rule for health timing or for diagnosing illness. Option B's claim of uniformly poor health contradicts even option A's own premise and has no doctrinal basis here. Option C overclaims: no Jyotish rule 'diagnoses' a specific illness, and the chart facts list no disease-specific evidence tied to this placement. Option A asserts a time-graded health outcome that the stated rule does not establish either. Therefore none of A–C is supported by the stated rule combined with this chart.


Saturn occupies the eighth house, not the seventh, so statements about Saturn in the seventh are not applicable to this chart.

Statement A presumes Saturn in the seventh; the chart shows Saturn in the eighth house, so the rule does not apply as stated.

Same premise error: Saturn is not in the seventh house in this chart.

Besides the house mismatch, no classical rule establishes that Saturn necessarily ends a marriage; such certainty is an overclaim regardless of placement.

Explanation: The only computed fact is /placements/Saturn/house = 8. Since Saturn is in the eighth rather than the seventh house, statements A-C do not apply to this chart; D is selected and the conclusion is insufficient for a marriage polarity assessment from the listed statements alone.


A single house placement (2nd lord Venus in the 9th) does not establish a temporal trajectory of health (early-poor/late-good) nor a uniform lifelong condition, and no Jyotish rule of this kind diagnoses a specific illness.

Explanation: The chart fact is only that Venus, lord of the 2nd (Taurus), occupies the 9th (Sagittarius) (/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse = 9; /placements/Venus/house = 9). Statement A asserts a specific early-vs-late health trajectory, statement B a uniformly poor lifelong health, and statement C a diagnostic power for specific illness — none of these follow from the stated placement rule alone; such rules indicate general tendencies at most, never disease diagnosis. Hence A–C are not established and option D applies. With no applicable affirmative statement, no supportive/challenging polarity can be set from the listed options.


The second lord (Venus) is placed in the ninth house, but the stated rule does not support any specific health timeline or diagnosis.

Statement B is contradicted: the chart shows supportive yogas (Gaja Kesari, Adhi Yoga, Raja/Dhana yogas) that would not be consistent with 'uniformly poor health'.

Nothing in the rule 'second lord in the ninth' establishes an early-weak/later-better health trajectory; the second house concerns wealth/family/speech and its lord's placement alone does not yield this timeline.

'Uniformly poor health' is not a standard reading of second-lord-in-ninth; benefic Venus (/placements/Venus/isBenefic) in the 9th trine is generally benign for this claim.

House/lord placements do not diagnose specific illnesses; Jyotish rules of this kind indicate general areas of vulnerability at most.

Explanation: Venus, lord of the 2nd, sits in the 9th (/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse = 9). None of statements A–C follows from that placement: A invents an unsupported time trend, B overstates it as uniformly poor health despite the chart's strong benefic yogas, and C wrongly treats the rule as diagnostic of a specific illness. Therefore only option D applies.


The second house relates to food/intake and family resources rather than being the primary health significator; the 6th/8th houses and lagna are the main health axes here.

Venus (lord of the 2nd, Taurus) sits in the 9th in Sagittarius, unafflicted and non-combust — a benefic in a trikona, which at most gives a mildly supportive indication for vitality, with no time-phased or diagnostic content.

Statement A's 'weaker early / better later' trajectory is not derivable from a static natal placement alone without dasha sequencing tied to that specific rule.

Statements B (uniformly poor health) and C (diagnosing a specific illness) are contradicted by both the chart and the scope of any such placement rule.

A second-lord-in-ninth placement does not by itself establish a time-graded health pattern; that requires additional reasoning (e.g., dasha activation) beyond the stated rule.

No single placement rule establishes uniformly poor health throughout life; the chart also contains supportive factors such as exalted Moon and Gaja Kesari Yoga.

Jyotish rules indicate tendencies and domains of vulnerability; they do not diagnose specific illnesses.

Exact wording/source of the 'stated rule' being evaluated

Explanation: The chart fact relevant to all three statements is Venus, lord of the 2nd (/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse), placed in the 9th (/placements/Venus/house). Statement A asserts a temporal trajectory (poor early health, improving later) that cannot be read off a single static placement; it would require dasha-linked argumentation not supplied by the stated rule. Statement B ('uniformly poor health') is even stronger and equally unsupported, and is further undercut by chart strengths like the exalted Moon in Taurus (/placements/Moon/dignity) and Gaja Kesari Yoga (/yogas/0). Statement C overclaims diagnostic power for what is an indicative rule. Since A, B, and C each fail on evidence-order grounds, option D applies, and the conclusion polarity is insufficient.


Lagna lord Saturn is strong by placement in the 11th (a house of gains) and forms a Dhana/Raja yoga with Mars there, giving underlying stamina and recuperative resilience.

Budha-Aditya Yoga in the lagna supports vitality, mental alertness and self-possession.

Jupiter aspects the 2nd and 4th houses from the 8th; Gaja Kesari Yoga from the Moon lends emotional stability and protection to diet/family and home life.

The Moon, a benefic and significator of fluids/mind, sits in the 2nd but is combust — indicating sensitivity of mind/emotional health and possible issues around diet or speech.

Saturn in enemy sign Scorpio in the 11th casts its aspect onto the lagna itself, weighing on the body and general vitality over time.

Mars aspects the 6th house of disease while Rahu/Ketu axis afflicts the 5th (and Ketu aspects the 11th), pointing to episodic acute complaints and vulnerability around digestion/acidity-type Mars-Saturn-Scorpio signatures.

Current dasha Mercury–Jupiter–Venus: Jupiter as 12th lord placed in the 8th (Vipareeta position) can bring periods of low energy or hospital-type experiences even when outcomes ultimately turn favourable.

Transit Saturn conjunct natal Venus in Pisces and transiting Ketu on natal Jupiter in the 8th suggest a phase requiring extra care with chronic/slow-developing matters; however gochara Saturn is at 12 from the Moon, i.e., sade sati has concluded, easing long-term pressure.

Explanation: The chart shows a resilient constitutional base (lagna lord strong in the 11th, Budha-Aditya in lagna) offset by a combust Moon, Saturn's aspect on the lagna, and malefic influence on the 5th/6th axis. The present Mercury–Jupiter–Venus dasha with Jupiter as 12th-lord-in-8th, combined with transit Ketu over natal Jupiter, argues for caution rather than alarm. Overall reading: mixed, with supportive fundamentals.


Lagna lord Saturn is placed in the 11th (a good upachaya) but in an enemy sign, so vitality is workable yet not robust; self/body house lord away from the 1st weakens constitutional strength.

Saturn and Ketu both aspect the 1st house (self/body), a classically draining influence on stamina and overall resilience.

The Moon — significator of the mind and fluids — is combust and at only 0°04' in Aquarius in the 2nd; a weakened Chandra typically flags mental restlessness, anxiety, or dietary irregularity.

6th lord Mercury sits in the 1st with the Sun (Budha-Aditya Yoga), which gives intellect and recovery capacity, but a dusthana lord on the lagna keeps disease matters personally close.

Jupiter forms Vipareeta Raja Yoga as 12th lord in the 8th; this can convert chronic/sudden health vulnerabilities into resilience over time, though it marks the native's life with health-related transformation.

Mars aspects the 6th house of disease from the 11th; Mars-Saturn conjunction in the 11th can indicate injuries, inflammation, or joint/blood-related strain surfacing through overexertion.

Currently running Mercury–Jupiter dasha (to Nov 2026); Jupiter is a benefic placed in the 8th and retrograde — periods of its sub-lordship often bring health check-ups or latent chronic matters to attention rather than acute crises.

Transit Rahu is conjunct natal Moon in the natal 2nd and transiting Ketu conjunct natal Jupiter in the 8th (as of 2026-01-01), suggesting heightened stress sensitivity and need for disciplined routine now; Saturn transit from Moon = 2 places the native in sade sati, adding fatigue and pressure.

Upcoming Mercury–Saturn antardasha (Nov 2026–Jul 2029): Saturn is lagna lord in enemy sign; a Saturn sub-period under a neutral benefic mahadasha usually demands routine care, joints/bones attention, but is not inherently disease-giving for a lagna lord.

D30 (Trimshamsha) chart for detailed disease analysis

Exact afflictions to the 6th house cusp / arudha considerations

Current age-specific medical history to calibrate indications

Explanation: Health indicators are genuinely two-sided. Supporting: Budha-Aditya Yoga on the lagna, lagna lord in an upachaya, and Vipareeta Raja Yoga via Jupiter. Challenging: Saturn+Ketu aspecting the lagna, combust Moon at the very edge of Aquarius, Mars-Saturn conjunction, and current sade-sati with Rahu on the natal Moon. Net reading: adequate underlying constitution with vulnerability around stress, digestion/diet (combust Moon in 2nd — food), and joints/fatigue (Saturn), requiring disciplined routine especially through the Mercury–Saturn period from late 2026. No prediction of specific disease is made.


```json
{
 "case_id": "health-synthesis-01-paraphrase",
 "domain": "health",
 "conclusion": "mixed",
 "confidence": 0.55,
 "selected_option_ids": [],
 "factors": [
  {"claim": "Lagna is Capricorn with lagna lord Saturn placed in the 11th (a house of gains), giving the native resilience and strong recuperative grounding; Saturn aspects its own sign Capricorn/1st house, strengthening the body's framework.", "effect": "supporting", "evidence": ["/lagna/sign", "/placements/Saturn/house", "/houses/0/aspectedBy"]},
  {"claim": "Budha-Aditya Yoga (Sun + Mercury) in the 1st house supports vitality of intellect and nervous coordination, though Sun in an enemy sign slightly dilutes it.", "effect": "supporting", "evidence": ["/placements/Sun/house", "/placements/Mercury/house", "/placements/Sun/dignity", "/yogas"]},
  {"claim": "Gaja Kesari Yoga (Jupiter in 7th from Moon) offers protective grace and recovery capacity.", "effect": "supporting", "evidence": ["/yogas"]},
  {"claim": "Mars in own sign Scorpio in the 11th gives robust constitution and stamina.", "effect": "supporting", "evidence": ["/placements/Mars/dignity", "/placements/Mars/house"]},
  {"claim": "The natal Moon, significator of mind and fluids, is combust in the 2nd house — a classic indication of emotional stress affecting physical well-being (diet, sleep, speech-related issues).", "effect": "challenging", "evidence": ["/placements/Moon/combust", "/placements/Moon/house"]},
  {"claim": "Saturn sits in an enemy sign in the 11th with Rahu (debilitated) alongside Mars — a Mars-Saturn-Rahu cluster that can indicate chronic joint, circulatory, or toxin-accumulation tendencies; Saturn also aspects the 1st, 5th, and 8th houses, weighing on vitality and longevity matters.", "effect": "challenging", "evidence": ["/placements/Saturn/sign", "/placements/Saturn/dignity", "/placements/Rahu/house", "/placements/Rahu/dignity", "/aspects/Saturn"]},
  {"claim": "Jupiter (12th lord) retrograde in the 8th house forms Vipareeta Raja Yoga — protective against chronic disease per doctrine, but the 8th placement itself flags sudden health events and hidden conditions.", "effect": "mixed", "evidence": ["/placements/Jupiter/house", "/placements/Jupiter/retrograde", "/yogas"]},
  {"claim": "5th house (well-being via purva punya) is occupied by debilitated Ketu and aspected by Mars, Saturn, and Rahu — indicating weakened natural immunity reserves and possible issues connected to children/stomach region.", "effect": "challenging", "evidence": ["/placements/Ketu/house", "/placements/Ketu/dignity", "/houses/4/aspectedBy"]},
  {"claim": "Currently running Mercury–Jupiter antardasha with Jupiter in the 8th house natally: this sub-period can surface latent or chronic matters requiring attention.", "effect": "mixed", "evidence": ["/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord", "/dasha/current/antardasha/lord", "/placements/Jupiter/house"]},
  {"claim": "Transit Saturn in Pisces conjuncts natal Venus (3rd house) and aspects the 9th and 12th; transit Ketu sits on natal Jupiter in the 8th while transit Rahu conjoins the natal Moon — a period of heightened sensitivity, anxiety, and vulnerability to sudden ailments around early 2026.", "effect": "challenging", "evidence": ["/transits/asOf", "/transits/contacts"]},
  {"claim": "Gochara Saturn from Moon stands at 2 (Aquarius Moon), placing the native inside sade sati — fatigue, low morale, and slow recovery are typical indications during this window.", "effect": "challenging", "evidence": ["/transits/saturnFromMoon"]}
 ],
 "contradictions": [],
 "missing_information": [
  "Exact current health complaints or medical history of the subject",
  "Divisional charts beyond D7/D9/D10 (no specific health varga available)",
  "Birth-time rectification confirmation given lagna at only ~0°29' Capricorn"
 ],
 "rationale": "The chart shows a fundamentally sturdy frame — Capricorn lagna with its lord in the 11th, Mars in own sign, Budha-Aditya in the 1st, and Gaja Kesari protection — but layered with genuine vulnerabilities: a combust Moon (mind-body link), a heavy Mars–Saturn–Rahu load in the 11th with Saturn aspecting the lagna, debilitated nodes, and Jupiter in the 8th. The present Mercury–Jupiter dasha coincides with sade sati, transit Ketu on natal Jupiter in the 8th, and transit Rahu on the natal Moon, so the near-term window (2026) reads as more sensitive than the baseline chart itself. Overall verdict: mixed — sound underlying constitution under periodic stress, warranting routine care rather than alarm. These are astrological indications only, not medical advice or diagnosis."
}
```


Explanation: The chart facts show the second lord (Mercury) placed in the twelfth house (/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse = 12), not the eleventh. Statements A, B, and C all concern a second-lord-in-eleventh placement, which is not present in this chart. Therefore none of A–C is established by the stated rule and chart, and D applies.


The second lord is Mercury and it is placed in the twelfth house, not the eleventh.

The second lord (Mercury) is in the twelfth house, not the eleventh, so statement A does not apply to this chart.

No placement guarantees lifelong illness; moreover the second lord is in the twelfth, not the eleventh.

The stated rule concerns second lord in the eleventh as a challenging indication, not strong vitality; and the placement here is in the twelfth.

Explanation: The chart shows the second lord Mercury placed in the twelfth house (/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse = 12), so none of statements A-C about a second lord in the eleventh applies. Therefore D is selected and no health polarity can be established from these statements.


Lagna lord Saturn is strong by own-sign Mars association in the 11th (Dhana/Raja yoga), supporting vitality and recovery capacity, though Saturn is in 'Enemy' dignity and Saturn aspects the lagna itself (/aspects/Saturn includes house 1), a classic pressure on the body.

6th lord Mercury sits in the lagna with the Sun (Budha-Aditya), placing a dusthana lord on the self — disease/service matters are tied to the body; Mercury's 7th-house aspect touches the 7th (partnerships).

8th house holds retrograde Jupiter (lord of 12) — Vipareeta Raja Yoga offers protection from chronic/sudden harm, but Jupiter also aspects the 2nd, 4th and 12th houses, linking Moon (mind/fluids) to 8th-house transformation themes.

Moon is combust and at 0° Aquarius in the 2nd, aspected only toward the 8th; a combust, sandhi-degree Moon weakens emotional resilience and digestion-related significations.

Mars aspects the 6th house of disease directly (/aspects/Mars), and Ketu debilitated in the 5th receives Mars and Saturn aspects — stress-prone, inflammatory indications around diet/speculation.

Current dasha: Mercury mahadasha (2012–2029) — Mercury as 6th lord in lagna keeps health/service themes active; Jupiter antardasha until 2026-11-19 is a natural benefic period offering mitigation.

Transits as of 2026-01-01: sade sati phase (Saturn 2nd from Moon per /transits/saturnFromMoon = 2), Rahu transiting natal Moon in the 2nd, and a heavy Sagittarius stellium (Sun, Mars, Venus, Mercury) in the 12th of loss/hospitalization — an elevated-stress transit window for body and mind.

Explanation: The chart shows genuine protective architecture (Vipareeta Raja Yoga via Jupiter in the 8th; strong lagna-lord/lagna pairing in Dhana-Raja yoga; benefic Jupiter antardasha now) set against structural vulnerabilities (6th lord in lagna, combust sandhi Moon linked to the 8th, Mars aspect on the 6th, debilitated Ketu in the 5th). The current transit picture — late sade sati, Rahu over the natal Moon, and a 12th-house stellium — tilts the near term toward elevated fatigue/stress load rather than acute crisis, but this is probabilistic indication, not diagnosis or prediction.


Explanation: The chart facts show the second lord is Mercury placed in the 12th house (/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse = 12), not the 11th. Therefore statements A, B, and C, which all concern a second lord in the eleventh, are not applicable to this chart. Statement D is correct: none of A–C is established by the stated rule and chart.


Lagna is early Capricorn with Saturn as lagna lord placed in the 11th in its own-sign Mars's territory — the native's vitality is tied to Saturn, whose condition is mixed (Enemy dignity, but conjunct its friend Mars and forming a Raja/Dhana yoga), suggesting durable constitution with chronic, Saturnian slow-burn issues.

Sun (natural significator of vitality) sits in the 1st house in Enemy dignity at 29° Capricorn — self and body are strongly identified, but vitality runs hot-and-cold under a hostile dispositor.

Budha-Aditya yoga in the lagna gives resilience of mind-body coordination and recovery capacity.

The Moon, karaka of fluids and mind, is combust in the 2nd and aspected by Mars and Jupiter — emotional/nervous strain and dietary/speech-related sensitivities are indicated.

6th house (disease) Gemini is empty with lord Mercury strong in the lagna — good placement: disease capacity is handled by a well-placed lagna occupant, supporting recovery from acute illness.

However Mercury rules the 6th from the 1st: health matters stay close to the body/self; daily-routine discipline is the lever for health outcomes.

8th house Leo holds retrograde Jupiter and is aspected by natal Saturn and Moon — chronic or hard-to-diagnose tendencies, plus Vipareeta Raja Yoga (12th lord in 8th), which classically converts adversity into eventual relief.

Current dasha context: Mercury mahadasha (2012–2029) with Jupiter antardasha until Nov 2026 — Jupiter is 12th lord in the 8th natally, so this period can bring hospitalization-type or isolation-flavored episodes even while ultimately protective (Vipareeta pattern).

Transits as of 2026-01-01: transiting Rahu conjunct natal Moon (mind, sleep, anxiety) and transiting Ketu over natal Jupiter in the 8th; transiting Saturn conjunct natal Venus in the 3rd aspecting houses 5/9/12 — a period of mental restlessness, disturbed sleep, and low-grade depletion rather than acute danger.

Gochara check: Saturn is 2 signs from the natal Moon (sade sati phase) and Jupiter 5 from the Moon — sade sati typically raises fatigue, joint/knee complaints, and mental heaviness; Jupiter's position offers some protection.

Upcoming Mercury–Saturn antardasha (Nov 2026–Jul 2029): Saturn is lagna lord in Enemy sign in the 11th — likely a demanding stretch where routine, joints, and stamina need deliberate care; not an indication of catastrophic outcome.

Vipareeta Raja Yoga does not guarantee immunity to illness; it indicates eventual resolution/benefit emerging from difficulty, with uncertainty about timing and severity.

Any health synthesis must note this is astrological indication only, not medical diagnosis; no birth-time rectification data or medical history is available to confirm patterns.

Exact nature of any existing health conditions or symptoms (chart alone cannot diagnose)

Whether birth time is rectified (lagna at 0°29' Capricorn is near a cusp-sensitive point, raising sensitivity of all house assignments)

Divisional charts beyond D9/D10/D7 relevant to specific health assessment (D60)

Explanation: The chart shows a fundamentally resilient frame — Budha-Aditya in the lagna, empty well-disposed 6th, and a protective Vipareeta Raja Yoga through Jupiter in the 8th — offset by a combust Moon, hostile-dignity Sun as vitality karaka, and heavy Saturnian influence on the body via lagna lordship. Current-period overlays (Mercury–Jupiter dasha touching the 8th/12th axis, sade sati, Rahu on natal Moon, Ketu on natal Jupiter in the 8th) point to fatigue, sleep/anxiety strain, and possible medical attention during late 2024–2026, with the Mercury–Saturn antardasha (Nov 2026–mid 2029) demanding disciplined routine rather than signaling crisis. Conclusion: mixed, with proportionate uncertainty and no medical claims.


The ascendant lord (Moon) occupies the tenth house, which is classically treated as supportive of professional success/specialization.

This placement does not guarantee any specific profession; no option or rule establishes a particular vocation.

Explanation: Option A applies: /lagna/lordInHouse = 10 and /placements/Moon/house = 10 show the Cancer-lagna lord Moon in the 10th, a standard supportive indication for career standing — not a career-loss indication, so B fails; and no rule or chart fact guarantees a specific profession, so C fails; D therefore also fails.


Explanation: The chart facts state the lagna lord Moon is placed in house 10 (/lagna/lordInHouse = 10, /placements/Moon/house = 10), and the 10th signifies career, status, authority, and public standing (/houses/9/significations). Classical treatment of the ascendant lord in a kendra, especially the 10th, supports professional success/specialization — so A applies. B contradicts the standard reading of this placement (no rule or chart evidence frames it as career loss). C overclaims: no single placement guarantees a specific profession; the D10 shows Sun/Mercury/Moon in Leo in its own 10th (/vargas/D10/placements) but that indicates strength of career significations, not a fixed profession. Hence only A is established.


Lagna lord Saturn placed in the 11th with Mars and Rahu; lagna itself is aspected by natal Saturn and debilitated Ketu, indicating a constitution that holds up under strain but is vulnerable to chronic, slow-developing issues (Saturn) and sudden/acute episodes (Mars-Rahu).

The 6th house of disease is unoccupied but its lord Mercury sits in the 1st (lagna), tying disease matters directly to the body/self; Mercury also aspects the 7th. A 6th lord in the 1st classically links health sensitivity to the native's own vitality.

Jupiter, a natural benefic, occupies the 8th (chronic matters, longevity) retrograde, forming Vipareeta Raja Yoga — one dusthana lord fallen into another — which traditionally converts adversity into resilience; it also aspects the 12th (hospitalization/isolation), softening those significations.

Moon (2nd house, combust per /placements/Moon/combust) aspects the 8th; an afflicted Moon aspecting the 8th points to mind-body linkage, sleep/fluid-related vulnerability, and stress-driven flare-ups.

Current period: Mercury mahadasha (Mercury is 6th lord of disease sitting in the 1st), Jupiter antardasha (Jupiter in the 8th house natally) until Nov 2026 — a dasha sequence that activates both the disease axis and the chronic/8th-house axis simultaneously.

Transits as of 2026-01-01: Saturn from Moon = 2 (within sade sati range 12-1-2), and Rahu transiting natal house 2 conjunct natal Moon while Ketu transits natal house 8 conjunct natal Jupiter — nodal transit over the Moon and across the 2/8 axis raises stress, diet, and sudden-event sensitivity.

Mitigating: transiting Jupiter is retrograde in the natal 6th (house of disease) aspecting houses 10 and 12 — benefic presence on the 6th can indicate recovery capacity and successful management rather than pure affliction.

Upcoming Ketu mahadasha begins Dec 2029 after Mercury–Saturn ends Jul 2029; Saturn antardasha over a natal Saturn-Mars-Rahu conjunction in the 11th suggests a demanding stretch for stamina in 2026–2029, though not deterministically adverse.

Vipareeta Raja Yoga via Jupiter in the 8th does not guarantee immunity to illness; it indicates resilience and favorable outcomes from adversity, so it should temper but not override the challenging 6th-lord-in-lagna indication.

Exact divisional strength of the 6th/8th lords in relevant vargas (D3/D7/D9/D12 do not bear directly on health; D60 would help)

Natal planetary strengths (shadbala/vimsopaka) not provided

Actual medical history or symptoms of the subject

Explanation: The chart shows a mixed health picture: genuine vulnerabilities (6th lord Mercury in the 1st; Moon combust aspecting the 8th; Mars-Saturn-Rahu pressure on the lagna lord in the 11th; active Mercury-Jupiter dasha running through the disease and 8th-house axes; sade sati-range Saturn plus Rahu/Ketu transiting the natal Moon and 8th) are counterweighted by protective factors (Jupiter's Vipareeta Raja Yoga in the 8th, benefic Jupiter transiting the 6th). Overall conclusion: mixed — heightened sensitivity and stress-linked flare-ups likely during 2026–2029, but with real recovery and management capacity; no deterministic illness prediction should be made.


Ascendant lord (Moon) is placed in the 10th house of career, a kendra, which classically supports professional standing and direction.

The 10th is aspected by no malefic occupants and the lagna lord there does not constitute a loss indication; no chart evidence supports statement B.

While the placement supports career success in principle, it does not specify or guarantee any particular profession — no rule establishes that (statement C not established).

Lagna lord in the 10th supports career strength generally but cannot guarantee a specific profession from this placement alone.

Explanation: Option A is directly supported: the Cancer lagna's lord Moon sits in the 10th house (Aries) per /placements/Mouse... i.e., /placements/Moon/house = 10, and the 10th carries career significations (/houses/10/significations). Statement B contradicts standard doctrine and finds no support here. Statement C overclaims specificity, so it is rejected. Only A applies, giving a supportive polarity.


Ascendant lord (Moon, lord of Cancer lagna) placed in the 10th house of career — a classical supportive indication for professional standing and specialization

The 10th-house placement does not fix or guarantee any specific profession; the chart indicates strength of career significations, not a particular vocation

No chart evidence supports treating lagna lord in the 10th as primarily career-loss; the 10th is a kendra of action and status

Lagna lord in the 10th is classically read as strengthening career and public standing, not as a loss indication.

Placement in the 10th supports professional success generally but cannot determine a specific profession from this evidence alone.

Option A IS established by the stated rule and the chart (Moon as Cancer lagna lord in Aries, the 10th whole-sign house).

Explanation: The chart facts show Cancer lagna whose lord is Moon (/lagna/lord), and /lagna/lordInHouse = 10 with Moon in the 10th house (/placements/Moon/house = 10). This establishes option A. Option B contradicts standard doctrine and has no chart support; option C overclaims specificity, which no single placement guarantees; therefore D is also false.


```json
{
 "case_id": "career-application-01-evidence-order",
 "domain": "career",
 "conclusion": "supportive",
 "confidence": 0.9,
 "selected_option_ids": ["A"],
 "factors": [
  {
   "claim": "The ascendant lord (Moon, lord of Cancer lagna) is placed in the 10th house of career/status in Aries, which classical doctrine treats as a strong support for professional success and specialization.",
   "effect": "supporting",
   "evidence": ["/lagna/sign", "/lagna/lord", "/lagna/lordInHouse", "/placements/Moon/house", "/placements/Moon/sign"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "The 10th lord Mars is placed in the 9th with a mutual-aspect Raja Yoga between Mars (10th lord) and Jupiter (9th lord), reinforcing the career-supportive reading rather than contradicting it.",
   "effect": "supporting",
   "evidence": ["/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse", "/yogas/2", "/yogas/3/name"]
  }
 ],
 "contradictions": [
  {
   "statement_id": "B",
   "error_type": "doctrinal",
   "correction": "Ascendant lord in the 10th is a kendra placement of the lagna lord, classically read as strength for self and career, not primarily a career-loss indication. No chart evidence supports a loss reading here.",
   "evidence": ["/lagna/lordInHouse", "/placements/Moon/house"]
  },
  {
   "statement_id": "C",
   "error_type": "overclaim",
   "correction": "The placement indicates career strength/success potential but does not guarantee any specific profession; specific profession requires further factors (D10, dasha context) and is never 'guaranteed' by one placement.",
   "evidence": ["/placements/Moon/house", "/vargas/D10"]
  }
 ],
 "missing_information": [],
 "rationale": "Statement A is directly established: the chart shows Cancer lagna with its lord Moon in the 10th house (/lagna/lord = Moon, /lagna/lordInHouse = 10, /placements/Moon/house = 10), a kendra placement traditionally supportive of professional success. Statement B reverses standard doctrine without support, and statement C overclaims certainty; neither is applicable. The polarity of the applicable statement (A) is positive, so conclusion is supportive."
}
```


The ascendant lord Moon is placed in the 10th house of career, a kendra, which the classical rule treats as supportive of professional success and standing.

Lagnesh in the 10th is not a career-loss indication; statement B contradicts standard doctrine.

No rule or chart evidence guarantees a specific profession from this placement alone; the D10 shows supporting structure (Sun, Mercury, Moon in Leo 10th of D10) but no specific-profession guarantee follows from A.

Ascendant lord in the tenth is a strength for career, not primarily a loss indication.

The placement supports professional success generally but does not guarantee a particular profession.

Explanation: Only statement A is established: /lagna/lord is Moon, and /placements/Moon/house = 10 (Aries), with the Moon also aspecting the 4th — lagnesh in the 10th kendra is classically read as supportive of professional success/specialization. B is doctrinally wrong, and C overclaims; neither is applicable. The conclusion polarity therefore follows A: supportive. Supporting context: Jupiter (lord of 9) aspects the 10th per /aspects/Jupiter, forming a Raja Yoga with Mars (/yogas index 2).


Jupiter, the lagna lord and a single-lordship Raja Yoga (rules 1st and 4th kendras/trikonas), sits in the 10th house of career — a strong career anchor.

10th lord Mercury is well placed in the 2nd house (wealth/speech) with benefic Venus, linking career to finance, communication and earning capacity; Mercury–Venus in 2nd also supports Adhi Yoga from the Moon.

Current Saturn mahadasha with Saturn aspecting natal house 10 (Saturn's 3rd aspect from Scorpio/12th), giving disciplined but heavy career pressure during 2022–2041.

Ketu aspects the 10th house, adding detachment or unconventional shifts in career direction.

Natal Saturn sits in the 12th in enemy sign with debilitated Rahu — its dasha periods may bring expenditure, foreign relocation, or behind-the-scenes roles rather than visible authority.

In D10, Saturn and Ketu occupy the 12th (own-sign Saturn) while Sun-Moon-Venus cluster in the 2nd and Jupiter-Rahu sit in the 6th — career success comes through service and steady accumulation rather than positional power.

Transit Saturn in Pisces (natal 4th) aspects natal house 10 as of Jan 2026, coinciding with Saturn–Mercury antardasha (Mercury being 10th lord), pointing to an active, work-focused phase through late 2027.

Explanation: The chart shows genuine career strength: lagna lord Jupiter's placement in the 10th with a kendra-trikona Raja Yoga, plus 10th lord Mercury joining Venus in the wealth house. However, the current long Saturn dasha draws energy from a 12th-house Saturn afflicted by debilitated Rahu, and Ketu's aspect on the 10th suggests phases of detachment or redirection. Net indication is a capable professional life with meaningful output, tempered by periodic withdrawal, foreign/isolation themes, and less appetite for overt authority during Saturn's dasha.


Explanation: The chart facts show the tenth lord is Mars and it is placed in the 2nd house (/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse = 2), not the first. Statements A–C all presuppose the tenth lord in the first, which this chart does not establish; therefore none of them applies, and D is selected.


Explanation: The chart facts show the tenth lord is Mars and it is placed in the 2nd house (/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse = 2), not the first. Therefore none of statements A–C (which all concern the tenth lord in the first) is established by this chart; D applies. Conclusion polarity is set from the applicable listed statement only: D is neutral/none-applicable, so no supportive or challenging career indication can be claimed from these rules.


Jupiter (Lagna lord) in the 10th house is a strong career anchor, forming a single-lordship Raja Yoga (rules 4th kendra and 1st trikona), indicating status and authority through dharmic work.

10th lord Mercury placed in the 2nd house links career to wealth, speech, finance and communication; Mercury with Venus there supports earning through skilled articulation.

Adhi Yoga from the Moon (Venus, Mercury benefics in 6th/7th/8th from Moon) indicates a comfortable, respected life overall.

Mars strong in own sign Aries in the 5th aspects the 11th house of gains, supporting initiative-driven income.

Jupiter is retrograde and in enemy sign Virgo in the 10th — dignity weakness tempers the Raja Yoga's full expression.

Ketu aspects the 10th house, adding detachment or discontinuity to public standing.

Saturn, 2nd/3rd lord, sits in the 12th (enemy sign) with debilitated Rahu — income linked to expenditure, foreign settings, or behind-the-scenes work; Saturn also aspects the 9th and 2nd.

Current Saturn mahadasha / Mercury antardasha: Saturn dasha lord in the 12th colors the period with effort and isolation themes, though Mercury antardasha (10th lord) activates career matters through 2027.

D10: Jupiter exalted-equivalent in Cancer in D10 6th, Saturn own-sign Capricorn in D10 12th, Sun-Moon-Venus cluster in Pisces 2nd — service-oriented, disciplined career with steady resource flow but a 12th-house Saturn suggesting foreign/institutional settings.

Exact career field/profession of the subject for corroboration

Explanation: The chart shows genuine career strength — Lagna lord Jupiter in the 10th with a Raja Yoga, 10th lord Mercury in the wealth house, and Adhi Yoga — but dignity weaknesses (Jupiter enemy-sign retrograde, Saturn enemy-sign in the 12th with debilitated Rahu, Ketu aspecting the 10th) prevent an unambiguously supportive reading. The current Saturn–Mercury period keeps career themes active but colored by Saturn's 12th-house placement.


Explanation: The chart facts show the tenth lord is Mars and it is placed in the 2nd house (/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse = 2), not in the first. Therefore none of statements A–C (which all concern the tenth lord in the first) are established by this chart. Statement D applies.


```json
{
 "case_id": "career-synthesis-01-paraphrase",
 "domain": "career",
 "conclusion": "mixed",
 "confidence": 0.7,
 "selected_option_ids": [],
 "factors": [
  {
   "claim": "Lagna lord Jupiter placed in the 10th house of career, forming a Raja Yoga (Jupiter rules both the kendra 4th and trikona 1st), is a major career-supporting combination for status and authority.",
   "effect": "supporting",
   "evidence": ["/lagna/lordInHouse", "/placements/Jupiter/house", "/yogas/0"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "However, Jupiter is retrograde and in an enemy sign (Virgo) in the natal chart, so career gains come with friction, delays, or a sense of under-recognition.",
   "effect": "challenging",
   "evidence": ["/placements/Jupiter/retrograde", "/placements/Jupiter/dignity"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "The D10 dashamsa lagna is Aquarius ruled by Saturn, and Saturn sits in its own sign Capricorn in D10's 12th — indicating disciplined, behind-the-scenes or institutional work rather than public limelight.",
   "effect": "mixed",
   "evidence": ["/vargas/D10/lagnaSign", "/vargas/D10/placements/6"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "In D1, the 10th lord Mercury occupies the 2nd house with Venus (11th lord) — linking career to finance, speech, commerce, and income generation; this Venus–Mercury pairing in the 2nd also supports Adhi Yoga from the Moon.",
   "effect": "supporting",
   "evidence": ["/placements/Mercury/house", "/placements/Venus/house", "/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse", "/yogas/1"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Ketu aspects the 10th house (from the 6th), which can bring detachment from conventional status, sudden shifts in professional direction, or technical/specialized inclinations.",
   "effect": "challenging",
   "evidence": ["/aspects/Ketu", "/placements/Ketu/house"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "The current Saturn mahadasha (2022–2041) runs Saturn, which natally sits in the 12th in enemy sign Scorpio conjunct Rahu — the dasha lord's weak placement suggests heavy workload, expenditure, foreign/isolated postings, or working without proportional recognition during much of this period.",
   "effect": "challenging",
   "evidence": ["/dasha/current/mahadasha", "/placements/Saturn/house", "/placements/Saturn/dignity", "/placements/Rahu/house"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "The running Saturn–Mercury antardasha (2025-04-04 to 2027-12-13) activates the 10th-lord Mercury in the 2nd, a comparatively favorable window within the Saturn dasha for work tied to communication, accounts, advisory or commercial roles, and income.",
   "effect": "supporting",
   "evidence": ["/dasha/current/antardasha", "/placements/Mercury/house"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Transit Jupiter in Gemini aspects the natal 11th house of gains while transiting Saturn in Pisces aspects the natal 10th house, indicating steady effort toward gains around the reference date, though Saturn's aspect on the 6th and 10th keeps pressure on service and duty.",
   "effect": "mixed",
   "evidence": ["tool:transits_at#/0", "/transits/contacts/6"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Mars strong in its own sign Aries in the 5th aspects the 11th and 12th houses, giving drive, initiative, and capacity for gains through self-directed effort, but also impulsive spending or risk-taking that can offset gains.",
   "effect": "mixed",
   "evidence": ["/placements/Mars/dignity", "/aspects/Mars"]
  }
 ],
 "contradictions": [],
 "missing_information": [
  "Exact nature of the native's profession/industry (needed for concrete role-level synthesis)",
  "Full birth-time rectification confirmation given sensitivity of house cusps in Whole Sign system"
 ],
 "rationale": "Career fundamentals are genuinely strong: lagna lord Jupiter in the 10th forms a single-lordship Raja Yoga (/yogas/0), and the 10th lord Mercury joins the 11th lord Venus in the wealth house, tying profession to income. But both key grahas are compromised — Jupiter retrograde in an enemy sign, Mercury neutral — and the long-running Saturn dasha draws on a Saturn placed in the 12th with Rahu in an enemy sign, coloring the period with workload, expense, and delayed recognition. The current Saturn–Mercury antardasha is the most workable stretch in the near term. Net indication: mixed, with capability and status potential tempered by the Saturn dasha's grind."
}
```


Explanation: The chart shows the lagna lord Sun placed in the 11th house of gains (/lagna/lordInHouse = 11, /placements/Sun/house = 11, with Venus lord of the 10th also there forming a raja yoga per /yogas[4]). Statement A correctly states this is treated as supportive of gains and earning capacity — a proportionate reading consistent with the 11th house signifying 'gains, income, fulfilment of desire' (/reference/houseSignifications/11). Statement B overclaims: classical placement supports gains but never guarantees 'enormous profits,' especially with Ketu also in the 11th and Kemadruma Yoga present (/yogas[0]). Statement C contradicts the standard signification of the 11th as a house of gains; nothing in the rule or chart establishes it as primarily a loss indication. Hence only A applies.


Lagna lord Jupiter in the 10th house of career is a strong anchor for professional life and public standing.

Jupiter forms a Raja Yoga by ruling both a kendra (4) and a trikona (1), supporting status and authority.

10th lord Mercury placed in the 2nd house links career to wealth, speech and accumulated resources; Mercury also participates in Adhi Yoga with Venus.

Ketu aspects the 10th house, introducing detachment or unconventional elements in career direction.

Natal Saturn (current mahadasha lord 2022–2041) sits in the 12th house in enemy sign, suggesting periods of expenditure, foreign connections or reduced visibility during Saturn dasha.

Current antardasha lord Mercury is well-placed in the 2nd with Venus and in own-sign Virgo in D10's 11th (gains from profession).

D10 lagna lord Saturn in its own sign Capricorn in the D10 12th suggests career involving behind-the-scenes work, institutions, or foreign settings, with strong but self-contained discipline.

D10 Jupiter in Cancer (6th) with Rahu indicates service-oriented work environments and possible workplace friction or competition.

A Raja Yoga from single lordship supports potential for status but does not guarantee it; it must be weighed against Saturn dasha running through the 12th house.

Navamsa (D9) strength of Jupiter and Mercury for fuller career assessment

Exact pratyantardasha sequencing within Saturn–Mercury beyond current period

Explanation: The chart shows genuine career strength: lagna lord in the 10th (/placements/Jupiter/house), a Raja Yoga (/yogas/0), and 10th lord Mercury linked to the wealth house (/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse). However, the long-running Saturn mahadasha places the spotlight on 12th-house themes (/placements/Saturn/house), tempering visibility and gains. Overall indication is mixed-to-supportive: solid professional foundation with periodic phases of lower profile or higher expenditure.