```json
{
 "case_id": "career-synthesis-01-evidence-order",
 "domain": "career",
 "conclusion": "supportive",
 "confidence": 0.7,
 "selected_option_ids": [],
 "factors": [
  {
   "claim": "Lagna lord Jupiter placed in the 10th house of career is a strong central indicator: the self's ruler sits in the karma bhava, tying identity to profession and public standing.",
   "effect": "supporting",
   "evidence": ["/placements/Jupiter/house", "/lagna/lordInHouse"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Jupiter forms a Raja Yoga by single lordship of both a kendra (4th) and trikona (1st), and this yoga-lord occupies the 10th — amplifying authority and status potential.",
   "effect": "supporting",
   "evidence": ["/yogas/0", "/placements/Jupiter/house"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Jupiter is retrograde and in 'Enemy' dignity in Virgo (10th): the yoga functions but with internal revision, delays, or unconventional expression of authority.",
   "effect": "mixed",
   "evidence": ["/placements/Jupiter/retrograde", "/placements/Jupiter/dignity", "/houses/9/sign"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Mercury, the 7th and 10th lord, is placed in the 2nd house with Venus — career lord linked to wealth/speech house, suggesting income through communication, trade, advisory or analytical skill.",
   "effect": "supporting",
   "evidence": ["/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse", "/placements/Mercury/house", "/placements/Venus/house"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Venus–Mercury form Adhi Yoga (benefics in 6th/7th/8th from Moon), supporting gains and comfort through professional activity.",
   "effect": "supporting",
   "evidence": ["/yogas/1"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Ketu aspects the 10th house, introducing detachment, sudden shifts of direction, or technical/occult flavor in career.",
   "effect": "mixed",
   "evidence": ["/aspects/Ketu", "/houses/9/aspectedBy"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Saturn (current mahadasha lord) is placed in the 12th with Rahu — dasha lord in a dusthana suggests the Saturn period (2022–2041) carries themes of foreign settings, institutions, behind-the-scenes work, expenditure, or isolation alongside duty.",
   "effect": "challenging",
   "evidence": ["/dasha/current/mahadasha", "/placements/Saturn/house", "/houses/11/occupants"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "D10 shows lagna Aquarius with Saturn (its dispositor chain via Ketu/Saturn in Capricorn 12th) and Sun+Moon+Venus clustered in the D10 2nd (Pisces) — earnings-oriented career; Mercury in D10 11th supports gains through intellect/networks.",
   "effect": "mixed",
   "evidence": ["/vargas/D10/placements", "/vargas/D10/lagnaSign"]
  },
  {
   "claim": "Transit context (asOf 2026-01-01): Jupiter retrograde transiting natal 7th aspecting natal 7th; Saturn transiting Pisces (natal 4th) aspecting houses 1, 6, 10 — transit Saturn directly touches the 10th, indicating pressure/restructuring phase on career during its current run.",
   "effect": "mixed",
   "evidence": ["/transits/contacts/4", "/transits/contacts/6/aspectingNatalHouses"]
  }
 ],
 "contradictions": [
  {
   "statement_id": "S1",
   "error_type": "overclaim",
   "correction": "A Raja Yoga in the 10th does not guarantee uninterrupted rise: Jupiter's retrograde motion, Enemy dignity, and Ketu's aspect on the 10th temper the promise with delays and redirection. The correct reading is strong career orientation realized unevenly.",
   "evidence": ["/yogas/0", "/placements/Jupiter/dignity", "/aspects/Ketu"]
  },
  {
   "statement_id": "S2",
   "error_type": "omission",
   "correction": "Any synthesis must weigh that the running Saturn mahadasha lord sits in the 12th with debilitated Rahu; ignoring this would overstate the favorable 10th-house picture for the 2022–2041 span.",
   "evidence": ["/dasha/current/mahadasha", "/placements/Saturn/house", "/placements/Rahu/dignity"]
  }
 ],
 "missing_information": [
  "Exact antardasha-level career events (promotions, job changes) would require correlating specific past dates with dasha_timeline results",
  "No birth-time rectification status; lagna degree sensitivity affects whole-sign assignments near boundaries",
  "Upapada/amatyakaraka (Jaimini) analysis not present in chart facts"
 ],
 "rationale": "The chart's core career signature is strong: lagna lord Jupiter in the 10th carrying a kendra-trikona Raja Yoga (/yogas/0, /placements/Jupiter/house), reinforced by 10th lord Mercury in the wealth house with Venus (/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse) and Adhi Yoga (/yogas/1). Qualifications are Jupiter's retrogression and Enemy dignity, Ketu's aspect on the 10th, and above all the current Saturn mahadasha whose lord occupies the 12th with Rahu — pointing to a long period where career progress routes through foreign/institutional/behind-the-scenes channels and demands patience. Transit Saturn currently aspecting the natal 10th confirms an active restructuring phase. Net assessment: fundamentally supportive career promise, expressed with delays, detours, and non-linear growth during the Saturn dasha."
}
```


The ascendant lord (Sun, lord of Leo lagna) is placed in the 11th house of gains, which classically supports earning capacity and fulfilment of desires.

Statement B overclaims: placement in the 11th supports gains but does not guarantee enormous profits; the Sun is neutral in dignity and the 11th also contains Ketu, a shadowy graha that can dilute results.

Statement C contradicts the classical reading: the 11th house signifies gains and income, not financial loss; loss houses are 6, 8, 12.

Explanation: Only option A follows from the stated rule and the chart: /lagna/lordInHouse shows the ascendant lord Sun in the 11th house (/placements/Sun/house), whose significations are 'gains, income... fulfilment of desire' (/houses/10/significations). This supports gains without guaranteeing them (ruling out B) and certainly does not indicate loss (ruling out C). D fails since A is established.


Lagna lord Jupiter placed in the 10th house of career links self and life-direction directly to profession — a strong anchor for career significance.

Jupiter forms a Raja Yoga by ruling both a kendra (4th) and trikona (1st), and this yogakaraka-quality planet sits in the 10th, supporting status and authority.

Jupiter is retrograde and in Enemy dignity in Virgo (/placements/Jupiter/dignity), so the 10th-house placement delivers with friction — delays, revisions, or working under conditions not fully one's own.

Mercury, lord of the 7th and 10th (career and public dealings), is placed in the 2nd house of wealth and speech — career tied to communication, commerce, finance, and income generation.

Ketu aspects the 10th house (/aspects/Ketu includes 10; /houses/9/aspectedBy), introducing detachment, unconventional paths, or periodic loss of interest in conventional authority structures.

D10 shows Saturn in own sign Capricorn in the D10 12th with Ketu — behind-the-scenes work, institutions, foreign or isolated settings, and disciplined but low-visibility roles; dispositor Saturn is natal 2nd/3rd lord in the 12th natally.

D10 Jupiter in the 6th (Cancer) conjunct Rahu suggests service-oriented, competitive, possibly conflict-laden professional environments; Mercury in D10 11th (Sagittarius) supports gains through networks, analysis, trade.

Adhi Yoga from the Moon (benefics Venus and Mercury in 6th/7th/8th from Moon) supports overall rise, comfort and respect over the life course.

Current Saturn mahadasha (2022–2041) runs Saturn–Mercury antardasha to Dec 2027: Saturn is 12th-house occupant and 2nd/3rd lord, Mercury is 10th lord — dasha lords connect career (Mercury) with expenditure/foreign/isolation themes (Saturn in 12th), indicating productive but demanding years.

Saturn–Venus antardasha (Jan 2029 – Mar 2032) follows: Venus is 6th and 11th lord in the 2nd, supporting gains/income consolidation within service contexts.

A 10th-house lagna lord does not guarantee eminence on its own; here it is tempered by Jupiter's enemy dignity, retrogression, and Ketu's aspect on the 10th, so the correct reading is 'strong career orientation with friction', not assured high office.

Saturn's D10 12th-house placement should not be read as career failure; the 12th of the Dashamsa indicates work behind the scenes, in foreign lands, research, or institutional/isolation settings — Saturn being in own sign Capricorn there actually gives steady, disciplined output in such domains.

Exact D10 ascendant lord strength / D10 10th house occupants are inferable from placements but no explicit D10 10th-lord analysis was supplied

No shadbala or vimshopaka strength scores to weigh Jupiter vs Saturn quantitatively

No birth-time rectification confirmation for a 3:33 AM lagna

Explanation: The chart shows a career-centred life: lagna lord Jupiter in the 10th forming a single-lordship Raja Yoga, with 10th lord Mercury in the wealth/speech house pointing to communication-, trade- or finance-linked work, reinforced by Adhi Yoga for eventual rise. These strengths are offset by Jupiter's retrograde enemy-dignity placement, Ketu's aspect on the 10th, and a D10 pattern (Saturn-Ketu in Capricorn 12th, Jupiter-Rahu in 6th) indicating behind-the-scenes, service-heavy or institutionally constrained roles rather than visible authority. The running Saturn mahadasha with Mercury antardasha (to Dec 2027) ties career activity to Saturn's 12th-house themes — demanding, lower-visibility, possibly foreign-connected — followed by the Venus antardasha (2029–2032) favouring income consolidation via Venus as 11th lord. Net assessment: mixed — solid career orientation and long-term rise, delivered through less glamorous channels than the 10th-house emphasis alone would suggest.


The ascendant lord (Sun) occupies the eleventh house of gains, which classical doctrine treats as supportive of earning capacity.

Supporting context for gains: Venus, lord of the 10th, is also in the 11th with the Sun (Raja Yoga conjunction), and Mercury (2nd lord) sits in the 10th with its lord in the 11th — a strong income/career axis.

'Guarantees enormous profits' overstates the rule; placement indicates supportive potential, not guaranteed magnitude of wealth. Ketu also sits in the 11th with these grahas and Kemadruma afflicts the Moon, tempering the indication.

The ascendant lord in the 11th is not primarily a financial-loss indication; the 11th signifies gains (/houses/10/significations). Loss houses are the dusthanas (6, 8, 12), where the lagna lord does not sit.

Explanation: Statement A correctly applies: the lagna lord Sun is placed in the 11th house of gains (/placements/Sun/house), classically read as favorable for earnings. B is an overclaim (no guarantee of magnitude), and C contradicts standard house significations. Hence only A applies and the polarity is supportive.


```json
{
  "case_id": "wealth-application-01-paraphrase",
  "domain": "wealth",
  "conclusion": "supportive",
  "confidence": 0.95,
  "selected_option_ids": ["A"],
  "factors": [
    {
      "claim": "Ascendant lord Sun placed in the eleventh house of gains supports earning capacity and income (option A).",
      "effect": "supporting",
      "evidence": ["/lagna/lordInHouse", "/placements/Sun/house", "/houses/10/significations"]
    },
    {
      "claim": "The ascendant lord's placement in the 11th does not guarantee enormous profits — a single placement cannot guarantee magnitude of outcome (option B is an overclaim).",
      "effect": "neutral",
      "evidence": ["/placements/Sun/house"]
    },
    {
      "claim": "The same placement is not a financial-loss indication; the 11th signifies gains and fulfilment of desire (option C is contrary to chart facts).",
      "effect": "neutral",
      "evidence": ["/reference/houseSignifications/11"]
    }
  ],
  "contradictions": [
    {
      "statement_id": "B",
      "error_type": "overclaim",
      "correction": "Lagna lord in the 11th supports gains but guarantees nothing about magnitude; other factors (e.g., Kemadruma Yoga from the Moon) temper the picture.",
      "evidence": ["/placements/Sun/house", "/yogas"]
    },
    {
      "statement_id": "C",
      "error_type": "factual",
      "correction": "The 11th is the house of gains; lagna lord there is read as supportive of income, not loss.",
      "evidence": ["/reference/houseSignifications/11", "/lagna/lordInHouse"]
    }
  ],
  "missing_information": [],
  "rationale": "Only option A is established by the chart: the Leo lagna's lord Sun sits in Gemini in the 11th house (/lagna/lordInHouse, /placements/Sun/house), the house of gains, alongside Venus (lord of 10) forming a raja yoga for income. Option B overclaims certainty/magnitude not warranted by any rule or chart fact, and option C contradicts the standard signification of the 11th house."
}
```


The ascendant lord (Sun) is placed in the 11th house of gains, supporting earning capacity.

Placement in the 11th supports gains but does not guarantee enormous profits; no rule guarantees magnitude of wealth from this placement alone.

The 11th is a house of gains and income, not primarily a financial-loss indication; the loss house is the 12th.

Explanation: Statement A is established: the lagna lord Sun occupies the natal 11th (gains/income), a classically supportive placement for earnings. Statement B overclaims certainty/magnitude; statement C contradicts standard signification of the 11th. Only A applies, so conclusion polarity is supportive.


```json
{"case_id":"wealth-application-01-evidence-order","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The ascendant lord (Sun, Leo lagna) is placed in the 11th house of gains and income, a classically supportive placement for earning capacity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house","/houses/10"]},{"claim":"Supporting the gains theme, Mercury (2nd lord of wealth) sits in the 11th, linking wealth to income networks; Venus (10th lord) also joins Sun in the 11th forming a raja-yoga conjunction relevant to status-based gains.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Venus/house","/yogas/4"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"'Guarantees enormous profits' is an absolute outcome claim; classical rules indicate support for gains, not guaranteed magnitude. The 11th also holds Ketu with the Sun-Venus conjunction aspected by Rahu/Moon, so gains indications are mixed in quality, not guaranteed.","evidence":["/placements/Ketu/house","/aspects/Rahu","/aspects/Moon"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"There is no doctrinal basis for treating the ascendant lord in the 11th as primarily a financial-loss indication; the 11th signifies gains (/reference/houseSignifications/11).","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/reference/houseSignifications/11"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only statement A is established: the lagna lord Sun occupies the natal 11th house of gains, which is traditionally read as supportive of earning capacity. Statement B overclaims by guaranteeing outcomes, and statement C contradicts standard doctrine. Hence conclusion polarity follows the single applicable statement A: supportive."}
```


Strong Dhana Yogas: Jupiter (lord of 2 and 11) conjunct Saturn (lagna lord) in the 11th house of gains, with Jupiter in Moolatrikona in its own sign

Raja Yoga: Venus rules both the 4th (kendra) and 9th (trikona) and sits in its own sign Libra in the 9th, conjunct Mercury — a classic wealth-and-fortune combination

Adhi Yoga from the Moon — benefics Jupiter, Venus, Mercury in the 6th/7th/8th from an exalted Moon — indicates prosperity and comfort

Exalted Moon in the 4th aspects the 10th, supporting steady income through career/public standing

Current Mercury mahadasha (2018–2035) runs a yogakaraka-type benefic placed in the 9th Raja Yoga conjunction, favorable for gains; Mercury–Jupiter period (2030–2032) activates the Dhana Yoga directly

2nd lord Jupiter well-placed but the 8th house (Sun there) is aspected by Mars and Saturn, indicating sudden expenses or transformation-linked financial events

Mars in enemy sign in the 5th (speculation) aspects the 11th and 12th — caution against speculative losses and elevated expenditure

Mercury–Mars antardasha (2026–2027) brings a malefic in enemy dignity into play during the gains-oriented mahadasha, suggesting volatile income phases

Explanation: The chart carries unusually strong wealth combinations: two Dhana Yogas via Jupiter-Saturn in the 11th, a kendra-trikona Raja Yoga through Venus in its own 9th with Mercury, and Adhi Yoga on an exalted Moon. The main cautions come from Mars (enemy sign, aspecting 11th/12th) affecting speculation and expenditure, and 8th-house afflictions to the Sun. Overall conclusion is supportive, with volatility expected around the Mercury–Mars antardasha and stronger consolidation likely in Mercury–Jupiter (2030–2032).


Strong dhana yogas: Jupiter (lord of 2 and 11) conjunct Saturn (lagna lord) in the 11th house of gains, directly linking wealth, income and self.

Raja yoga from Venus ruling both 4th (kendra) and 9th (trikona) as a single lord, placed in its own sign Libra in the 9th with Mercury — a powerful lakshmi-flavored fortune combination.

Venus–Mercury conjunction in house 9 forms a Raja yoga (4th lord + 5th lord), supporting fortune, learning-based income and accumulated resources.

Adhi Yoga — benefics Jupiter, Venus, Mercury in 6th/7th/8th from the Moon — classically indicates prosperity and comfort.

Mars–Saturn mutual aspect (10th lord + lagna lord) is a raja yoga supporting career-driven earnings.

Exalted Moon in the 4th aspecting the 10th supports contentment, property and stable livelihood.

2nd lord Jupiter in Moolatrikona in the 11th is strong for savings and fulfilment of desires.

Sun in the 8th (a dusthana) aspected by Mars and Saturn can bring sudden disruptions to shared resources or inheritance matters.

Mars, a malefic in enemy sign Gemini in the 5th, aspects houses 8, 11 and 12, adding volatility and expenditure pressure on gains and losses.

Rahu in the 7th (trade/partnerships) in enemy Leo suggests instability or unconventional dealings in partnership-based income.

Current Mercury mahadasha (2018–2035): Mercury rules the 5th and 8th and sits in the 9th with Venus — largely fortunate for wealth, though its 8th lordship ties gains to sudden events; Moon antardasha (to Jul 2026) has exalted Moon ruling the 6th, mixed for finances.

Explanation: The chart shows genuinely strong wealth combinations — multiple dhana and raja yogas anchored on the 11th-house Jupiter-Saturn conjunction and the Venus-Mercury pair in the 9th — offset by dusthana placements (Sun in 8th), a malefic Mars influencing gains/losses houses, and Rahu in the 7th affecting partnerships. Net reading: solid earning capacity and accumulation potential with periodic volatility, especially through partnerships and sudden events. Confidence moderate because no birth-time rectification or divisional confirmation beyond D1/D9 was applied.


Strong Dhana Yogas: Jupiter (lord of 2 and 11) conjunct Saturn (lagna lord) in the 11th house of gains, with Jupiter in Moolatrikona in its own sign

Raja Yoga: Venus rules both the 4th (kendra) and 9th (trikona) and sits in its own sign Libra in the 9th — a Lakshmi-sthana placement favoring fortune and accumulated wealth

Additional Raja Yoga: Venus (4th lord) conjunct Mercury (5th lord) in house 9 links kendra-trikona lords for prosperity

Adhi Yoga from the Moon — benefics Jupiter, Venus and Mercury occupy the 6th, 7th or 8th from the exalted Moon — classically indicates comfort and affluence

Mars–Saturn Raja Yoga (10th lord and lagna lord mutual aspect) supports earning capacity through career/status

Current Mercury mahadasha activates the 2nd-lord/8th-lord Mercury placed in the 9th with Venus — dasha lord is well-placed for wealth during 2018–2035

Mercury–Moon antardasha (2025-02 to 2026-07): Moon is exalted in the 4th as 6th lord; gains are likely but with expenses tied to home/family matters

Upcoming Mercury–Rahu (2027–2030): Rahu sits in the 7th in enemy dignity; partnerships and contracts could bring volatile or irregular financial outcomes

Sun in the 8th (as 7th lord) suggests income via spouse/partnership channels may involve sudden events or inheritance rather than steady flow; the 8th also receives aspects of Mars and Saturn

Lagna lord Saturn in the 11th supports gains but Saturn is neutral and Mars (a malefic) also aspects the 11th — gains may come slowly or after effort

Explanation: The chart carries multiple classical wealth yogas centered on the 9th and 11th houses: a strong Dhana Yoga (Jupiter-Saturn in the 11th), two Raja Yogas involving Venus and one linking Mars-Saturn, plus Adhi Yoga from an exalted Moon. The running Mercury mahadasha places a dignified 2nd/8th lord in the 9th at the helm, which favors wealth accumulation through 2035. Challenges are moderate rather than structural: Rahu in the 7th threatens volatility in the Mercury-Rahu antardasha (2027–2030), the Sun's 8th-house placement makes partnership-linked income uneven, and Mars' aspect on the 11th implies effortful rather than effortless gains. Overall conclusion: supportive, with timing-dependent fluctuations.


Explanation: The chart facts show the FIRST lord (Venus) placed in the SECOND house (/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse = 2), not the second lord in the first. Statements A-C all concern the second lord in the first, which is not what this chart shows; therefore none of A-C is established by the stated rule and chart.


Strong dhana yoga: Jupiter (lord of both 2nd and 11th) conjunct lagna-lord Saturn in the 11th house of gains — gains tied directly to self-effort and sustained accumulation.

11th lord Jupiter placed in its own sign/house (Sagittarius, moolatrikona) strengthens income networks and fulfilment of desires.

Raja yoga of Venus (4th & 9th lord) conjunct Mercury (5th lord) in the 9th house of fortune — luck, dharma-linked prosperity, and the current mahadasha lord (Mercury) sits inside this yoga, activating it through 2035.

Exalted Moon in the 4th aspecting the 10th supports property/assets and stable career-based earnings; Adhi Yoga (benefics 6th/7th/8th from Moon) indicates comfort and wealth.

Mars (10th lord) aspects the 11th and 12th houses — energetic pursuit of gains but also pressure toward expenditure and impulsive financial decisions.

Sun in the 8th (a dusthana) as 7th lord suggests partnership/contract-related volatility affecting finances; Rahu in the 7th reinforces irregularity in partnerships/trade.

Timing: Mercury mahadasha (2018–2035) runs the fortune-yoga lord; current Mercury–Moon antardasha (to 2026-07-29) links income to assets/home; subsequent Mercury–Rahu (from 2027-07-27) and Mercury–Saturn (2032–2035) periods bring higher-gain but more volatile phases given Rahu/Saturn placements.

The strong dhana yogas are partially offset by dusthana placement of the 7th lord (Sun in 8th) and Mars's aspect on the 12th; a synthesis citing only the yogas would overstate unqualified prosperity.

Navamsa dignity confirmation for Jupiter and Saturn beyond D9 sign listing (D9 shows Jupiter in Taurus/8th, Saturn in Virgo/12th — vargottama status not flagged)

Exact degrees of any applying/separating conjunction between Jupiter and Saturn within the 11th (both present at /placements/Jupiter and /placements/Saturn)

Second-house occupancy/aspects detail relevant to savings flow (house 2 empty, only Sun's aspect noted)

Explanation: Wealth indications are net supportive: a direct 2nd/11th-lord + lagna-lord dhana yoga in the 11th, an activated Venus–Mercury raja yoga in the 9th whose lord rules the running Mercury mahadasha, and an exalted Moon supporting asset base. Offsets are partnership volatility (Sun in 8th as 7th lord, Rahu in 7th) and Mars aspects on 11th/12th indicating gain-expenditure swings. Conclusion: supportive overall, with volatility around Mercury–Rahu (2027–2030) and Mercury–Saturn (2032–2035) sub-periods.


```json
{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-01-evidence-order","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.72,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Dhana Yoga: Jupiter (2nd & 11th lord) conjunct lagna lord Saturn in the 11th house of gains — a strong, doubly-validated wealth combination in its own house","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/3","/yogas/4","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"claim":"Jupiter is in Moolatrikona (Sagittarius), strengthening the dhana yoga; Jupiter aspects the 5th (speculation) and 7th (trade)","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/aspects/Jupiter"]},{"claim":"Raja Yoga: Venus (4th & 9th lord) and Mercury (5th lord) conjunct in the 9th house of fortune — Venus in own sign Libra, indicating wealth via dharma, higher learning, fortune","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/0","/placements/Venus/dignity","/houses/9"]},{"claim":"Adhi Yoga — Jupiter, Venus, Mercury in 6th/7th/8th from Moon — a classical prosperity combination","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/5"]},{"claim":"Current Mercury mahadasha (2018–2035) runs a 9th-lord dasha lord placed with yogakaraka-like Venus in the 9th; Mercury–Jupiter antardasha (2030–2032) activates the Dhana yoga directly","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha","/dasha/upcoming/2"]},{"claim":"Transit Jupiter retrograde in natal 5th (Gemini) aspecting houses 1, 9, 11 supports gains flows as of reference date","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/transits/contacts/4"]},{"claim":"Mars, karaka of drive but placed in enemy sign in the 5th (speculation) and aspecting 8th, 11th, 12th, can bring speculative losses and expenditure pressure on gains","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mars/dignity","/aspects/Mars"]},{"claim":"Saturn (lagna lord) in Purva Ashadha under Venus nakshatra is neutral in dignity and hemmed by Mars/Rahu influences on the 11th (Mars aspects 11th, Rahu aspects 11th), tempering gain stability","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/dignity","/houses/11/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"12th lord Saturn placed in 11th links income to expenditure channels; gains may flow through foreign/isolation-related or service contexts","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/12/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"omission","correction":"The strong Dhana yogas are partially offset by malefic influence on the 11th house (Mars and Rahu aspects per /houses/11/aspectedBy); a synthesis citing only yogas would overstate the promise.","evidence":["/houses/11/aspectedBy","/placements/Mars/dignity"]}],"missing_information":["Exact strength/vimshopaka bala values for Jupiter and Saturn","Natal Moon sign gochara confirmation of sade sati status beyond snapshot (currently SaturnFromMoon = 11, so no sade sati)","Arudha and argala computations not provided"],"rationale":"Wealth indications are strongly supportive at their core: a double-anchored Dhana Yoga (Jupiter as 2nd+11th lord conjunct lagna lord Saturn in the 11th itself, /yogas/3,/yogas/4) plus a Raja Yoga of Venus+Mercury in the fortunate 9th (/yogas/0) and Adhi Yoga (/yogas/5). The running Mercury mahadasha (a 9th-house occupant and 5th lord, /dasha/current/mahadasha) keeps these combinations active through 2035, with Mercury–Jupiter (2030–2032) the peak activation window (/dasha/upcoming/2). Friction points: Mars in enemy dignity in the 5th aspecting the 11th introduces speculation/expenditure risk (/placements/Mars/dignity,/aspects/Mars), and 12th lordship of Saturn ties income streams to outflow channels. Net reading: supportive, with discipline needed around speculative ventures and expense management."}
```


Explanation: The chart facts show the first lord (Venus) placed in the second house (/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse = 2), which is the reverse of the configuration described in statements A-C (second lord in the first). No chart fact establishes a second-lord-in-first placement, so none of A-C is applicable; D is selected.


Dhana Yoga: Jupiter (2nd and 11th lord) conjunct Saturn in the 11th house of gains — a direct, double wealth combination placed in the house it signifies

Jupiter is in Moolatrikona (Sagittarius), strengthening the Dhana Yoga; Saturn is the lagna lord disposited by Jupiter, tying self to gains

Raja Yoga: Venus (4th and 9th lord) conjunct Mercury (5th lord) in the 9th — fortune through trine lords, supporting prosperity via dharma, higher learning, luck

Venus in own sign Libra in the 9th is strong; Mercury in Swati (Rahu's nakshatra) links wealth to Rahu-flavoured/networked means

Adhi Yoga from Moon: benefics Jupiter, Venus, Mercury occupy the 6th/7th/8th from natal Moon — a classical prosperity/lordliness yoga

Moon exalted in Taurus in the 4th aspects the 10th — comfort, property, and career-linked affluence

Mars (10th lord) in enemy sign Gemini in the 5th, aspecting houses 8, 11 and 12 — earnings come with effort, speculation risk, expenditure and exposure to sudden/8th-house matters; Mars also aspects the Dhana Yoga cluster in the 11th, energising but agitating it

Sun (7th lord) debilitated-adjacent placement in Virgo in the 8th — partnership/trade income can be unstable or tied to others' resources, inheritance, or transformation events

Rahu in the 7th aspected by transiting nodes; Ketu on lagna — partnership dealings need care, though this is more trade than accumulation per se

Current Mercury mahadasha (to Jan 2035): Mercury is a 5th-lord Raja-Yoga partner in the 9th in Swati — dasha of a wealth-supportive graha. Mercury–Moon (to Jul 2026), then Mercury–Mars (mixed, Mars is 10th lord in enemy sign), Mercury–Rahu (2027–2030, volatile gains), Mercury–Jupiter (2030–2032, peak for the Dhana Yoga since Jupiter is its key planet), Mercury–Saturn (2032–2035)

Transits as of 2026-01-01: transit Jupiter retrograde in natal 5th conjunct natal Mars, aspecting natal 1st/9th/11th — supports the gains axis; transit Saturn in Pisces in natal 2nd (wealth house) aspects natal 4/8/11 — consolidating pressure on finances with discipline required

Saturn transiting 2nd is not sade-sati (saturnFromMoon=11).

A synthesis citing only the Dhana Yogas would overstate ease; Mars's 12th-house aspect and Sun in the 8th indicate leakage and dependency on others' money that must be reconciled against the strong yogas.

Navamsa strength of Jupiter/Saturn relative to D1 (D9 shows Jupiter in 8th of navamsa, Venus in 8th — some inner weakening of yoga planets worth weighing)

Ashtakavarga bindus for houses 2 and 11 to grade promise magnitude

Specific question timeframe (accumulation vs income vs inheritance)

Explanation: Wealth promise is genuinely strong: a double Dhana Yoga (2nd+11th lord Jupiter with lagna lord Saturn in the 11th), a Venus–Mercury Raja Yoga in the 9th with Venus in own sign, exalted Moon aspecting the 10th, and Adhi Yoga from the Moon. The current Mercury mahadasha runs a Raja-Yoga partner well-placed in the 9th until early 2035, with Mercury–Jupiter (2030–2032) the strongest sub-period for gains. Offsetting factors are Mars (10th lord) in an enemy sign aspecting the 12th, and Sun (7th lord) in the 8th — indicating effortful earnings, expenditure leaks, and instability in trade/partnership income rather than weak overall capacity. Net reading: supportive, with volatility around partnerships and speculative ventures.


Explanation: The chart facts show the FIRST lord (Venus) placed in the SECOND house (/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse), not the second lord in the first. Statements A-C all concern a 'second lord in the first' configuration, which is not present; therefore none is established, and D applies.