{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-knowledge-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-knowledge-01","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"rationale":"The rule name SaturnIn7thNotLagnaLord indicates that Saturn placed in the 7th house is a challenging indication for marriage when it does not own the ascendant (or 7th). Option A states exactly this. B overclaims by guaranteeing divorce; C inverts the condition by dropping the ownership exception."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-knowledge-01\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"confidence\":0.9,\"rationale\":\"The rule name SaturnIn7thNotLagnaLord indicates that Saturn placed in the 7th house is a challenging indication for marriage when it does not own the ascendant (or 7th). Option A states exactly this. B overclaims by guaranteeing divorce; C inverts the condition by dropping the ownership exception.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-application-02","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-02","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the seventh house, the house of marriage","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the seventh is not wholly beneficial; classical treatment acknowledges both stabilizing and restrictive effects.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the seventh does not necessarily end a marriage; it indicates delay, seriousness, or coldness at most.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart fact /placements/Saturn/house = 7 confirms Saturn in the seventh. Statement A correctly reflects the standard mixed reading (stability with emotional coldness); B overclaims benefit; C overclaims a deterministic negative outcome. Conclusion follows the polarity of applicable statement A: mixed."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-02\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.85,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies the seventh house, the house of marriage\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn in the seventh is not wholly beneficial; classical treatment acknowledges both stabilizing and restrictive effects.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn in the seventh does not necessarily end a marriage; it indicates delay, seriousness, or coldness at most.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart fact /placements/Saturn/house = 7 confirms Saturn in the seventh. Statement A correctly reflects the standard mixed reading (stability with emotional coldness); B overclaims benefit; C overclaims a deterministic negative outcome. Conclusion follows the polarity of applicable statement A: mixed.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-knowledge-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-knowledge-01","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"rationale":"The rule SaturnIn7thNotLagnaLord indicates that Saturn placed in the seventh house, when it is not the lord of the ascendant (and per option A's phrasing, neither of ascendant nor seventh), is read as a challenging indication for marital happiness. Option A restates this correctly. Option B overclaims by asserting a guaranteed divorce, which no such rule establishes. Option C contradicts the rule's own condition, since the exception/qualification depends on Saturn NOT ruling those houses; if it did rule them, the rule would not apply as stated."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-knowledge-01\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"confidence\":0.85,\"rationale\":\"The rule SaturnIn7thNotLagnaLord indicates that Saturn placed in the seventh house, when it is not the lord of the ascendant (and per option A's phrasing, neither of ascendant nor seventh), is read as a challenging indication for marital happiness. Option A restates this correctly. Option B overclaims by asserting a guaranteed divorce, which no such rule establishes. Option C contradicts the rule's own condition, since the exception/qualification depends on Saturn NOT ruling those houses; if it did rule them, the rule would not apply as stated.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-application-02","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-02","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the seventh house, the house of marriage, indicating a mixed influence: potential stability tempered by coldness or delay.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the seventh is not wholly beneficial; classical treatment views it as mixed (stability with emotional distance/delay).","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the seventh does not necessarily end a marriage; it is a mixed indication, not a categorical one.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart shows Saturn in the seventh house (/placements/Saturn/house). Statement A correctly reflects the standard doctrinal reading of this placement as mixed—stability alongside emotional coldness or delay. Statements B and C overclaim in opposite directions and are not established."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-02\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.9,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies the seventh house, the house of marriage, indicating a mixed influence: potential stability tempered by coldness or delay.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn in the seventh is not wholly beneficial; classical treatment views it as mixed (stability with emotional distance/delay).\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn in the seventh does not necessarily end a marriage; it is a mixed indication, not a categorical one.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart shows Saturn in the seventh house (/placements/Saturn/house). Statement A correctly reflects the standard doctrinal reading of this placement as mixed—stability alongside emotional coldness or delay. Statements B and C overclaim in opposite directions and are not established.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-application-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-01","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the seventh house, a classic challenging indication for marital happiness when it does not rule the ascendant or the seventh.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/houses/6/lord","/houses/7/lord","/houses/0/sign"]},{"claim":"The exception (which requires Saturn to rule lagna or the seventh) cannot apply: Saturn rules Capricorn and Aquarius, i.e. houses 10 and 11, not houses 1 or 7.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/sign","/houses/9/lord","/houses/10/lord"]},{"claim":"Mitigating context: Saturn is exalted in Libra in the seventh, forming Sasa Yoga; this softens but does not negate the rule-based challenge.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/dignity","/yogas/1"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the seventh never guarantees divorce; classical doctrine treats it as an affliction to be judged with dignity, aspects, and dasha context. Here Saturn is even exalted forming Sasa Yoga.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/dignity","/yogas/1"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The exception explicitly requires Saturn to rule the ascendant or the seventh; here it rules houses 10 and 11 only, so the exception does not apply.","evidence":["/houses/6/lord","/houses/7/lord"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Statement A is established: natal Saturn sits in house 7 (/placements/Saturn/house) while ruling Capricorn and Aquarius — houses 10 and 11 (/houses/9/lord,/houses/10/lord), neither the ascendant (Aries) nor the seventh (Libra). Hence the exception fails and A's rule applies as a challenging indication. B is an overclaim contradicted by Saturn's exaltation and Sasa Yoga; C misstates the exception's condition."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-01\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"challenging\",\"confidence\":0.9,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies the seventh house, a classic challenging indication for marital happiness when it does not rule the ascendant or the seventh.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/houses/7/lord\",\"/houses/0/sign\"]},{\"claim\":\"The exception (which requires Saturn to rule lagna or the seventh) cannot apply: Saturn rules Capricorn and Aquarius, i.e. houses 10 and 11, not houses 1 or 7.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/sign\",\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/10/lord\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mitigating context: Saturn is exalted in Libra in the seventh, forming Sasa Yoga; this softens but does not negate the rule-based challenge.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/yogas/1\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn in the seventh never guarantees divorce; classical doctrine treats it as an affliction to be judged with dignity, aspects, and dasha context. Here Saturn is even exalted forming Sasa Yoga.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The exception explicitly requires Saturn to rule the ascendant or the seventh; here it rules houses 10 and 11 only, so the exception does not apply.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/houses/7/lord\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Statement A is established: natal Saturn sits in house 7 (/placements/Saturn/house) while ruling Capricorn and Aquarius — houses 10 and 11 (/houses/9/lord,/houses/10/lord), neither the ascendant (Aries) nor the seventh (Libra). Hence the exception fails and A's rule applies as a challenging indication. B is an overclaim contradicted by Saturn's exaltation and Sasa Yoga; C misstates the exception's condition.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-application-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-01","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn is placed in the seventh house (Libra) and rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh house, so the stated rule classifies it as a challenging indication for marital happiness.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/lagna/lord"]},{"claim":"Saturn in the seventh does not categorically guarantee divorce; exaltation in Libra with Sasa Yoga shows strength and dignity rather than a fixed negative outcome.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/dignity","/yogas"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn's placement in the seventh indicates challenge to marital harmony per the rule, but no chart factor guarantees divorce.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The challenging reading applies precisely because Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh; there is no exception when this condition holds.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/signIndex","/houses/1/lord","/houses/7/lord"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Saturn occupies the natal 7th (/placements/Saturn/house) while Mars rules the lagna (/lagna/lord) and Venus rules the 7th (/houses/7/lord); since Saturn rules neither, option A's rule applies and yields a challenging indication for marriage. Option B is an unsupported absolute claim, and option C reverses the rule's condition. Mitigating context: Saturn is exalted in its own sign of exaltation forming Sasa Yoga (/placements/Saturn/dignity,/yogas), so difficulty, delay, or seriousness in marriage is indicated rather than categorical failure."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-01\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"challenging\",\"confidence\":0.85,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn is placed in the seventh house (Libra) and rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh house, so the stated rule classifies it as a challenging indication for marital happiness.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/lagna/lord\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn in the seventh does not categorically guarantee divorce; exaltation in Libra with Sasa Yoga shows strength and dignity rather than a fixed negative outcome.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/yogas\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn's placement in the seventh indicates challenge to marital harmony per the rule, but no chart factor guarantees divorce.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The challenging reading applies precisely because Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh; there is no exception when this condition holds.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/signIndex\",\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/7/lord\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Saturn occupies the natal 7th (/placements/Saturn/house) while Mars rules the lagna (/lagna/lord) and Venus rules the 7th (/houses/7/lord); since Saturn rules neither, option A's rule applies and yields a challenging indication for marriage. Option B is an unsupported absolute claim, and option C reverses the rule's condition. Mitigating context: Saturn is exalted in its own sign of exaltation forming Sasa Yoga (/placements/Saturn/dignity,/yogas), so difficulty, delay, or seriousness in marriage is indicated rather than categorical failure.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-application-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-01","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the seventh house while ruling neither the ascendant nor the seventh house — its lordships are Capricorn (10th) and Aquarius (11th), lagna lord is Mars (/lagna/lordInHouse = 3) and seventh lord is Venus (/placements/Venus/house = 1). Statement A therefore applies.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/houses/6/lord","/houses/9/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"claim":"Statement B ('guarantees divorce') is an overclaim; no astrological placement guarantees a specific outcome such as divorce.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"claim":"Statement C inverts the rule's own condition: the exception requires Saturn to rule the ascendant or the seventh, which is not the case here (/houses/6/lord = Venus, /houses/9/lord = Jupiter).","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/houses/6/lord","/houses/9/lord"]},{"claim":"Mitigating context exists but does not negate statement A: Saturn is exalted forming Sasa Yoga (/yogas[1]), and Venus from the lagna aspects the seventh (/aspects/Venus = [7]); however, the task restricts conclusion to applicable listed statements only.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/yogas/1/because","/aspects/Venus","/placements/Saturn/dignity"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"A placement cannot guarantee divorce; classical indications are at most adverse or favourable tendencies.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The exception applies only when Saturn rules the ascendant or the seventh; here Saturn rules the 10th and 11th houses.","evidence":["/houses/9/lord","/houses/10/lord","/placements/Saturn/signIndex"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart facts show Saturn in the seventh house (/placements/Saturn/house) with lordship of the 10th and 11th houses only, so neither the ascendant nor the seventh is ruled by Saturn. The conditional rule in statement A is therefore triggered, making it the sole applicable option; B is an overclaim and C contradicts the rule's stated condition. Per instruction, the conclusion takes the polarity of the applicable statement (challenging). Note that exaltation (Sasa Yoga) and Venus's aspect on the seventh are real mitigations in the chart, but they do not fall within the listed statements."},"extracted":"{\n \"case_id\": \"marriage-application-01\",\n \"domain\": \"marriage\",\n \"conclusion\": \"challenging\",\n \"confidence\": 0.85,\n \"selected_option_ids\": [\"A\"],\n \"factors\": [\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Saturn occupies the seventh house while ruling neither the ascendant nor the seventh house — its lordships are Capricorn (10th) and Aquarius (11th), lagna lord is Mars (/lagna/lordInHouse = 3) and seventh lord is Venus (/placements/Venus/house = 1). Statement A therefore applies.\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Saturn/house\", \"/houses/6/lord\", \"/houses/9/lord\", \"/lagna/lordInHouse\", \"/placements/Venus/house\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Statement B ('guarantees divorce') is an overclaim; no astrological placement guarantees a specific outcome such as divorce.\",\n   \"effect\": \"neutral\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Statement C inverts the rule's own condition: the exception requires Saturn to rule the ascendant or the seventh, which is not the case here (/houses/6/lord = Venus, /houses/9/lord = Jupiter).\",\n   \"effect\": \"neutral\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/houses/6/lord\", \"/houses/9/lord\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Mitigating context exists but does not negate statement A: Saturn is exalted forming Sasa Yoga (/yogas[1]), and Venus from the lagna aspects the seventh (/aspects/Venus = [7]); however, the task restricts conclusion to applicable listed statements only.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/1/because\", \"/aspects/Venus\", \"/placements/Saturn/dignity\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"contradictions\": [\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"B\",\n   \"error_type\": \"overclaim\",\n   \"correction\": \"A placement cannot guarantee divorce; classical indications are at most adverse or favourable tendencies.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"C\",\n   \"error_type\": \"doctrinal\",\n   \"correction\": \"The exception applies only when Saturn rules the ascendant or the seventh; here Saturn rules the 10th and 11th houses.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/houses/9/lord\", \"/houses/10/lord\", \"/placements/Saturn/signIndex\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"missing_information\": [],\n \"rationale\": \"The chart facts show Saturn in the seventh house (/placements/Saturn/house) with lordship of the 10th and 11th houses only, so neither the ascendant nor the seventh is ruled by Saturn. The conditional rule in statement A is therefore triggered, making it the sole applicable option; B is an overclaim and C contradicts the rule's stated condition. Per instruction, the conclusion takes the polarity of the applicable statement (challenging). Note that exaltation (Sasa Yoga) and Venus's aspect on the seventh are real mitigations in the chart, but they do not fall within the listed statements.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-knowledge-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-knowledge-01","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"rationale":"The rule name 'SaturnIn7thNotLagnaLord' indicates that Saturn placed in the seventh house, when it is not the lord of the ascendant (lagna), is treated as a challenging indication for marriage. Option A restates this correctly (adding the seventh-lord exclusion, consistent with the rule's intent). Option B overclaims by asserting a guaranteed divorce, which no such rule establishes. Option C inverts the rule's condition — the exception applies only when Saturn does rule the lagna or seventh, not when it rules neither."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-knowledge-01\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"confidence\":0.85,\"rationale\":\"The rule name 'SaturnIn7thNotLagnaLord' indicates that Saturn placed in the seventh house, when it is not the lord of the ascendant (lagna), is treated as a challenging indication for marriage. Option A restates this correctly (adding the seventh-lord exclusion, consistent with the rule's intent). Option B overclaims by asserting a guaranteed divorce, which no such rule establishes. Option C inverts the rule's condition — the exception applies only when Saturn does rule the lagna or seventh, not when it rules neither.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-application-02","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-02","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the seventh house, the house of marriage, indicating a mixed influence: stability and endurance may coexist with delay or emotional coldness.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the seventh is not wholly beneficial; classical treatment views it as a mixed malefic-benefic influence on marriage.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the seventh does not necessarily end a marriage; it is a mixed indication, not a categorical one.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart fact /placements/Saturn/house = 7 confirms Saturn in the seventh house. Statement A correctly captures the traditional mixed reading (stability with coldness/delay), so it is selected. B overclaims benefit and C overclaims dissolution; both are rejected. The conclusion polarity follows the applicable statement A: mixed."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-02\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.85,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies the seventh house, the house of marriage, indicating a mixed influence: stability and endurance may coexist with delay or emotional coldness.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn in the seventh is not wholly beneficial; classical treatment views it as a mixed malefic-benefic influence on marriage.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn in the seventh does not necessarily end a marriage; it is a mixed indication, not a categorical one.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart fact /placements/Saturn/house = 7 confirms Saturn in the seventh house. Statement A correctly captures the traditional mixed reading (stability with coldness/delay), so it is selected. B overclaims benefit and C overclaims dissolution; both are rejected. The conclusion polarity follows the applicable statement A: mixed.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-application-03","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-03","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Mars and Venus are conjunct in the seventh house, matching the passionate-partnership indication in statement A.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Venus/house","/houses/6"]},{"claim":"Statement B is not applicable: Mars is not alone in the seventh; Venus occupies the same sign Libra.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/houses/6/occupants"]},{"claim":"Statement C is an overclaim — a Mars–Venus conjunction does not guarantee compatibility; the chart also shows Ketu aspecting the seventh and Venus in D9 placed in the 11th with dispositor Mars.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/6/aspectedBy","/vargas/D9/placements"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only statement A is established: both /placements/Mars/house and /placements/Venus/house equal 7 (Libra), so the conjunction condition holds and A's 'strong passion' indication applies. B fails because Mars is not alone (/houses/6/occupants includes both). C is rejected as an overclaim since no rule guarantees outcomes. With only the supportive statement A applicable, conclusion polarity is supportive."},"extracted":"{\n \"case_id\": \"marriage-application-03\",\n \"domain\": \"marriage\",\n \"conclusion\": \"supportive\",\n \"confidence\": 0.9,\n \"selected_option_ids\": [\"A\"],\n \"factors\": [\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Mars and Venus are conjunct in the seventh house, matching the passionate-partnership indication in statement A.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mars/house\", \"/placements/Venus/house\", \"/houses/6\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Statement B is not applicable: Mars is not alone in the seventh; Venus occupies the same sign Libra.\",\n   \"effect\": \"neutral\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/houses/6/occupants\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Statement C is an overclaim — a Mars–Venus conjunction does not guarantee compatibility; the chart also shows Ketu aspecting the seventh and Venus in D9 placed in the 11th with dispositor Mars.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\", \"/vargas/D9/placements\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"contradictions\": [],\n \"missing_information\": [],\n \"rationale\": \"Only statement A is established: both /placements/Mars/house and /placements/Venus/house equal 7 (Libra), so the conjunction condition holds and A's 'strong passion' indication applies. B fails because Mars is not alone (/houses/6/occupants includes both). C is rejected as an overclaim since no rule guarantees outcomes. With only the supportive statement A applicable, conclusion polarity is supportive.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-application-03","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":false,"error":"JSON Parse error: Expected '}'","extracted":"{\n  \"case_id\": \"marriage-application-03\",\n  \"domain\": \"marriage\",\n  \"conclusion\": \"supportive\",\n  \"confidence\": 0.9,\n  \"selected_option_ids\": [\"A\"],\n  \"factors\": [\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Mars and Venus are conjunct in the seventh house, matching the classical indication of strong passion in partnership; Venus is additionally in its own sign Libra forming Malavya Yoga.\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mars/house\", \"/placements/Venus/house\", \"/placements/Venus/dignity\", \"/yogas/0\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Statement B fails: Mars is not alone in the seventh — Venus occupies the same house.\",\n      \"effect\": \"neutral\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/houses/6/occupants\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Statement C overclaims: the conjunction indicates passion, not guaranteed compatibility; Ketu also aspects the seventh, a complicating factor for partnership harmony.\",\n      \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\", \"/aspects/Ketu\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"contradictions\": [\n    {\n      \"statement_id\": \"B\",\n      \"error_type\": \"factual\",\n      \"correction\": \"Mars does not stand alone in the seventh; Venus (21°10'37\" Libra) is conjunct with Mars (20°09'56\" Libra) there.\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/houses/6/occupants\", \"/placements/Venus/house\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"statement_id\": \"C\",\n      \"error_type\": \"overclaim\",\n      \"correction\": \"The Mars–Venus combination indicates passion/intensity in partnership, but no rule guarantees compatibility; Ketu's aspect on the seventh adds an element of detachment or disruption.\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\", \"/yogas/3\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"missing_information\": [],\n  \"rationale\": \"Only statement A is established: /placements/Mars and /placements/Venus both show house 7 in Libra, with Venus in own sign (Malavya Yoga per /yogas/0), supporting the 'strong passion in partnership' reading. B is factually false because Venus shares the house. C is an overclaim since the rule speaks to passion, not assured compatibility, and Ketu aspects the seventh (/houses/6/aspectedBy). The applicable listed statement is positive in polarity, hence conclusion 'supportive'.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-application-03","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-03","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Mars and Venus are conjunct in the 7th house (Libra), the classical passionate-partnership combination; Venus is in own sign and forms Malavya Yoga, while Ketu also aspects the 7th, tempering but not nullifying it.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/dignity","/houses/6/occupants"]},{"claim":"The conjunction is a Raja/Dhana yoga pairing 1st and 7th lords in the 7th — supportive of partnership, but no guarantee of compatibility.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/yogas"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"factual","correction":"Mars is not alone in the 7th; Venus occupies the same house.","evidence":["/houses/6/occupants"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"No rule guarantees compatibility; Mars-Venus in the 7th is only an indication of strong passion, with Ketu's aspect on the 7th adding complexity to marital harmony.","evidence":["/aspects/Ketu"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Statement A applies: /placements/Mars/house = 7 and /placements/Venus/house = 7 show Mars-Venus together in the 7th, traditionally read as strong passion in partnership. B fails because Mars is not alone (/houses/6/occupants includes both). C fails as an overclaim — the yoga supports partnership strength (Malavya Yoga, /vargas/D9/placements Venus in Aries 11) but cannot guarantee compatibility. Hence conclusion polarity of applicable statements: mixed."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-03\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.9,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Mars and Venus are conjunct in the 7th house (Libra), the classical passionate-partnership combination; Venus is in own sign and forms Malavya Yoga, while Ketu also aspects the 7th, tempering but not nullifying it.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/houses/6/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"The conjunction is a Raja/Dhana yoga pairing 1st and 7th lords in the 7th — supportive of partnership, but no guarantee of compatibility.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Mars is not alone in the 7th; Venus occupies the same house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/occupants\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"No rule guarantees compatibility; Mars-Venus in the 7th is only an indication of strong passion, with Ketu's aspect on the 7th adding complexity to marital harmony.\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Ketu\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Statement A applies: /placements/Mars/house = 7 and /placements/Venus/house = 7 show Mars-Venus together in the 7th, traditionally read as strong passion in partnership. B fails because Mars is not alone (/houses/6/occupants includes both). C fails as an overclaim — the yoga supports partnership strength (Malavya Yoga, /vargas/D9/placements Venus in Aries 11) but cannot guarantee compatibility. Hence conclusion polarity of applicable statements: mixed.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-application-04","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-04","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Jupiter occupies the natal 7th house (Leo), which the stated rule treats as supporting a considerate spouse and gains through marriage.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Jupiter is in a friend's sign with benefic status, reinforcing its capacity to act supportively in the 7th.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic"]},{"claim":"The 7th house is simultaneously aspected by Saturn and Ketu, tempering — but not negating — the supportive indication of Jupiter's placement.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/6/aspectedBy","/aspects/Saturn","/aspects/Ketu"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Jupiter in the seventh is classically a benefic placement for marriage, not a primary indication of marital conflict.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"No single placement 'guarantees' a perfect spouse; Jupiter's presence is supportive at most, and Saturn/Ketu aspects on the 7th qualify it.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/aspects/Saturn","/aspects/Ketu"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Statement A is directly established by the chart facts (/placements/Jupiter/house = 7). Statements B and C are doctrinally wrong or overclaimed, so they are not selected. With only statement A applicable and supportive, the conclusion polarity is supportive."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-04\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.85,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Jupiter occupies the natal 7th house (Leo), which the stated rule treats as supporting a considerate spouse and gains through marriage.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter is in a friend's sign with benefic status, reinforcing its capacity to act supportively in the 7th.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 7th house is simultaneously aspected by Saturn and Ketu, tempering — but not negating — the supportive indication of Jupiter's placement.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Saturn\",\"/aspects/Ketu\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Jupiter in the seventh is classically a benefic placement for marriage, not a primary indication of marital conflict.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"No single placement 'guarantees' a perfect spouse; Jupiter's presence is supportive at most, and Saturn/Ketu aspects on the 7th qualify it.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/aspects/Saturn\",\"/aspects/Ketu\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Statement A is directly established by the chart facts (/placements/Jupiter/house = 7). Statements B and C are doctrinally wrong or overclaimed, so they are not selected. With only statement A applicable and supportive, the conclusion polarity is supportive.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-application-04","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-04","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Jupiter occupies the 7th house of spouse/partnership","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Jupiter is a natural benefic in friendly dignity in the 7th","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/dignity"]},{"claim":"Jupiter is aspected by Saturn and Ketu in the 7th, tempering but not negating its benefic promise","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/6/aspectedBy"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Jupiter is a benefic; classical doctrine treats it in the 7th as favorable to marriage, not as a primary indication of conflict. The chart's 7th-house afflictions come from Saturn's aspect and Ketu's aspect/conjunction, not Jupiter.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/aspects/Saturn","/aspects/Ketu"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"No single placement 'guarantees' anything; the same 7th house receives Saturn and Ketu aspects, so indications are mixed rather than perfect.","evidence":["/aspects/Saturn","/aspects/Ketu","/houses/6/aspectedBy"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only statement A matches both the rule (benefic Jupiter in the 7th favors a considerate partner and gains through marriage) and the chart (/placements/Jupiter/house = 7, dignity Friend). B misstates classical doctrine, and C overclaims certainty. Supporting evidence includes the D9, where Venus sits in Scorpio in the 11th with Ketu — mixed inner-marriage signals — so confidence is not absolute. Conclusion polarity follows the sole applicable statement: supportive."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-04\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.85,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Jupiter occupies the 7th house of spouse/partnership\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter is a natural benefic in friendly dignity in the 7th\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter is aspected by Saturn and Ketu in the 7th, tempering but not negating its benefic promise\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Jupiter is a benefic; classical doctrine treats it in the 7th as favorable to marriage, not as a primary indication of conflict. The chart's 7th-house afflictions come from Saturn's aspect and Ketu's aspect/conjunction, not Jupiter.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/aspects/Saturn\",\"/aspects/Ketu\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"No single placement 'guarantees' anything; the same 7th house receives Saturn and Ketu aspects, so indications are mixed rather than perfect.\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Saturn\",\"/aspects/Ketu\",\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only statement A matches both the rule (benefic Jupiter in the 7th favors a considerate partner and gains through marriage) and the chart (/placements/Jupiter/house = 7, dignity Friend). B misstates classical doctrine, and C overclaims certainty. Supporting evidence includes the D9, where Venus sits in Scorpio in the 11th with Ketu — mixed inner-marriage signals — so confidence is not absolute. Conclusion polarity follows the sole applicable statement: supportive.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-application-04","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-04","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Jupiter occupies the seventh house, supporting the classical reading of a considerate spouse and gains through marriage.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/houses/6"]},{"claim":"Jupiter in the seventh aspected by Saturn and Ketu adds tempering/complication to the marriage indications.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/6/aspectedBy","/aspects/Saturn","/aspects/Ketu"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"factual","correction":"Jupiter is a natural benefic; its placement in the seventh is traditionally read as favorable to the spouse's character, not a primary indication of marital conflict.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"No single placement guarantees a perfect spouse; Jupiter's condition here is further modified by aspects of Saturn and Ketu on the seventh house.","evidence":["/houses/6/aspectedBy"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"omission","correction":"Statement A is established by the rule and chart (Jupiter in the seventh), so D does not hold.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart facts place Jupiter in Leo, whole-sign seventh house from the Aquarius lagna (/placements/Jupiter/house = 7). Classical doctrine treats Jupiter, a natural benefic, in the seventh as indicating a wise, considerate partner and benefit through partnership — statement A. Statement B contradicts this doctrine, and statement C overstates it into a guarantee; both are rejected. The seventh also receives Saturn's and Ketu's aspects (/houses/6/aspectedBy), so support is qualified rather than absolute, but only listed statements determine polarity, giving a supportive conclusion."},"extracted":"{\n  \"case_id\": \"marriage-application-04\",\n  \"domain\": \"marriage\",\n  \"conclusion\": \"supportive\",\n  \"confidence\": 0.85,\n  \"selected_option_ids\": [\"A\"],\n  \"factors\": [\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Jupiter occupies the seventh house, supporting the classical reading of a considerate spouse and gains through marriage.\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Jupiter/house\", \"/houses/6\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Jupiter in the seventh aspected by Saturn and Ketu adds tempering/complication to the marriage indications.\",\n      \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\", \"/aspects/Saturn\", \"/aspects/Ketu\"],\n      \"note\": \"contextual only; not among the listed statements\"\n    }\n  ],\n  \"contradictions\": [\n    {\n      \"statement_id\": \"B\",\n      \"error_type\": \"factual\",\n      \"correction\": \"Jupiter is a natural benefic; its placement in the seventh is traditionally read as favorable to the spouse's character, not a primary indication of marital conflict.\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Jupiter/house\", \"/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"statement_id\": \"C\",\n      \"error_type\": \"overclaim\",\n      \"correction\": \"No single placement guarantees a perfect spouse; Jupiter's condition here is further modified by aspects of Saturn and Ketu on the seventh house.\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"statement_id\": \"D\",\n      \"error_type\": \"omission\",\n      \"correction\": \"Statement A is established by the rule and chart (Jupiter in the seventh), so D does not hold.\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"missing_information\": [],\n  \"rationale\": \"The chart facts place Jupiter in Leo, whole-sign seventh house from the Aquarius lagna (/placements/Jupiter/house = 7). Classical doctrine treats Jupiter, a natural benefic, in the seventh as indicating a wise, considerate partner and benefit through partnership — statement A. Statement B contradicts this doctrine, and statement C overstates it into a guarantee; both are rejected. The seventh also receives Saturn's and Ketu's aspects (/houses/6/aspectedBy), so support is qualified rather than absolute, but only listed statements determine polarity, giving a supportive conclusion.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-contradiction-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-contradiction-01","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.95,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Mars in the seventh is treated as an indication of clashes or tension in married life (Manglik/Kuja dosha consideration).","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/houses/7"]},{"claim":"Mars in the seventh being unambiguously harmonious is an overclaim/doctrinal error.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house"]},{"claim":"Mars occupies house 7, not house 8 (house 8 holds Jupiter and Ketu).","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Ketu/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Mars in the seventh is classically read as Manglik/Kuja dosha — a malefic placement indicating clashes, aggression, or tension in marriage, not 'unambiguously harmonious'. It is also vargottama (Mars in Taurus in D1 and D9), and in the D9 it falls in the 6th with Saturn/Rahu, further coloring marital indications as mixed rather than clearly favorable.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/sign","/vargottama","/vargas/D9/placements/2"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Mars occupies house 7 (Taurus), not house 8. House 8 contains Jupiter and Ketu.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/sign","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Ketu/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is doctrinally sound: natal Mars sits in the 7th house (/placements/Mars/house = 7), which is the textbook Manglik configuration associated with marital friction. S2 directly contradicts this classical reading and is an overclaim. S3 misstates Mars's house; the chart places Mars in Taurus, house 7, while Jupiter and Ketu occupy house 8."},"extracted":"{\n \"case_id\": \"marriage-contradiction-01\",\n \"domain\": \"marriage\",\n \"conclusion\": \"mixed\",\n \"confidence\": 0.95,\n \"selected_option_ids\": [],\n \"factors\": [\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Mars in the seventh is treated as an indication of clashes or tension in married life (Manglik/Kuja dosha consideration).\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mars/house\", \"/houses/7\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Mars in the seventh being unambiguously harmonious is an overclaim/doctrinal error.\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mars/house\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Mars occupies house 7, not house 8 (house 8 holds Jupiter and Ketu).\",\n   \"effect\": \"neutral\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mars/house\", \"/placements/Jupiter/house\", \"/placements/Ketu/house\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"contradictions\": [\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"S2\",\n   \"error_type\": \"overclaim\",\n   \"correction\": \"Mars in the seventh is classically read as Manglik/Kuja dosha — a malefic placement indicating clashes, aggression, or tension in marriage, not 'unambiguously harmonious'. It is also vargottama (Mars in Taurus in D1 and D9), and in the D9 it falls in the 6th with Saturn/Rahu, further coloring marital indications as mixed rather than clearly favorable.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mars/house\", \"/placements/Mars/sign\", \"/vargottama\", \"/vargas/D9/placements/2\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"S3\",\n   \"error_type\": \"factual\",\n   \"correction\": \"Mars occupies house 7 (Taurus), not house 8. House 8 contains Jupiter and Ketu.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mars/house\", \"/placements/Mars/sign\", \"/placements/Jupiter/house\", \"/placements/Ketu/house\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"missing_information\": [],\n \"rationale\": \"S1 is doctrinally sound: natal Mars sits in the 7th house (/placements/Mars/house = 7), which is the textbook Manglik configuration associated with marital friction. S2 directly contradicts this classical reading and is an overclaim. S3 misstates Mars's house; the chart places Mars in Taurus, house 7, while Jupiter and Ketu occupy house 8.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-contradiction-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-contradiction-01","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.95,"selected_option_ids":["S2","S3"],"factors":[{"claim":"Mars in the seventh is traditionally read as an indication of friction or clashes in married life (Kuja/Mangal consideration)","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/sign"]},{"claim":"Mars actually occupies the 7th house in Taurus, not the 8th","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Mars in the 7th is classically treated as a source of tension/clashes in marriage (Mangal dosha consideration), not as unambiguously harmonious. S2 directly reverses the accepted reading.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/houses/7"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Mars occupies house 7 (Taurus, Rohini), not house 8. House 8 holds Jupiter and Ketu.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/sign","/houses/8/occupants"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is accurate: Mars sits in the natal 7th (/placements/Mars/house), which tradition reads as an indicator of marital friction. S2 is a doctrinal reversal of that reading. S3 is factually wrong about Mars's house placement."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-contradiction-01\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.95,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"S2\",\"S3\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Mars in the seventh is traditionally read as an indication of friction or clashes in married life (Kuja/Mangal consideration)\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/sign\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars actually occupies the 7th house in Taurus, not the 8th\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Mars in the 7th is classically treated as a source of tension/clashes in marriage (Mangal dosha consideration), not as unambiguously harmonious. S2 directly reverses the accepted reading.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/houses/7\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Mars occupies house 7 (Taurus, Rohini), not house 8. House 8 holds Jupiter and Ketu.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/sign\",\"/houses/8/occupants\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S1 is accurate: Mars sits in the natal 7th (/placements/Mars/house), which tradition reads as an indicator of marital friction. S2 is a doctrinal reversal of that reading. S3 is factually wrong about Mars's house placement.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-contradiction-02","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":false,"error":"✖ Invalid input: expected number, received undefined\n  → at confidence","extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-contradiction-02\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The Sun in the 7th house is at most an indication of delay, friction or a strong-willed spouse in classical doctrine; it never 'guarantees' that marriage never occurs. Here the Sun is exalted (/placements/Sun/dignity: Exalted), which substantially softens the indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Sun/dignity\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"The Sun occupies the 7th house (Aries), not the 8th; it is exalted there and aspects the lagna.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Sun/sign\"]}],\"rationale\":\"S1 is doctrinally acceptable as stated. S2 overstates the classical reading into an absolute guarantee contradicted by the exalted status of the Sun. S3 misreports the Sun's house placement.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-contradiction-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-contradiction-01","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.95,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Mars in the seventh is traditionally read as Mangal/Kuja Dosha-type friction in marriage; this is a valid statement.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/houses/7/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Mars in the 7th is not unambiguously harmonious; classical Parashari doctrine treats malefic Mars in the kendra of marriage as an indication of clashes or tension in married life (Kuja Dosha), though its full effect depends on dignity, aspects, and sign. Here Mars is neutral in Taurus, aspected by nothing adverse in the rasi chart but placed in the D9 6th with Saturn and Rahu, which does not support 'unambiguously harmonious'.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity","/vargas/D9/placements"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Mars occupies house 7 (Taurus), not house 8. House 8 (Gemini) contains Jupiter and Ketu.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/houses/7/occupants","/houses/8/occupants"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is doctrinally sound and consistent with the chart: Mars sits in the 7th house of spouse/partnership (/placements/Mars/house), the classical Kuja Dosha placement associated with marital friction, softened here by neutral dignity in Taurus and Venus (7th lord) exalted in the 5th (/placements/Venus/dignity). S2 is wrong because it flatly contradicts standard doctrine and S1's framing. S3 is wrong because the chart places Mars in house 7, not 8."},"extracted":"{\n \"case_id\": \"marriage-contradiction-01\",\n \"domain\": \"marriage\",\n \"conclusion\": \"mixed\",\n \"confidence\": 0.95,\n \"selected_option_ids\": [],\n \"factors\": [\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Mars in the seventh is traditionally read as Mangal/Kuja Dosha-type friction in marriage; this is a valid statement.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mars/house\", \"/houses/7/significations\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"contradictions\": [\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"S2\",\n   \"error_type\": \"doctrinal\",\n   \"correction\": \"Mars in the 7th is not unambiguously harmonious; classical Parashari doctrine treats malefic Mars in the kendra of marriage as an indication of clashes or tension in married life (Kuja Dosha), though its full effect depends on dignity, aspects, and sign. Here Mars is neutral in Taurus, aspected by nothing adverse in the rasi chart but placed in the D9 6th with Saturn and Rahu, which does not support 'unambiguously harmonious'.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mars/house\", \"/placements/Mars/dignity\", \"/vargas/D9/placements\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"S3\",\n   \"error_type\": \"factual\",\n   \"correction\": \"Mars occupies house 7 (Taurus), not house 8. House 8 (Gemini) contains Jupiter and Ketu.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mars/house\", \"/houses/7/occupants\", \"/houses/8/occupants\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"missing_information\": [],\n \"rationale\": \"S1 is doctrinally sound and consistent with the chart: Mars sits in the 7th house of spouse/partnership (/placements/Mars/house), the classical Kuja Dosha placement associated with marital friction, softened here by neutral dignity in Taurus and Venus (7th lord) exalted in the 5th (/placements/Venus/dignity). S2 is wrong because it flatly contradicts standard doctrine and S1's framing. S3 is wrong because the chart places Mars in house 7, not 8.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-contradiction-02","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-contradiction-02","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.95,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"S1 is accurate: Sun occupies the 7th house (Aries), classically read as a challenging factor for marriage (delay/strain), even though the Sun is exalted there.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/sign","/placements/Sun/dignity"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"No single placement 'guarantees' that marriage never occurs. The Sun in the 7th indicates strain/delay or a strong-willed spouse at most; here it is exalted in Aries and its dispositor Mars is exalted in the 4th aspecting the 7th, which softens rather than negates marriage indications.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/dignity","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity","/houses/7/aspectedBy"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"The Sun is placed in house 7 (Aries), not house 8.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/sign","/placements/Sun/longitude","/houses/7/occupants"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 correctly reflects both the chart fact (Sun in /houses/7) and standard Parashari doctrine that the Sun, as a separative/karaka of ego, in the 7th is a challenging marriage indicator — the statement is appropriately qualified and not erroneous. S2 overclaims certainty from a single placement, contradicting doctrine and ignoring mitigating factors (exalted Sun, exalted Mars dispositor aspecting the 7th). S3 misstates the Sun's house; the chart facts place the Sun in house 7, with Mercury/Venus/Ketu occupying house 8."},"extracted":"{\n \"case_id\": \"marriage-contradiction-02\",\n \"domain\": \"marriage\",\n \"conclusion\": \"mixed\",\n \"confidence\": 0.95,\n \"selected_option_ids\": [],\n \"factors\": [\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"S1 is accurate: Sun occupies the 7th house (Aries), classically read as a challenging factor for marriage (delay/strain), even though the Sun is exalted there.\",\n   \"effect\": \"neutral\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Sun/house\", \"/placements/Sun/sign\", \"/placements/Sun/dignity\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"contradictions\": [\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"S2\",\n   \"error_type\": \"overclaim\",\n   \"correction\": \"No single placement 'guarantees' that marriage never occurs. The Sun in the 7th indicates strain/delay or a strong-willed spouse at most; here it is exalted in Aries and its dispositor Mars is exalted in the 4th aspecting the 7th, which softens rather than negates marriage indications.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Sun/house\", \"/placements/Sun/dignity\", \"/placements/Mars/house\", \"/placements/Mars/dignity\", \"/houses/7/aspectedBy\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"S3\",\n   \"error_type\": \"factual\",\n   \"correction\": \"The Sun is placed in house 7 (Aries), not house 8.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Sun/house\", \"/placements/Sun/sign\", \"/placements/Sun/longitude\", \"/houses/7/occupants\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"missing_information\": [],\n \"rationale\": \"S1 correctly reflects both the chart fact (Sun in /houses/7) and standard Parashari doctrine that the Sun, as a separative/karaka of ego, in the 7th is a challenging marriage indicator — the statement is appropriately qualified and not erroneous. S2 overclaims certainty from a single placement, contradicting doctrine and ignoring mitigating factors (exalted Sun, exalted Mars dispositor aspecting the 7th). S3 misstates the Sun's house; the chart facts place the Sun in house 7, with Mercury/Venus/Ketu occupying house 8.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-contradiction-02","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-contradiction-02","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The Sun is placed in the natal 7th house in Aries, exalted, and the 7th lord Mars sits in the 4th aspecting the 7th — a mixed indication for marriage (classical texts flag Sun in the 7th as challenging for marital harmony/delay, but exaltation and Mars's own-sign rulership mitigate)","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/sign","/placements/Sun/dignity","/houses/6"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"factual","correction":"No error — S1 is accurate: the Sun does occupy house 7 (/placements/Sun/house = 7), and Sun in the 7th of marriage is traditionally read as a challenging factor (delay/friction), though here it is exalted in Aries, which softens the indication.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/dignity"]},{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The claim that Sun in the 7th 'guarantees marriage never occurs' is an overclaim. Classical doctrine treats Sun in the 7th as an affliction indicating delay, ego-conflict or difficulty in marriage — not absolute denial of marriage. Here the Sun is exalted (/placements/Sun/dignity = Exalted) and the 7th lord Mars is exalted in a kendra (/placements/Mars/house = 4, /yogas Ruchaka Yoga), which are strong mitigating supports for marriage occurring.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/dignity","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Incorrect. The Sun occupies house 7 (Aries, 13°04'), not house 8. House 8 contains Mercury, Venus and Ketu.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/sign","/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Ketu/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Audit result: S1 is correct as stated; S2 is an overclaim (affliction ≠ denial of marriage, with strong mitigations from exalted Sun and exalted 7th-lord Mars forming Ruchaka Yoga); S3 is factually wrong about house placement (Sun is in the 7th, not the 8th)."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-contradiction-02\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.0,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The Sun is placed in the natal 7th house in Aries, exalted, and the 7th lord Mars sits in the 4th aspecting the 7th — a mixed indication for marriage (classical texts flag Sun in the 7th as challenging for marital harmony/delay, but exaltation and Mars's own-sign rulership mitigate)\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Sun/sign\",\"/placements/Sun/dignity\",\"/houses/6\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"No error — S1 is accurate: the Sun does occupy house 7 (/placements/Sun/house = 7), and Sun in the 7th of marriage is traditionally read as a challenging factor (delay/friction), though here it is exalted in Aries, which softens the indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Sun/dignity\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The claim that Sun in the 7th 'guarantees marriage never occurs' is an overclaim. Classical doctrine treats Sun in the 7th as an affliction indicating delay, ego-conflict or difficulty in marriage — not absolute denial of marriage. Here the Sun is exalted (/placements/Sun/dignity = Exalted) and the 7th lord Mars is exalted in a kendra (/placements/Mars/house = 4, /yogas Ruchaka Yoga), which are strong mitigating supports for marriage occurring.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Sun/dignity\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Incorrect. The Sun occupies house 7 (Aries, 13°04'), not house 8. House 8 contains Mercury, Venus and Ketu.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Sun/sign\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Ketu/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Audit result: S1 is correct as stated; S2 is an overclaim (affliction ≠ denial of marriage, with strong mitigations from exalted Sun and exalted 7th-lord Mars forming Ruchaka Yoga); S3 is factually wrong about house placement (Sun is in the 7th, not the 8th).\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-01","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.65,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"7th lord Mercury is placed in the 8th house and in an enemy sign (Cancer), weakening the karaka house of partnership and tying marriage to 8th-house themes of turbulence, secrecy, and sudden change","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/dignity","/houses/6"]},{"claim":"The 7th house itself is occupied by Sun and Mars — Sun neutral, Mars in enemy sign and combust — indicating heat, conflict, and ego friction within the marital sphere","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/6/occupants","/placements/Sun/dignity","/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Mars/combust"]},{"claim":"Mars aspects the 1st house (self) from the 7th, and Ketu also aspects the 7th, adding detachment or severing tendencies toward partnership","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Mars","/aspects/Ketu"]},{"claim":"A strong Raja Yoga exists between Jupiter (lagna lord) and Mercury (7th lord / 10th lord) by mutual aspect, which supports eventual stability and dignity through partnership","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/1","/yogas/2"]},{"claim":"Venus, the natural karaka of marriage, is a benefic placed in the trikona 5th house with Rahu; its placement in a trine is favorable though Rahu's conjunction introduces unconventional or amplifying influences on romance","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/isBenefic","/houses/4/occupants"]},{"claim":"Navamsa lagna is Leo with Moon and Mercury in D9 lagna; Venus sits in Sagittarius in D9's 5th dispositor-linked to Jupiter — inner strength for relationship matters is moderate-to-good, but Mars falls into the D9 8th house, echoing marital discord at depth","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D9/lagnaSign","/vargas/D9/placements/1","/vargas/D9/placements/5","/vargas/D9/placements/2"]},{"claim":"Current Ketu mahadasha with Mercury antardasha (to 2026-07-29): Ketu aspects the 7th natally and Mercury is the afflicted 7th lord, so this window is unlikely to favor marriage formation","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/dasha/current","/aspects/Ketu","/placements/Mercury/house"]},{"claim":"Upcoming Venus mahadasha from 2026-07-29 places the marriage karaka in charge for 20 years; Venus–Venus (2026-2029) and Venus–Sun are early sub-periods where marriage indications activate, aided by transiting Jupiter currently conjunct natal Sun-Mars in the 7th house","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/dasha/upcoming/0","/transits/Jupiter/inNatalHouse","/transits/Jupiter/conjunctNatal"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The presence of malefics in the 7th does not by itself deny marriage; it indicates friction that the Jupiter–Mercury Raja Yoga partially compensates. Both must be weighed together.","evidence":["/yogas/1","/houses/6/occupants"]}],"missing_information":["Exact timing of any past relationship/marriage history to calibrate dasha activation","Upapada lagna (Jaimini) not provided in chart facts","D9 7th-house occupants' full aspect analysis beyond placements listed"],"rationale":"Marriage indications are genuinely two-sided: the 7th house carries Sun-Mars with combust, enemy-sign Mars, the 7th lord Mercury falls in the 8th in enemy sign, and Ketu aspects the 7th — all pointing to conflict, delay, or turbulence. Against this stand a genuine Jupiter–Mercury Raja Yoga linking self and partnership, benefic Venus (marriage karaka) in the 5th trine, a serviceable Navamsa, and a forward-looking Venus mahadasha beginning July 2026 whose early antardashas coincide with Jupiter transiting the natal 7th. Net reading: mixed — marriage is indicated but likely with friction or delay, with the Venus–Venus and Venus–Sun periods (2026–2030) as the most supportive windows. Astrological indication only; no outcome is certain."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-synthesis-01\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.65,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"7th lord Mercury is placed in the 8th house and in an enemy sign (Cancer), weakening the karaka house of partnership and tying marriage to 8th-house themes of turbulence, secrecy, and sudden change\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/dignity\",\"/houses/6\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 7th house itself is occupied by Sun and Mars — Sun neutral, Mars in enemy sign and combust — indicating heat, conflict, and ego friction within the marital sphere\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/occupants\",\"/placements/Sun/dignity\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/placements/Mars/combust\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars aspects the 1st house (self) from the 7th, and Ketu also aspects the 7th, adding detachment or severing tendencies toward partnership\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/aspects/Ketu\"]},{\"claim\":\"A strong Raja Yoga exists between Jupiter (lagna lord) and Mercury (7th lord / 10th lord) by mutual aspect, which supports eventual stability and dignity through partnership\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\",\"/yogas/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus, the natural karaka of marriage, is a benefic placed in the trikona 5th house with Rahu; its placement in a trine is favorable though Rahu's conjunction introduces unconventional or amplifying influences on romance\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Venus/isBenefic\",\"/houses/4/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"Navamsa lagna is Leo with Moon and Mercury in D9 lagna; Venus sits in Sagittarius in D9's 5th dispositor-linked to Jupiter — inner strength for relationship matters is moderate-to-good, but Mars falls into the D9 8th house, echoing marital discord at depth\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/lagnaSign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/1\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current Ketu mahadasha with Mercury antardasha (to 2026-07-29): Ketu aspects the 7th natally and Mercury is the afflicted 7th lord, so this window is unlikely to favor marriage formation\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current\",\"/aspects/Ketu\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Upcoming Venus mahadasha from 2026-07-29 places the marriage karaka in charge for 20 years; Venus–Venus (2026-2029) and Venus–Sun are early sub-periods where marriage indications activate, aided by transiting Jupiter currently conjunct natal Sun-Mars in the 7th house\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/upcoming/0\",\"/transits/Jupiter/inNatalHouse\",\"/transits/Jupiter/conjunctNatal\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The presence of malefics in the 7th does not by itself deny marriage; it indicates friction that the Jupiter–Mercury Raja Yoga partially compensates. Both must be weighed together.\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\",\"/houses/6/occupants\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"Exact timing of any past relationship/marriage history to calibrate dasha activation\",\"Upapada lagna (Jaimini) not provided in chart facts\",\"D9 7th-house occupants' full aspect analysis beyond placements listed\"],\"rationale\":\"Marriage indications are genuinely two-sided: the 7th house carries Sun-Mars with combust, enemy-sign Mars, the 7th lord Mercury falls in the 8th in enemy sign, and Ketu aspects the 7th — all pointing to conflict, delay, or turbulence. Against this stand a genuine Jupiter–Mercury Raja Yoga linking self and partnership, benefic Venus (marriage karaka) in the 5th trine, a serviceable Navamsa, and a forward-looking Venus mahadasha beginning July 2026 whose early antardashas coincide with Jupiter transiting the natal 7th. Net reading: mixed — marriage is indicated but likely with friction or delay, with the Venus–Venus and Venus–Sun periods (2026–2030) as the most supportive windows. Astrological indication only; no outcome is certain.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-01","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.7,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"7th lord Mercury is placed in the 8th house, linking marriage to the dusthana of sudden events and transformation","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/houses/6"]},{"claim":"Sun and Mars occupy the 7th house itself; Mars there is combust and in enemy sign, indicating friction and dominance themes in partnership","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/combust","/placements/Mars/dignity"]},{"claim":"Mars aspects the lagna (and via 8th aspect house 2), giving a Mangal-influenced flavor to self and family matters","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Mars"]},{"claim":"Raja yoga between Mercury (lord 7) and Jupiter (lord 1) through mutual aspect — a strong supportive signature for marriage despite Mercury's placement","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas"]},{"claim":"Jupiter (lagna lord and karaka for dharmic union) sits debilitated and retrograde in the 2nd (family), but retrogression plus raja-yoga status partially redeems it","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Venus (natural karaka of marriage) at 29°12' Aries in the 5th, neutral dignity, late degree — functional but weakly placed, aspecting the 11th of fulfilment of desire","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Venus/formatted","/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/dignity","/aspects/Venus"]},{"claim":"Ketu aspects the 7th house, adding detachment or karmic coloring to partnerships","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Ketu"]},{"claim":"D9: Venus in Sagittarius in 5th with Jupiter dispositor; Moon+Mercury in D9 lagna Leo — inner strength for relationship present but D9 Mars in 8th echoes marital turbulence","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements"]},{"claim":"Current dasha Ketu–Mercury (until 2026-07-29): Ketu aspects natal 7th and Mercury is the 7th lord — an active period for relationship matters, colored by Ketu's detachment; upcoming Venus mahadasha from 2026-07-29 strongly activates marriage significations (Venus is karaka, in 5th of romance)","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/dasha/current","/dasha/upcoming","/aspects/Ketu"]},{"claim":"Transit Jupiter (as of 2026-01-01) is retrograde in natal 7th conjunct natal Sun and Mars — activating the 7th house directly during this window","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/transits/asOf"]},{"claim":"Natal Moon debilitated in Scorpio in 12th, though forming Vipareeta Raja Yoga — emotional undercurrents affect intimacy but convert to resilience","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Moon/dignity","/placements/Moon/house","/yogas"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The combust Mars in the 7th suggests marital friction, yet the Mercury–Jupiter mutual-aspect raja yoga involving the 7th lord indicates eventual stability — these are reconciled by reading early turbulence maturing into a dharmic bond rather than outright denial of marriage.","evidence":["/yogas","/placements/Mars/combust"]},{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"omission","correction":"A synthesis should weigh the upcoming Venus mahadasha (2026 onwards) as the strongest timing factor for marriage-related developments; Venus is both karaka and 5th-house occupant.","evidence":["/dasha/upcoming","/placements/Venus/house"]}],"missing_information":["Navamsa lagna lord strength details beyond provided D9 placements","Exact birth-time rectification confirmation for fine-grained D9 accuracy"],"rationale":"The chart shows a genuinely mixed marriage picture. The 7th is heavily tenanted (Sun + combust Mars) with Ketu's aspect, and its lord Mercury falls in the 8th — classic indicators of friction, delays, or a transformative/karmic partner. However, multiple mitigating structures exist: the Mercury–Jupiter mutual-aspect raja yogas bind the 1st and 7th lords, Venus as karaka occupies the romantic 5th aspecting the 11th, and D9 shows Moon-Mercury in its own lagna. Timing-wise, Ketu–Mercury dasha (now) keeps relationship themes active under a detached tone, while the Venus mahadasha beginning July 2026 is the most supportive long window for marriage or significant deepening of partnership, further activated by transit Jupiter currently moving through the natal 7th."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-synthesis-01\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.7,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"7th lord Mercury is placed in the 8th house, linking marriage to the dusthana of sudden events and transformation\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/houses/6\"]},{\"claim\":\"Sun and Mars occupy the 7th house itself; Mars there is combust and in enemy sign, indicating friction and dominance themes in partnership\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/combust\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars aspects the lagna (and via 8th aspect house 2), giving a Mangal-influenced flavor to self and family matters\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Mars\"]},{\"claim\":\"Raja yoga between Mercury (lord 7) and Jupiter (lord 1) through mutual aspect — a strong supportive signature for marriage despite Mercury's placement\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter (lagna lord and karaka for dharmic union) sits debilitated and retrograde in the 2nd (family), but retrogression plus raja-yoga status partially redeems it\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus (natural karaka of marriage) at 29°12' Aries in the 5th, neutral dignity, late degree — functional but weakly placed, aspecting the 11th of fulfilment of desire\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/formatted\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/aspects/Venus\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu aspects the 7th house, adding detachment or karmic coloring to partnerships\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Ketu\"]},{\"claim\":\"D9: Venus in Sagittarius in 5th with Jupiter dispositor; Moon+Mercury in D9 lagna Leo — inner strength for relationship present but D9 Mars in 8th echoes marital turbulence\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current dasha Ketu–Mercury (until 2026-07-29): Ketu aspects natal 7th and Mercury is the 7th lord — an active period for relationship matters, colored by Ketu's detachment; upcoming Venus mahadasha from 2026-07-29 strongly activates marriage significations (Venus is karaka, in 5th of romance)\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current\",\"/dasha/upcoming\",\"/aspects/Ketu\"]},{\"claim\":\"Transit Jupiter (as of 2026-01-01) is retrograde in natal 7th conjunct natal Sun and Mars — activating the 7th house directly during this window\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/transits/asOf\"]},{\"claim\":\"Natal Moon debilitated in Scorpio in 12th, though forming Vipareeta Raja Yoga — emotional undercurrents affect intimacy but convert to resilience\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/dignity\",\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/yogas\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The combust Mars in the 7th suggests marital friction, yet the Mercury–Jupiter mutual-aspect raja yoga involving the 7th lord indicates eventual stability — these are reconciled by reading early turbulence maturing into a dharmic bond rather than outright denial of marriage.\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas\",\"/placements/Mars/combust\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"omission\",\"correction\":\"A synthesis should weigh the upcoming Venus mahadasha (2026 onwards) as the strongest timing factor for marriage-related developments; Venus is both karaka and 5th-house occupant.\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/upcoming\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"Navamsa lagna lord strength details beyond provided D9 placements\",\"Exact birth-time rectification confirmation for fine-grained D9 accuracy\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart shows a genuinely mixed marriage picture. The 7th is heavily tenanted (Sun + combust Mars) with Ketu's aspect, and its lord Mercury falls in the 8th — classic indicators of friction, delays, or a transformative/karmic partner. However, multiple mitigating structures exist: the Mercury–Jupiter mutual-aspect raja yogas bind the 1st and 7th lords, Venus as karaka occupies the romantic 5th aspecting the 11th, and D9 shows Moon-Mercury in its own lagna. Timing-wise, Ketu–Mercury dasha (now) keeps relationship themes active under a detached tone, while the Venus mahadasha beginning July 2026 is the most supportive long window for marriage or significant deepening of partnership, further activated by transit Jupiter currently moving through the natal 7th.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-02","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-02","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.7,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"7th house is Libra, its own sign of the 7th lord Venus; Venus is placed in the 1st house (lagna), so the karaka and 7th lord are strong and connected to self — a spouse-oriented, partnership-focused life","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/7/sign","/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/isBenefic"]},{"claim":"Saturn is exalted (Sasa Mahapurusha Yoga) in the 7th house, giving a serious, loyal, dutiful approach to partnership and a mature/older or responsible spouse","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/1","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity"]},{"claim":"Saturn is retrograde in the 7th and casts graha drishti onto the lagna (/aspects/Saturn → house 1); Saturnian delay, caution, or a reserved emotional tone in marriage is indicated despite exaltation","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/retrograde","/houses/1/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Venus aspects its own 7th house from the lagna, strengthening the marriage house further","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/aspects/Venus"]},{"claim":"In D9, Venus (karaka of marriage) is debilitated in Virgo with the Moon in the 11th; the inner strength of the marriage karaka is weakened, indicating dissatisfaction or criticality toward the partner despite outer stability","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/5"]},{"claim":"D9 shows Sun conjunct Rahu in the D9 7th house, suggesting ego/foreign/unconventional elements entering the marriage dynamic","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/0","/vargas/D9/placements/6","/vargas/D9/lagnaSign"]},{"claim":"Ketu aspects the 7th house (/aspects/Ketu → house 7) and Ketu sits with Mars/Mercury in the 3rd aspecting it; a detached or dispassionate undercurrent toward partnership","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Ketu"]},{"claim":"Currently running Saturn–Saturn dasha with Saturn as the 7th occupant; Saturn periods typically consolidate, formalize, or weigh on marital matters rather than disrupt them abruptly","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord","/dasha/current/antardasha/lord"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"omission","correction":"Exalted Saturn in the 7th should not be read purely negatively: as a kendra-based Sasa Yoga it is a strength for commitment; its challenges are temperamental (delay, coldness), not structural instability","evidence":["/yogas/1","/houses/7/occupants"]}],"missing_information":["Upapada Lagna (UL) for corroboration of marriage outcomes","Exact timing of marriage events / current marital status of subject","2nd-house family continuity factors beyond Sun's occupancy (Sun in enemy dignity in Taurus mildly afflicts family happiness)","Navamsa dispositor condition chain (Mercury in D9 lagna Scorpio) strength assessment via shadbala"],"rationale":"Rasi-level indications are strongly supportive: 7th lord Venus in lagna aspecting its own 7th, plus exalted Saturn forming Sasa Yoga in the 7th — stable, committed partnership with a mature spouse. However, three moderating factors keep this 'mixed': retrograde Saturn delays and cools emotional expression; Ketu's aspect on the 7th adds detachment; and in D9 the marriage karaka Venus is debilitated while Sun–Rahu occupy the D9 7th, indicating inner dissatisfaction, criticism, or unconventional elements beneath an outwardly solid marriage. Overall: durable marriage requiring conscious warmth; not fragile, but not effortless."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-synthesis-02\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.7,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"7th house is Libra, its own sign of the 7th lord Venus; Venus is placed in the 1st house (lagna), so the karaka and 7th lord are strong and connected to self — a spouse-oriented, partnership-focused life\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/7/sign\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Venus/isBenefic\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn is exalted (Sasa Mahapurusha Yoga) in the 7th house, giving a serious, loyal, dutiful approach to partnership and a mature/older or responsible spouse\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn is retrograde in the 7th and casts graha drishti onto the lagna (/aspects/Saturn → house 1); Saturnian delay, caution, or a reserved emotional tone in marriage is indicated despite exaltation\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/retrograde\",\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus aspects its own 7th house from the lagna, strengthening the marriage house further\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Venus\"]},{\"claim\":\"In D9, Venus (karaka of marriage) is debilitated in Virgo with the Moon in the 11th; the inner strength of the marriage karaka is weakened, indicating dissatisfaction or criticality toward the partner despite outer stability\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/5\"]},{\"claim\":\"D9 shows Sun conjunct Rahu in the D9 7th house, suggesting ego/foreign/unconventional elements entering the marriage dynamic\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/0\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/6\",\"/vargas/D9/lagnaSign\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu aspects the 7th house (/aspects/Ketu → house 7) and Ketu sits with Mars/Mercury in the 3rd aspecting it; a detached or dispassionate undercurrent toward partnership\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Ketu\"]},{\"claim\":\"Currently running Saturn–Saturn dasha with Saturn as the 7th occupant; Saturn periods typically consolidate, formalize, or weigh on marital matters rather than disrupt them abruptly\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord\",\"/dasha/current/antardasha/lord\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"omission\",\"correction\":\"Exalted Saturn in the 7th should not be read purely negatively: as a kendra-based Sasa Yoga it is a strength for commitment; its challenges are temperamental (delay, coldness), not structural instability\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\",\"/houses/7/occupants\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"Upapada Lagna (UL) for corroboration of marriage outcomes\",\"Exact timing of marriage events / current marital status of subject\",\"2nd-house family continuity factors beyond Sun's occupancy (Sun in enemy dignity in Taurus mildly afflicts family happiness)\",\"Navamsa dispositor condition chain (Mercury in D9 lagna Scorpio) strength assessment via shadbala\"],\"rationale\":\"Rasi-level indications are strongly supportive: 7th lord Venus in lagna aspecting its own 7th, plus exalted Saturn forming Sasa Yoga in the 7th — stable, committed partnership with a mature spouse. However, three moderating factors keep this 'mixed': retrograde Saturn delays and cools emotional expression; Ketu's aspect on the 7th adds detachment; and in D9 the marriage karaka Venus is debilitated while Sun–Rahu occupy the D9 7th, indicating inner dissatisfaction, criticism, or unconventional elements beneath an outwardly solid marriage. Overall: durable marriage requiring conscious warmth; not fragile, but not effortless.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-02","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-02","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.65,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"7th lord Venus is placed in the 1st house and aspects its own 7th house, a strong protective placement for partnership matters","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/aspects/Venus"]},{"claim":"Saturn is exalted in the 7th house forming Sasa Mahapurusha Yoga in a kendra, indicating a serious, enduring, duty-bound marriage despite delays","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"Saturn in the 7th is retrograde and Saturn aspects the lagna, adding weight, delay or age-gap themes to union","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/retrograde","/houses/0/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"D9 shows Venus debilitated in Virgo in the 11th with the Moon, weakening the karaka of marriage at the level of inner/spousal experience","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/5"]},{"claim":"D9 7th house holds Sun conjunct Rahu in Taurus, indicating ego/Rahu-type disturbances around spouse or public partnership image","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/0","/vargas/D9/placements/7"]},{"claim":"Ketu sits on the D9 lagna with Mercury, suggesting detachment or spiritualized orientation within the marital self","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/8"]},{"claim":"Current dasha is Saturn–Saturn (2024-12 to 2027-12); Saturn is both 7th occupant/exalted and dasha lord, so marriage-related matters are strongly activated in this period","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha","/dasha/current/antardasha"]},{"claim":"Natal Ketu aspects the 7th house from the 3rd, adding a mild severance/renunciate undertone alongside Saturn's stabilizing presence","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Ketu"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"omission","correction":"A reading citing only exalted Saturn in the 7th would overstate harmony; the debilitated D9 Venus and Rahu in the D9 7th must be weighed against it.","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/5","/vargas/D9/placements/7"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The rasi chart is strong for marriage structurally: 7th lord Venus in lagna aspecting its own house (/placements/Venus/house, /aspects/Venus) and an exalted retrograde Saturn in the 7th forming Sasa Yoga (/yogas/1). This promises a durable, committed union, likely after some delay given Saturn's retrogradation and its aspect on the lagna (/placements/Saturn/retrograde). However, divisional evidence tempers this: Venus is debilitated in the D9 (/vargas/D9/placements/5), and the D9 7th carries Sun–Rahu (/vargas/D9/placements/0,/vargas/D9/placements/7), pointing to friction between outer commitment and inner spousal satisfaction, plus ego/independence issues. The current Saturn mahadasha activates the 7th-house axis through 2027 (/dasha/current/mahadasha). Overall: mixed-to-supportive — stable, long-lasting partnership indicated, with delayed onset and periodic emotional detachment or status-related tension requiring conscious effort."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-synthesis-02\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.65,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"7th lord Venus is placed in the 1st house and aspects its own 7th house, a strong protective placement for partnership matters\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/aspects/Venus\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn is exalted in the 7th house forming Sasa Mahapurusha Yoga in a kendra, indicating a serious, enduring, duty-bound marriage despite delays\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn in the 7th is retrograde and Saturn aspects the lagna, adding weight, delay or age-gap themes to union\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/retrograde\",\"/houses/0/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"D9 shows Venus debilitated in Virgo in the 11th with the Moon, weakening the karaka of marriage at the level of inner/spousal experience\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/5\"]},{\"claim\":\"D9 7th house holds Sun conjunct Rahu in Taurus, indicating ego/Rahu-type disturbances around spouse or public partnership image\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/0\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/7\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu sits on the D9 lagna with Mercury, suggesting detachment or spiritualized orientation within the marital self\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/8\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current dasha is Saturn–Saturn (2024-12 to 2027-12); Saturn is both 7th occupant/exalted and dasha lord, so marriage-related matters are strongly activated in this period\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/mahadasha\",\"/dasha/current/antardasha\"]},{\"claim\":\"Natal Ketu aspects the 7th house from the 3rd, adding a mild severance/renunciate undertone alongside Saturn's stabilizing presence\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Ketu\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"omission\",\"correction\":\"A reading citing only exalted Saturn in the 7th would overstate harmony; the debilitated D9 Venus and Rahu in the D9 7th must be weighed against it.\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/5\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/7\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The rasi chart is strong for marriage structurally: 7th lord Venus in lagna aspecting its own house (/placements/Venus/house, /aspects/Venus) and an exalted retrograde Saturn in the 7th forming Sasa Yoga (/yogas/1). This promises a durable, committed union, likely after some delay given Saturn's retrogradation and its aspect on the lagna (/placements/Saturn/retrograde). However, divisional evidence tempers this: Venus is debilitated in the D9 (/vargas/D9/placements/5), and the D9 7th carries Sun–Rahu (/vargas/D9/placements/0,/vargas/D9/placements/7), pointing to friction between outer commitment and inner spousal satisfaction, plus ego/independence issues. The current Saturn mahadasha activates the 7th-house axis through 2027 (/dasha/current/mahadasha). Overall: mixed-to-supportive — stable, long-lasting partnership indicated, with delayed onset and periodic emotional detachment or status-related tension requiring conscious effort.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-01","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.72,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"7th house occupied by Sun and Mars; Mars combust and in enemy sign Gemini — a hot, afflicted 7th indicating friction, dominance struggles and impatience in partnership","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/combust"]},{"claim":"7th lord Mercury in the 8th in enemy sign — marriage linked to sudden events/transformations; delays and turbulence indicated","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/houses/8/significations"]},{"claim":"Ketu aspects the 7th (and Sun/Mars there), adding detachment, dissatisfaction or karmic coldness to the marital axis","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Ketu"]},{"claim":"Mars (also lord of the 12th) sits in the 7th — Mangal-type affliction of the karaka of marriage; Mars is the 12th lord placed in the 7th, a classic bed-pleasures/separation indicator","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/houses/12/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"Venus (karaka of marriage) at the very last degree of Aries in the 5th with Rahu — Venus conjunct Rahu amplifies desire, unconventional attraction, but instability; Venus also aspected by Saturn","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Rahu/house","/aspects/Saturn"]},{"claim":"Strong mitigating yoga: Mercury (7L/10L) and Jupiter (1L/4L) mutually aspect, forming two Raja Yogas connecting self and spouse houses — capacity for an ultimately dignified partnership","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/1","/yogas/2"]},{"claim":"D9 lagna Leo with Moon+Mercury in D9 lagna gives emotional resilience; D9 Venus in Sagittarius 5th disposited by Jupiter is decent for the inner marriage significator","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/1","/vargas/D9/placements/3","/vargs/D9/placements/5"]},{"claim":"D9 Mars in Pisces 8th confirms the rasi-level Mars affliction of marriage at the deeper level","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/2"]},{"claim":"Jupiter debilitated retrograde in natal 2nd (family house) — family dimension of married life under strain, though retrogression offers partial cancellation (nicha-bhanga flavor)","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Currently Ketu–Mercury dasha: Ketu MD aspects the 7th and Mercury is the afflicted 7th lord — present period carries the chart's core marital stressors; Venus MD from Jul 2026 (Venus–Venus) brings the benefic marriage karaka forward","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord","/dasha/current/antardasha/lord","/dasha/upcoming/0"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Exact timing/event dates of marriage (if any) to correlate dasha activation","Upapada lagna not provided","Navamsa 7th lord strength assessment beyond placements given"],"rationale":"The rasi chart shows an afflicted 7th: Sun+combust Mars occupying it, 7th lord Mercury fallen into the 8th, Ketu aspecting it, and Venus (karaka) joined Rahu and aspected by Saturn. These point to conflict, delay and karmic intensity in marriage. However, two Mercury–Jupiter mutual-aspect Raja Yogas link lagna to the 7th and 10th lords, Jupiter aspects both the 8th (protective) and 10th, and the D9 shows Moon+Mercury strong in the D9 lagna with a well-placed D9 Venus — indicating that despite friction, a workable and eventually dignified union is achievable. Timing-wise, Ketu–Mercury (now) stresses marriage matters, while Venus mahadasha beginning July 2026 activates the benefic significator. Net verdict: mixed — challenging indications requiring effort/compatibility work, offset by genuine yogic support."},"extracted":"{\n \"case_id\": \"marriage-synthesis-01\",\n \"domain\": \"marriage\",\n \"conclusion\": \"mixed\",\n \"confidence\": 0.72,\n \"selected_option_ids\": [],\n \"factors\": [\n  {\"claim\":\"7th house occupied by Sun and Mars; Mars combust and in enemy sign Gemini — a hot, afflicted 7th indicating friction, dominance struggles and impatience in partnership\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/combust\"]},\n  {\"claim\":\"7th lord Mercury in the 8th in enemy sign — marriage linked to sudden events/transformations; delays and turbulence indicated\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/houses/8/significations\"]},\n  {\"claim\":\"Ketu aspects the 7th (and Sun/Mars there), adding detachment, dissatisfaction or karmic coldness to the marital axis\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Ketu\"]},\n  {\"claim\":\"Mars (also lord of the 12th) sits in the 7th — Mangal-type affliction of the karaka of marriage; Mars is the 12th lord placed in the 7th, a classic bed-pleasures/separation indicator\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/houses/12/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},\n  {\"claim\":\"Venus (karaka of marriage) at the very last degree of Aries in the 5th with Rahu — Venus conjunct Rahu amplifies desire, unconventional attraction, but instability; Venus also aspected by Saturn\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/aspects/Saturn\"]},\n  {\"claim\":\"Strong mitigating yoga: Mercury (7L/10L) and Jupiter (1L/4L) mutually aspect, forming two Raja Yogas connecting self and spouse houses — capacity for an ultimately dignified partnership\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\",\"/yogas/2\"]},\n  {\"claim\":\"D9 lagna Leo with Moon+Mercury in D9 lagna gives emotional resilience; D9 Venus in Sagittarius 5th disposited by Jupiter is decent for the inner marriage significator\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/1\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/3\",\"/vargs/D9/placements/5\"]},\n  {\"claim\":\"D9 Mars in Pisces 8th confirms the rasi-level Mars affliction of marriage at the deeper level\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/2\"]},\n  {\"claim\":\"Jupiter debilitated retrograde in natal 2nd (family house) — family dimension of married life under strain, though retrogression offers partial cancellation (nicha-bhanga flavor)\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},\n  {\"claim\":\"Currently Ketu–Mercury dasha: Ketu MD aspects the 7th and Mercury is the afflicted 7th lord — present period carries the chart's core marital stressors; Venus MD from Jul 2026 (Venus–Venus) brings the benefic marriage karaka forward\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord\",\"/dasha/current/antardasha/lord\",\"/dasha/upcoming/0\"]}\n ],\n \"contradictions\": [],\n \"missing_information\": [\"Exact timing/event dates of marriage (if any) to correlate dasha activation\",\"Upapada lagna not provided\",\"Navamsa 7th lord strength assessment beyond placements given\"],\n \"rationale\":\"The rasi chart shows an afflicted 7th: Sun+combust Mars occupying it, 7th lord Mercury fallen into the 8th, Ketu aspecting it, and Venus (karaka) joined Rahu and aspected by Saturn. These point to conflict, delay and karmic intensity in marriage. However, two Mercury–Jupiter mutual-aspect Raja Yogas link lagna to the 7th and 10th lords, Jupiter aspects both the 8th (protective) and 10th, and the D9 shows Moon+Mercury strong in the D9 lagna with a well-placed D9 Venus — indicating that despite friction, a workable and eventually dignified union is achievable. Timing-wise, Ketu–Mercury (now) stresses marriage matters, while Venus mahadasha beginning July 2026 activates the benefic significator. Net verdict: mixed — challenging indications requiring effort/compatibility work, offset by genuine yogic support.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-knowledge-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-knowledge-01","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"rationale":"The VedAstro rule House2LordInHouse9 describes the 2nd lord placed in the 9th as giving mixed health results over time — weaker health in early life improving later. It is a general health-strength indication, not a diagnosis of any specific illness, so B and C are incorrect."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-knowledge-01\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"confidence\":0.85,\"rationale\":\"The VedAstro rule House2LordInHouse9 describes the 2nd lord placed in the 9th as giving mixed health results over time — weaker health in early life improving later. It is a general health-strength indication, not a diagnosis of any specific illness, so B and C are incorrect.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-knowledge-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-knowledge-01","confidence":0.7,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"rationale":"The VedAstro rule House2LordInHouse9 describes the second lord in the ninth as giving mixed health outcomes that improve with time—poorer health in early life and better health later. It is a general strength/quality indication, not a diagnosis of any specific illness. Hence A matches; B (uniformly poor) and C (specific illness) are not established by the rule."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-knowledge-01\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"confidence\":0.7,\"rationale\":\"The VedAstro rule House2LordInHouse9 describes the second lord in the ninth as giving mixed health outcomes that improve with time—poorer health in early life and better health later. It is a general strength/quality indication, not a diagnosis of any specific illness. Hence A matches; B (uniformly poor) and C (specific illness) are not established by the rule.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-02","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-02","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.72,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"7th lord Venus is placed in the lagna itself, in own nakshatra Bharani, linking spouse/partnership strongly to self and personal identity; Venus aspects its own 7th house, a protective influence on marriage.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/nakshatra","/aspects/Venus","/houses/7/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"Saturn sits in the 7th house exalted (Libra), forming Sasa Mahapurusha Yoga; this gives a mature, dutiful, possibly older or serious spouse and durable commitment, but Saturn's placement in the 7th classically delays marriage and brings restraint/coolness in partnership.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"Saturn retrograde in the 7th intensifies karmic weight on partnership; delays, second-attempts, or an unconventional marital timeline are indicated.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/retrograde"]},{"claim":"Ketu aspects the 7th (Ketu's 9th aspect from Gemini/3rd to Libra/7th per /aspects/Ketu includes 7), adding detachment or spiritualized orientation toward marriage alongside Saturn's aspect back to lagna.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Ketu","/houses/7/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"In D9, lagna is Scorpio with Mercury and Ketu in D9-lagna; Venus (karaka of marriage) falls in Virgo (debilitated) in D9 11th — the inner strength of the marriage karaka is weakened despite dignity 'Neutral' in rasi.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/5/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/5/house"]},{"claim":"Sun-Rahu occupy D9 7th house (Taurus) — Rahu in the navamsa 7th suggests an unconventional, foreign-culture, or karmically charged spousal connection with potential instability.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/0/house","/vargas/D9/placements/7/house"]},{"claim":"Jupiter, natural karaka for women/husband-significator balance and the chart's Hamsa Yoga planet, aspects the 10th but not the 7th directly; however Jupiter's exaltation in a kendra supports overall relational dharma and family life (also 4th house = domestic contentment).","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/0","/placements/Jupiter/house","/aspects/Jupiter"]},{"claim":"Current Saturn mahadasha–Saturn antardasha (from 2024-12-03): the 7th-lord-of-10th dasha lord sitting natal in the 7th house makes partnership themes prominent throughout this period; Saturn–Venus antardasha (2031-09-25 to 2034-11-25) is the strongest activation window for marriage matters given Venus is both 2nd and 7th lord in the lagna.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord","/dasha/upcoming/3"]},{"claim":"Transit context as of 2026: transiting Ketu conjuncts natal Moon in the 5th (romance/emotional axis) while transiting Jupiter aspects the 11th and 7th houses — emotional recalibration around love, but Jupiter's grace touches the partnership house.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["tool:transits_at#/transits/Ketu/conjunctNatal","/transits/asOf"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Exact date/status of marriage (married, unmarried, divorced) to anchor timing claims","Spouse birth details for compatibility/comparison","D7 details are provided but children status unknown"],"rationale":"The 7th house is doubly emphasized: its lord Venus sits in the lagna in own nakshatra aspecting it, and Saturn occupies it exalted in Sasa Yoga. This is a chart where marriage is central but Saturnian — delayed, serious, duty-bound, possibly to an older/mature partner, with retrogression suggesting karmic complexity. The navamsa complicates the picture: Venus debilitated in D9 11th and Sun-Rahu in D9 7th weaken the inner durability of partnership even though the rasi promises stability. Offsetting factors are exalted Jupiter in the 4th kendra (domestic happiness, Hamsa Yoga) and Venus's strong rasi position. Net assessment: mixed — marriage occurs/is sustained with gravity and delay rather than ease; periods ruled by Saturn and especially Venus (Saturn–Venus AD 2031–2034) carry the most activation. Confidence moderate because timing depends on actual marital status not supplied."},"extracted":"{\n \"case_id\": \"marriage-synthesis-02\",\n \"domain\": \"marriage\",\n \"conclusion\": \"mixed\",\n \"confidence\": 0.72,\n \"selected_option_ids\": [],\n \"factors\": [\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"7th lord Venus is placed in the lagna itself, in own nakshatra Bharani, linking spouse/partnership strongly to self and personal identity; Venus aspects its own 7th house, a protective influence on marriage.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Venus/house\", \"/placements/Venus/nakshatra\", \"/aspects/Venus\", \"/houses/7/lordPlacedInHouse\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Saturn sits in the 7th house exalted (Libra), forming Sasa Mahapurusha Yoga; this gives a mature, dutiful, possibly older or serious spouse and durable commitment, but Saturn's placement in the 7th classically delays marriage and brings restraint/coolness in partnership.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Saturn/house\", \"/placements/Saturn/dignity\", \"/yogas/1\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Saturn retrograde in the 7th intensifies karmic weight on partnership; delays, second-attempts, or an unconventional marital timeline are indicated.\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Saturn/retrograde\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Ketu aspects the 7th (Ketu's 9th aspect from Gemini/3rd to Libra/7th per /aspects/Ketu includes 7), adding detachment or spiritualized orientation toward marriage alongside Saturn's aspect back to lagna.\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/aspects/Ketu\", \"/houses/7/aspectedBy\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"In D9, lagna is Scorpio with Mercury and Ketu in D9-lagna; Venus (karaka of marriage) falls in Virgo (debilitated) in D9 11th — the inner strength of the marriage karaka is weakened despite dignity 'Neutral' in rasi.\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/sign\", \"/vargas/D9/placements/5/house\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Sun-Rahu occupy D9 7th house (Taurus) — Rahu in the navamsa 7th suggests an unconventional, foreign-culture, or karmically charged spousal connection with potential instability.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/vargas/D9/placements/0/house\", \"/vargas/D9/placements/7/house\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Jupiter, natural karaka for women/husband-significator balance and the chart's Hamsa Yoga planet, aspects the 10th but not the 7th directly; however Jupiter's exaltation in a kendra supports overall relational dharma and family life (also 4th house = domestic contentment).\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/0\", \"/placements/Jupiter/house\", \"/aspects/Jupiter\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Current Saturn mahadasha–Saturn antardasha (from 2024-12-03): the 7th-lord-of-10th dasha lord sitting natal in the 7th house makes partnership themes prominent throughout this period; Saturn–Venus antardasha (2031-09-25 to 2034-11-25) is the strongest activation window for marriage matters given Venus is both 2nd and 7th lord in the lagna.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord\", \"/dasha/upcoming/3\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Transit context as of 2026: transiting Ketu conjuncts natal Moon in the 5th (romance/emotional axis) while transiting Jupiter aspects the 11th and 7th houses — emotional recalibration around love, but Jupiter's grace touches the partnership house.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"tool:transits_at#/transits/Ketu/conjunctNatal\", \"/transits/asOf\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"contradictions\": [],\n \"missing_information\": [\n  \"Exact date/status of marriage (married, unmarried, divorced) to anchor timing claims\",\n  \"Spouse birth details for compatibility/comparison\",\n  \"D7 details are provided but children status unknown\"\n ],\n \"rationale\": \"The 7th house is doubly emphasized: its lord Venus sits in the lagna in own nakshatra aspecting it, and Saturn occupies it exalted in Sasa Yoga. This is a chart where marriage is central but Saturnian — delayed, serious, duty-bound, possibly to an older/mature partner, with retrogression suggesting karmic complexity. The navamsa complicates the picture: Venus debilitated in D9 11th and Sun-Rahu in D9 7th weaken the inner durability of partnership even though the rasi promises stability. Offsetting factors are exalted Jupiter in the 4th kendra (domestic happiness, Hamsa Yoga) and Venus's strong rasi position. Net assessment: mixed — marriage occurs/is sustained with gravity and delay rather than ease; periods ruled by Saturn and especially Venus (Saturn–Venus AD 2031–2034) carry the most activation. Confidence moderate because timing depends on actual marital status not supplied.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-03","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-03","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.55,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"7th house of marriage is occupied by the Moon, a benefic, indicating a caring, emotionally present partnership significator in the marriage house itself","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/isBenefic"]},{"claim":"7th lord Jupiter is exalted in the 11th house of gains and casts its aspect onto the 7th house, a strong classical indicator of a dignified spouse and gains through partnership","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/house","/aspects/Jupiter"]},{"claim":"Navamsa lagna is Pisces with Venus (karaka of marriage) and Moon placed together in its 5th house, supporting affection and emotional fulfilment in union","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D9/lagnaSign","/vargas/D9/placements/3","/vargas/D9/placements/5"]},{"claim":"In the Navamsa, Jupiter (the 7th lord of rasi chart) sits in the 6th house with the Sun, weakening the inner strength of the primary marriage lord and suggesting friction or service-related strain within the union","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/4"]},{"claim":"Transiting Saturn is currently conjunct natal Moon in the 7th house and this is also sade sati (Saturn 1st from Moon), indicating a period of heaviness, delay, or testing in relationship/emotional matters","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/transits/6/inNatalHouse","/transits/saturnFromMoon"]},{"claim":"Rahu sits in the natal 4th house aspected by Ketu's dispositional network into domestic houses, while Ketu occupies the 10th — some detachment themes color home/partnership balance, though not directly afflicting the 7th","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Rahu/house","/placements/Ketu/house"]},{"claim":"Current Mahadasha lord Moon occupies the 7th house, so the running period activates the marriage house itself, making relationship matters prominent now through 2034","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord","/placements/Moon/house"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Venus condition relative to 7th-lord strength in D9 beyond placement (e.g., nakshatra-level detail)","Specific timing question from the native (whether assessing current marriage, prospects, or a specific event date)","Upapada lagna / Jaimini marriage indicators, not provided in facts"],"rationale":"The rasi chart is fundamentally strong for marriage: benefic Moon in the 7th (/placements/Moon/house), an exalted 7th lord Jupiter aspecting its own house from the 11th (/placements/Jupiter), and Venus well-placed in the Navamsa 5th. However, the same Jupiter falls to the D9 6th house with the Sun (/vargas/D9/placements/4), tempering inner marital harmony, and transiting Saturn currently sits on the natal Moon in the 7th during sade sati (/transits/saturnFromMoon = 1), signalling present-day pressure, delay, or emotional testing. The verdict is therefore mixed: sound underlying promise for marriage, with current-period strain requiring patience rather than indicating an adverse outcome."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-synthesis-03\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.55,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"7th house of marriage is occupied by the Moon, a benefic, indicating a caring, emotionally present partnership significator in the marriage house itself\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/isBenefic\"]},{\"claim\":\"7th lord Jupiter is exalted in the 11th house of gains and casts its aspect onto the 7th house, a strong classical indicator of a dignified spouse and gains through partnership\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/aspects/Jupiter\"]},{\"claim\":\"Navamsa lagna is Pisces with Venus (karaka of marriage) and Moon placed together in its 5th house, supporting affection and emotional fulfilment in union\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/lagnaSign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/3\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5\"]},{\"claim\":\"In the Navamsa, Jupiter (the 7th lord of rasi chart) sits in the 6th house with the Sun, weakening the inner strength of the primary marriage lord and suggesting friction or service-related strain within the union\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/4\"]},{\"claim\":\"Transiting Saturn is currently conjunct natal Moon in the 7th house and this is also sade sati (Saturn 1st from Moon), indicating a period of heaviness, delay, or testing in relationship/emotional matters\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/transits/6/inNatalHouse\",\"/transits/saturnFromMoon\"]},{\"claim\":\"Rahu sits in the natal 4th house aspected by Ketu's dispositional network into domestic houses, while Ketu occupies the 10th — some detachment themes color home/partnership balance, though not directly afflicting the 7th\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/placements/Ketu/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current Mahadasha lord Moon occupies the 7th house, so the running period activates the marriage house itself, making relationship matters prominent now through 2034\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"Venus condition relative to 7th-lord strength in D9 beyond placement (e.g., nakshatra-level detail)\",\"Specific timing question from the native (whether assessing current marriage, prospects, or a specific event date)\",\"Upapada lagna / Jaimini marriage indicators, not provided in facts\"],\"rationale\":\"The rasi chart is fundamentally strong for marriage: benefic Moon in the 7th (/placements/Moon/house), an exalted 7th lord Jupiter aspecting its own house from the 11th (/placements/Jupiter), and Venus well-placed in the Navamsa 5th. However, the same Jupiter falls to the D9 6th house with the Sun (/vargas/D9/placements/4), tempering inner marital harmony, and transiting Saturn currently sits on the natal Moon in the 7th during sade sati (/transits/saturnFromMoon = 1), signalling present-day pressure, delay, or emotional testing. The verdict is therefore mixed: sound underlying promise for marriage, with current-period strain requiring patience rather than indicating an adverse outcome.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-03","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-03","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.55,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The 7th house of marriage (Pisces) is occupied by the Moon, a benefic placed in the 7th itself, which supports partnership and public dealings.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/houses/6/occupants"]},{"claim":"The 7th lord Jupiter is exalted in the natal chart (Cancer), a strong dignity for the karaka of marriage among the natural benefics.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/dignity"]},{"claim":"Jupiter, as 7th lord, casts its full aspect onto its own 7th house, protecting and strengthening the marriage significations.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/aspects/Jupiter"]},{"claim":"Jupiter is retrograde at birth, which many traditions read as adding hesitation, delay, or internal reworking to the matters it governs, including marriage.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/retrograde"]},{"claim":"In the D9 (Navamsa), Venus and Moon sit together in the 5th with Rahu, while the D9 7th house (Virgo) is unoccupied — affection and romance are supported, but the spouse-house itself carries no benefic anchor there.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements"]},{"claim":"Transiting Saturn currently sits in Pisces conjunct the natal Moon in the 7th house, and gochara reckoning shows Saturn 1st from the Moon (sade sati onset), a classic pressure period on emotional life and partnership matters.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/transits/Saturn/inNatalHouse","/transits/saturnFromMoon","/transits/Saturn/conjunctNatal"]},{"claim":"Current dasha is Moon–Mars–Saturn (as of early 2026): the Moon sits in the 7th natally (marriage-relevant), while Mars is a dusthana occupant (6th) whose aspect falls on the 1st rather than supporting the 7th, so the running periods give a blended, not clearly favorable, signal.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current","/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Mars/house","/aspects/Mars"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Exact marriage-related timing would require checking specific antardasha/pratyantardasha windows against the 2nd, 7th and 11th houses; no target date was supplied for the question.","Upapada lagna or Jaimini marriage indicators are not present in the chart facts.","Whether the native is unmarried, married, or seeking remarriage — the question's intent is not stated."],"rationale":"Marriage indications are genuinely two-sided. On the positive side, the 7th house holds a benefic Moon (/placements/Moon/house), its lord Jupiter is exalted (/placements/Jupiter/dignity) and aspects its own 7th (/aspects/Jupiter), and Budha-Aditya plus the Mercury raja yoga lend overall chart strength. Against this, Jupiter's retrogression adds delay/hesitation, the D9 shows Venus-Moon-Rahu clustered away from an empty D9 7th (/vargas/D9/placements), transit Saturn now conjoins the natal Moon in the 7th with sade sati beginning (/transits/Saturn/conjunctNatal, /transits/saturnFromMoon), and the current Moon–Mars dasha mixes a 7th-house Moon with a 6th-house Mars (/dasha/current). The doctrine represented here supports 'mixed': strong underlying marriage yoga, currently under visible pressure, without grounds for either a firm endorsement or a denial."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-synthesis-03\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.55,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The 7th house of marriage (Pisces) is occupied by the Moon, a benefic placed in the 7th itself, which supports partnership and public dealings.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/houses/6/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 7th lord Jupiter is exalted in the natal chart (Cancer), a strong dignity for the karaka of marriage among the natural benefics.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter, as 7th lord, casts its full aspect onto its own 7th house, protecting and strengthening the marriage significations.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Jupiter\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter is retrograde at birth, which many traditions read as adding hesitation, delay, or internal reworking to the matters it governs, including marriage.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\"]},{\"claim\":\"In the D9 (Navamsa), Venus and Moon sit together in the 5th with Rahu, while the D9 7th house (Virgo) is unoccupied — affection and romance are supported, but the spouse-house itself carries no benefic anchor there.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements\"]},{\"claim\":\"Transiting Saturn currently sits in Pisces conjunct the natal Moon in the 7th house, and gochara reckoning shows Saturn 1st from the Moon (sade sati onset), a classic pressure period on emotional life and partnership matters.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/transits/Saturn/inNatalHouse\",\"/transits/saturnFromMoon\",\"/transits/Saturn/conjunctNatal\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current dasha is Moon–Mars–Saturn (as of early 2026): the Moon sits in the 7th natally (marriage-relevant), while Mars is a dusthana occupant (6th) whose aspect falls on the 1st rather than supporting the 7th, so the running periods give a blended, not clearly favorable, signal.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current\",\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/aspects/Mars\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"Exact marriage-related timing would require checking specific antardasha/pratyantardasha windows against the 2nd, 7th and 11th houses; no target date was supplied for the question.\",\"Upapada lagna or Jaimini marriage indicators are not present in the chart facts.\",\"Whether the native is unmarried, married, or seeking remarriage — the question's intent is not stated.\"],\"rationale\":\"Marriage indications are genuinely two-sided. On the positive side, the 7th house holds a benefic Moon (/placements/Moon/house), its lord Jupiter is exalted (/placements/Jupiter/dignity) and aspects its own 7th (/aspects/Jupiter), and Budha-Aditya plus the Mercury raja yoga lend overall chart strength. Against this, Jupiter's retrogression adds delay/hesitation, the D9 shows Venus-Moon-Rahu clustered away from an empty D9 7th (/vargas/D9/placements), transit Saturn now conjoins the natal Moon in the 7th with sade sati beginning (/transits/Saturn/conjunctNatal, /transits/saturnFromMoon), and the current Moon–Mars dasha mixes a 7th-house Moon with a 6th-house Mars (/dasha/current). The doctrine represented here supports 'mixed': strong underlying marriage yoga, currently under visible pressure, without grounds for either a firm endorsement or a denial.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-03","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-03","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.6,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"7th house of marriage is occupied by the Moon, a benefic, indicating a spouse/partnership presence in the chart","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/houses/6"]},{"claim":"7th lord Jupiter is exalted and placed in the 11th house of gains, a strong dignity for the karaka/significator of marriage","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/house","/houses/6"]},{"claim":"Exalted Jupiter aspects the 7th house from the 11th, protecting partnership matters","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/aspects/Jupiter"]},{"claim":"Jupiter, the 7th lord, is retrograde natally, which many traditions read as delay, reversal, or reconsideration in the significations it governs","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/retrograde"]},{"claim":"D9 (Navamsa) lagna is Pisces with Venus (marriage karaka) in the 5th disposited by the Moon — reasonably supportive for marital sentiment, though Venus sits with Rahu in the 5th, adding intensity/unconventionality to romance","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D9/lagnaSign","/vargas/D9/placements/4","/vargas/D9/placements/7"]},{"claim":"Transiting Saturn sits in the natal 7th conjunct natal Moon, and gochara reckoning shows Saturn 1st from the Moon (sade sati onset), a classically taxing period for emotional life and partnerships","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/transits/Saturn/inNatalHouse","/transits/Saturn/conjunctNatal","/transits/saturnFromMoon"]},{"claim":"Current period is Moon–Mars–Saturn; Mars is 2nd-lord-for-family and also 8th lord sitting in the 6th (Vipareeta Raja Yoga), while Saturn's pratyantardasha coincides with Saturn transiting the 7th — a pressured stretch rather than an easy one for marital matters","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/dasha/current","/placements/Mars/house","/yogas/2"]},{"claim":"Upcoming Moon–Rahu antardasha (from May 2026) runs a node that aspects the 10th/12th axis natally and currently conjoins natal Mars in the 6th — relationship friction indicators should be watched, not asserted","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/upcoming/0","/transits/Rahu/conjunctNatal"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"An exalted 7th lord does not by itself guarantee a happy or intact marriage; it must be weighed against the retrogression of Jupiter, the D9 placement, and current dasha/transit pressure.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde"]},{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"omission","correction":"Any assessment ignoring the D9 chart would be incomplete, since Navamsa specifically governs spouse and marital dharma.","evidence":["/vargas/D9/meaning"]}],"missing_information":["Exact timing/context of the specific marriage question (marriage, discord, reconciliation) — the case does not state which is being asked","Whether the subject is already married (birth data alone does not establish marital status)","Upapada Lagna / Jaimini marriage references are not present in the facts"],"rationale":"The chart shows genuinely strong marriage fundamentals: a benefic Moon in the 7th (/placements/Moon/house), an exalted 7th lord Jupiter aspecting its own house (/placements/Jupiter/dignity, /aspects/Jupiter). These are offset by Jupiter's retrogression (/placements/Jupiter/retrograde), a mixed D9 where Venus shares the 5th with Rahu (/vargas/D9/placements), and a live period of pressure — transiting Saturn on the natal Moon in the 7th at sade sati onset (/transits/Saturn/inNatalHouse, /transits/saturnFromMoon) under a Moon–Mars–Saturn dasha (/dasha/current). The represented doctrine supports 'mixed' with moderate confidence: strong promise under present strain, without grounds to assert either marital success or failure as certain."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-synthesis-03\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.6,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"7th house of marriage is occupied by the Moon, a benefic, indicating a spouse/partnership presence in the chart\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/houses/6\"]},{\"claim\":\"7th lord Jupiter is exalted and placed in the 11th house of gains, a strong dignity for the karaka/significator of marriage\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/houses/6\"]},{\"claim\":\"Exalted Jupiter aspects the 7th house from the 11th, protecting partnership matters\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Jupiter\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter, the 7th lord, is retrograde natally, which many traditions read as delay, reversal, or reconsideration in the significations it governs\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\"]},{\"claim\":\"D9 (Navamsa) lagna is Pisces with Venus (marriage karaka) in the 5th disposited by the Moon — reasonably supportive for marital sentiment, though Venus sits with Rahu in the 5th, adding intensity/unconventionality to romance\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/lagnaSign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/4\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/7\"]},{\"claim\":\"Transiting Saturn sits in the natal 7th conjunct natal Moon, and gochara reckoning shows Saturn 1st from the Moon (sade sati onset), a classically taxing period for emotional life and partnerships\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/transits/Saturn/inNatalHouse\",\"/transits/Saturn/conjunctNatal\",\"/transits/saturnFromMoon\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current period is Moon–Mars–Saturn; Mars is 2nd-lord-for-family and also 8th lord sitting in the 6th (Vipareeta Raja Yoga), while Saturn's pratyantardasha coincides with Saturn transiting the 7th — a pressured stretch rather than an easy one for marital matters\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/yogas/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"Upcoming Moon–Rahu antardasha (from May 2026) runs a node that aspects the 10th/12th axis natally and currently conjoins natal Mars in the 6th — relationship friction indicators should be watched, not asserted\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/upcoming/0\",\"/transits/Rahu/conjunctNatal\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"An exalted 7th lord does not by itself guarantee a happy or intact marriage; it must be weighed against the retrogression of Jupiter, the D9 placement, and current dasha/transit pressure.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"omission\",\"correction\":\"Any assessment ignoring the D9 chart would be incomplete, since Navamsa specifically governs spouse and marital dharma.\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/meaning\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"Exact timing/context of the specific marriage question (marriage, discord, reconciliation) — the case does not state which is being asked\",\"Whether the subject is already married (birth data alone does not establish marital status)\",\"Upapada Lagna / Jaimini marriage references are not present in the facts\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart shows genuinely strong marriage fundamentals: a benefic Moon in the 7th (/placements/Moon/house), an exalted 7th lord Jupiter aspecting its own house (/placements/Jupiter/dignity, /aspects/Jupiter). These are offset by Jupiter's retrogression (/placements/Jupiter/retrograde), a mixed D9 where Venus shares the 5th with Rahu (/vargas/D9/placements), and a live period of pressure — transiting Saturn on the natal Moon in the 7th at sade sati onset (/transits/Saturn/inNatalHouse, /transits/saturnFromMoon) under a Moon–Mars–Saturn dasha (/dasha/current). The represented doctrine supports 'mixed' with moderate confidence: strong promise under present strain, without grounds to assert either marital success or failure as certain.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-application-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-01","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.7,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The second lord Venus occupies the ninth house, matching the rule's premise of a mixed long-term indication for health.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/8/significations"]},{"claim":"The chart carries additional afflictions relevant to vitality (four grahas in the 8th house including debilitated Rahu and combust Saturn), which is consistent with a 'weaker early' reading rather than uniformly poor health.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/7/occupants","/placements/Rahu/dignity","/placements/Saturn/combust"]},{"claim":"Exalted Moon in the 2nd with Gaja Kesari Yoga supports improving strength later in life, consistent with the 'better later' clause.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Moon/dignity","/yogas"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"A single placement does not indicate uniformly poor health throughout life; the rule itself treats it as mixed over time.","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"This rule gives a general health tendency only; it cannot diagnose any specific illness.","evidence":[]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Statement A matches the rule's actual claim (second lord in the ninth → mixed: weaker early, better later), and the chart confirms the premise via /placements/Venus/house=9 and /houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse=9. Statements B and C overstate what the rule establishes. Since only A applies and its polarity is mixed, the conclusion is set to mixed."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-01\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.7,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The second lord Venus occupies the ninth house, matching the rule's premise of a mixed long-term indication for health.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/8/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The chart carries additional afflictions relevant to vitality (four grahas in the 8th house including debilitated Rahu and combust Saturn), which is consistent with a 'weaker early' reading rather than uniformly poor health.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/7/occupants\",\"/placements/Rahu/dignity\",\"/placements/Saturn/combust\"]},{\"claim\":\"Exalted Moon in the 2nd with Gaja Kesari Yoga supports improving strength later in life, consistent with the 'better later' clause.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/dignity\",\"/yogas\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"A single placement does not indicate uniformly poor health throughout life; the rule itself treats it as mixed over time.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"This rule gives a general health tendency only; it cannot diagnose any specific illness.\",\"evidence\":[]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Statement A matches the rule's actual claim (second lord in the ninth → mixed: weaker early, better later), and the chart confirms the premise via /placements/Venus/house=9 and /houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse=9. Statements B and C overstate what the rule establishes. Since only A applies and its polarity is mixed, the conclusion is set to mixed.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-application-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-01","domain":"health","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.7,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The second lord Venus is placed in the ninth house, matching the rule's condition.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"Venus is a natural benefic and the 2nd house receives multiple benefic yogas (Adhi Yoga), which supports the 'better later' reading rather than uniformly poor health.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Venus/isBenefic","/yogas"]},{"claim":"Rules of planetary placement indicate general tendencies, not diagnoses; statement C is not established.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/placements"]},{"claim":"Statement B ('uniformly poor health throughout life') overstates the rule; nothing in the chart facts supports lifelong poor health from 2nd-lord-in-9th alone.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/yogas"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart satisfies the rule's premise: Venus, lord of the Taurus 2nd (/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse), sits in the 9th (/placements/Venus/house). The traditional reading of this placement for vitality is mixed — early-life strain improving with maturity — so A applies. B's absolute claim contradicts both the mixed framing and the chart's strong benefic support (exalted Moon in 2nd /placements/Moon/dignity; Adhi Yoga). C is doctrinally invalid since such rules describe tendencies, not specific illness diagnoses."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-01\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.7,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The second lord Venus is placed in the ninth house, matching the rule's condition.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus is a natural benefic and the 2nd house receives multiple benefic yogas (Adhi Yoga), which supports the 'better later' reading rather than uniformly poor health.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/isBenefic\",\"/yogas\"]},{\"claim\":\"Rules of planetary placement indicate general tendencies, not diagnoses; statement C is not established.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements\"]},{\"claim\":\"Statement B ('uniformly poor health throughout life') overstates the rule; nothing in the chart facts supports lifelong poor health from 2nd-lord-in-9th alone.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart satisfies the rule's premise: Venus, lord of the Taurus 2nd (/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse), sits in the 9th (/placements/Venus/house). The traditional reading of this placement for vitality is mixed — early-life strain improving with maturity — so A applies. B's absolute claim contradicts both the mixed framing and the chart's strong benefic support (exalted Moon in 2nd /placements/Moon/dignity; Adhi Yoga). C is doctrinally invalid since such rules describe tendencies, not specific illness diagnoses.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-application-02","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-02","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"rationale":"The chart fact /houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse=11 confirms the second lord (Mercury) is in the eleventh house. However, none of the listed statements is established: A asserts a challenging childhood-health rule that is not part of any stated doctrine, B makes an absolute guarantee (overclaim), and C claims strong childhood vitality from a placement with no such doctrinal basis. Therefore only D applies."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-02\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"confidence\":0.85,\"rationale\":\"The chart fact /houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse=11 confirms the second lord (Mercury) is in the eleventh house. However, none of the listed statements is established: A asserts a challenging childhood-health rule that is not part of any stated doctrine, B makes an absolute guarantee (overclaim), and C claims strong childhood vitality from a placement with no such doctrinal basis. Therefore only D applies.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-application-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-01","domain":"health","conclusion":"insufficient","confidence":0.75,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"factors":[],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"In this chart the second lord is Venus, placed in the ninth house (Sagittarius) per /placements/Venus/house and /placements/Venus/sign. Statements A and B attribute specific temporal health outcomes ('weaker early / better later' vs 'uniformly poor throughout life') to the placement of the second lord in the ninth. No such classical Parashari rule is established — second-lord placement primarily concerns wealth, family and speech significations (/houses/2/significations), not a determinate lifelong or time-phased health verdict. Statement C is doctrinally incorrect on its face: jyotish rules indicate tendencies and do not diagnose specific illnesses. Therefore none of A–C is established by the stated rule and chart, so D applies. Health assessment here would instead rest on factors like the heavily occupied eighth house (/houses/8/occupants: Sun, Mercury combust, Saturn combust, Rahu debilitated) and lagna lord Mars in the seventh (/lagna/lordInHouse), but these are general indications requiring proportionate uncertainty, not diagnoses."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-01\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"insufficient\",\"confidence\":0.75,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"factors\":[],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"In this chart the second lord is Venus, placed in the ninth house (Sagittarius) per /placements/Venus/house and /placements/Venus/sign. Statements A and B attribute specific temporal health outcomes ('weaker early / better later' vs 'uniformly poor throughout life') to the placement of the second lord in the ninth. No such classical Parashari rule is established — second-lord placement primarily concerns wealth, family and speech significations (/houses/2/significations), not a determinate lifelong or time-phased health verdict. Statement C is doctrinally incorrect on its face: jyotish rules indicate tendencies and do not diagnose specific illnesses. Therefore none of A–C is established by the stated rule and chart, so D applies. Health assessment here would instead rest on factors like the heavily occupied eighth house (/houses/8/occupants: Sun, Mercury combust, Saturn combust, Rahu debilitated) and lagna lord Mars in the seventh (/lagna/lordInHouse), but these are general indications requiring proportionate uncertainty, not diagnoses.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-application-02","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-02","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"rationale":"The chart facts show the 2nd lord (Mercury) placed in the 11th house (/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse = 11). No stated rule links this placement to childhood health outcomes, so statements A-C are not established by the given rule and chart; D applies."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-02\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"confidence\":0.85,\"rationale\":\"The chart facts show the 2nd lord (Mercury) placed in the 11th house (/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse = 11). No stated rule links this placement to childhood health outcomes, so statements A-C are not established by the given rule and chart; D applies.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-application-02","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-02","domain":"health","conclusion":"insufficient","confidence":0.7,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"factors":[{"claim":"The second house lord (Mercury) is placed in the eleventh house.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"Second lord in the eleventh is not a recognized rule for challenging childhood health; it is classically read as a wealth/gain indication.","effect":"neutral","evidence":[]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"A","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Second lord in the eleventh is not a standard challenging childhood-health rule; classical Jyotish treats this as a dhana/labha (gains) placement.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"No placement guarantees lifelong illness; this is an absolute claim unsupported by any stated rule or chart fact.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"A single placement cannot by itself establish strong childhood vitality; vitality assessment requires lagna, lagna lord, Moon, and 6th/8th house condition.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"missing_information":["Lagna sign and lagna lord placement","Moon sign and strength","Sixth and eighth house lords and occupants","Any stated rule text defining second-lord-in-eleventh as a health indicator"],"rationale":"Chart facts show only that the second lord (Mercury) sits in the eleventh (/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse). Statements A-C each fail: A misstates doctrine (this is a gains placement, not a childhood-health affliction rule), B is an unsupported guarantee, and C overclaims vitality from a single factor. Therefore none of A-C is established, option D applies, and no health polarity can be concluded from the given facts."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-02\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"insufficient\",\"confidence\":0.7,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The second house lord (Mercury) is placed in the eleventh house.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"Second lord in the eleventh is not a recognized rule for challenging childhood health; it is classically read as a wealth/gain indication.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"A\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Second lord in the eleventh is not a standard challenging childhood-health rule; classical Jyotish treats this as a dhana/labha (gains) placement.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"No placement guarantees lifelong illness; this is an absolute claim unsupported by any stated rule or chart fact.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"A single placement cannot by itself establish strong childhood vitality; vitality assessment requires lagna, lagna lord, Moon, and 6th/8th house condition.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"Lagna sign and lagna lord placement\",\"Moon sign and strength\",\"Sixth and eighth house lords and occupants\",\"Any stated rule text defining second-lord-in-eleventh as a health indicator\"],\"rationale\":\"Chart facts show only that the second lord (Mercury) sits in the eleventh (/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse). Statements A-C each fail: A misstates doctrine (this is a gains placement, not a childhood-health affliction rule), B is an unsupported guarantee, and C overclaims vitality from a single factor. Therefore none of A-C is established, option D applies, and no health polarity can be concluded from the given facts.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-application-03","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-03","domain":"health","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.8,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Jupiter, lord of the 12th, occupies the 6th house — a Vipareeta Raja Yoga (one dusthana lord fallen into another), traditionally treated as supportive of resilience rather than as a vitality weakness","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/sign","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/yogas/2"]},{"claim":"The yoga does not confer guaranteed immunity from illness; the 6th remains a dusthana of disease and its lord Mercury sits in the 2nd, while transiting Rahu aspects the natal 6th","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/reference/houseSignifications/6","/placements/Mercury/house","/transits/Rahu/aspectingNatalHouses"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"No chart or rule guarantees freedom from illness; Vipareeta Raja Yoga at most indicates resilience through adversity, not immunity.","evidence":["/yogas/2"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"A dusthana lord in another dusthana is read as Vipareeta Raja Yoga (a strength), not necessarily a weak-vitality indication.","evidence":["/yogas/2"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"omission","correction":"Statement A is established by the chart: Jupiter rules the 12th (/houses/12/lord) and sits in the 6th (/placements/Jupiter/house).","evidence":["/houses/12/lord","/placements/Jupiter/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only statement A matches the chart facts and doctrine: /houses/12/lord shows Jupiter rules the 12th, and /placements/Jupiter/house places it in the 6th, matching the Vipareeta Raja Yoga entry (/yogas/2). This is treated as supportive of resilience (hence conclusion 'supportive'), while B's guarantee and C's necessary weakness are both unsupported."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-03\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Jupiter, lord of the 12th, occupies the 6th house — a Vipareeta Raja Yoga (one dusthana lord fallen into another), traditionally treated as supportive of resilience rather than as a vitality weakness\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/sign\",\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/yogas/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"The yoga does not confer guaranteed immunity from illness; the 6th remains a dusthana of disease and its lord Mercury sits in the 2nd, while transiting Rahu aspects the natal 6th\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/reference/houseSignifications/6\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/transits/Rahu/aspectingNatalHouses\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"No chart or rule guarantees freedom from illness; Vipareeta Raja Yoga at most indicates resilience through adversity, not immunity.\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/2\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"A dusthana lord in another dusthana is read as Vipareeta Raja Yoga (a strength), not necessarily a weak-vitality indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/2\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"omission\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established by the chart: Jupiter rules the 12th (/houses/12/lord) and sits in the 6th (/placements/Jupiter/house).\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/12/lord\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only statement A matches the chart facts and doctrine: /houses/12/lord shows Jupiter rules the 12th, and /placements/Jupiter/house places it in the 6th, matching the Vipareeta Raja Yoga entry (/yogas/2). This is treated as supportive of resilience (hence conclusion 'supportive'), while B's guarantee and C's necessary weakness are both unsupported.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-application-03","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-03","domain":"health","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Jupiter, lord of the 12th, occupies the 6th house — a Vipareeta Raja Yoga configuration traditionally read as supportive of resilience through adversity","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/yogas/2"]},{"claim":"Statement B is not established: Vipareeta Raja Yoga does not guarantee freedom from illness; the 6th still holds Ketu with the 12th-lord placement","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/yogas/2","/houses/6/occupants"]},{"claim":"Statement C is contradicted by the stated yoga classification, which frames 12th-lord-in-6th as a raja yoga rather than a weak-vitality indication","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/yogas/2"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The rule treats the placement as supportive via Vipareeta Raja Yoga but confers no guarantee of freedom from illness.","evidence":["/yogas/2"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Under Parashari doctrine this placement forms a raja yoga (dusthana lord in another dusthana), so it is not necessarily a weak-vitality indication.","evidence":["/yogas/2"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only statement A is established: /placements/Jupiter/house = 6 and the chart facts explicitly list 'Vipareeta Raja Yoga' because Jupiter, lord of the 12th, sits in the 6th (/yogas/2). This supports general resilience framing. Statements B (guarantee of health) and C (necessarily weak vitality) both overstate or contradict the rule, so they are not selected. The conclusion polarity follows A alone: supportive."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-03\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.85,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Jupiter, lord of the 12th, occupies the 6th house — a Vipareeta Raja Yoga configuration traditionally read as supportive of resilience through adversity\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/yogas/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"Statement B is not established: Vipareeta Raja Yoga does not guarantee freedom from illness; the 6th still holds Ketu with the 12th-lord placement\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/2\",\"/houses/6/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"Statement C is contradicted by the stated yoga classification, which frames 12th-lord-in-6th as a raja yoga rather than a weak-vitality indication\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/2\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The rule treats the placement as supportive via Vipareeta Raja Yoga but confers no guarantee of freedom from illness.\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/2\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Under Parashari doctrine this placement forms a raja yoga (dusthana lord in another dusthana), so it is not necessarily a weak-vitality indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/2\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only statement A is established: /placements/Jupiter/house = 6 and the chart facts explicitly list 'Vipareeta Raja Yoga' because Jupiter, lord of the 12th, sits in the 6th (/yogas/2). This supports general resilience framing. Statements B (guarantee of health) and C (necessarily weak vitality) both overstate or contradict the rule, so they are not selected. The conclusion polarity follows A alone: supportive.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-application-03","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-03","domain":"health","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.8,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The twelfth lord Jupiter placed in the sixth forms a Vipareeta Raja Yoga, classically treated as supportive of resilience through adversity rather than as a weak-vitality indication.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/2","/placements/Jupiter/house","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"The yoga does not guarantee freedom from illness; house 6 still signifies disease and contains Ketu with multiple afflictions (aspects of Mars, Venus, Rahu).","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/yogas/2/because","/houses/6/occupants","/houses/6/aspectedBy","/reference/houseSignifications/6"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"No rule states that Vipareeta Raja Yoga guarantees freedom from illness; it indicates gains from adversity at best.","evidence":["/yogas/2"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"A dusthana lord in another dusthana is read as Harsha/Vipareeta-type Raja Yoga, not necessarily a weak-vitality indication.","evidence":["/yogas/2/because"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only statement A reflects the stated rule: Jupiter, lord of the twelfth, sits in the sixth, forming Vipareeta Raja Yoga (/yogas/2), which is treated as supportive of resilience. Statements B (guarantee) and C (necessarily weak vitality) are not established by doctrine or this chart, so they are excluded and the conclusion takes the polarity of A alone."},"extracted":"{\n \"case_id\": \"health-application-03\",\n \"domain\": \"health\",\n \"conclusion\": \"supportive\",\n \"confidence\": 0.8,\n \"selected_option_ids\": [\"A\"],\n \"factors\": [\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"The twelfth lord Jupiter placed in the sixth forms a Vipareeta Raja Yoga, classically treated as supportive of resilience through adversity rather than as a weak-vitality indication.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/2\", \"/placements/Jupiter/house\", \"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"The yoga does not guarantee freedom from illness; house 6 still signifies disease and contains Ketu with multiple afflictions (aspects of Mars, Venus, Rahu).\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/2/because\", \"/houses/6/occupants\", \"/houses/6/aspectedBy\", \"/reference/houseSignifications/6\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"contradictions\": [\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"B\",\n   \"error_type\": \"overclaim\",\n   \"correction\": \"No rule states that Vipareeta Raja Yoga guarantees freedom from illness; it indicates gains from adversity at best.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/2\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"C\",\n   \"error_type\": \"doctrinal\",\n   \"correction\": \"A dusthana lord in another dusthana is read as Harsha/Vipareeta-type Raja Yoga, not necessarily a weak-vitality indication.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/2/because\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"missing_information\": [],\n \"rationale\": \"Only statement A reflects the stated rule: Jupiter, lord of the twelfth, sits in the sixth, forming Vipareeta Raja Yoga (/yogas/2), which is treated as supportive of resilience. Statements B (guarantee) and C (necessarily weak vitality) are not established by doctrine or this chart, so they are excluded and the conclusion takes the polarity of A alone.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-application-04","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-04","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"rationale":"Venus sits in house 3 (Scorpio) with Neutral dignity (/placements/Venus/house, /placements/Venus/dignity). House 3 signifies courage, initiative and communication — not vitality (house 1) or disease (houses 6/8/12). No standard Parashari rule makes Venus in the 3rd a challenge to vitality (A), and no astrological statement 'proves' a medical diagnosis (B). Nor is it an unqualified strong-vitality indication (C) — the 3rd simply is not a vitality house. Therefore none of A–C is established; D applies. Since only D is applicable and D negates A–C, the conclusion polarity of applicable statements is not a health-supporting or challenging finding."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-04\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"confidence\":0.85,\"rationale\":\"Venus sits in house 3 (Scorpio) with Neutral dignity (/placements/Venus/house, /placements/Venus/dignity). House 3 signifies courage, initiative and communication — not vitality (house 1) or disease (houses 6/8/12). No standard Parashari rule makes Venus in the 3rd a challenge to vitality (A), and no astrological statement 'proves' a medical diagnosis (B). Nor is it an unqualified strong-vitality indication (C) — the 3rd simply is not a vitality house. Therefore none of A–C is established; D applies. Since only D is applicable and D negates A–C, the conclusion polarity of applicable statements is not a health-supporting or challenging finding.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-application-04","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-04","domain":"health","conclusion":"insufficient","confidence":0.7,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"factors":[{"claim":"Venus occupies the 3rd house (Scorpio), a neutral-dignity benefic in an upachaya; the chart does not establish it as either a challenging or a strong vitality indication.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/dignity","/houses/3/significations"]},{"claim":"Statement B (diagnosis proof) has no doctrinal or chart basis; astrology cannot prove a medical diagnosis.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["No stated rule text linking Venus-in-3rd to vitality outcomes","No lagna/6th-house affliction data beyond natal Mars placement"],"rationale":"Venus is in the 3rd house (/placements/Venus/house) with neutral dignity (/placements/Venus/dignity). The 3rd signifies courage and initiative (/houses/3/significations), not vitality directly, so neither a challenging reading (A) nor an unqualified strong-vitality reading (C) is established by any stated rule. Statement B overclaims by asserting diagnostic proof, which no chart factor can establish. Therefore none of A-C applies (D)."},"extracted":"{\n  \"case_id\": \"health-application-04\",\n  \"domain\": \"health\",\n  \"conclusion\": \"insufficient\",\n  \"confidence\": 0.7,\n  \"selected_option_ids\": [\"D\"],\n  \"factors\": [\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Venus occupies the 3rd house (Scorpio), a neutral-dignity benefic in an upachaya; the chart does not establish it as either a challenging or a strong vitality indication.\",\n      \"effect\": \"neutral\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Venus/house\", \"/placements/Venus/dignity\", \"/houses/3/significations\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Statement B (diagnosis proof) has no doctrinal or chart basis; astrology cannot prove a medical diagnosis.\",\n      \"effect\": \"neutral\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Venus/house\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"contradictions\": [],\n  \"missing_information\": [\n    \"No stated rule text linking Venus-in-3rd to vitality outcomes\",\n    \"No lagna/6th-house affliction data beyond natal Mars placement\"\n  ],\n  \"rationale\": \"Venus is in the 3rd house (/placements/Venus/house) with neutral dignity (/placements/Venus/dignity). The 3rd signifies courage and initiative (/houses/3/significations), not vitality directly, so neither a challenging reading (A) nor an unqualified strong-vitality reading (C) is established by any stated rule. Statement B overclaims by asserting diagnostic proof, which no chart factor can establish. Therefore none of A-C applies (D).\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-application-04","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-04","domain":"health","conclusion":"insufficient","confidence":0.7,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"factors":[],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["A stated classical rule governing Venus's effect on vitality by house placement"],"rationale":"None of the three statements is established. B ('proves a medical diagnosis') is an overclaim astrology cannot support under any rule. C is contradicted by the chart itself: Venus sits in the 3rd (/placements/Venus/house), and the 3rd's significations are 'courage, siblings, initiative...' (/houses/2/significations) — no unqualified strong-vitality result follows from this placement. A would require a specific doctrinal rule treating benefics in the 3rd as adverse to vitality, which is neither supplied nor standard; classically the 3rd is an upachaya where even mild placements tend toward neutral-to-favorable outcomes over time. With no applicable statement, the polarity is indeterminate."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-04\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"insufficient\",\"confidence\":0.7,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"factors\":[],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"A stated classical rule governing Venus's effect on vitality by house placement\"],\"rationale\":\"None of the three statements is established. B ('proves a medical diagnosis') is an overclaim astrology cannot support under any rule. C is contradicted by the chart itself: Venus sits in the 3rd (/placements/Venus/house), and the 3rd's significations are 'courage, siblings, initiative...' (/houses/2/significations) — no unqualified strong-vitality result follows from this placement. A would require a specific doctrinal rule treating benefics in the 3rd as adverse to vitality, which is neither supplied nor standard; classically the 3rd is an upachaya where even mild placements tend toward neutral-to-favorable outcomes over time. With no applicable statement, the polarity is indeterminate.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-contradiction-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-contradiction-01","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.95,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Sun in the 6th is a general health indication only, not a diagnosis.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"A 6th-house Sun indicates susceptibility to health challenges generally; it does not prove any specific disease such as heart disease, and no diagnosis can be drawn from chart facts.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/sign"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"The Sun occupies house 6 (Aries), not house 7; Mars occupies house 7.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Mars/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is accurate: the exalted Sun sits in the 6th house (/placements/Sun/house), a dusthana tied to disease and debt, so a general health challenge reading is appropriate without diagnosing. S2 is an overclaim — no chart fact supports proving heart disease. S3 misstates placement; Sun is in Aries in the 6th, not the 7th."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-contradiction-01\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.95,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Sun in the 6th is a general health indication only, not a diagnosis.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"A 6th-house Sun indicates susceptibility to health challenges generally; it does not prove any specific disease such as heart disease, and no diagnosis can be drawn from chart facts.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Sun/sign\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"The Sun occupies house 6 (Aries), not house 7; Mars occupies house 7.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Mars/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S1 is accurate: the exalted Sun sits in the 6th house (/placements/Sun/house), a dusthana tied to disease and debt, so a general health challenge reading is appropriate without diagnosing. S2 is an overclaim — no chart fact supports proving heart disease. S3 misstates placement; Sun is in Aries in the 6th, not the 7th.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-contradiction-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-contradiction-01","domain":"health","conclusion":"insufficient","confidence":0.95,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"S1 is accurate: Sun in 6th (house of disease) noted as a general indication, not a diagnosis","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house"]},{"claim":"S2 is an overclaim: no placement proves a specific disease; Sun in 6th is only a general health/disease-house indication","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house"]},{"claim":"S3 is factually wrong: Sun is in house 6, not house 7 (Mars occupies the 7th)","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Mars/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Sun exalted in the 6th is at most a general indication regarding disease/enemies/service; Jyotish placements do not prove specific diseases like heart disease. No diagnosis can be established from this chart alone.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/sign"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"The Sun occupies natal house 6 (Aries, Ashwini), not house 7. House 7 (Taurus) contains Mars.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/signIndex","/houses/6/occupants","/houses/7/occupants"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 correctly frames the Sun-in-6th as a general health indicator without diagnosing (/placements/Sun/house). S2 overclaims by asserting heart disease from a single placement — astrology cannot prove diagnoses. S3 misstates the Sun's house: it is in the 6th per /placements/Sun/house, while /houses/7/occupants shows Mars, not the Sun."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-contradiction-01\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"insufficient\",\"confidence\":0.95,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"S1 is accurate: Sun in 6th (house of disease) noted as a general indication, not a diagnosis\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"S2 is an overclaim: no placement proves a specific disease; Sun in 6th is only a general health/disease-house indication\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"S3 is factually wrong: Sun is in house 6, not house 7 (Mars occupies the 7th)\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Mars/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Sun exalted in the 6th is at most a general indication regarding disease/enemies/service; Jyotish placements do not prove specific diseases like heart disease. No diagnosis can be established from this chart alone.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Sun/sign\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"The Sun occupies natal house 6 (Aries, Ashwini), not house 7. House 7 (Taurus) contains Mars.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Sun/signIndex\",\"/houses/6/occupants\",\"/houses/7/occupants\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S1 correctly frames the Sun-in-6th as a general health indicator without diagnosing (/placements/Sun/house). S2 overclaims by asserting heart disease from a single placement — astrology cannot prove diagnoses. S3 misstates the Sun's house: it is in the 6th per /placements/Sun/house, while /houses/7/occupants shows Mars, not the Sun.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-contradiction-02","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-contradiction-02","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Ruchaka Yoga (Mars own-sign in kendra house 4) supports physical vitality and courage","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/0","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity"]},{"claim":"Chart also carries health-relevant stress: Saturn in enemy sign in 4th, debilitated Rahu/Ketu, and 6th-house occupancy of Venus and Mercury with Saturn aspecting the 6th","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Rahu/dignity","/placements/Venus/house","/aspects/Saturn"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Ruchaka Yoga does not guarantee perfect health. It is a supportive Mahapurusha indication for strength and resilience; it cannot nullify other chart factors such as Saturn's enemy placement (/placements/Saturn/dignity), debilitated nodes (/placements/Rahu/dignity), or dusthana-linked significations. Astrological yogas indicate tendencies, never certainties.","evidence":["/yogas/0","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Rahu/dignity"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Ruchaka Yoga IS present in the computed yoga list: 'Mars is own sign in Scorpio and occupies house 4, a kendra'. Statement S3 directly contradicts /yogas/0.","evidence":["/yogas/0","/placements/Mars/sign","/placements/Mars/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is accurate: Ruchaka Yoga is listed (/yogas/0) via Mars in own-sign Scorpio in the 4th (kendra), and as a Mahapurusha yoga it is reasonably treated as supportive of physique/vitality. S2 overclaims certainty from a supportive factor. S3 is factually wrong since the yoga explicitly appears in the computed list."},"extracted":"{\n \"case_id\":\"health-contradiction-02\",\n \"domain\":\"health\",\n \"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\n \"confidence\":0.9,\n \"selected_option_ids\":[],\n \"factors\":[\n  {\"claim\":\"Ruchaka Yoga (Mars own-sign in kendra house 4) supports physical vitality and courage\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\"]},\n  {\"claim\":\"Chart also carries health-relevant stress: Saturn in enemy sign in 4th, debilitated Rahu/Ketu, and 6th-house occupancy of Venus and Mercury with Saturn aspecting the 6th\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Rahu/dignity\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/aspects/Saturn\"]}\n ],\n \"contradictions\":[\n  {\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Ruchaka Yoga does not guarantee perfect health. It is a supportive Mahapurusha indication for strength and resilience; it cannot nullify other chart factors such as Saturn's enemy placement (/placements/Saturn/dignity), debilitated nodes (/placements/Rahu/dignity), or dusthana-linked significations. Astrological yogas indicate tendencies, never certainties.\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Rahu/dignity\"]},\n  {\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Ruchaka Yoga IS present in the computed yoga list: 'Mars is own sign in Scorpio and occupies house 4, a kendra'. Statement S3 directly contradicts /yogas/0.\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0\",\"/placements/Mars/sign\",\"/placements/Mars/house\"]}\n ],\n \"missing_information\":[],\n \"rationale\":\"S1 is accurate: Ruchaka Yoga is listed (/yogas/0) via Mars in own-sign Scorpio in the 4th (kendra), and as a Mahapurusha yoga it is reasonably treated as supportive of physique/vitality. S2 overclaims certainty from a supportive factor. S3 is factually wrong since the yoga explicitly appears in the computed list.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-contradiction-02","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-contradiction-02","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Ruchaka Yoga is present and can reasonably be read as supportive of a strong physique, but it does not guarantee health.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/yogas/0","/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Mars/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Ruchaka Yoga (Mars in own sign in a kendra) is an indicator of vigor and courage; no yoga 'guarantees perfect health.' Health indications here are mixed — the 4th-house cluster of Mars, Saturn (in enemy sign), and debilitated Rahu, with Ketu aspecting the 6th house of disease, tempers any promise of robust health.","evidence":["/yogas/0/because","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Rahu/dignity","/placements/Rahu/house","/houses/5/aspectedBy"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Ruchaka Yoga is explicitly present in the computed yoga list: Mars is in own sign Scorpio in the 4th house, a kendra.","evidence":["/yogas/0/name","/placements/Mars/sign","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 stands as stated: Ruchaka Yoga (/yogas/0) from Mars' own-sign Scorpio placement in kendra house 4 supports physical strength by standard doctrine. S2 overclaims certainty ('guarantees perfect health'), ignoring countervailing factors like Saturn in enemy sign and Rahu's debilitation in the 4th. S3 directly contradicts the chart facts, which list Ruchaka Yoga first among computed yogas."},"extracted":"{\n \"case_id\": \"health-contradiction-02\",\n \"domain\": \"health\",\n \"conclusion\": \"mixed\",\n \"confidence\": 0.9,\n \"selected_option_ids\": [],\n \"factors\": [\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Ruchaka Yoga is present and can reasonably be read as supportive of a strong physique, but it does not guarantee health.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/0\", \"/placements/Mars/dignity\", \"/placements/Mars/house\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"contradictions\": [\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"S2\",\n   \"error_type\": \"overclaim\",\n   \"correction\": \"Ruchaka Yoga (Mars in own sign in a kendra) is an indicator of vigor and courage; no yoga 'guarantees perfect health.' Health indications here are mixed — the 4th-house cluster of Mars, Saturn (in enemy sign), and debilitated Rahu, with Ketu aspecting the 6th house of disease, tempers any promise of robust health.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/0/because\", \"/placements/Saturn/dignity\", \"/placements/Rahu/dignity\", \"/placements/Rahu/house\", \"/houses/5/aspectedBy\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"S3\",\n   \"error_type\": \"factual\",\n   \"correction\": \"Ruchaka Yoga is explicitly present in the computed yoga list: Mars is in own sign Scorpio in the 4th house, a kendra.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/0/name\", \"/placements/Mars/sign\", \"/placements/Mars/house\", \"/placements/Mars/dignity\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"missing_information\": [],\n \"rationale\": \"S1 stands as stated: Ruchaka Yoga (/yogas/0) from Mars' own-sign Scorpio placement in kendra house 4 supports physical strength by standard doctrine. S2 overclaims certainty ('guarantees perfect health'), ignoring countervailing factors like Saturn in enemy sign and Rahu's debilitation in the 4th. S3 directly contradicts the chart facts, which list Ruchaka Yoga first among computed yogas.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-contradiction-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-contradiction-01","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.95,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Sun in the 6th house (Aries, exalted) is a general indication of health-related themes (disease/debt/enemies house) but not a diagnosis","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/houses/6/significations","/placements/Sun/dignity"]},{"claim":"Statement S3 wrongly places the Sun in house 7; the Sun is actually in house 6","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The Sun in the 6th is a general indication concerning health/disease themes and does not prove any specific disease such as heart disease. Diagnosis cannot be made from a single placement. Note also the Sun here is exalted (/placements/Sun/dignity), which many traditions read as strengthening vitality rather than indicating illness.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/dignity","/houses/6/significations"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"The Sun occupies house 6 (Aries), not house 7; Mars occupies house 7.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/sign","/placements/Mars/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is accurate and appropriately hedged: it treats Sun-in-6 as a general health-theme indication without diagnosing, consistent with /houses/6/significations ('disease, debt, enemies, litigation, service') and /placements/Sun/house = 6. S2 overclaims by asserting heart disease from one placement — Jyotish does not permit disease diagnosis from a single factor, and the Sun's exaltation further weakens any illness reading. S3 is factually wrong: /placements/Sun/house shows house 6, while house 7 holds Mars (/placements/Mars/house)."},"extracted":"{\n \"case_id\": \"health-contradiction-01\",\n \"domain\": \"health\",\n \"conclusion\": \"mixed\",\n \"confidence\": 0.95,\n \"selected_option_ids\": [],\n \"factors\": [\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Sun in the 6th house (Aries, exalted) is a general indication of health-related themes (disease/debt/enemies house) but not a diagnosis\",\n   \"effect\": \"neutral\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Sun/house\", \"/houses/6/significations\", \"/placements/Sun/dignity\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Statement S3 wrongly places the Sun in house 7; the Sun is actually in house 6\",\n   \"effect\": \"neutral\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Sun/house\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"contradictions\": [\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"S2\",\n   \"error_type\": \"overclaim\",\n   \"correction\": \"The Sun in the 6th is a general indication concerning health/disease themes and does not prove any specific disease such as heart disease. Diagnosis cannot be made from a single placement. Note also the Sun here is exalted (/placements/Sun/dignity), which many traditions read as strengthening vitality rather than indicating illness.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Sun/house\", \"/placements/Sun/dignity\", \"/houses/6/significations\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"S3\",\n   \"error_type\": \"factual\",\n   \"correction\": \"The Sun occupies house 6 (Aries), not house 7; Mars occupies house 7.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Sun/house\", \"/placements/Sun/sign\", \"/placements/Mars/house\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"missing_information\": [],\n \"rationale\": \"S1 is accurate and appropriately hedged: it treats Sun-in-6 as a general health-theme indication without diagnosing, consistent with /houses/6/significations ('disease, debt, enemies, litigation, service') and /placements/Sun/house = 6. S2 overclaims by asserting heart disease from one placement — Jyotish does not permit disease diagnosis from a single factor, and the Sun's exaltation further weakens any illness reading. S3 is factually wrong: /placements/Sun/house shows house 6, while house 7 holds Mars (/placements/Mars/house).\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-contradiction-02","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-contradiction-02","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Ruchaka Yoga present: Mars own-sign Scorpio in 4th (kendra), supporting vitality/strong physique indication","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Mars/house","/yogas/0"]},{"claim":"Saturn and Rahu also occupy the 4th with Mars; Saturn aspects the lagna, tempering the health picture","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/3/occupants","/aspects/Saturn","/placements/Rahu/dignity"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Ruchaka Yoga is an indication of physical strength and courage, not a guarantee of perfect health. No yoga guarantees perfect health; here Saturn's aspect on the lagna (/aspects/Saturn -> house 1) and Saturn-Rahu placement in the 4th (/houses/3/occupants) introduce mixed health indications.","evidence":["/yogas/0","/aspects/Saturn","/houses/3/occupants"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Ruchaka Yoga IS present in the computed yoga list: it is the first entry, because Mars is own sign in Scorpio occupying kendra house 4.","evidence":["/yogas/0/name","/yogas/0/because","/placements/Mars/sign","/placements/Mars/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 correctly states Ruchaka Yoga's supportive indication for a strong physique, matching /yogas/0. S2 overstates by converting an indication into a guarantee of perfect health — doctrinally unsound and contradicted by Saturn's lagna aspect and malefic occupancy of the 4th. S3 factually denies a yoga that is explicitly computed at /yogas/0."},"extracted":"{\n  \"case_id\": \"health-contradiction-02\",\n  \"domain\": \"health\",\n  \"conclusion\": \"mixed\",\n  \"confidence\": 0.9,\n  \"selected_option_ids\": [],\n  \"factors\": [\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Ruchaka Yoga present: Mars own-sign Scorpio in 4th (kendra), supporting vitality/strong physique indication\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mars/dignity\", \"/placements/Mars/house\", \"/yogas/0\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Saturn and Rahu also occupy the 4th with Mars; Saturn aspects the lagna, tempering the health picture\",\n      \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/houses/3/occupants\", \"/aspects/Saturn\", \"/placements/Rahu/dignity\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"contradictions\": [\n    {\n      \"statement_id\": \"S2\",\n      \"error_type\": \"overclaim\",\n      \"correction\": \"Ruchaka Yoga is an indication of physical strength and courage, not a guarantee of perfect health. No yoga guarantees perfect health; here Saturn's aspect on the lagna (/aspects/Saturn -> house 1) and Saturn-Rahu placement in the 4th (/houses/3/occupants) introduce mixed health indications.\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/0\", \"/aspects/Saturn\", \"/houses/3/occupants\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"statement_id\": \"S3\",\n      \"error_type\": \"factual\",\n      \"correction\": \"Ruchaka Yoga IS present in the computed yoga list: it is the first entry, because Mars is own sign in Scorpio occupying kendra house 4.\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/0/name\", \"/yogas/0/because\", \"/placements/Mars/sign\", \"/placements/Mars/house\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"missing_information\": [],\n  \"rationale\": \"S1 correctly states Ruchaka Yoga's supportive indication for a strong physique, matching /yogas/0. S2 overstates by converting an indication into a guarantee of perfect health — doctrinally unsound and contradicted by Saturn's lagna aspect and malefic occupancy of the 4th. S3 factually denies a yoga that is explicitly computed at /yogas/0.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-synthesis-02","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-02","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.7,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Lagna lord Moon is debilitated in Scorpio in the 5th, weakening vitality and resilience at the root level","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Moon/dignity","/placements/Moon/house","/lagna/lord"]},{"claim":"Rahu occupies the 6th house of disease, a classic indicator of hard-to-diagnose or stress-linked ailments","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Rahu/house","/houses/5"]},{"claim":"Saturn aspects the lagna (1st) and the 6th house from Libra, adding chronicity and slow-recovery themes to body and disease houses","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Saturn"]},{"claim":"Mars also aspects the 1st house; combined Saturn-Mars influence on the lagna can indicate injuries, inflammation or blood/pitta-type complaints despite Mars's own-sign strength","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/aspects/Mars","/placements/Mars/dignity"]},{"claim":"Jupiter, lord of the 6th, is placed in the 12th forming Vipareeta Raja Yoga — a mitigating factor where illness lords weaken each other, suggesting recovery from adversity","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/4","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Mercury (lord of 12) in the 8th forms a second Vipareeta Raja Yoga, further buffering chronic/sudden health events","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/5","/placements/Mercury/house"]},{"claim":"Current Jupiter mahadasha: Jupiter rules the 6th (disease) and sits in the 12th retrograde in enemy sign — health requires attention during this period (2025-2041)","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord","/houses/5/significations"]},{"claim":"Transits as of 2026-01-01: transit Rahu conjunct natal Mercury in natal 8th; transit Saturn conjunct natal Sun in 9th; multiple planets transiting natal 6th over Rahu — elevated acute-stress indicators now","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/transits/contacts/7","/transits/contacts/6","/transits/contacts/2"]},{"claim":"Gochara Saturn is 5th from natal Moon and Jupiter 8th from Moon — outside sade sati but not fully comfortable lunar transits","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/transits/saturnFromMoon","/transits/jupiterFromMoon"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Debilitated lagna lord would suggest poor vitality outright, but the double Vipareeta Raja Yoga and exalted Saturn (Sasa Yoga) on a kendra counterbalance this; the correct reading is vulnerability with strong recovery capacity, not chronic ill-health.","evidence":["/yogas/1","/yogas/4","/yogas/5"]}],"missing_information":["Exact current health complaints and age-related context","D60 and medical-specific vargas for finer confirmation"],"rationale":"The chart shows genuine constitutional vulnerability: a debilitated lagna lord (/placements/Moon/dignity), Rahu in the 6th (/placements/Rahu/house), and dual Saturn-Mars aspects on the lagna (/aspects/Saturn,/aspects/Mars), all aggravated by a current Jupiter dasha whose lord rules the disease house and sits in the 12th (/dasha/current). However, two Vipareeta Raja Yogas (/yogas/4,/yogas/5) and Sasa Yoga (/yogas/1) provide strong compensatory recovery power. Present transits (Rahu over natal Mercury in the 8th, Saturn over natal Sun) suggest an acutely sensitive window rather than a structural decline. Overall: mixed — watch health proactively during Jupiter mahadasha, especially the Jupiter-Saturn antardasha from 2027 (/dasha/upcoming/0), but no fatalistic reading is warranted."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-synthesis-02\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.7,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Lagna lord Moon is debilitated in Scorpio in the 5th, weakening vitality and resilience at the root level\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/dignity\",\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/lagna/lord\"]},{\"claim\":\"Rahu occupies the 6th house of disease, a classic indicator of hard-to-diagnose or stress-linked ailments\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/houses/5\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn aspects the lagna (1st) and the 6th house from Libra, adding chronicity and slow-recovery themes to body and disease houses\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Saturn\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars also aspects the 1st house; combined Saturn-Mars influence on the lagna can indicate injuries, inflammation or blood/pitta-type complaints despite Mars's own-sign strength\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter, lord of the 6th, is placed in the 12th forming Vipareeta Raja Yoga — a mitigating factor where illness lords weaken each other, suggesting recovery from adversity\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/4\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury (lord of 12) in the 8th forms a second Vipareeta Raja Yoga, further buffering chronic/sudden health events\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/5\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current Jupiter mahadasha: Jupiter rules the 6th (disease) and sits in the 12th retrograde in enemy sign — health requires attention during this period (2025-2041)\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord\",\"/houses/5/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Transits as of 2026-01-01: transit Rahu conjunct natal Mercury in natal 8th; transit Saturn conjunct natal Sun in 9th; multiple planets transiting natal 6th over Rahu — elevated acute-stress indicators now\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/transits/contacts/7\",\"/transits/contacts/6\",\"/transits/contacts/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"Gochara Saturn is 5th from natal Moon and Jupiter 8th from Moon — outside sade sati but not fully comfortable lunar transits\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/transits/saturnFromMoon\",\"/transits/jupiterFromMoon\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Debilitated lagna lord would suggest poor vitality outright, but the double Vipareeta Raja Yoga and exalted Saturn (Sasa Yoga) on a kendra counterbalance this; the correct reading is vulnerability with strong recovery capacity, not chronic ill-health.\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\",\"/yogas/4\",\"/yogas/5\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"Exact current health complaints and age-related context\",\"D60 and medical-specific vargas for finer confirmation\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart shows genuine constitutional vulnerability: a debilitated lagna lord (/placements/Moon/dignity), Rahu in the 6th (/placements/Rahu/house), and dual Saturn-Mars aspects on the lagna (/aspects/Saturn,/aspects/Mars), all aggravated by a current Jupiter dasha whose lord rules the disease house and sits in the 12th (/dasha/current). However, two Vipareeta Raja Yogas (/yogas/4,/yogas/5) and Sasa Yoga (/yogas/1) provide strong compensatory recovery power. Present transits (Rahu over natal Mercury in the 8th, Saturn over natal Sun) suggest an acutely sensitive window rather than a structural decline. Overall: mixed — watch health proactively during Jupiter mahadasha, especially the Jupiter-Saturn antardasha from 2027 (/dasha/upcoming/0), but no fatalistic reading is warranted.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-synthesis-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-01","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.6,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Lagna lord Saturn placed in the 11th in enemy sign but conjunct its dispositor Mars (own-sign) forms a Raja/Dhana yoga, giving underlying vitality and resilience of the body's framework.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Mars/sign","/yogas"]},{"claim":"Budha-Aditya yoga in the lagna (Sun + Mercury in Capricorn) supports mental clarity and recuperative intellect, though Sun is in enemy dignity and Saturn aspects the lagna from the 11th, adding chronic, slow-building strain to the constitution.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Sun/dignity","/aspects/Saturn","/houses/0/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Moon, a key significator of fluids and mind, is combust and sits in the 2nd aspected by Mars and Jupiter; combustion weakens the Moon's protective role for health.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Moon/combust","/placements/Moon/house","/houses/1/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"The 8th house (chronic matters, longevity) contains retrograde Jupiter in friendly Leo, forming Vipareeta Raja Yoga (12th lord in 8th), which classically converts adversity into resilience — an overall protective indication for longevity despite dusthana placement.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/yogas"]},{"claim":"The 6th house (disease) has no occupants; its lord Mercury is strong in the lagna with Budha-Aditya support, indicating good capacity to manage illness, though Mars aspects the 6th, bringing inflammatory/acute episodes when activated.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/5/occupants","/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/aspects/Mars","/houses/5/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Current period Mercury–Jupiter–Venus: Jupiter is a dusthana lord (12th) placed in the 8th natally, so its antardasha can surface chronic or hidden matters; Venus is exalted and forms the strongest raja yoga, buffering outcomes.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Venus/dignity","/yogas"]},{"claim":"Upcoming Mercury–Saturn antardasha (Nov 2026 – Jul 2029): Saturn is lagna lord in enemy sign in the 11th and aspects the lagna and natal 8th house, suggesting a period requiring disciplined attention to chronic, structural, or age-related health maintenance (subject turns ~70 during this window).","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/dasha/upcoming/0","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Saturn/house","/aspects/Saturn"]},{"claim":"Transits as of 2026-01-01: transiting Rahu conjuncts natal Moon in the 2nd and transiting Ketu conjuncts natal Jupiter in the 8th; transiting Saturn sits on natal exalted Venus in the 3rd. Rahu over the Moon can disturb sleep, anxiety and diet; Ketu over 8th-house Jupiter warrants care with sudden/hidden matters — these are transient pressures, not fixed indications.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/transits/Rahu/conjunctNatal","/transits/Ketu/conjunctNatal","/transits/Saturn/conjunctNatal"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Vipareeta Raja Yoga via Jupiter in the 8th should not be read as immunity to illness; it indicates gains or resilience emerging through adversity, while the 8th placement itself still marks susceptibility to chronic/sudden matters.","evidence":["/yogas","/houses/7/significations"]},{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"omission","correction":"A purely negative reading of the combust Moon ignores that it is aspected by Jupiter (Gaja Kesari configuration from Moon), which softens mental/emotional health vulnerabilities considerably.","evidence":["/placements/Moon/combust","/houses/1/aspectedBy","/yogas"]}],"missing_information":["Actual medical history, symptoms, or lifestyle data — astrological factors cannot substitute for clinical assessment","Exact birth-time rectification confidence (lagna at 0°29' Capricorn is near sign boundary)","Shadbala / ashtakavarga strength scores for grahas, which would refine judgments of vitality","Specific varga relevant to health beyond D1 (e.g., D60) is not provided"],"rationale":"The chart shows a fundamentally resilient core: strong lagna-lord/dispositor conjunction in the 11th (Raja + Dhana yoga), an unoccupied 6th with its lord dignified in the lagna (Budha-Aditya), and a protective Vipareeta Raja Yoga in the 8th. Against this, the combust Moon, Saturn's enemy-sign dignity and aspect on the lagna, and Mars' aspect on the 6th indicate vulnerability to stress-driven, chronic, and occasionally acute conditions. The current Mercury–Jupiter–Venus sequence is buffered by exalted Venus, but the approaching Mercury–Saturn antardasha (late 2026–mid 2029) combined with current Rahu-over-Moon/Ketu-over-Jupiter nodal transits suggests a window where preventive care, rest, and routine medical checkups are prudent. Overall conclusion: mixed — no indication of a broken constitution, but sustained maintenance rather than neglect is indicated. This synthesis describes astrological indications only and is not medical advice."},"extracted":"{\n  \"case_id\": \"health-synthesis-01\",\n  \"domain\": \"health\",\n  \"conclusion\": \"mixed\",\n  \"confidence\": 0.6,\n  \"selected_option_ids\": [],\n  \"factors\": [\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Lagna lord Saturn placed in the 11th in enemy sign but conjunct its dispositor Mars (own-sign) forms a Raja/Dhana yoga, giving underlying vitality and resilience of the body's framework.\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Saturn/house\", \"/placements/Saturn/dignity\", \"/placements/Mars/sign\", \"/yogas\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Budha-Aditya yoga in the lagna (Sun + Mercury in Capricorn) supports mental clarity and recuperative intellect, though Sun is in enemy dignity and Saturn aspects the lagna from the 11th, adding chronic, slow-building strain to the constitution.\",\n      \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Sun/house\", \"/placements/Mercury/house\", \"/placements/Sun/dignity\", \"/aspects/Saturn\", \"/houses/0/aspectedBy\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Moon, a key significator of fluids and mind, is combust and sits in the 2nd aspected by Mars and Jupiter; combustion weakens the Moon's protective role for health.\",\n      \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Moon/combust\", \"/placements/Moon/house\", \"/houses/1/aspectedBy\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"The 8th house (chronic matters, longevity) contains retrograde Jupiter in friendly Leo, forming Vipareeta Raja Yoga (12th lord in 8th), which classically converts adversity into resilience — an overall protective indication for longevity despite dusthana placement.\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Jupiter/house\", \"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\", \"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\", \"/yogas\"],\n      \"note\": \"Vipareeta Raja Yoga is traditionally read as protection arising through difficulty rather than absence of difficulty.\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"The 6th house (disease) has no occupants; its lord Mercury is strong in the lagna with Budha-Aditya support, indicating good capacity to manage illness, though Mars aspects the 6th, bringing inflammatory/acute episodes when activated.\",\n      \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/houses/5/occupants\", \"/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse\", \"/placements/Mercury/house\", \"/aspects/Mars\", \"/houses/5/aspectedBy\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Current period Mercury–Jupiter–Venus: Jupiter is a dusthana lord (12th) placed in the 8th natally, so its antardasha can surface chronic or hidden matters; Venus is exalted and forms the strongest raja yoga, buffering outcomes.\",\n      \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/dasha/current\", \"/placements/Jupiter/house\", \"/placements/Venus/dignity\", \"/yogas\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Upcoming Mercury–Saturn antardasha (Nov 2026 – Jul 2029): Saturn is lagna lord in enemy sign in the 11th and aspects the lagna and natal 8th house, suggesting a period requiring disciplined attention to chronic, structural, or age-related health maintenance (subject turns ~70 during this window).\",\n      \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/dasha/upcoming/0\", \"/placements/Saturn/dignity\", \"/placements/Saturn/house\", \"/aspects/Saturn\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Transits as of 2026-01-01: transiting Rahu conjuncts natal Moon in the 2nd and transiting Ketu conjuncts natal Jupiter in the 8th; transiting Saturn sits on natal exalted Venus in the 3rd. Rahu over the Moon can disturb sleep, anxiety and diet; Ketu over 8th-house Jupiter warrants care with sudden/hidden matters — these are transient pressures, not fixed indications.\",\n      \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/transits/Rahu/conjunctNatal\", \"/transits/Ketu/conjunctNatal\", \"/transits/Saturn/conjunctNatal\"],\n      \"note\": \"Transit effects are temporary; sade-sati is not active (Saturn is 2 signs from Moon per /transits/saturnFromMoon).\"\n    }\n  ],\n  \"contradictions\": [\n    {\n      \"statement_id\": \"S1\",\n      \"error_type\": \"overclaim\",\n      \"correction\": \"Vipareeta Raja Yoga via Jupiter in the 8th should not be read as immunity to illness; it indicates gains or resilience emerging through adversity, while the 8th placement itself still marks susceptibility to chronic/sudden matters.\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/yogas\", \"/houses/7/significations\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"statement_id\": \"S2\",\n      \"error_type\": \"omission\",\n      \"correction\": \"A purely negative reading of the combust Moon ignores that it is aspected by Jupiter (Gaja Kesari configuration from Moon), which softens mental/emotional health vulnerabilities considerably.\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Moon/combust\", \"/houses/1/aspectedBy\", \"/yogas\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"missing_information\": [\n    \"Actual medical history, symptoms, or lifestyle data — astrological factors cannot substitute for clinical assessment\",\n    \"Exact birth-time rectification confidence (lagna at 0°29' Capricorn is near sign boundary)\",\n    \"Shadbala / ashtakavarga strength scores for grahas, which would refine judgments of vitality\",\n    \"Specific varga relevant to health beyond D1 (e.g., D60) is not provided\"\n  ],\n  \"rationale\": \"The chart shows a fundamentally resilient core: strong lagna-lord/dispositor conjunction in the 11th (Raja + Dhana yoga), an unoccupied 6th with its lord dignified in the lagna (Budha-Aditya), and a protective Vipareeta Raja Yoga in the 8th. Against this, the combust Moon, Saturn's enemy-sign dignity and aspect on the lagna, and Mars' aspect on the 6th indicate vulnerability to stress-driven, chronic, and occasionally acute conditions. The current Mercury–Jupiter–Venus sequence is buffered by exalted Venus, but the approaching Mercury–Saturn antardasha (late 2026–mid 2029) combined with current Rahu-over-Moon/Ketu-over-Jupiter nodal transits suggests a window where preventive care, rest, and routine medical checkups are prudent. Overall conclusion: mixed — no indication of a broken constitution, but sustained maintenance rather than neglect is indicated. This synthesis describes astrological indications only and is not medical advice.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-synthesis-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-01","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.55,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Capricorn lagna at very early degree; vitality is governed by Saturn placed in the 11th (Scorpio) in an enemy sign, conjunct Mars and debilitated Rahu — the body's significator sits in a pressured, malefic-heavy house.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/lagna/signIndex","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Rahu/house"]},{"claim":"Saturn retro-aspects its own lagna (house 1), giving resilience but also chronic, slow-burning strain on self/vitality.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/aspects/Saturn","/houses/1/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Moon (a benefic) is combust in Aquarius in the 2nd and aspects the 8th — emotional/moisture-related systems under pressure; Moon also rules the 7th from the lagna.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Moon/combust","/placements/Moon/house","/aspects/Moon"]},{"claim":"Jupiter in the 8th (retrograde, friend's sign Leo) forms Vipareeta Raja Yoga (12th-lord in 8th); classically this converts adversity into protection, supporting recovery capacity despite 8th-house activation of chronic/transformational matters.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/[5]","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde"]},{"claim":"Gaja Kesari Yoga (Jupiter 7th from Moon) adds general protective strength to mind and constitution.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/[0]"]},{"claim":"Current period Mercury–Jupiter–Venus: Jupiter antardasha activates natal 12th-lord-in-8th placement (isolation/hospitalization indications possible); Venus pratyantardasha is exalted natally in the 3rd, which softens outcomes.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current","/placements/Venus/dignity","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"claim":"Transits as of 2026-01-01: transiting Saturn conjuncts natal exalted Venus in the 3rd and aspects houses 9 and 12; transiting Rahu sits on the natal combust Moon in the 2nd while Ketu sits on natal Jupiter in the 8th — a nodal axis directly touching both luminaries' dispositors and the 8th house, indicating heightened sensitivity now.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/transits/contacts/[6]","/transits/contacts/[7]","/transits/contacts/[8]"]},{"claim":"saturnFromMoon = 2: the native is within Sade Sati's middle phase (Saturn 2nd from natal Moon), a recognized window of fatigue, stress load, and reduced immunity in gochara reckoning.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["tool:transits_at#"]},{"claim":"jupiterFromMoon = 5: transit Jupiter is favorably placed from the Moon (not in 6/8/12 from Chandra), providing gochara protection that partially offsets the above.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["tool:dasha_at#/"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"omission","correction":"The chart shows simultaneous stress markers (Sade Sati, nodal contacts to Moon and Jupiter, 8th-house emphasis) AND protective yogas (Gaja Kesari, Vipareeta Raja Yoga, exalted Venus). A synthesis reading only one side would overstate either fragility or robustness.","evidence":["/yogas","/transits/saturnFromMoon","/transits/jupiterFromMoon"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The health picture is genuinely mixed. Structural strength comes from Gaja Kesari Yoga and the Vipareeta Raja Yoga formed by retrograde Jupiter as 12th lord in the 8th (/yogas/[5]), plus exalted Venus ruling the 10th (/placements/Venus/dignity). Structural vulnerability comes from the lagna lord Saturn in an enemy sign crowded by Mars and debilitated Rahu in the 11th (/placements/Saturn/dignity, /placements/Rahu/dignity), a combust Moon aspecting the 8th (/placements/Moon/combust, /aspects/Moon), and Saturn's own aspect back onto the lagna (/houses/1/aspectedBy). Timing-wise, the current Mercury–Jupiter–Venus dasha runs Jupiter's antardasha over an 8th-house natal placement (/dasha/current), while transits show Saturn conjunct natal Venus, Rahu on the natal combust Moon, Ketu on natal Jupiter in the 8th (/transits/contacts/[6..8]), and active Sade Sati (saturnFromMoon = 2). Transit Jupiter being 5th from the Moon offers partial mitigation. Net indication: elevated stress/fatigue susceptibility during roughly 2024–2027, with protective yogas limiting severity; no terminal or specific-disease prediction is made or should be inferred."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-synthesis-01\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.55,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Capricorn lagna at very early degree; vitality is governed by Saturn placed in the 11th (Scorpio) in an enemy sign, conjunct Mars and debilitated Rahu — the body's significator sits in a pressured, malefic-heavy house.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/signIndex\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn retro-aspects its own lagna (house 1), giving resilience but also chronic, slow-burning strain on self/vitality.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Saturn\",\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"Moon (a benefic) is combust in Aquarius in the 2nd and aspects the 8th — emotional/moisture-related systems under pressure; Moon also rules the 7th from the lagna.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/combust\",\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/aspects/Moon\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter in the 8th (retrograde, friend's sign Leo) forms Vipareeta Raja Yoga (12th-lord in 8th); classically this converts adversity into protection, supporting recovery capacity despite 8th-house activation of chronic/transformational matters.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/[5]\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\"]},{\"claim\":\"Gaja Kesari Yoga (Jupiter 7th from Moon) adds general protective strength to mind and constitution.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/[0]\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current period Mercury–Jupiter–Venus: Jupiter antardasha activates natal 12th-lord-in-8th placement (isolation/hospitalization indications possible); Venus pratyantardasha is exalted natally in the 3rd, which softens outcomes.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Transits as of 2026-01-01: transiting Saturn conjuncts natal exalted Venus in the 3rd and aspects houses 9 and 12; transiting Rahu sits on the natal combust Moon in the 2nd while Ketu sits on natal Jupiter in the 8th — a nodal axis directly touching both luminaries' dispositors and the 8th house, indicating heightened sensitivity now.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/transits/contacts/[6]\",\"/transits/contacts/[7]\",\"/transits/contacts/[8]\"]},{\"claim\":\"saturnFromMoon = 2: the native is within Sade Sati's middle phase (Saturn 2nd from natal Moon), a recognized window of fatigue, stress load, and reduced immunity in gochara reckoning.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"tool:transits_at#\"]},{\"claim\":\"jupiterFromMoon = 5: transit Jupiter is favorably placed from the Moon (not in 6/8/12 from Chandra), providing gochara protection that partially offsets the above.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"tool:dasha_at#/\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"omission\",\"correction\":\"The chart shows simultaneous stress markers (Sade Sati, nodal contacts to Moon and Jupiter, 8th-house emphasis) AND protective yogas (Gaja Kesari, Vipareeta Raja Yoga, exalted Venus). A synthesis reading only one side would overstate either fragility or robustness.\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas\",\"/transits/saturnFromMoon\",\"/transits/jupiterFromMoon\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The health picture is genuinely mixed. Structural strength comes from Gaja Kesari Yoga and the Vipareeta Raja Yoga formed by retrograde Jupiter as 12th lord in the 8th (/yogas/[5]), plus exalted Venus ruling the 10th (/placements/Venus/dignity). Structural vulnerability comes from the lagna lord Saturn in an enemy sign crowded by Mars and debilitated Rahu in the 11th (/placements/Saturn/dignity, /placements/Rahu/dignity), a combust Moon aspecting the 8th (/placements/Moon/combust, /aspects/Moon), and Saturn's own aspect back onto the lagna (/houses/1/aspectedBy). Timing-wise, the current Mercury–Jupiter–Venus dasha runs Jupiter's antardasha over an 8th-house natal placement (/dasha/current), while transits show Saturn conjunct natal Venus, Rahu on the natal combust Moon, Ketu on natal Jupiter in the 8th (/transits/contacts/[6..8]), and active Sade Sati (saturnFromMoon = 2). Transit Jupiter being 5th from the Moon offers partial mitigation. Net indication: elevated stress/fatigue susceptibility during roughly 2024–2027, with protective yogas limiting severity; no terminal or specific-disease prediction is made or should be inferred.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-synthesis-02","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-02","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.6,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Lagna lord Moon is debilitated in Scorpio in the 5th house — a core vitality weakness; the body/self significator is at its weakest dignity.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Moon/dignity","/placements/Moon/house"]},{"claim":"The debilitated Moon receives the full 4th-house aspect of Mars from Aries, adding heat/inflammation-type stress to the lagna lord.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Mars","/placements/Moon/house","/houses/5/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Lagna itself is aspected by Mars, Venus and Saturn — mixed influences; Saturn's drishti on the lagna can indicate chronicity or slow-recovering conditions.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/1/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"6th house (disease) holds Rahu in Mula; its dispositor Jupiter sits in the 12th, forming a Vipareeta Raja Yoga that can convert illness into eventual gain but signals recurring dusthana-linked health themes.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Rahu/house","/placements/Jupiter/house","/yogas/5"]},{"claim":"Mercury (lord of 12, placed in the 8th) forms a second Vipareeta Raja Yoga; 8th/12th involvement points to sudden or hidden matters rather than overt acute disease.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/yogas/4"]},{"claim":"Saturn exalted in Libra in the 4th (Sasa Yoga) aspects the 6th house of disease — an exalted malefic guarding the disease house supports recovery power and endurance.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Saturn/house","/aspects/Saturn","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"Current period Jupiter–Jupiter (Mercury pratyantardasha): Jupiter is retrograde, in enemy sign Gemini in the 12th with Ketu, and is 6th lord — the running dasha lord carries a dusthana signature.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord","/placements/Jupiter/sign","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Transit Saturn in Pisces conjoins natal Sun in the 9th and aspects natal houses 3, 6 and 11 — Saturn's gochara contact with the 6th stresses health routines during this window.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["tool:transits_at#/transits/Saturn/conjunctNatal"]},{"claim":"Transit Rahu over natal Mercury in the 8th (Aquarius) can coincide with nervous/restless or diagnostic uncertainty themes; transit Jupiter retrograde on natal Jupiter-Ketu in the 12th suggests hospitalisation/isolation signatures are activated.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["tool:transits_at#/transits/Rahu/conjunctNatal","tool:transits_at#/transits/Jupiter/conjunctNatal"]},{"claim":"Sade sati check: Saturn is 5 signs from the natal Moon — not in sade sati, so lunar-mind health pressure is not maximal.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/transits/saturnFromMoon"]},{"claim":"D9 Moon in Pisces (own-nakshatra-like benefic placement, dispositor Jupiter) shows inner resilience improving after mid-life; the debilitated D1 Moon is supported at the navamsa level.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/1"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"omission","correction":"Debilitated lagna lord suggests poor baseline vitality, but this must be weighed against exalted Saturn's protective aspect on the 6th and Vipareeta yogas that neutralise dusthana harm; the chart is not uniformly weak for health.","evidence":["/placements/Moon/dignity","/placements/Saturn/house","/yogas/3"]},{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Transit activations (Rahu-Mercury in 8th, Saturn-Sun) indicate a sensitive window, not a deterministic illness outcome; timing statements should remain probabilistic.","evidence":["tool:transits_at#/transits/Rahu/conjunctNatal","tool:transits_at#/transits/Saturn/conjunctNatal"]}],"missing_information":["Actual medical history / presenting complaints of the subject","Divisional vargas beyond those provided (e.g., D27/D60) for finer health assessment","Exact birth-time rectification confirmation given early-degree Cancer lagna"],"rationale":"Baseline vitality is compromised by a debilitated, Mars-aspected lagna lord (/placements/Moon/dignity), while protective factors include Sasa Yoga Saturn exalted in the 4th aspecting the 6th (/placements/Saturn/dignity, /aspects/Saturn), two Vipareeta Raja Yogas converting dusthana lords into hidden strength (/yogas/3, /yogas/4), and a D9-supported Moon (/vargas/D9/placements/1). The current Jupiter mahadasha runs through a 12th-house enemy-sign retrograde Jupiter who owns the 6th (/dasha/current/mahadasha, /placements/Jupiter/house), and 2026 transits show Saturn on natal Sun with drishti to the 6th plus Rahu on natal Mercury in the 8th — an active sensitivity window. Net reading: mixed — chronic rather than catastrophic indications, with recovery capacity present; no death or disease prediction is made."},"extracted":"{\n \"case_id\": \"health-synthesis-02\",\n \"domain\": \"health\",\n \"conclusion\": \"mixed\",\n \"confidence\": 0.6,\n \"selected_option_ids\": [],\n \"factors\": [\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Lagna lord Moon is debilitated in Scorpio in the 5th house — a core vitality weakness; the body/self significator is at its weakest dignity.\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Moon/dignity\", \"/placements/Moon/house\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"The debilitated Moon receives the full 4th-house aspect of Mars from Aries, adding heat/inflammation-type stress to the lagna lord.\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/aspects/Mars\", \"/placements/Moon/house\", \"/houses/5/aspectedBy\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Lagna itself is aspected by Mars, Venus and Saturn — mixed influences; Saturn's drishti on the lagna can indicate chronicity or slow-recovering conditions.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"6th house (disease) holds Rahu in Mula; its dispositor Jupiter sits in the 12th, forming a Vipareeta Raja Yoga that can convert illness into eventual gain but signals recurring dusthana-linked health themes.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Rahu/house\", \"/placements/Jupiter/house\", \"/yogas/5\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Mercury (lord of 12, placed in the 8th) forms a second Vipareeta Raja Yoga; 8th/12th involvement points to sudden or hidden matters rather than overt acute disease.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mercury/house\", \"/yogas/4\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Saturn exalted in Libra in the 4th (Sasa Yoga) aspects the 6th house of disease — an exalted malefic guarding the disease house supports recovery power and endurance.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\", \"/placements/Saturn/house\", \"/aspects/Saturn\", \"/yogas/1\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Current period Jupiter–Jupiter (Mercury pratyantardasha): Jupiter is retrograde, in enemy sign Gemini in the 12th with Ketu, and is 6th lord — the running dasha lord carries a dusthana signature.\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord\", \"/placements/Jupiter/sign\", \"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Transit Saturn in Pisces conjoins natal Sun in the 9th and aspects natal houses 3, 6 and 11 — Saturn's gochara contact with the 6th stresses health routines during this window.\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"tool:transits_at#/transits/Saturn/conjunctNatal\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Transit Rahu over natal Mercury in the 8th (Aquarius) can coincide with nervous/restless or diagnostic uncertainty themes; transit Jupiter retrograde on natal Jupiter-Ketu in the 12th suggests hospitalisation/isolation signatures are activated.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"tool:transits_at#/transits/Rahu/conjunctNatal\", \"tool:transits_at#/transits/Jupiter/conjunctNatal\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Sade sati check: Saturn is 5 signs from the natal Moon — not in sade sati, so lunar-mind health pressure is not maximal.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/transits/saturnFromMoon\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"D9 Moon in Pisces (own-nakshatra-like benefic placement, dispositor Jupiter) shows inner resilience improving after mid-life; the debilitated D1 Moon is supported at the navamsa level.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/vargas/D9/placements/1\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"contradictions\": [\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"S1\",\n   \"error_type\": \"omission\",\n   \"correction\": \"Debilitated lagna lord suggests poor baseline vitality, but this must be weighed against exalted Saturn's protective aspect on the 6th and Vipareeta yogas that neutralise dusthana harm; the chart is not uniformly weak for health.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Moon/dignity\", \"/placements/Saturn/house\", \"/yogas/3\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"S2\",\n   \"error_type\": \"overclaim\",\n   \"correction\": \"Transit activations (Rahu-Mercury in 8th, Saturn-Sun) indicate a sensitive window, not a deterministic illness outcome; timing statements should remain probabilistic.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"tool:transits_at#/transits/Rahu/conjunctNatal\", \"tool:transits_at#/transits/Saturn/conjunctNatal\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"missing_information\": [\n  \"Actual medical history / presenting complaints of the subject\",\n  \"Divisional vargas beyond those provided (e.g., D27/D60) for finer health assessment\",\n  \"Exact birth-time rectification confirmation given early-degree Cancer lagna\"\n ],\n \"rationale\": \"Baseline vitality is compromised by a debilitated, Mars-aspected lagna lord (/placements/Moon/dignity), while protective factors include Sasa Yoga Saturn exalted in the 4th aspecting the 6th (/placements/Saturn/dignity, /aspects/Saturn), two Vipareeta Raja Yogas converting dusthana lords into hidden strength (/yogas/3, /yogas/4), and a D9-supported Moon (/vargas/D9/placements/1). The current Jupiter mahadasha runs through a 12th-house enemy-sign retrograde Jupiter who owns the 6th (/dasha/current/mahadasha, /placements/Jupiter/house), and 2026 transits show Saturn on natal Sun with drishti to the 6th plus Rahu on natal Mercury in the 8th — an active sensitivity window. Net reading: mixed — chronic rather than catastrophic indications, with recovery capacity present; no death or disease prediction is made.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-synthesis-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-01","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.65,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Lagna is Capricorn ruled by Saturn; the lagna lord sits in the 11th in enemy sign Scorpio conjunct Mars and debilitated Rahu — vitality is work-driven but stress-exposed, with a hard-edged gains/network axis feeding back into the body.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/lagna/sign","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/houses/10/occupants"]},{"claim":"Saturn aspects the lagna (house 1) and the 8th house, adding dryness, chronicity and slow-burning constitutional strain to self and longevity matters.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Saturn","/houses/1/aspectedBy","/houses/8/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Sun placed in the lagna in an enemy sign gives a fiery, driven temperament that can over-heat the constitution; it also rules the 8th from the 1st, linking vitality to sudden/chronic matters.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/dignity","/houses/8/lord"]},{"claim":"Moon, the significator of fluids and mind, is combust in the 2nd house at 0° Aquarius — emotional/nutritional resilience is compromised, though it forms Gaja Kesari Yoga with Jupiter, which buffers mental health.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Moon/combust","/placements/Moon/house","/yogas/0/name"]},{"claim":"6th lord Mercury (disease/debt karaka house) is placed in the lagna itself: disease potential comes close to the body, but Mercury unafflicted by combustion and forming Budha-Aditya Yoga indicates strong recuperative intelligence and good management of illness.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/combust","/yogas/1/name"]},{"claim":"Jupiter retrograde in the 8th creates Vipareeta Raja Yoga (12th lord in 8th): classical doctrine reads this as protection through adversity — crises tend to resolve favourably rather than destroy.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/yogas/5/name"]},{"claim":"Ketu aspects the lagna while its dispositor axis (Rahu/Ketu both debilitated across 11/5) suggests nervous, erratic or psychosomatic tendencies rather than gross structural disease.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/1/aspectedBy","/placements/Rahu/dignity","/placements/Ketu/dignity"]},{"claim":"Current period Mercury–Jupiter (Aug 2024–Nov 2026): Mercury is a functional 6th lord for this chart, so the mahadasha keeps health on the agenda, but Jupiter antardasha as VRY-forming benefic in the 8th supports recovery and protective outcomes within it.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord","/dasha/current/antardasha/lord","/placements/Jupiter/house","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"Transit picture (as of 2026-01-01): transiting Saturn sits on natal Venus in the 3rd and transiting Rahu conjoins natal Moon in the 2nd, while transiting Ketu sits on natal Jupiter in the 8th — a cluster of nodal-luminary and Saturnian contacts indicating a period of heightened somatic sensitivity, fatigue-prone routines and need for disciplined regimen; sade-sati is not active (Saturn is 2 signs from natal Moon).","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/transits/contacts/6/conjunctNatal","/transits/contacts/7/conjunctNatal","/transits/contacts/8/conjunctNatal","/transits/saturnFromMoon"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The afflicted 6th lord in the lagna would naively read as 'illness in the body', but Parashari doctrine treats a dignified, yoga-forming 6th lord in the 1st as capacity to defeat disease (service/enemy-conquering strength), so the factor must be weighted mixed, not purely negative.","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/yogas/1/name"]},{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Vipareeta Raja Yoga via Jupiter in the 8th offers crisis-protection, but Jupiter is retrograde and under Saturn's aspect; it moderates severity of indications rather than guaranteeing immunity.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/houses/8/aspectedBy","/yogas/5/name"]}],"missing_information":["Actual medical history or presenting complaints of the subject","Exact birth-time rectification confidence (lagna at only 0°29' Capricorn is sensitive)","Shad-bala / ashtakavarga strength scores not supplied"],"rationale":"Constitutionally this is a Saturnine Capricorn chart with an afflicted-but-strong 11th-house stellium (Mars own-sign + Saturn + Rahu), a combust Moon, and Sun in enemy sign in the lagna — indicating chronic, stress-mediated, vata-fire type vulnerability rather than acute fatal indications. Counterweights are real: Budha-Aditya and Gaja Kesari yogas, a well-disposed 6th lord in the 1st, and Vipareeta Raja Yoga through Jupiter in the 8th all point toward recovery capacity and protection through adversity. The current Mercury–Jupiter period plus the 2026 nodal contacts (Rahu on Moon, Ketu on Jupiter, Saturn on Venus) mark a season demanding regimen discipline, but the overall balance is mixed-to-manageable rather than challenging."},"extracted":"{\n \"case_id\": \"health-synthesis-01\",\n \"domain\": \"health\",\n \"conclusion\": \"mixed\",\n \"confidence\": 0.65,\n \"selected_option_ids\": [],\n \"factors\": [\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Lagna is Capricorn ruled by Saturn; the lagna lord sits in the 11th in enemy sign Scorpio conjunct Mars and debilitated Rahu — vitality is work-driven but stress-exposed, with a hard-edged gains/network axis feeding back into the body.\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/lagna/sign\", \"/placements/Saturn/house\", \"/placements/Saturn/dignity\", \"/houses/10/occupants\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Saturn aspects the lagna (house 1) and the 8th house, adding dryness, chronicity and slow-burning constitutional strain to self and longevity matters.\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/aspects/Saturn\", \"/houses/1/aspectedBy\", \"/houses/8/aspectedBy\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Sun placed in the lagna in an enemy sign gives a fiery, driven temperament that can over-heat the constitution; it also rules the 8th from the 1st, linking vitality to sudden/chronic matters.\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Sun/house\", \"/placements/Sun/dignity\", \"/houses/8/lord\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Moon, the significator of fluids and mind, is combust in the 2nd house at 0° Aquarius — emotional/nutritional resilience is compromised, though it forms Gaja Kesari Yoga with Jupiter, which buffers mental health.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Moon/combust\", \"/placements/Moon/house\", \"/yogas/0/name\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"6th lord Mercury (disease/debt karaka house) is placed in the lagna itself: disease potential comes close to the body, but Mercury unafflicted by combustion and forming Budha-Aditya Yoga indicates strong recuperative intelligence and good management of illness.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\", \"/placements/Mercury/house\", \"/placements/Mercury/combust\", \"/yogas/1/name\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Jupiter retrograde in the 8th creates Vipareeta Raja Yoga (12th lord in 8th): classical doctrine reads this as protection through adversity — crises tend to resolve favourably rather than destroy.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Jupiter/house\", \"/yogas/5/name\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Ketu aspects the lagna while its dispositor axis (Rahu/Ketu both debilitated across 11/5) suggests nervous, erratic or psychosomatic tendencies rather than gross structural disease.\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\", \"/placements/Rahu/dignity\", \"/placements/Ketu/dignity\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Current period Mercury–Jupiter (Aug 2024–Nov 2026): Mercury is a functional 6th lord for this chart, so the mahadasha keeps health on the agenda, but Jupiter antardasha as VRY-forming benefic in the 8th supports recovery and protective outcomes within it.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord\", \"/dasha/current/antardasha/lord\", \"/placements/Jupiter/house\", \"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Transit picture (as of 2026-01-01): transiting Saturn sits on natal Venus in the 3rd and transiting Rahu conjoins natal Moon in the 2nd, while transiting Ketu sits on natal Jupiter in the 8th — a cluster of nodal-luminary and Saturnian contacts indicating a period of heightened somatic sensitivity, fatigue-prone routines and need for disciplined regimen; sade-sati is not active (Saturn is 2 signs from natal Moon).\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/transits/contacts/6/conjunctNatal\", \"/transits/contacts/7/conjunctNatal\", \"/transits/contacts/8/conjunctNatal\", \"/transits/saturnFromMoon\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"contradictions\": [\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"S1\",\n   \"error_type\": \"doctrinal\",\n   \"correction\": \"The afflicted 6th lord in the lagna would naively read as 'illness in the body', but Parashari doctrine treats a dignified, yoga-forming 6th lord in the 1st as capacity to defeat disease (service/enemy-conquering strength), so the factor must be weighted mixed, not purely negative.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mercury/house\", \"/yogas/1/name\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"S2\",\n   \"error_type\": \"overclaim\",\n   \"correction\": \"Vipareeta Raja Yoga via Jupiter in the 8th offers crisis-protection, but Jupiter is retrograde and under Saturn's aspect; it moderates severity of indications rather than guaranteeing immunity.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\", \"/houses/8/aspectedBy\", \"/yogas/5/name\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"missing_information\": [\n  \"Actual medical history or presenting complaints of the subject\",\n  \"Exact birth-time rectification confidence (lagna at only 0°29' Capricorn is sensitive)\",\n  \"Shad-bala / ashtakavarga strength scores not supplied\"\n ],\n \"rationale\": \"Constitutionally this is a Saturnine Capricorn chart with an afflicted-but-strong 11th-house stellium (Mars own-sign + Saturn + Rahu), a combust Moon, and Sun in enemy sign in the lagna — indicating chronic, stress-mediated, vata-fire type vulnerability rather than acute fatal indications. Counterweights are real: Budha-Aditya and Gaja Kesari yogas, a well-disposed 6th lord in the 1st, and Vipareeta Raja Yoga through Jupiter in the 8th all point toward recovery capacity and protection through adversity. The current Mercury–Jupiter period plus the 2026 nodal contacts (Rahu on Moon, Ketu on Jupiter, Saturn on Venus) mark a season demanding regimen discipline, but the overall balance is mixed-to-manageable rather than challenging.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-knowledge-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-knowledge-01","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"rationale":"The VedAstro rule House1LordInHouse10 describes the ascendant (1st house) lord placed in the 10th house as a favorable placement for career, profession, fame, and public standing. Option A matches this supportive interpretation. Option B contradicts the rule's positive framing, and Option C overclaims, since the rule indicates tendencies toward professional success rather than guaranteeing a specific profession."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-knowledge-01\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"confidence\":0.85,\"rationale\":\"The VedAstro rule House1LordInHouse10 describes the ascendant (1st house) lord placed in the 10th house as a favorable placement for career, profession, fame, and public standing. Option A matches this supportive interpretation. Option B contradicts the rule's positive framing, and Option C overclaims, since the rule indicates tendencies toward professional success rather than guaranteeing a specific profession.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-synthesis-03","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-03","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.55,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Lagna lord Mars is in the 3rd house but in enemy sign (Gemini) alongside Ketu, indicating a body/self-lord that is active yet strained, a mixed vitality indicator","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Ketu/house"]},{"claim":"The ascendant itself is aspected by exalted Saturn (from the 7th) and by Rahu, adding pressure on the body and general constitution per Parashari doctrine on 1st-house afflictions","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/0/aspectedBy","/aspects/Saturn","/aspects/Rahu"]},{"claim":"Jupiter, the great protector, is exalted in Cancer in the 4th (Hamsa Yoga) and aspects the 8th house of longevity and chronic matters, which classically supports resilience and recovery capacity","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/house","/yogas/0","/aspects/Jupiter"]},{"claim":"The 6th lord of disease (Mercury) is in its own sign in the 3rd, a strong placement suggesting reasonable ability to manage illness, though the 6th is simultaneously aspected by Mars","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/dignity","/houses/5/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Sun, significator of vitality, sits in an enemy sign in the 2nd house, a mild weakening of core life-force indicators","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Sun/dignity","/placements/Sun/house"]},{"claim":"Current Saturn mahadasha–Saturn antardasha (from /dasha/current) runs a natal exalted kendra Saturn (Sasa Yoga), generally a stabilising period, though Saturn's nature remains austere; no health-specific dasha affliction is established from the data alone","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord","/dasha/current/antardasha/from","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"Transiting Saturn is in the natal 12th house and Ketu transits over the natal Moon in the 5th (as of the chart's transit snapshot); gochara Saturn from the Moon is 8th position, outside sade sati range, so no classical sade-sati stress applies at this time","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/transits/saturnFromMoon","/transits/contacts/6/inNatalHouse","/transits/contacts/8/conjunctNatal"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Specific health complaint or symptom the querent has in mind","Divisional varga relevant to chronic health assessment beyond those provided","Exact birth-time rectification confidence, since lagna degree affects house-sensitive judgments"],"rationale":"The chart presents genuinely offsetting indications: protective factors (exalted Jupiter's Hamsa Yoga aspecting the 8th, own-sign 6th lord Mercury, exalted Saturn as yogakaraka-like kendra occupant) balance against stressors (enemy-sign lagna lord Mars conjunct Ketu, Rahu and Saturn aspecting the ascendant, enemy-sign Sun as vitality significator). Current dasha is a stable Saturn period without clear health-specific affliction, and sade sati is not operative. The supported doctrine supports a 'mixed' reading rather than either a strongly supportive or challenging verdict; a more specific answer would require knowing the actual health concern."},"extracted":"{\n \"case_id\": \"health-synthesis-03\",\n \"domain\": \"health\",\n \"conclusion\": \"mixed\",\n \"confidence\": 0.55,\n \"selected_option_ids\": [],\n \"factors\": [\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Lagna lord Mars is in the 3rd house but in enemy sign (Gemini) alongside Ketu, indicating a body/self-lord that is active yet strained, a mixed vitality indicator\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mars/house\", \"/placements/Mars/dignity\", \"/placements/Ketu/house\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"The ascendant itself is aspected by exalted Saturn (from the 7th) and by Rahu, adding pressure on the body and general constitution per Parashari doctrine on 1st-house afflictions\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/houses/0/aspectedBy\", \"/aspects/Saturn\", \"/aspects/Rahu\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Jupiter, the great protector, is exalted in Cancer in the 4th (Hamsa Yoga) and aspects the 8th house of longevity and chronic matters, which classically supports resilience and recovery capacity\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\", \"/placements/Jupiter/house\", \"/yogas/0\", \"/aspects/Jupiter\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"The 6th lord of disease (Mercury) is in its own sign in the 3rd, a strong placement suggesting reasonable ability to manage illness, though the 6th is simultaneously aspected by Mars\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mercury/house\", \"/placements/Mercury/dignity\", \"/houses/5/aspectedBy\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Sun, significator of vitality, sits in an enemy sign in the 2nd house, a mild weakening of core life-force indicators\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Sun/dignity\", \"/placements/Sun/house\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Current Saturn mahadasha–Saturn antardasha (from /dasha/current) runs a natal exalted kendra Saturn (Sasa Yoga), generally a stabilising period, though Saturn's nature remains austere; no health-specific dasha affliction is established from the data alone\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord\", \"/dasha/current/antardasha/from\", \"/yogas/1\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Transiting Saturn is in the natal 12th house and Ketu transits over the natal Moon in the 5th (as of the chart's transit snapshot); gochara Saturn from the Moon is 8th position, outside sade sati range, so no classical sade-sati stress applies at this time\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/transits/saturnFromMoon\", \"/transits/contacts/6/inNatalHouse\", \"/transits/contacts/8/conjunctNatal\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"contradictions\": [],\n \"missing_information\": [\n  \"Specific health complaint or symptom the querent has in mind\",\n  \"Divisional varga relevant to chronic health assessment beyond those provided\",\n  \"Exact birth-time rectification confidence, since lagna degree affects house-sensitive judgments\"\n ],\n \"rationale\": \"The chart presents genuinely offsetting indications: protective factors (exalted Jupiter's Hamsa Yoga aspecting the 8th, own-sign 6th lord Mercury, exalted Saturn as yogakaraka-like kendra occupant) balance against stressors (enemy-sign lagna lord Mars conjunct Ketu, Rahu and Saturn aspecting the ascendant, enemy-sign Sun as vitality significator). Current dasha is a stable Saturn period without clear health-specific affliction, and sade sati is not operative. The supported doctrine supports a 'mixed' reading rather than either a strongly supportive or challenging verdict; a more specific answer would require knowing the actual health concern.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-synthesis-02","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-02","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.65,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Lagna lord Moon is debilitated in Scorpio in the 5th house — the primary significator of vitality and the body is weak, indicating underlying sensitivity of health and emotional stress impacting wellbeing.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Moon/dignity","/placements/Moon/house"]},{"claim":"Both Mars and Saturn aspect the lagna (/aspects lists Mars→1, Saturn→1): Saturn's 10th-house drishti on the ascendant brings chronicity and slow strain to the body; Mars adds inflammatory/acute tendencies.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Saturn","/aspects/Mars"]},{"claim":"Saturn is exalted (Sasa Yoga) in the 4th kendra — a strong protective graha whose aspect on the lagna, while heavy, comes from a dignified planet, giving endurance and recovery capacity rather than pure affliction.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/yogas/2","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"claim":"Vipareeta Raja Yogas: 6th lord Jupiter in 12th and 12th lord Mercury in 8th — dusthana lords placed in other dusthanas classically confer resilience against disease/debt/enemies; disease matters tend to resolve or turn favorable after difficulty.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/4","/yogas/5","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Mercury/house"]},{"claim":"Rahu occupies the 6th house of disease natally, with Ketu/Jupiter in the 12th (hospitalization/isolation axis), suggesting susceptibility to hard-to-diagnose, toxin- or stress-related complaints.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Rahu/house","/houses/5/occupants","/houses/11/occupants"]},{"claim":"Current dasha Jupiter–Jupiter with Mercury pratyantar: Jupiter is a benefic running Vipareeta Raja Yoga as 6th lord in 12th, but also sits in the 12th house natally retrograde in enemy sign — periods of Jupiter can bring expenditure, retreat, and health attention even while protecting from outright harm.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Transit Saturn at ~2° Pisces conjoins natal Sun in the 9th and casts drishti on natal houses 3, 6 and 11; gochara Saturn is 12 signs from the natal Moon — sade sati has begun, a recognized window of fatigue, joint/vitality strain and increased health vigilance.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["tool:transits_at#/transits/Saturn"]},{"claim":"Transit Rahu in Aquarius conjoins natal Mercury in the 8th (chronic matters/transformation house); combined with transit Ketu aspecting the 6th and 8th, sudden or confusing diagnostic episodes are indicated during this window.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["tool:transits_at#/transits/Rahu/conjunctNatal","/transits/Ketu/aspectingNatalHouses"]},{"claim":"Transit Jupiter is retrograde conjunct natal Jupiter/Ketu in the 12th, aspecting the 6th — a protective, remedial influence touching the disease house, supporting treatment success and recovery.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["tool:transits_at#/transits/Jupiter/conjunctNatal","/aspects/Jupiter"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Debilitated Moon plus Saturn's aspect on the lagna does not by itself indicate serious illness; it marks constitutional sensitivity that must be weighed against exalted Saturn (Sasa Yoga) and two Vipareeta Raja Yogas, which classical doctrine treats as strongly protective against disease outcomes.","evidence":["/yogas/2","/yogas/4","/yogas/5"]},{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"omission","correction":"Any synthesis must include the current sade-sati context (Saturn 12 from natal Moon) — omitting it would understate present-period health strain while overstating long-term weakness.","evidence":["/transits/saturnFromMoon"]}],"missing_information":["Navamsa dignity of the Moon beyond sign placement (Pisces D9 placement is given, but strength grading requires interpretation outside provided facts)","Exact degrees for applying/exact transit conjunctions over time (only as-of-date snapshot available)","Specific body-region indications require nakshatra-level medical analysis not supplied"],"rationale":"Constitution shows genuine vulnerability (debilitated lagna lord Moon, Saturn+Mars aspecting the ascendant, Rahu in the 6th) balanced by strong structural protection (exalted Sasa-Yoga Saturn, dual Vipareeta Raja Yogas). The present window (Jupiter–Mercury period, early sade sati, transit Rahu on natal Mercury in the 8th, Saturn on natal Sun) concentrates strain on health themes — fatigue, chronic/sudden diagnostic matters — but Jupiter's transit back onto its own natal position in the 12th aspecting the 6th supports successful management and recovery. Overall: mixed, requiring vigilance during 2026–2030 (Jupiter dasha through Jupiter–Saturn antardasha), not an adverse lifelong verdict. Astrological indication only; not medical advice."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-synthesis-02\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.65,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Lagna lord Moon is debilitated in Scorpio in the 5th house — the primary significator of vitality and the body is weak, indicating underlying sensitivity of health and emotional stress impacting wellbeing.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/dignity\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Both Mars and Saturn aspect the lagna (/aspects lists Mars→1, Saturn→1): Saturn's 10th-house drishti on the ascendant brings chronicity and slow strain to the body; Mars adds inflammatory/acute tendencies.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Saturn\",\"/aspects/Mars\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn is exalted (Sasa Yoga) in the 4th kendra — a strong protective graha whose aspect on the lagna, while heavy, comes from a dignified planet, giving endurance and recovery capacity rather than pure affliction.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/2\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Vipareeta Raja Yogas: 6th lord Jupiter in 12th and 12th lord Mercury in 8th — dusthana lords placed in other dusthanas classically confer resilience against disease/debt/enemies; disease matters tend to resolve or turn favorable after difficulty.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/4\",\"/yogas/5\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Rahu occupies the 6th house of disease natally, with Ketu/Jupiter in the 12th (hospitalization/isolation axis), suggesting susceptibility to hard-to-diagnose, toxin- or stress-related complaints.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/houses/5/occupants\",\"/houses/11/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current dasha Jupiter–Jupiter with Mercury pratyantar: Jupiter is a benefic running Vipareeta Raja Yoga as 6th lord in 12th, but also sits in the 12th house natally retrograde in enemy sign — periods of Jupiter can bring expenditure, retreat, and health attention even while protecting from outright harm.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Transit Saturn at ~2° Pisces conjoins natal Sun in the 9th and casts drishti on natal houses 3, 6 and 11; gochara Saturn is 12 signs from the natal Moon — sade sati has begun, a recognized window of fatigue, joint/vitality strain and increased health vigilance.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"tool:transits_at#/transits/Saturn\"],\"missing\":\"saturnFromMoon=12 per /transits/saturnFromMoon\"},{\"claim\":\"Transit Rahu in Aquarius conjoins natal Mercury in the 8th (chronic matters/transformation house); combined with transit Ketu aspecting the 6th and 8th, sudden or confusing diagnostic episodes are indicated during this window.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"tool:transits_at#/transits/Rahu/conjunctNatal\",\"/transits/Ketu/aspectingNatalHouses\"]},{\"claim\":\"Transit Jupiter is retrograde conjunct natal Jupiter/Ketu in the 12th, aspecting the 6th — a protective, remedial influence touching the disease house, supporting treatment success and recovery.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"tool:transits_at#/transits/Jupiter/conjunctNatal\",\"/aspects/Jupiter\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Debilitated Moon plus Saturn's aspect on the lagna does not by itself indicate serious illness; it marks constitutional sensitivity that must be weighed against exalted Saturn (Sasa Yoga) and two Vipareeta Raja Yogas, which classical doctrine treats as strongly protective against disease outcomes.\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/2\",\"/yogas/4\",\"/yogas/5\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"omission\",\"correction\":\"Any synthesis must include the current sade-sati context (Saturn 12 from natal Moon) — omitting it would understate present-period health strain while overstating long-term weakness.\",\"evidence\":[\"/transits/saturnFromMoon\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"Navamsa dignity of the Moon beyond sign placement (Pisces D9 placement is given, but strength grading requires interpretation outside provided facts)\",\"Exact degrees for applying/exact transit conjunctions over time (only as-of-date snapshot available)\",\"Specific body-region indications require nakshatra-level medical analysis not supplied\"],\"rationale\":\"Constitution shows genuine vulnerability (debilitated lagna lord Moon, Saturn+Mars aspecting the ascendant, Rahu in the 6th) balanced by strong structural protection (exalted Sasa-Yoga Saturn, dual Vipareeta Raja Yogas). The present window (Jupiter–Mercury period, early sade sati, transit Rahu on natal Mercury in the 8th, Saturn on natal Sun) concentrates strain on health themes — fatigue, chronic/sudden diagnostic matters — but Jupiter's transit back onto its own natal position in the 12th aspecting the 6th supports successful management and recovery. Overall: mixed, requiring vigilance during 2026–2030 (Jupiter dasha through Jupiter–Saturn antardasha), not an adverse lifelong verdict. Astrological indication only; not medical advice.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-knowledge-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-knowledge-01","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"rationale":"The VedAstro rule House1LordInHouse10 treats the ascendant lord's placement in the 10th house as a favorable indication for career, status, and professional achievement. Option A matches this supportive framing. Option B contradicts the rule (it is not a career-loss indication), and Option C overclaims by asserting a guaranteed specific profession, which no such rule establishes."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-knowledge-01\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"confidence\":0.85,\"rationale\":\"The VedAstro rule House1LordInHouse10 treats the ascendant lord's placement in the 10th house as a favorable indication for career, status, and professional achievement. Option A matches this supportive framing. Option B contradicts the rule (it is not a career-loss indication), and Option C overclaims by asserting a guaranteed specific profession, which no such rule establishes.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-synthesis-03","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-03","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.6,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Exalted Jupiter (Hamsa Yoga) in the 4th casts its aspect on the 8th house of longevity and chronic matters, a classical protective factor for vitality and recovery.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/aspects/Jupiter"]},{"claim":"Lagna lord Mars is placed in the 3rd but in an enemy sign, and the lagna itself is aspected by Saturn and Rahu — indications of reduced resilience of the body and vulnerability to nervous/vata-type complaints under stress.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mars/dignity","/houses/1/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"The 6th lord Mercury sits in the 3rd with Ketu while malefic Mars aspects the empty 6th house, so disease significations are present but not strongly fortified; Mercury's own-sign dignity limits the damage.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/dignity","/houses/6/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Current Saturn–Saturn dasha with the lord retrograde and exalted in the 7th: Saturn periods typically bring slower metabolism, fatigue, and joint-related sensitivity, though exaltation moderates severity.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord","/placements/Saturn/retrograde","/placements/Saturn/dignity"]},{"claim":"Transiting Saturn occupies the natal 12th house (loss/isolation/hospitalisation) and aspects natal houses 2, 6, and 9; gochara Saturn is 12th from the natal Moon — the entry phase toward sade sati, often associated with increased expenditure on health and disturbed rest.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["tool:transits_at#/transits/Saturn/inNatalHouse","tool:transits_at#/saturnFromMoon"]},{"claim":"Transiting Ketu conjoins the natal Moon in the 5th, which can accompany mental restlessness or anxiety rather than organic disease.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["tool:transits_at#/transits/Ketu/conjunctNatal"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Exact birth-time rectification margin for fine house cusps","Any actual medical history or symptom data to correlate with chart indications","Divisional D60 or shad-bala data to weigh planetary strengths beyond dignity"],"rationale":"The chart shows genuine protective factors — an exalted kendra Jupiter (Hamsa Yoga) guarding the 8th house by aspect and an exalted Saturn as a Mahapurusha yoga — against real vulnerabilities: an enemy-sign lagna lord, a Saturn-and-Rahu-aspected lagna, and a 6th-lord/Ketu association. The running Saturn mahadasha combined with transiting Saturn through the natal 12th and 12th from the Moon tilts the near-term indication toward fatigue, sleep disturbance, and chronic low-grade issues rather than acute crisis. Overall the evidence supports a mixed, non-alarming reading; no terminal or specific diagnosis should be inferred from these placements alone."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-synthesis-03\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.6,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Exalted Jupiter (Hamsa Yoga) in the 4th casts its aspect on the 8th house of longevity and chronic matters, a classical protective factor for vitality and recovery.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/aspects/Jupiter\"]},{\"claim\":\"Lagna lord Mars is placed in the 3rd but in an enemy sign, and the lagna itself is aspected by Saturn and Rahu — indications of reduced resilience of the body and vulnerability to nervous/vata-type complaints under stress.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 6th lord Mercury sits in the 3rd with Ketu while malefic Mars aspects the empty 6th house, so disease significations are present but not strongly fortified; Mercury's own-sign dignity limits the damage.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/dignity\",\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current Saturn–Saturn dasha with the lord retrograde and exalted in the 7th: Saturn periods typically bring slower metabolism, fatigue, and joint-related sensitivity, though exaltation moderates severity.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord\",\"/placements/Saturn/retrograde\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Transiting Saturn occupies the natal 12th house (loss/isolation/hospitalisation) and aspects natal houses 2, 6, and 9; gochara Saturn is 12th from the natal Moon — the entry phase toward sade sati, often associated with increased expenditure on health and disturbed rest.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"tool:transits_at#/transits/Saturn/inNatalHouse\",\"tool:transits_at#/saturnFromMoon\"]},{\"claim\":\"Transiting Ketu conjoins the natal Moon in the 5th, which can accompany mental restlessness or anxiety rather than organic disease.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"tool:transits_at#/transits/Ketu/conjunctNatal\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"Exact birth-time rectification margin for fine house cusps\",\"Any actual medical history or symptom data to correlate with chart indications\",\"Divisional D60 or shad-bala data to weigh planetary strengths beyond dignity\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart shows genuine protective factors — an exalted kendra Jupiter (Hamsa Yoga) guarding the 8th house by aspect and an exalted Saturn as a Mahapurusha yoga — against real vulnerabilities: an enemy-sign lagna lord, a Saturn-and-Rahu-aspected lagna, and a 6th-lord/Ketu association. The running Saturn mahadasha combined with transiting Saturn through the natal 12th and 12th from the Moon tilts the near-term indication toward fatigue, sleep disturbance, and chronic low-grade issues rather than acute crisis. Overall the evidence supports a mixed, non-alarming reading; no terminal or specific diagnosis should be inferred from these placements alone.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-synthesis-03","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-03","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.55,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Lagna is Aries with its lord Mars placed in house 3 but in enemy-sign dignity, weakening the primary significator of vitality","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/lagna/sign","/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Mars/house"]},{"claim":"Saturn (retrograde, though exalted in Libra) casts full aspect on the lagna, a classical pressure on the body and stamina","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/retrograde","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/aspects/Saturn"]},{"claim":"Rahu also aspects the lagna and the lagna is occupied only by Venus (neutral dignity), giving mixed rather than fortified self-strength","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Rahu","/placements/Venus/dignity","/houses/0/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Jupiter is exalted in Cancer in the 4th (Hamsa Mahapurusha Yoga), a strong protective benefic supporting inner contentment and overall resilience","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/house","/yogas"]},{"claim":"Sun, karaka of vitality, sits in enemy-sign Taurus in the 2nd, another mild depletion of core vigor","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Sun/dignity","/placements/Sun/house"]},{"claim":"Currently in Saturn–Saturn mahadasha-antardasha (2024-12-03 to 2027-12-07); Saturn is exalted and yogakaraka-like by placement in kendra 7, which tempers the period's heaviness even though Saturn naturally afflicts health houses here (it aspects lagna, 4th, 9th)","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord","/dasha/current/antardasha/from","/placements/Saturn/house","/aspects/Saturn"]},{"claim":"As of 2026-01-01 transiting Saturn is in Pisces/natal 12th (loss, isolation, hospitalization-significator house), and gochara reckoning shows Saturn 8th from natal Moon — not sade sati, but an 8th-from-Moon position classically read as strain on wellbeing","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/transits/saturnFromMoon","/transits/contacts/6/inNatalHouse","/transits/note"]},{"claim":"Transiting Ketu sits conjunct the natal Moon in the 5th, disturbing mental ease during the current period; the running pratyantardasha is Ketu (ending 2026-01-01)","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/transits/contacts/7/conjunctNatal","/transits/contacts/8/conjunctNatal","/dasha/current/pratyantardasha/lord"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Specific health complaint or body system of concern","Divisional charts beyond D9/D10/D7 relevant to health (D60/D30) are not provided","No birth-time rectification status to confirm the 04:52 chart"],"rationale":"The chart presents genuinely mixed indications for health: the lagna and its lord are weakened (Mars in enemy sign in the 3rd, lagna aspected by Saturn and Rahu, vitality-karaka Sun also in enemy dignity), while exalted Jupiter in a kendra (Hamsa Yoga) provides substantial protective strength. The current Saturn–Saturn period with transiting Saturn through the natal 12th and Ketu over natal Moon suggests a phase of fatigue or low-grade stress rather than acute crisis, and sade sati is explicitly absent (/transits/saturnFromMoon). The represented doctrine supports a 'watchful, manageable' reading, not a definitive one; no specific disease can be named from this evidence."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-synthesis-03\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.55,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Lagna is Aries with its lord Mars placed in house 3 but in enemy-sign dignity, weakening the primary significator of vitality\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/sign\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/placements/Mars/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn (retrograde, though exalted in Libra) casts full aspect on the lagna, a classical pressure on the body and stamina\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/retrograde\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/aspects/Saturn\"]},{\"claim\":\"Rahu also aspects the lagna and the lagna is occupied only by Venus (neutral dignity), giving mixed rather than fortified self-strength\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Rahu\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/houses/0/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter is exalted in Cancer in the 4th (Hamsa Mahapurusha Yoga), a strong protective benefic supporting inner contentment and overall resilience\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/yogas\"]},{\"claim\":\"Sun, karaka of vitality, sits in enemy-sign Taurus in the 2nd, another mild depletion of core vigor\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/dignity\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Currently in Saturn–Saturn mahadasha-antardasha (2024-12-03 to 2027-12-07); Saturn is exalted and yogakaraka-like by placement in kendra 7, which tempers the period's heaviness even though Saturn naturally afflicts health houses here (it aspects lagna, 4th, 9th)\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord\",\"/dasha/current/antardasha/from\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/aspects/Saturn\"]},{\"claim\":\"As of 2026-01-01 transiting Saturn is in Pisces/natal 12th (loss, isolation, hospitalization-significator house), and gochara reckoning shows Saturn 8th from natal Moon — not sade sati, but an 8th-from-Moon position classically read as strain on wellbeing\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/transits/saturnFromMoon\",\"/transits/contacts/6/inNatalHouse\",\"/transits/note\"]},{\"claim\":\"Transiting Ketu sits conjunct the natal Moon in the 5th, disturbing mental ease during the current period; the running pratyantardasha is Ketu (ending 2026-01-01)\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/transits/contacts/7/conjunctNatal\",\"/transits/contacts/8/conjunctNatal\",\"/dasha/current/pratyantardasha/lord\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"Specific health complaint or body system of concern\",\"Divisional charts beyond D9/D10/D7 relevant to health (D60/D30) are not provided\",\"No birth-time rectification status to confirm the 04:52 chart\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart presents genuinely mixed indications for health: the lagna and its lord are weakened (Mars in enemy sign in the 3rd, lagna aspected by Saturn and Rahu, vitality-karaka Sun also in enemy dignity), while exalted Jupiter in a kendra (Hamsa Yoga) provides substantial protective strength. The current Saturn–Saturn period with transiting Saturn through the natal 12th and Ketu over natal Moon suggests a phase of fatigue or low-grade stress rather than acute crisis, and sade sati is explicitly absent (/transits/saturnFromMoon). The represented doctrine supports a 'watchful, manageable' reading, not a definitive one; no specific disease can be named from this evidence.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-application-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-01","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The ascendant lord (Moon) occupies the tenth house, which the stated rule treats as supportive of professional success or specialization.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house","/houses/9/significations"]},{"claim":"Statement B contradicts the rule; the ascendant lord in the tenth is not a career-loss indication.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse"]},{"claim":"Statement C overclaims: no single placement guarantees a specific profession. The Moon in Aries in the 10th supports career activity but does not determine a particular vocation.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Moon/sign","/placements/Moon/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Ascendant lord in the 10th (Moon at /placements/Moon/house=10 with /lagna/lordInHouse=10) is classically read as strengthening career and public standing, not as a loss indication.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"No placement 'guarantees' a specific profession; chart indications are probabilistic and must be weighed with dasha and transits.","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/dasha/current"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only statement A is established: the lagna lord Moon sits in the 10th house (/lagna/lordInHouse, /placements/Moon/house), a placement traditionally treated as supportive of professional standing and specialization. Statement B is doctrinally wrong, and statement C is an overclaim since no single yoga guarantees a specific profession. The applicable statements are therefore positive, so conclusion polarity is supportive."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-01\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.85,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The ascendant lord (Moon) occupies the tenth house, which the stated rule treats as supportive of professional success or specialization.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Statement B contradicts the rule; the ascendant lord in the tenth is not a career-loss indication.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"Statement C overclaims: no single placement guarantees a specific profession. The Moon in Aries in the 10th supports career activity but does not determine a particular vocation.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/sign\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Ascendant lord in the 10th (Moon at /placements/Moon/house=10 with /lagna/lordInHouse=10) is classically read as strengthening career and public standing, not as a loss indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"No placement 'guarantees' a specific profession; chart indications are probabilistic and must be weighed with dasha and transits.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/dasha/current\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only statement A is established: the lagna lord Moon sits in the 10th house (/lagna/lordInHouse, /placements/Moon/house), a placement traditionally treated as supportive of professional standing and specialization. Statement B is doctrinally wrong, and statement C is an overclaim since no single yoga guarantees a specific profession. The applicable statements are therefore positive, so conclusion polarity is supportive.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-knowledge-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":false,"error":"No JSON object found."},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-application-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-01","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Ascendant lord Moon occupies the 10th house, supporting professional standing/specialization.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"Moon in the 10th in Aries, with 10th lord Mars forming a raja yoga (lord of 5 and 10; mutual aspect with Jupiter), reinforces career indications without guaranteeing a specific profession.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Moon/sign","/yogas"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The ascendant lord in the 10th is a classical strength for career/status, not a career-loss indication.","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/houses/10/significations"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"No placement guarantees a specific profession; the chart shows supportive indications only.","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Statement A is established by the chart facts: the lagna lord Moon sits in the 10th house (/placements/Moon/house, /houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse). Statement B contradicts standard Parashari doctrine. Statement C overclaims — no chart factor fixes a specific profession. Conclusion follows the polarity of the single applicable statement (A): supportive."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-01\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.9,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Ascendant lord Moon occupies the 10th house, supporting professional standing/specialization.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"Moon in the 10th in Aries, with 10th lord Mars forming a raja yoga (lord of 5 and 10; mutual aspect with Jupiter), reinforces career indications without guaranteeing a specific profession.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/sign\",\"/yogas\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The ascendant lord in the 10th is a classical strength for career/status, not a career-loss indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"No placement guarantees a specific profession; the chart shows supportive indications only.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Statement A is established by the chart facts: the lagna lord Moon sits in the 10th house (/placements/Moon/house, /houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse). Statement B contradicts standard Parashari doctrine. Statement C overclaims — no chart factor fixes a specific profession. Conclusion follows the polarity of the single applicable statement (A): supportive.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-application-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-01","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Ascendant lord Moon is placed in the 10th house, which classical rule treats as supportive of professional standing and career focus.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house"]},{"claim":"The 10th is occupied by Aries with Mars as its lord; Mars also rules the 5th, forming a raja yoga by single lordship of a kendra and trikona, reinforcing career strength alongside statement A's rule.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/1","/placements/Mars/house"]},{"claim":"The placement does not guarantee a specific profession — no rule in Parashari doctrine fixes an exact occupation from lagna-lord-in-10th alone; D10 shows Sun, Moon and Mercury in its 10th but this indicates inclination, not certainty.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Lagna lord in the 10th is a standard supportive placement for career/status (the lord in a kendra, specifically the karma bhava), not primarily a career-loss indication.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"No chart placement guarantees a specific profession; astrology at most indicates fields and strengths, never a guaranteed occupation.","evidence":["/houses/9"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only statement A is established: the ascendant lord Moon sits in the 10th house (/lagna/lordInHouse, /placements/Moon/house), a classically supportive placement for professional success, further reinforced by the Mars raja yoga (/yogas/1). Statement B contradicts standard doctrine, and statement C overclaims certainty. Hence conclusion polarity is supportive."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-01\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.9,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Ascendant lord Moon is placed in the 10th house, which classical rule treats as supportive of professional standing and career focus.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 10th is occupied by Aries with Mars as its lord; Mars also rules the 5th, forming a raja yoga by single lordship of a kendra and trikona, reinforcing career strength alongside statement A's rule.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\",\"/placements/Mars/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"The placement does not guarantee a specific profession — no rule in Parashari doctrine fixes an exact occupation from lagna-lord-in-10th alone; D10 shows Sun, Moon and Mercury in its 10th but this indicates inclination, not certainty.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Lagna lord in the 10th is a standard supportive placement for career/status (the lord in a kendra, specifically the karma bhava), not primarily a career-loss indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"No chart placement guarantees a specific profession; astrology at most indicates fields and strengths, never a guaranteed occupation.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only statement A is established: the ascendant lord Moon sits in the 10th house (/lagna/lordInHouse, /placements/Moon/house), a classically supportive placement for professional success, further reinforced by the Mars raja yoga (/yogas/1). Statement B contradicts standard doctrine, and statement C overclaims certainty. Hence conclusion polarity is supportive.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-knowledge-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-knowledge-01","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"rationale":"The VedAstro rule House1LordInHouse10 describes the ascendant (1st house) lord placed in the 10th house as a favorable placement for career, profession, and public standing. Option A matches this supportive interpretation. Option B contradicts the rule's positive framing; Option C overclaims by asserting a guaranteed specific profession, which no such rule establishes."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-knowledge-01\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"confidence\":0.85,\"rationale\":\"The VedAstro rule House1LordInHouse10 describes the ascendant (1st house) lord placed in the 10th house as a favorable placement for career, profession, and public standing. Option A matches this supportive interpretation. Option B contradicts the rule's positive framing; Option C overclaims by asserting a guaranteed specific profession, which no such rule establishes.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-application-03","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-03","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Sun in the 10th house supports professional success, visibility, and authority.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/houses/10/significations"]},{"claim":"The Sun in the 10th does not guarantee government employment.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house"]},{"claim":"The Sun in the 10th is not a loss-of-status indication here; it is strengthened by Jupiter's aspect and the Sun rules the 3rd from a kendra.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/aspects/Jupiter"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Statement A is established: the Sun occupies the 10th house (/placements/Sun/house), whose significations are career, status, action in the world, authority, and public standing. Statement B overclaims — nothing in the rule or chart guarantees government employment. Statement C is false: no chart evidence supports loss of status; on the contrary, exalted retrograde Jupiter aspects the 10th house (/aspects/Jupiter), reinforcing it. Therefore only A applies, giving a supportive polarity."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-03\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.9,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Sun in the 10th house supports professional success, visibility, and authority.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Sun in the 10th does not guarantee government employment.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Sun in the 10th is not a loss-of-status indication here; it is strengthened by Jupiter's aspect and the Sun rules the 3rd from a kendra.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/aspects/Jupiter\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Statement A is established: the Sun occupies the 10th house (/placements/Sun/house), whose significations are career, status, action in the world, authority, and public standing. Statement B overclaims — nothing in the rule or chart guarantees government employment. Statement C is false: no chart evidence supports loss of status; on the contrary, exalted retrograde Jupiter aspects the 10th house (/aspects/Jupiter), reinforcing it. Therefore only A applies, giving a supportive polarity.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-application-03","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-03","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Sun in the 10th house supports career, status and authority; Sun also has dig bala in the kendra of action.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/houses/9/significations"]},{"claim":"10th lord Jupiter is exalted in the 2nd and aspects the 10th, reinforcing the career indication alongside the Sun's placement.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse","/aspects/Jupiter"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"No rule or chart evidence establishes guaranteed government employment from the Sun in the 10th; that is an overreach beyond what the placement supports.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The Sun in the 10th is classically a strength for professional standing, not primarily a loss-of-status indicator; nothing in the chart supports statement C.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/houses/9/significations"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Statement A is established: the Sun sits in the 10th (/placements/Sun/house), a kendra of career, authority and public standing (/houses/9/significations), with dig bala conventionally attributed to the Sun there. Statement B overclaims (no guarantee of government employment follows), and statement C contradicts standard doctrine. Only A applies, so the conclusion polarity is supportive."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-03\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.9,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Sun in the 10th house supports career, status and authority; Sun also has dig bala in the kendra of action.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"10th lord Jupiter is exalted in the 2nd and aspects the 10th, reinforcing the career indication alongside the Sun's placement.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/aspects/Jupiter\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"No rule or chart evidence establishes guaranteed government employment from the Sun in the 10th; that is an overreach beyond what the placement supports.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The Sun in the 10th is classically a strength for professional standing, not primarily a loss-of-status indicator; nothing in the chart supports statement C.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Statement A is established: the Sun sits in the 10th (/placements/Sun/house), a kendra of career, authority and public standing (/houses/9/significations), with dig bala conventionally attributed to the Sun there. Statement B overclaims (no guarantee of government employment follows), and statement C contradicts standard doctrine. Only A applies, so the conclusion polarity is supportive.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-application-02","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-02","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The tenth lord is Mars, placed in the first house, supporting independent professional advancement through personal effort.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/10/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"A tenth lord in the first is a favorable indication but does not guarantee fame; no chart fact establishes fame.","evidence":["/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The tenth lord in the first is not necessarily a dependent-career indication; it is classically read as self-driven career activity.","evidence":["/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Chart facts show the tenth lord Mars placed in the first house (/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse = 1), which matches statement A's rule of supportive independent professional advancement. Statements B (guarantee of fame) and C (necessarily dependent career) are overclaims/doctrinal errors and are not established. Conclusion polarity follows the applicable statement A: supportive."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-02\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.85,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The tenth lord is Mars, placed in the first house, supporting independent professional advancement through personal effort.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"A tenth lord in the first is a favorable indication but does not guarantee fame; no chart fact establishes fame.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The tenth lord in the first is not necessarily a dependent-career indication; it is classically read as self-driven career activity.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Chart facts show the tenth lord Mars placed in the first house (/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse = 1), which matches statement A's rule of supportive independent professional advancement. Statements B (guarantee of fame) and C (necessarily dependent career) are overclaims/doctrinal errors and are not established. Conclusion polarity follows the applicable statement A: supportive.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-application-03","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-03","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Sun in the 10th house (Pisces) supports career, status, and authority","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/houses/10/significations"]},{"claim":"Sun is a dignified (Friend) graha in the 10th, not combust, strengthening the indication","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Sun/dignity","/placements/Sun/combust"]},{"claim":"D9 Sun in own-sign Leo supports inner strength of the career significator","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/0"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The chart shows no rule establishing guaranteed government employment; the Sun's nakshatra lord Saturn and D10 placement do not support a guarantee.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/nakshatraLord","/vargas/D10/placements/0"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The 10th is the house of career/status (/reference/houseSignifications/10); the Sun there is not primarily a loss-of-status indication.","evidence":["/reference/houseSignifications/10","/placements/Sun/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Statement A applies: the Sun occupies the 10th house of career and status (/placements/Sun/house), with friendly dignity. Statement B overclaims — no guarantee of government employment follows from the stated rule or chart facts. Statement C contradicts the standard signification of the 10th. Conclusion polarity reflects A only."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-03\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.9,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Sun in the 10th house (Pisces) supports career, status, and authority\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Sun is a dignified (Friend) graha in the 10th, not combust, strengthening the indication\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/dignity\",\"/placements/Sun/combust\"]},{\"claim\":\"D9 Sun in own-sign Leo supports inner strength of the career significator\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/0\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The chart shows no rule establishing guaranteed government employment; the Sun's nakshatra lord Saturn and D10 placement do not support a guarantee.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/nakshatraLord\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/0\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The 10th is the house of career/status (/reference/houseSignifications/10); the Sun there is not primarily a loss-of-status indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/reference/houseSignifications/10\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Statement A applies: the Sun occupies the 10th house of career and status (/placements/Sun/house), with friendly dignity. Statement B overclaims — no guarantee of government employment follows from the stated rule or chart facts. Statement C contradicts the standard signification of the 10th. Conclusion polarity reflects A only.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-application-04","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-04","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.95,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Mercury occupies the 10th house of career, in friendly sign Taurus, as a benefic — supportive of knowledge-oriented professional work.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/sign","/placements/Mercury/dignity","/placements/Mercury/isBenefic"]},{"claim":"Mercury is dispositor-linked to strong gains houses: it rules the 11th (gains) from the 10th, and the Venus–Sun raja yoga sits in house 11, reinforcing professional success indications.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/yogas"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"'Guarantees success in every undertaking' is not a valid astrological rule; no single placement guarantees outcomes across all domains.","evidence":["/placements/Mercury"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Mercury in the 10th is a benefic in a kendra (dasa-karmadhipati-style placement), not a career-obstruction indication; obstructions would come from dusthana or afflicted placements, which this is not.","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/isBenefic"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Statement A is established by the chart facts: Mercury (benefic, in friendly dignity) sits in the 10th house (/placements/Mercury/house), the classical career bhava associated with intellect, reputation, and professional standing. Statements B and C are doctrinally unsound overclaims/falsifications and are rejected. The applicable listed statement's polarity is positive, so conclusion is 'supportive', with proportionate uncertainty since dasha context and full strength assessment are outside the stated rule."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-04\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.95,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Mercury occupies the 10th house of career, in friendly sign Taurus, as a benefic — supportive of knowledge-oriented professional work.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/sign\",\"/placements/Mercury/dignity\",\"/placements/Mercury/isBenefic\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury is dispositor-linked to strong gains houses: it rules the 11th (gains) from the 10th, and the Venus–Sun raja yoga sits in house 11, reinforcing professional success indications.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/yogas\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"'Guarantees success in every undertaking' is not a valid astrological rule; no single placement guarantees outcomes across all domains.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Mercury in the 10th is a benefic in a kendra (dasa-karmadhipati-style placement), not a career-obstruction indication; obstructions would come from dusthana or afflicted placements, which this is not.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/isBenefic\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Statement A is established by the chart facts: Mercury (benefic, in friendly dignity) sits in the 10th house (/placements/Mercury/house), the classical career bhava associated with intellect, reputation, and professional standing. Statements B and C are doctrinally unsound overclaims/falsifications and are rejected. The applicable listed statement's polarity is positive, so conclusion is 'supportive', with proportionate uncertainty since dasha context and full strength assessment are outside the stated rule.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-application-02","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-02","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The tenth lord Mars is placed in the first house, supporting independent professional advancement through personal effort.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/10/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Tenth lord in the first is a favorable indication but does not guarantee fame; no rule or chart fact establishes certainty of fame.","evidence":["/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"A tenth lord in the first is not necessarily dependent-career; it is classically read as self-driven career expression through the self/body.","evidence":["/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Chart facts show the tenth lord is Mars and it is placed in the first house (/houses/10/lord, /houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse). Statement A correctly describes this as supportive of independent advancement through personal effort, so A is selected. Statement B overclaims by asserting guaranteed fame, which no stated rule establishes. Statement C contradicts the classical reading. Conclusion polarity follows the applicable statement A: supportive."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-02\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.85,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The tenth lord Mars is placed in the first house, supporting independent professional advancement through personal effort.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Tenth lord in the first is a favorable indication but does not guarantee fame; no rule or chart fact establishes certainty of fame.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"A tenth lord in the first is not necessarily dependent-career; it is classically read as self-driven career expression through the self/body.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Chart facts show the tenth lord is Mars and it is placed in the first house (/houses/10/lord, /houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse). Statement A correctly describes this as supportive of independent advancement through personal effort, so A is selected. Statement B overclaims by asserting guaranteed fame, which no stated rule establishes. Statement C contradicts the classical reading. Conclusion polarity follows the applicable statement A: supportive.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-application-04","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-04","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Mercury in the tenth supports knowledge-oriented work, reputation, and professional success.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/sign","/placements/Mercury/dignity","/placements/Mercury/isBenefic","/houses/10/occupants"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Mercury's placement in the 10th indicates favorable potential for career, but no single placement guarantees success in every undertaking; other chart factors (e.g., Mercury aspected by no malefic here but dispositor Venus in 11, Kemadruma Yoga present) qualify outcomes.","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/yogas/0"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Mercury in the 10th is not a career-obstruction indication; it is classically a strong placement, and here it sits in a friendly sign as a benefic.","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/dignity","/placements/Mercury/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Statement A matches the chart: Mercury occupies the 10th house (/placements/Mercury/house) in Taurus, a friendly sign (/placements/Mercury/dignity = Friend), and is a benefic (/placements/Mercury/isBenefic), supporting career/reputation indications. Statement B overstates the rule with an absolute guarantee, and statement C contradicts standard doctrine and the chart evidence. Only A is applicable, so the polarity of applicable statements is supportive."},"extracted":"{\n  \"case_id\": \"career-application-04\",\n  \"domain\": \"career\",\n  \"conclusion\": \"supportive\",\n  \"confidence\": 0.9,\n  \"selected_option_ids\": [\"A\"],\n  \"factors\": [\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Mercury in the tenth supports knowledge-oriented work, reputation, and professional success.\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mercury/house\", \"/placements/Mercury/sign\", \"/placements/Mercury/dignity\", \"/placements/Mercury/isBenefic\", \"/houses/10/occupants\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"contradictions\": [\n    {\n      \"statement_id\": \"B\",\n      \"error_type\": \"overclaim\",\n      \"correction\": \"Mercury's placement in the 10th indicates favorable potential for career, but no single placement guarantees success in every undertaking; other chart factors (e.g., Mercury aspected by no malefic here but dispositor Venus in 11, Kemadruma Yoga present) qualify outcomes.\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mercury/house\", \"/yogas/0\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"statement_id\": \"C\",\n      \"error_type\": \"doctrinal\",\n      \"correction\": \"Mercury in the 10th is not a career-obstruction indication; it is classically a strong placement, and here it sits in a friendly sign as a benefic.\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mercury/dignity\", \"/placements/Mercury/house\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"missing_information\": [],\n  \"rationale\": \"Statement A matches the chart: Mercury occupies the 10th house (/placements/Mercury/house) in Taurus, a friendly sign (/placements/Mercury/dignity = Friend), and is a benefic (/placements/Mercury/isBenefic), supporting career/reputation indications. Statement B overstates the rule with an absolute guarantee, and statement C contradicts standard doctrine and the chart evidence. Only A is applicable, so the polarity of applicable statements is supportive.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-contradiction-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-contradiction-01","confidence":0,"selected_option_ids":[],"rationale":"Audit of three statements: S1 is correct — Jupiter in the 10th (career/status house), in Leo, a friendly sign, supports professional standing and principled authority (/placements/Jupiter/house). S2 is erroneous (overclaim): no chart factor 'guarantees' a specific outcome like a government post; Jupiter in the 10th is only an indication. Correction: Jupiter in the 10th is a supportive indicator for career and authority, not a guarantee of any particular position. Evidence: /placements/Jupiter/house, /placements/Jupiter/sign, /yogas. S3 is erroneous (factual): Jupiter occupies house 10, not 11; houses 11 contains Mars and Mercury (/placements/Jupiter/house = 10, /placements/Mercury/house = 11, /placements/Mars/house = 11)."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-contradiction-01\",\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"confidence\":0.0,\"rationale\":\"Audit of three statements: S1 is correct — Jupiter in the 10th (career/status house), in Leo, a friendly sign, supports professional standing and principled authority (/placements/Jupiter/house). S2 is erroneous (overclaim): no chart factor 'guarantees' a specific outcome like a government post; Jupiter in the 10th is only an indication. Correction: Jupiter in the 10th is a supportive indicator for career and authority, not a guarantee of any particular position. Evidence: /placements/Jupiter/house, /placements/Jupiter/sign, /yogas. S3 is erroneous (factual): Jupiter occupies house 10, not 11; houses 11 contains Mars and Mercury (/placements/Jupiter/house = 10, /placements/Mercury/house = 11, /placements/Mars/house = 11).\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-contradiction-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-contradiction-01","domain":"career","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.95,"selected_option_ids":["S2","S3"],"factors":[{"claim":"Jupiter in the tenth is treated as supportive of professional standing, responsibility, and principled authority — this is doctrinally sound and matches the chart.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/houses/10/significations"]},{"claim":"Jupiter in the tenth guarantees a government post — erroneous overclaim; no chart factor can 'guarantee' an outcome, and Jupiter's placement supports career/status generally, not specifically a government post.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/houses/10/significations"]},{"claim":"Jupiter occupies house 11 — factually wrong; Jupiter occupies house 10 (Leo). House 11 (Virgo) holds Mars and Mercury.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/sign","/houses/11/occupants"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Jupiter in the 10th (Leo) is a supportive indicator for career, status and principled authority, but it does not guarantee a government post. Career specifics would require weighing D10, dasha context and other factors — e.g., D10 shows Jupiter in Virgo in house 1 with Mars and Ketu, not a government-service signature.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/vargas/D10/placements/4"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Jupiter occupies natal house 10 in Leo (/placements/Jupiter/house), not house 11. House 11 (Virgo) contains Mars and Mercury (/houses/11/occupants).","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/sign","/houses/11/occupants"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is accurate: Jupiter sits in the 10th house in Leo (/placements/Jupiter/house, /placements/Jupiter/sign), a classically supportive placement for career and standing, matching the 10th-house significations. S2 errs by converting an indication into a guarantee — no graha placement guarantees a specific post. S3 misstates Jupiter's house; it is in the 10th, while the 11th houses Mars and Mercury."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-contradiction-01\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.95,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"S2\",\"S3\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Jupiter in the tenth is treated as supportive of professional standing, responsibility, and principled authority — this is doctrinally sound and matches the chart.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter in the tenth guarantees a government post — erroneous overclaim; no chart factor can 'guarantee' an outcome, and Jupiter's placement supports career/status generally, not specifically a government post.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter occupies house 11 — factually wrong; Jupiter occupies house 10 (Leo). House 11 (Virgo) holds Mars and Mercury.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/sign\",\"/houses/11/occupants\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Jupiter in the 10th (Leo) is a supportive indicator for career, status and principled authority, but it does not guarantee a government post. Career specifics would require weighing D10, dasha context and other factors — e.g., D10 shows Jupiter in Virgo in house 1 with Mars and Ketu, not a government-service signature.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/4\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Jupiter occupies natal house 10 in Leo (/placements/Jupiter/house), not house 11. House 11 (Virgo) contains Mars and Mercury (/houses/11/occupants).\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/sign\",\"/houses/11/occupants\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S1 is accurate: Jupiter sits in the 10th house in Leo (/placements/Jupiter/house, /placements/Jupiter/sign), a classically supportive placement for career and standing, matching the 10th-house significations. S2 errs by converting an indication into a guarantee — no graha placement guarantees a specific post. S3 misstates Jupiter's house; it is in the 10th, while the 11th houses Mars and Mercury.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-contradiction-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-contradiction-01","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.95,"selected_option_ids":["S2","S3"],"factors":[{"claim":"Jupiter occupies the natal 10th house (Leo), supporting career significations","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/houses/9"]},{"claim":"Jupiter's dignity is 'Friend' in Leo, a benefic graha placed in the kendra of career","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Jupiter in the 10th supports status, responsibility, and principled authority, but no classical dictum guarantees a government post from this placement alone. Career outcomes would also depend on the Sun (10th lord) condition, D10 chart, dashas, etc. The word 'guarantees' makes this statement erroneous.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/houses/9"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Jupiter occupies house 10 (Leo), not house 11. House 11 (Virgo) contains Mars and Mercury.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mercury/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is doctrinally sound: Jupiter, a benefic with friendly dignity (/placements/Jupiter/dignity), sits in the 10th house of career and authority (/placements/Jupiter/house, /houses/9/significations), so treating it as supportive of professional standing and principled authority is appropriate. S2 errs by converting a supportive indication into an absolute guarantee of a government post — an overclaim unsupported by the chart or doctrine. S3 is factually wrong: the chart places Jupiter in house 10 (/placements/Jupiter/house); Mars and Mercury occupy house 11."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-contradiction-01\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.95,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"S2\",\"S3\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Jupiter occupies the natal 10th house (Leo), supporting career significations\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/houses/9\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter's dignity is 'Friend' in Leo, a benefic graha placed in the kendra of career\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Jupiter in the 10th supports status, responsibility, and principled authority, but no classical dictum guarantees a government post from this placement alone. Career outcomes would also depend on the Sun (10th lord) condition, D10 chart, dashas, etc. The word 'guarantees' makes this statement erroneous.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/houses/9\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Jupiter occupies house 10 (Leo), not house 11. House 11 (Virgo) contains Mars and Mercury.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S1 is doctrinally sound: Jupiter, a benefic with friendly dignity (/placements/Jupiter/dignity), sits in the 10th house of career and authority (/placements/Jupiter/house, /houses/9/significations), so treating it as supportive of professional standing and principled authority is appropriate. S2 errs by converting a supportive indication into an absolute guarantee of a government post — an overclaim unsupported by the chart or doctrine. S3 is factually wrong: the chart places Jupiter in house 10 (/placements/Jupiter/house); Mars and Mercury occupy house 11.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-application-04","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-04","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Mercury occupies the 10th house (Taurus), in friendly dignity and unafflicted (not combust, not retrograde), which supports the standard reading of tenth-house Mercury as favorable for knowledge-oriented work and professional standing.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/sign","/placements/Mercury/dignity","/placements/Mercury/combust","/placements/Mercury/retrograde"]},{"claim":"Mercury is a benefic here (/placements/Mercury/isBenefic) and its dispositors link career houses: Venus, lord of the 10th, is placed in the 11th with Sun (lord of the 1st), forming a Raja Yoga that reinforces career gains — consistent with statement A's positive framing.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/isBenefic","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/yogas/4"]},{"claim":"Statement B ('guarantees success in every undertaking') is an overclaim no rule or chart establishes; even a well-placed Mercury does not guarantee all outcomes (e.g., Kemadruma Yoga from the Moon is also present).","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/yogas/0"]},{"claim":"Statement C contradicts both classical doctrine and this chart: Mercury is benefic, in friendly sign, in the angular 10th — not a career-obstruction indication.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/dignity","/placements/Mercury/house"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only statement A is established: Mercury sits in the natal 10th house in Taurus, a friendly sign, benefic and unafflicted, matching the doctrinal reading of tenth-house Mercury supporting intellect-driven profession and reputation. B is an overclaim (no graha guarantees 'every' outcome) and C is factually/doctrinally wrong given Mercury's placement and dignity. The polarity of applicable statements is therefore positive."},"extracted":"{\n  \"case_id\": \"career-application-04\",\n  \"domain\": \"career\",\n  \"conclusion\": \"supportive\",\n  \"confidence\": 0.85,\n  \"selected_option_ids\": [\"A\"],\n  \"factors\": [\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Mercury occupies the 10th house (Taurus), in friendly dignity and unafflicted (not combust, not retrograde), which supports the standard reading of tenth-house Mercury as favorable for knowledge-oriented work and professional standing.\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mercury/house\", \"/placements/Mercury/sign\", \"/placements/Mercury/dignity\", \"/placements/Mercury/combust\", \"/placements/Mercury/retrograde\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Mercury is a benefic here (/placements/Mercury/isBenefic) and its dispositors link career houses: Venus, lord of the 10th, is placed in the 11th with Sun (lord of the 1st), forming a Raja Yoga that reinforces career gains — consistent with statement A's positive framing.\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mercury/isBenefic\", \"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\", \"/yogas/4\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Statement B ('guarantees success in every undertaking') is an overclaim no rule or chart establishes; even a well-placed Mercury does not guarantee all outcomes (e.g., Kemadruma Yoga from the Moon is also present).\",\n      \"effect\": \"neutral\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/0\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Statement C contradicts both classical doctrine and this chart: Mercury is benefic, in friendly sign, in the angular 10th — not a career-obstruction indication.\",\n      \"effect\": \"neutral\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mercury/dignity\", \"/placements/Mercury/house\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"contradictions\": [],\n  \"missing_information\": [],\n  \"rationale\": \"Only statement A is established: Mercury sits in the natal 10th house in Taurus, a friendly sign, benefic and unafflicted, matching the doctrinal reading of tenth-house Mercury supporting intellect-driven profession and reputation. B is an overclaim (no graha guarantees 'every' outcome) and C is factually/doctrinally wrong given Mercury's placement and dignity. The polarity of applicable statements is therefore positive.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-contradiction-02","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-contradiction-02","domain":"career","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.95,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn in the tenth is a mixed career indication: responsibility or status may coexist with sharp rises and falls.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/houses/9"]},{"claim":"Saturn occupies the tenth house (Sagittarius), aspecting houses 4, 7 and 12.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/sign","/aspects/Saturn"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the 10th does not promise uninterrupted success. It is classically a position of heavy responsibility, delayed but durable achievement, and fluctuation in status; here Saturn (neutral dignity) sits in Sagittarius in the 10th with Mars aspecting it, supporting a mixed reading of gains tempered by obstacles rather than unbroken success.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/houses/9","/aspects/Mars"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Saturn occupies house 10, not house 11. House 11 (Capricorn) is empty; its lord is Saturn placed in the 10th.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/houses/10","/houses/11"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 correctly describes the classical mixed nature of Saturn in the 10th, consistent with /placements/Saturn/house = 10, neutral dignity, and Mars's aspect on the career house. S2 overclaims by asserting uninterrupted success, which contradicts both doctrine and the chart's mixed indications. S3 misstates Saturn's house placement: it is in house 10 (Sagittarius), while house 11 (Capricorn) has no occupants."},"extracted":"{\n \"case_id\": \"career-contradiction-02\",\n \"domain\": \"career\",\n \"conclusion\": \"mixed\",\n \"confidence\": 0.95,\n \"selected_option_ids\": [],\n \"factors\": [\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Saturn in the tenth is a mixed career indication: responsibility or status may coexist with sharp rises and falls.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Saturn/house\", \"/houses/9\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Saturn occupies the tenth house (Sagittarius), aspecting houses 4, 7 and 12.\",\n   \"effect\": \"neutral\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Saturn/house\", \"/placements/Saturn/sign\", \"/aspects/Saturn\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"contradictions\": [\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"S2\",\n   \"error_type\": \"overclaim\",\n   \"correction\": \"Saturn in the 10th does not promise uninterrupted success. It is classically a position of heavy responsibility, delayed but durable achievement, and fluctuation in status; here Saturn (neutral dignity) sits in Sagittarius in the 10th with Mars aspecting it, supporting a mixed reading of gains tempered by obstacles rather than unbroken success.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Saturn/house\", \"/placements/Saturn/dignity\", \"/houses/9\", \"/aspects/Mars\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"S3\",\n   \"error_type\": \"factual\",\n   \"correction\": \"Saturn occupies house 10, not house 11. House 11 (Capricorn) is empty; its lord is Saturn placed in the 10th.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Saturn/house\", \"/houses/10\", \"/houses/11\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"missing_information\": [],\n \"rationale\": \"S1 correctly describes the classical mixed nature of Saturn in the 10th, consistent with /placements/Saturn/house = 10, neutral dignity, and Mars's aspect on the career house. S2 overclaims by asserting uninterrupted success, which contradicts both doctrine and the chart's mixed indications. S3 misstates Saturn's house placement: it is in house 10 (Sagittarius), while house 11 (Capricorn) has no occupants.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-contradiction-02","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-contradiction-02","domain":"career","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.95,"selected_option_ids":["S2","S3"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies natal house 10 (Sagittarius), the house of career, in a neutral dignity — a weighty, mixed career indicator rather than one of uninterrupted success.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/sign"]},{"claim":"Saturn aspects houses 4, 7 and 12 and receives Mars' aspect on the 10th, adding friction to career matters.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Saturn","/houses/9/aspectedBy"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the 10th is not an uninterrupted-success signature. Classical treatment is cautious/mixed: Saturn gives position through sustained effort, delay and fluctuation, especially here with Saturn of neutral dignity aspected by Mars (/houses/9/aspectedBy) and ruling dusthana houses 11–12 lords... more precisely Saturn rules Capricorn (house 11) and Aquarius (house 12), placed in 10. S1's 'mixed, rises and falls' framing is the correct reading; S2's absolute claim is wrong.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/houses/10/occupants","/aspects/Mars"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Saturn is placed in Sagittarius in house 10, not house 11; house 11 (Capricorn) has no occupants and is only its lordship.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/sign","/houses/11/occupants"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 correctly reflects the classical mixed reading of Saturn in the 10th (occupant of /houses/10, neutral dignity /placements/Saturn/dignity). S2 overstates by claiming guaranteed continuous success, contradicted by Saturn's neutral dignity and Mars' aspect on the 10th (/houses/9/aspectedBy). S3 misstates Saturn's house: it sits in house 10 per /placements/Saturn/house, while house 11 is empty (/houses/11/occupants)."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-contradiction-02\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.95,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"S2\",\"S3\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies natal house 10 (Sagittarius), the house of career, in a neutral dignity — a weighty, mixed career indicator rather than one of uninterrupted success.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/sign\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn aspects houses 4, 7 and 12 and receives Mars' aspect on the 10th, adding friction to career matters.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Saturn\",\"/houses/9/aspectedBy\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn in the 10th is not an uninterrupted-success signature. Classical treatment is cautious/mixed: Saturn gives position through sustained effort, delay and fluctuation, especially here with Saturn of neutral dignity aspected by Mars (/houses/9/aspectedBy) and ruling dusthana houses 11–12 lords... more precisely Saturn rules Capricorn (house 11) and Aquarius (house 12), placed in 10. S1's 'mixed, rises and falls' framing is the correct reading; S2's absolute claim is wrong.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/houses/10/occupants\",\"/aspects/Mars\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Saturn is placed in Sagittarius in house 10, not house 11; house 11 (Capricorn) has no occupants and is only its lordship.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/sign\",\"/houses/11/occupants\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S1 correctly reflects the classical mixed reading of Saturn in the 10th (occupant of /houses/10, neutral dignity /placements/Saturn/dignity). S2 overstates by claiming guaranteed continuous success, contradicted by Saturn's neutral dignity and Mars' aspect on the 10th (/houses/9/aspectedBy). S3 misstates Saturn's house: it sits in house 10 per /placements/Saturn/house, while house 11 is empty (/houses/11/occupants).\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-contradiction-02","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-contradiction-02","domain":"career","conclusion":"insufficient","confidence":1,"selected_option_ids":["S2","S3"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn in the 10th is a mixed career indication — Saturn is a natural malefic placed in a kendra, digbala-adjacent placement, but as an austere graha it gives status through delay and fluctuation rather than uninterrupted rise","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/houses/10/significations"]},{"claim":"S2 overstates: nothing in the chart supports 'uninterrupted success'; Saturn in 10 with Mars aspecting the 10th house suggests pressure and volatility","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/aspects/Mars"]},{"claim":"S3 factually wrong on house occupancy","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the 10th (house of career per /placements/Saturn/house) is traditionally a mixed indication: it can give responsibility, authority and durable standing, but Saturn's nature implies slow progress, delays, and rises and falls — not uninterrupted success. The chart itself labels this house as signifying 'career... public standing' with Saturn occupying it (/houses/10).","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/houses/10/significations"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Saturn occupies house 10 (Sagittarius), not house 11. House 11 has no occupants; its lord Saturn sits in the 10th.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/houses/11/occupants","/houses/10/occupants"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is doctrinally sound and consistent with the chart. S2 contradicts standard Parashari treatment of Saturn in a kendra (overclaim). S3 misstates the placement — Saturn is in the 10th house, Sagittarius, while house 11 (Capricorn, which Saturn rules) is empty."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-contradiction-02\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"insufficient\",\"confidence\":1.0,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"S2\",\"S3\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn in the 10th is a mixed career indication — Saturn is a natural malefic placed in a kendra, digbala-adjacent placement, but as an austere graha it gives status through delay and fluctuation rather than uninterrupted rise\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"S2 overstates: nothing in the chart supports 'uninterrupted success'; Saturn in 10 with Mars aspecting the 10th house suggests pressure and volatility\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/aspects/Mars\"]},{\"claim\":\"S3 factually wrong on house occupancy\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn in the 10th (house of career per /placements/Saturn/house) is traditionally a mixed indication: it can give responsibility, authority and durable standing, but Saturn's nature implies slow progress, delays, and rises and falls — not uninterrupted success. The chart itself labels this house as signifying 'career... public standing' with Saturn occupying it (/houses/10).\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Saturn occupies house 10 (Sagittarius), not house 11. House 11 has no occupants; its lord Saturn sits in the 10th.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/houses/11/occupants\",\"/houses/10/occupants\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S1 is doctrinally sound and consistent with the chart. S2 contradicts standard Parashari treatment of Saturn in a kendra (overclaim). S3 misstates the placement — Saturn is in the 10th house, Sagittarius, while house 11 (Capricorn, which Saturn rules) is empty.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-application-02","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-02","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The tenth lord Mars is placed in the first house, supporting independent professional advancement through personal effort.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9/lord","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Tenth lord in the first is a favorable indication but does not guarantee fame.","evidence":["/houses/9/lord","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Tenth lord in the first is not necessarily a dependent-career indication; it is classically read as self-driven career activity.","evidence":["/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Chart facts show the tenth lord (Mars) placed in the first house (/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse = 1). Statement A correctly applies this classical rule as supportive of independent professional advancement. Statement B overclaims by asserting guaranteed fame, and statement C contradicts the rule's polarity. Only A is selected, so the conclusion follows its supportive polarity."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-02\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.85,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The tenth lord Mars is placed in the first house, supporting independent professional advancement through personal effort.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Tenth lord in the first is a favorable indication but does not guarantee fame.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Tenth lord in the first is not necessarily a dependent-career indication; it is classically read as self-driven career activity.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Chart facts show the tenth lord (Mars) placed in the first house (/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse = 1). Statement A correctly applies this classical rule as supportive of independent professional advancement. Statement B overclaims by asserting guaranteed fame, and statement C contradicts the rule's polarity. Only A is selected, so the conclusion follows its supportive polarity.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-synthesis-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-01","domain":"career","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.65,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Lagna lord and yogakaraka-style raja-yoga planet Jupiter sits in the 10th house of career — a strong central career signature, though weakened by enemy-sign placement in Virgo and retrogression","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/yogas/0"]},{"claim":"Jupiter aspects the 2nd house of wealth from the 10th, linking profession to accumulated resources; the 10th is also aspected by Ketu, adding a technical/analytical or detachment flavour to career expression","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/aspects/Jupiter","/houses/9/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"D10 shows Jupiter (with Rahu) in the 6th house in Cancer — service-oriented work, competitive environments; dispositor Moon in the 2nd suggests earnings through communication/knowledge roles","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/4","/vargas/D10/placements/7"]},{"claim":"In D10, Saturn and Ketu occupy the 12th house with Saturn in its own sign Capricorn — capacity for disciplined behind-the-scenes or foreign-linked work; Ketu there can indicate periodic withdrawal or dissatisfaction with institutional structures","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/6","/vargas/D10/placements/8"]},{"claim":"D10 benefic cluster (Sun, Moon, Venus) in the 2nd house Pisces supports income through advisory, creative, or knowledge-based professional output","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/0","/vargas/D10/placements/1","/vargas/D10/placements/5"]},{"claim":"Current mahadasha is Saturn (2022–2041), a natural karaka for disciplined labour but placed natally in the 12th in an enemy sign with debilitated Rahu — gains come through persistence rather than quick elevation","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Rahu/dignity"]},{"claim":"Saturn–Mercury antardasha (Apr 2025–Dec 2027): Mercury rules both the 7th and 10th houses and occupies the 2nd — this is the single most career-active sub-period in the current mahadasha, favourable for contracts, partnerships and status consolidation","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/dasha/current/antardasha","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house"]},{"claim":"Natal 10th lord Mercury in the 2nd with Venus forms a dhana-flavoured link between profession and finances; Adhi Yoga (Venus, Mercury benefics from the Moon) supports overall standing","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/occupants","/placements/Venus/house","/yogas/1"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"A raja yoga via Jupiter in the 10th does not guarantee uninterrupted authority; Jupiter is retrograde and in an enemy sign, so results are moderated and often realized after delay or re-direction","evidence":["/yogas/0","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde"]},{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"omission","correction":"Any career reading must weigh that the dasha lord Saturn sits in the 12th with debilitated Rahu, which tempers the otherwise strong Jupiter-in-10th promise during the current mahadasha","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Rahu/dignity"]}],"missing_information":["Exact birth-time rectification confidence (lagna at 8°29' Sagittarius is mid-sign, so timing risk is low but non-zero)","Specific profession/industry of the native to map chart indications onto actual role","Divisional vargas beyond D9/D10 (e.g., no D24 for education-based career foundation)"],"rationale":"The core career architecture is strong: lagna lord Jupiter in the 10th forming a single-lordship raja yoga, 10th lord Mercury well-placed in the 2nd with Venus, and supportive D10 placements (benefics in the 2nd, dignified Saturn). These are offset by Jupiter's retrograde, enemy-sign condition, Ketu's aspect on the 10th, and a dasha lord (Saturn) placed in the 12th with debilitated Rahu — indicating steady but effortful professional progress. The current Saturn–Mercury period (through Dec 2027), with Mercury ruling the 10th, is the most career-favourable window within this mahadasha; later Saturn–Ketu and Saturn–Venus periods bring mixed results. Overall conclusion: mixed — solid foundational promise, realized through persistence rather than meteoric rise."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-synthesis-01\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.65,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Lagna lord and yogakaraka-style raja-yoga planet Jupiter sits in the 10th house of career — a strong central career signature, though weakened by enemy-sign placement in Virgo and retrogression\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/yogas/0\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter aspects the 2nd house of wealth from the 10th, linking profession to accumulated resources; the 10th is also aspected by Ketu, adding a technical/analytical or detachment flavour to career expression\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Jupiter\",\"/houses/9/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 shows Jupiter (with Rahu) in the 6th house in Cancer — service-oriented work, competitive environments; dispositor Moon in the 2nd suggests earnings through communication/knowledge roles\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/4\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/7\"]},{\"claim\":\"In D10, Saturn and Ketu occupy the 12th house with Saturn in its own sign Capricorn — capacity for disciplined behind-the-scenes or foreign-linked work; Ketu there can indicate periodic withdrawal or dissatisfaction with institutional structures\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/6\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/8\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 benefic cluster (Sun, Moon, Venus) in the 2nd house Pisces supports income through advisory, creative, or knowledge-based professional output\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/0\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/1\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/5\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current mahadasha is Saturn (2022–2041), a natural karaka for disciplined labour but placed natally in the 12th in an enemy sign with debilitated Rahu — gains come through persistence rather than quick elevation\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/mahadasha\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Rahu/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn–Mercury antardasha (Apr 2025–Dec 2027): Mercury rules both the 7th and 10th houses and occupies the 2nd — this is the single most career-active sub-period in the current mahadasha, favourable for contracts, partnerships and status consolidation\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/antardasha\",\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Natal 10th lord Mercury in the 2nd with Venus forms a dhana-flavoured link between profession and finances; Adhi Yoga (Venus, Mercury benefics from the Moon) supports overall standing\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/occupants\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/yogas/1\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"A raja yoga via Jupiter in the 10th does not guarantee uninterrupted authority; Jupiter is retrograde and in an enemy sign, so results are moderated and often realized after delay or re-direction\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"omission\",\"correction\":\"Any career reading must weigh that the dasha lord Saturn sits in the 12th with debilitated Rahu, which tempers the otherwise strong Jupiter-in-10th promise during the current mahadasha\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/dignity\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"Exact birth-time rectification confidence (lagna at 8°29' Sagittarius is mid-sign, so timing risk is low but non-zero)\",\"Specific profession/industry of the native to map chart indications onto actual role\",\"Divisional vargas beyond D9/D10 (e.g., no D24 for education-based career foundation)\"],\"rationale\":\"The core career architecture is strong: lagna lord Jupiter in the 10th forming a single-lordship raja yoga, 10th lord Mercury well-placed in the 2nd with Venus, and supportive D10 placements (benefics in the 2nd, dignified Saturn). These are offset by Jupiter's retrograde, enemy-sign condition, Ketu's aspect on the 10th, and a dasha lord (Saturn) placed in the 12th with debilitated Rahu — indicating steady but effortful professional progress. The current Saturn–Mercury period (through Dec 2027), with Mercury ruling the 10th, is the most career-favourable window within this mahadasha; later Saturn–Ketu and Saturn–Venus periods bring mixed results. Overall conclusion: mixed — solid foundational promise, realized through persistence rather than meteoric rise.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-synthesis-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-01","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.65,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Lagna lord Jupiter placed in the 10th house of career links self and vocation strongly; it is a kendra-trikona raja yoga by single lordship (rules 1st and 4th)","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house","/yogas/0"]},{"claim":"Jupiter is retrograde and in enemy sign Virgo in the 10th — career standing comes with internalized effort, delays, or work under others' systems rather than effortless authority","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"10th lord Mercury sits in the 2nd house with Venus, tying career to speech, finance, commerce, writing, or resource management; Mercury is neutral in Capricorn","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"claim":"Ketu aspects the 10th house from the 6th, introducing detachment, technical/specialist inclination, or periodic discontinuity in career direction","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/aspects/Ketu","/houses/9/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"D10 lagna Aquarius with Saturn as its dispositor placed own-sign in D10 12th: strong Saturnine, structured/technical career flavor but gains realized behind the scenes, abroad, or late","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/lagnaSign","/vargas/D10/placements/6"]},{"claim":"D10 shows Sun-Moon-Venus cluster in Pisces 2nd and Mercury in Sagittarius 11th — earnings through advisory/creative/knowledge work and gains via networks","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/0","/vargas/D10/placements/1","/vargas/D10/placements/5","/vargas/D10/placements/3"]},{"claim":"Adhi Yoga (Venus, Mercury benefics in 6th–8th from Moon) supports rise in status over life","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"Current Saturn mahadasha (2022–2041) — Saturn is a functional malefic for Sagittarius lagna (lord of 2nd and 3rd) placed in the 12th natal house in enemy sign; dasha favors steady service-oriented work but with expenditure, foreign placement, or isolation themes","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity"]},{"claim":"Saturn–Mercury antardasha (Apr 2025–Dec 2027): both are career-linked grahas here (Mercury rules the 10th); period favors consolidation, documentation, finance or communication-heavy roles","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/dasha/current/antardasha","/placements/Mercury/house"]},{"claim":"Transit Jupiter in Gemini aspects the natal 11th (gains) while transit Saturn in Pisces aspects the natal 10th — a window of visible professional consolidation around early 2026","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/transits/jupiterFromMoon","/transits/contacts/6"]},{"claim":"Mars strong in own sign Aries in the 5th aspecting the 11th gives drive, competitive intelligence and capacity for gains through initiative/speculative ventures","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Mars/house","/aspects/Mars"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"omission","correction":"A reading of 'strong 10th-house Jupiter = unqualified career authority' would be an overclaim: Jupiter is retrograde and in an enemy sign (/placements/Jupiter/dignity), so authority is earned slowly and often through service rather than command.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/placements/Jupiter/dignity"]},{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn dasha should not be read as purely adverse: despite 12th-house placement, D10 Saturn is own-sign in Capricorn (/vargas/D10/placements/6), giving durability and structural competence in career during this dasha.","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/6"]}],"missing_information":["Exact career field of the subject to weigh D10 significators against actual profession","Amatyakaraka (Jaimini) computation not provided","Divisional strength beyond D9/D10 (e.g., D24 for education background)","Specific dates of past career events for verification against dasha timeline"],"rationale":"The chart supports a substantive, durable career: lagna lord Jupiter in the 10th forms a kendra-trikona raja yoga, 10th lord Mercury joins Venus in the 2nd (speech/finance/commerce), and Adhi Yoga adds status over time. The current Saturn MD with Mercury AD activates exactly these career-linked grahas, and 2026 transits (Jupiter aspecting the 11th, Saturn aspecting the 10th) favor consolidation. Offsetting factors: retrograde, enemy-signed Jupiter in the 10th, Ketu's aspect on the 10th, and natal Saturn in the 12th indicate slow-building authority, specialist/behind-the-scenes or foreign-connected work, and periods of detachment or restructuring rather than a smooth linear ascent. Net assessment: supportive, with mixed texture — steady gains through knowledge/service roles, best expressed with patience through the Saturn mahadasha."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-synthesis-01\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.65,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Lagna lord Jupiter placed in the 10th house of career links self and vocation strongly; it is a kendra-trikona raja yoga by single lordship (rules 1st and 4th)\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/yogas/0\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter is retrograde and in enemy sign Virgo in the 10th — career standing comes with internalized effort, delays, or work under others' systems rather than effortless authority\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"10th lord Mercury sits in the 2nd house with Venus, tying career to speech, finance, commerce, writing, or resource management; Mercury is neutral in Capricorn\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu aspects the 10th house from the 6th, introducing detachment, technical/specialist inclination, or periodic discontinuity in career direction\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Ketu\",\"/houses/9/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 lagna Aquarius with Saturn as its dispositor placed own-sign in D10 12th: strong Saturnine, structured/technical career flavor but gains realized behind the scenes, abroad, or late\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/lagnaSign\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/6\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 shows Sun-Moon-Venus cluster in Pisces 2nd and Mercury in Sagittarius 11th — earnings through advisory/creative/knowledge work and gains via networks\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/0\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/1\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/5\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/3\"]},{\"claim\":\"Adhi Yoga (Venus, Mercury benefics in 6th–8th from Moon) supports rise in status over life\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current Saturn mahadasha (2022–2041) — Saturn is a functional malefic for Sagittarius lagna (lord of 2nd and 3rd) placed in the 12th natal house in enemy sign; dasha favors steady service-oriented work but with expenditure, foreign placement, or isolation themes\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/mahadasha\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn–Mercury antardasha (Apr 2025–Dec 2027): both are career-linked grahas here (Mercury rules the 10th); period favors consolidation, documentation, finance or communication-heavy roles\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/antardasha\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Transit Jupiter in Gemini aspects the natal 11th (gains) while transit Saturn in Pisces aspects the natal 10th — a window of visible professional consolidation around early 2026\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/transits/jupiterFromMoon\",\"/transits/contacts/6\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars strong in own sign Aries in the 5th aspecting the 11th gives drive, competitive intelligence and capacity for gains through initiative/speculative ventures\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/aspects/Mars\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"omission\",\"correction\":\"A reading of 'strong 10th-house Jupiter = unqualified career authority' would be an overclaim: Jupiter is retrograde and in an enemy sign (/placements/Jupiter/dignity), so authority is earned slowly and often through service rather than command.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn dasha should not be read as purely adverse: despite 12th-house placement, D10 Saturn is own-sign in Capricorn (/vargas/D10/placements/6), giving durability and structural competence in career during this dasha.\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/6\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"Exact career field of the subject to weigh D10 significators against actual profession\",\"Amatyakaraka (Jaimini) computation not provided\",\"Divisional strength beyond D9/D10 (e.g., D24 for education background)\",\"Specific dates of past career events for verification against dasha timeline\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart supports a substantive, durable career: lagna lord Jupiter in the 10th forms a kendra-trikona raja yoga, 10th lord Mercury joins Venus in the 2nd (speech/finance/commerce), and Adhi Yoga adds status over time. The current Saturn MD with Mercury AD activates exactly these career-linked grahas, and 2026 transits (Jupiter aspecting the 11th, Saturn aspecting the 10th) favor consolidation. Offsetting factors: retrograde, enemy-signed Jupiter in the 10th, Ketu's aspect on the 10th, and natal Saturn in the 12th indicate slow-building authority, specialist/behind-the-scenes or foreign-connected work, and periods of detachment or restructuring rather than a smooth linear ascent. Net assessment: supportive, with mixed texture — steady gains through knowledge/service roles, best expressed with patience through the Saturn mahadasha.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-synthesis-02","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-02","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.72,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Sasa Yoga (Mahapurusha): Saturn exalted in Libra in the 10th house — a first-rank career indicator giving authority, discipline and public standing","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/yogas/0"]},{"claim":"Lagna lord Saturn placed in the 10th house links self to career strongly; Dhanishta nakshatra (ruled by Mars) lagna adds drive","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/lagna/nakshatraLord"]},{"claim":"Raja Yoga: Venus rules both 10th (kendra) and 5th (trikona) — a single-lordship Raja Yoga supporting status and creative/professional success","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9","/houses/4","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"Vipareeta Raja Yoga: 12th lord Jupiter falls in the 6th — gains through adversity, service, litigation or competitive fields","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/yogas/2"]},{"claim":"Adhi Yoga from the Moon (benefics Venus, Mercury in 6th/7th/8th from Moon) indicates prosperity and leadership over peers","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/3"]},{"claim":"Career lord Venus is debilitated-positionally weak natally, placed in the 12th with Rahu — income/status lord in a dusthana suggests expenditure, foreign connections, or work behind the scenes; partially offset by its own Raja-Yoga lordship","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Rahu/house","/placements/Venus/dignity"]},{"claim":"Mars aspects the 10th house (6th, 9th, 10th aspects from Pisces) — energy, technical/engineering flavor, but also friction with authority","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/aspects/Mars","/placements/Mars/house"]},{"claim":"D10 shows Sun in Taurus D10-lagna, Venus in Aquarius in D10-10th, and Mercury+Jupiter+Rahu stacked in D10-11th (Pisces) — strong gains through intellect, communication, networks; Venus again as D10 karma-lord in the 10th reinforces the career theme despite natal 12th placement","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements"]},{"claim":"Current period Rahu–Venus–Saturn (to 2026-05): Rahu MD sits in natal 12th with Venus; Venus AD is both the Raja-Yoga lord and the 10th lord — high activity but also foreign/behind-the-scenes themes; Saturn PD is exalted in the 10th natally, favoring concrete professional consolidation now","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/dasha/current","/dasha/upcoming/0"]},{"claim":"Transits as of 2026-01: Jupiter retrograde conjunct natal Jupiter/Ketu in the 6th aspects the 10th; transiting Rahu on natal Mercury aspects the 10th — active pressure on career houses, with some instability (retrograde Jupiter, nodal influence)","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/transits/asOf","/transits/contacts/4","/transits/contacts/7"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"omission","correction":"The apparent conflict between exalted Saturn (Sasa Yoga) in the 10th and the 10th lord Venus in the 12th resolves by reading them together: Saturn delivers strong structural authority and longevity of career, while Venus-in-12th redirects expression toward foreign lands, institutions behind walls, research/isolation, or expenditure-heavy roles rather than denying career. D10 confirmation (Venus in D10-10th) supports this reconciliation.","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements","/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Saturn/house"]}],"missing_information":["Exact birth-time rectification confidence (whole-sign lagna at late Capricorn degree is sensitive to time error)","Specific profession/industry context of the native to map indications concretely"],"rationale":"The chart is career-strong overall: an exalted Saturn in the 10th forming Sasa Yoga, lagna lord also in the 10th, a Venus single-lordship Raja Yoga, Vipareeta Raja Yoga, and Adhi Yoga all point to durable professional standing and authority. The main weakness — 10th lord Venus in the 12th with Rahu — modifies rather than negates: it favors foreign, institutional, research-oriented or behind-the-scenes work and some leakage of earnings, corroborated in the D10 where Venus occupies the 10th and a benefic cluster sits in the 11th of gains. The current Rahu–Venus dasha with Saturn pratyantar (exalted natal 10th) favors consolidation through early 2026, followed by Rahu–Sun and Rahu–Moon periods that activate the 1st and 7th houses (partnerships/public dealings). Conclusion: supportive, with moderate confidence due to the Venus placement tension."},"extracted":"{\n  \"case_id\": \"career-synthesis-02\",\n  \"domain\": \"career\",\n  \"conclusion\": \"supportive\",\n  \"confidence\": 0.72,\n  \"selected_option_ids\": [],\n  \"factors\": [\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Sasa Yoga (Mahapurusha): Saturn exalted in Libra in the 10th house — a first-rank career indicator giving authority, discipline and public standing\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Saturn/house\", \"/placements/Saturn/dignity\", \"/yogas/0\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Lagna lord Saturn placed in the 10th house links self to career strongly; Dhanishta nakshatra (ruled by Mars) lagna adds drive\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/lagna/lordInHouse\", \"/lagna/nakshatraLord\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Raja Yoga: Venus rules both 10th (kendra) and 5th (trikona) — a single-lordship Raja Yoga supporting status and creative/professional success\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/houses/9\", \"/houses/4\", \"/yogas/1\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Vipareeta Raja Yoga: 12th lord Jupiter falls in the 6th — gains through adversity, service, litigation or competitive fields\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Jupiter/house\", \"/yogas/2\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Adhi Yoga from the Moon (benefics Venus, Mercury in 6th/7th/8th from Moon) indicates prosperity and leadership over peers\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/3\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Career lord Venus is debilitated-positionally weak natally, placed in the 12th with Rahu — income/status lord in a dusthana suggests expenditure, foreign connections, or work behind the scenes; partially offset by its own Raja-Yoga lordship\",\n      \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Venus/house\", \"/placements/Rahu/house\", \"/placements/Venus/dignity\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Mars aspects the 10th house (6th, 9th, 10th aspects from Pisces) — energy, technical/engineering flavor, but also friction with authority\",\n      \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/aspects/Mars\", \"/placements/Mars/house\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"D10 shows Sun in Taurus D10-lagna, Venus in Aquarius in D10-10th, and Mercury+Jupiter+Rahu stacked in D10-11th (Pisces) — strong gains through intellect, communication, networks; Venus again as D10 karma-lord in the 10th reinforces the career theme despite natal 12th placement\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/vargas/D10/placements\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Current period Rahu–Venus–Saturn (to 2026-05): Rahu MD sits in natal 12th with Venus; Venus AD is both the Raja-Yoga lord and the 10th lord — high activity but also foreign/behind-the-scenes themes; Saturn PD is exalted in the 10th natally, favoring concrete professional consolidation now\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/dasha/current\", \"/dasha/upcoming/0\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Transits as of 2026-01: Jupiter retrograde conjunct natal Jupiter/Ketu in the 6th aspects the 10th; transiting Rahu on natal Mercury aspects the 10th — active pressure on career houses, with some instability (retrograde Jupiter, nodal influence)\",\n      \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/transits/asOf\", \"/transits/contacts/4\", \"/transits/contacts/7\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"contradictions\": [\n    {\n      \"statement_id\": \"S1\",\n      \"error_type\": \"omission\",\n      \"correction\": \"The apparent conflict between exalted Saturn (Sasa Yoga) in the 10th and the 10th lord Venus in the 12th resolves by reading them together: Saturn delivers strong structural authority and longevity of career, while Venus-in-12th redirects expression toward foreign lands, institutions behind walls, research/isolation, or expenditure-heavy roles rather than denying career. D10 confirmation (Venus in D10-10th) supports this reconciliation.\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/vargas/D10/placements\", \"/placements/Venus/house\", \"/placements/Saturn/house\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"missing_information\": [\n    \"Exact birth-time rectification confidence (whole-sign lagna at late Capricorn degree is sensitive to time error)\",\n    \"Specific profession/industry context of the native to map indications concretely\"\n  ],\n  \"rationale\": \"The chart is career-strong overall: an exalted Saturn in the 10th forming Sasa Yoga, lagna lord also in the 10th, a Venus single-lordship Raja Yoga, Vipareeta Raja Yoga, and Adhi Yoga all point to durable professional standing and authority. The main weakness — 10th lord Venus in the 12th with Rahu — modifies rather than negates: it favors foreign, institutional, research-oriented or behind-the-scenes work and some leakage of earnings, corroborated in the D10 where Venus occupies the 10th and a benefic cluster sits in the 11th of gains. The current Rahu–Venus dasha with Saturn pratyantar (exalted natal 10th) favors consolidation through early 2026, followed by Rahu–Sun and Rahu–Moon periods that activate the 1st and 7th houses (partnerships/public dealings). Conclusion: supportive, with moderate confidence due to the Venus placement tension.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-synthesis-02","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-02","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.72,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Sasa Yoga (Mahapurusha): exalted Saturn in a kendra (10th house) is the single strongest career indicator — authority, discipline, durable public standing","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Saturn/house","/yogas/0"]},{"claim":"Lagna lord Saturn placed in the 10th links self and career tightly; career is central to identity","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/houses/9/occupants"]},{"claim":"Venus rules both the 10th kendra and 5th trikona — a Raja Yoga by single lordship — indicating status through Venusian/refined domains; however Venus sits in the 12th, suggesting gains realized abroad, behind-the-scenes work, or with expenditure/foreign connection","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/yogas/1","/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/sign"]},{"claim":"D10 supports: Sun in D10 lagna (self-directed career), Venus in D10 10th (career activation of the Raja Yoga lord), Mercury+Jupiter+Rahu in D10 11th (gains via intellect, advisory, networks)","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/0","/vargas/D10/placements/5","/vargas/D10/placements/3"]},{"claim":"10th house receives aspects from Mars (6/9/10 aspect), Jupiter, and Ketu — mixed influences: Mars energizes action, Jupiter blesses wisdom, Ketu adds detachment/unconventionality to the profession","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/9/aspectedBy","/aspects/Mars","/aspects/Jupiter","/aspects/Ketu"]},{"claim":"Jupiter vargottama (same sign D1 and D9) strengthens its aspect on the 10th — protective wisdom over career despite Jupiter's enemy-sign dignity in the 6th (also forming Vipareeta Raja Yoga: gains through adversity/service)","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargottama","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/yogas/2"]},{"claim":"Current Rahu–Venus–Saturn period (to 2026-12-07): Rahu MD in 12th (foreign/expansion), Venus AD activating the Raja Yoga lord but from the 12th, Saturn PD on the natal exalted Saturn — career-relevant and largely favorable though with foreign/behind-scenes flavor","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current","/placements/Rahu/house","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"claim":"Transits as of 2026-01-01: Jupiter retrograde over natal Jupiter/Ketu aspecting the 10th (re-evaluation with protection); Saturn conjunct natal Mars in 3rd (effort, persistence); transit Rahu over natal Mercury in 2nd aspecting 10th (ambition in income/speech-driven work)","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/transits/contacts/4","/transits/contacts/6","/transits/contacts/7"]},{"claim":"Gochara: Saturn at 9 from Moon and Jupiter at 12 from Moon — Jupiter transiting 12th-from-Moon dampens fortune/visibility short-term even as natal promise remains strong","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/transits/saturnFromMoon","/transits/jupiterFromMoon"]},{"claim":"Sun (8th lord) in lagna in enemy sign: dignity strain for authority figures/self-promotion; success comes more via steady Saturnian effort than charisma","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Sun/dignity","/placements/Sun/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"omission","correction":"Sasa Yoga's promise must be reconciled with 10th-lord Venus in the 12th: peak status may come through foreign lands, institutions, or service-oriented settings rather than conventional visible leadership. The Vipareeta Raja Yoga (Jupiter) reinforces gains arising from difficult/service contexts.","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/yogas/1","/yogas/2"]},{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"One should not read the Rahu–Venus antardasha as unambiguously prosperous: Venus is strong by yoga but located in the 12th, and Jupiter currently transits 12-from-Moon — expect meaningful career movement with some expenditure, relocation, or reduced visibility.","evidence":["/dasha/current","/placements/Venus/house","/transits/jupiterFromMoon"]}],"missing_information":["Exact birth-time reliability confirmation (lagna at 25° Capricorn is late in sign)","Occupation field of the subject to map significators (Saturn/Venus/Mercury) concretely","D24 or higher-order vargas if education-linked career analysis is wanted"],"rationale":"The chart shows an unusually strong structural career promise: exalted Saturn (lagna lord) in the 10th forms Sasa Yoga, and Venus's dual lordship of the 10th and 5th creates a Raja Yoga whose results are confirmed in D10 (Venus in D10 10th, benefic cluster in D10 11th). The main qualifications are Venus's 12th-house placement (foreign/behind-the-scenes realization of status), the Sun's enemy-sign dignity in lagna (authority earned rather than conferred), and current gochara (Jupiter 12-from-Moon) that temporarily mutes visibility. Net assessment: supportive, with a Saturnian slow-build character and likely foreign/institutional coloring."},"extracted":"{\n  \"case_id\": \"career-synthesis-02\",\n  \"domain\": \"career\",\n  \"conclusion\": \"supportive\",\n  \"confidence\": 0.72,\n  \"selected_option_ids\": [],\n  \"factors\": [\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Sasa Yoga (Mahapurusha): exalted Saturn in a kendra (10th house) is the single strongest career indicator — authority, discipline, durable public standing\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\", \"/placements/Saturn/house\", \"/yogas/0\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Lagna lord Saturn placed in the 10th links self and career tightly; career is central to identity\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/lagna/lordInHouse\", \"/houses/9/occupants\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Venus rules both the 10th kendra and 5th trikona — a Raja Yoga by single lordship — indicating status through Venusian/refined domains; however Venus sits in the 12th, suggesting gains realized abroad, behind-the-scenes work, or with expenditure/foreign connection\",\n      \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/1\", \"/placements/Venus/house\", \"/placements/Venus/sign\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"D10 supports: Sun in D10 lagna (self-directed career), Venus in D10 10th (career activation of the Raja Yoga lord), Mercury+Jupiter+Rahu in D10 11th (gains via intellect, advisory, networks)\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/vargas/D10/placements/0\", \"/vargas/D10/placements/5\", \"/vargas/D10/placements/3\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"10th house receives aspects from Mars (6/9/10 aspect), Jupiter, and Ketu — mixed influences: Mars energizes action, Jupiter blesses wisdom, Ketu adds detachment/unconventionality to the profession\",\n      \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/houses/9/aspectedBy\", \"/aspects/Mars\", \"/aspects/Jupiter\", \"/aspects/Ketu\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Jupiter vargottama (same sign D1 and D9) strengthens its aspect on the 10th — protective wisdom over career despite Jupiter's enemy-sign dignity in the 6th (also forming Vipareeta Raja Yoga: gains through adversity/service)\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/vargottama\", \"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\", \"/yogas/2\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Current Rahu–Venus–Saturn period (to 2026-12-07): Rahu MD in 12th (foreign/expansion), Venus AD activating the Raja Yoga lord but from the 12th, Saturn PD on the natal exalted Saturn — career-relevant and largely favorable though with foreign/behind-scenes flavor\",\n      \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/dasha/current\", \"/placements/Rahu/house\", \"/placements/Venus/house\"],\n      \"note\": \"dasha data from /dasha\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Transits as of 2026-01-01: Jupiter retrograde over natal Jupiter/Ketu aspecting the 10th (re-evaluation with protection); Saturn conjunct natal Mars in 3rd (effort, persistence); transit Rahu over natal Mercury in 2nd aspecting 10th (ambition in income/speech-driven work)\",\n      \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/transits/contacts/4\", \"/transits/contacts/6\", \"/transits/contacts/7\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Gochara: Saturn at 9 from Moon and Jupiter at 12 from Moon — Jupiter transiting 12th-from-Moon dampens fortune/visibility short-term even as natal promise remains strong\",\n      \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/transits/saturnFromMoon\", \"/transits/jupiterFromMoon\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Sun (8th lord) in lagna in enemy sign: dignity strain for authority figures/self-promotion; success comes more via steady Saturnian effort than charisma\",\n      \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Sun/dignity\", \"/placements/Sun/house\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"contradictions\": [\n    {\n      \"statement_id\": \"S1\",\n      \"error_type\": \"omission\",\n      \"correction\": \"Sasa Yoga's promise must be reconciled with 10th-lord Venus in the 12th: peak status may come through foreign lands, institutions, or service-oriented settings rather than conventional visible leadership. The Vipareeta Raja Yoga (Jupiter) reinforces gains arising from difficult/service contexts.\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Venus/house\", \"/yogas/1\", \"/yogas/2\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"statement_id\": \"S2\",\n      \"error_type\": \"overclaim\",\n      \"correction\": \"One should not read the Rahu–Venus antardasha as unambiguously prosperous: Venus is strong by yoga but located in the 12th, and Jupiter currently transits 12-from-Moon — expect meaningful career movement with some expenditure, relocation, or reduced visibility.\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/dasha/current\", \"/placements/Venus/house\", \"/transits/jupiterFromMoon\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"missing_information\": [\n    \"Exact birth-time reliability confirmation (lagna at 25° Capricorn is late in sign)\",\n    \"Occupation field of the subject to map significators (Saturn/Venus/Mercury) concretely\",\n    \"D24 or higher-order vargas if education-linked career analysis is wanted\"\n  ],\n  \"rationale\": \"The chart shows an unusually strong structural career promise: exalted Saturn (lagna lord) in the 10th forms Sasa Yoga, and Venus's dual lordship of the 10th and 5th creates a Raja Yoga whose results are confirmed in D10 (Venus in D10 10th, benefic cluster in D10 11th). The main qualifications are Venus's 12th-house placement (foreign/behind-the-scenes realization of status), the Sun's enemy-sign dignity in lagna (authority earned rather than conferred), and current gochara (Jupiter 12-from-Moon) that temporarily mutes visibility. Net assessment: supportive, with a Saturnian slow-build character and likely foreign/institutional coloring.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-synthesis-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-01","domain":"career","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.72,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Jupiter, the lagna lord and a single-lordship Raja Yoga graha (rules 1st and 4th kendras/trikonas), sits in the 10th house of career — a strong indicator of status and authority in profession.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/yogas/0"]},{"claim":"Jupiter is retrograde and in an enemy sign (Virgo) in the 10th, tempering the yoga — gains may come with delays, revisions of direction, or working under conditions not naturally aligned to the graha's nature.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"The 10th lord Mercury is placed in the 2nd house (wealth, speech) with Venus, indicating career tied to communication, finance, analysis, or commerce, and income derived from professional skill.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"claim":"Ketu aspects the 10th house (/aspects/Ketu includes 10) while Saturn also aspects it from the 12th via its 10th aspect — detachment, unconventional or technical/back-office work flavor, and pressure on public standing.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Ketu","/placements/Saturn/house","/aspects/Saturn"]},{"claim":"In D10, Saturn is in its own sign Capricorn in the 12th house (with Ketu), suggesting disciplined work executed behind the scenes, in foreign lands, institutions, or isolated settings rather than visible leadership.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["tool:varga#D10/placements/Saturn"]},{"claim":"D10 lagna Aquarius with Sun, Moon, and Venus all in the 2nd house of the D10 (Pisces), dispositor Jupiter placed in the D10 6th — earnings-oriented career with a service/problem-solving dimension; benefic cluster supports income through profession.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["tool:varga#D10/lagnaSign","tool:varga#D10/placements/Sun","tool:varga#D10/placements/Venus","tool:varga#D10/placements/Jupiter"]},{"claim":"Mercury in D10 sits in the 11th house (Sagittarius) — gains through intellect, trade, writing, consulting networks; consistent with Mercury as natal 10th lord.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["tool:varga#D10/placements/Mercury"]},{"claim":"Current dasha context: Saturn mahadasha (2022–2041) with Mercury antardasha (Apr 2025 – Dec 2027). Saturn is a 2nd/3rd lord placed in the 12th natally — effortful period with expenditure themes; Mercury antardasha activates the 10th-lord karaka, favorable for career activity despite the Saturn overlay.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha","/dasha/current/antardasha","/placements/Saturn/house","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"Adhi Yoga from the Moon (Venus, Mercury in 6th/7th/8th from Moon) supports overall prosperity and position, lending resilience to the career picture.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/1"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Jupiter in the 10th alone should not be read as guaranteed high office: it is retrograde, in an enemy sign, and receives Ketu's aspect, so the Raja Yoga delivers status with friction and delay rather than unimpeded authority.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/aspects/Ketu"]},{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"omission","correction":"The D10 must be weighed alongside D1: natal Jupiter-in-10th suggests visible authority, but D10 Saturn+Ketu in own-sign Capricorn in the 12th points to substantial behind-the-scenes, technical, institutional or foreign-land work. Both are true simultaneously — recognition earned through less-visible roles.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","tool:varga#D10/placements/Saturn"]}],"missing_information":["Exact birth-time rectification confidence (whole-sign lagna at Mula pada 3 assumed reliable)","Actual occupation/industry history to anchor the synthesis against lived events","Shadbala / vimshopaka strength figures for Jupiter and Mercury"],"rationale":"Career indications are genuinely mixed but net constructive. The core engine is strong: lagna lord and single-lordship Raja Yoga graha Jupiter in the 10th (/placements/Jupiter/house, /yogas/0), and 10th lord Mercury well-placed in the 2nd with Venus linking profession directly to wealth and speech. Adhi Yoga adds baseline prosperity. Friction comes from Jupiter's retrogradation and enemy-sign placement plus Ketu/Saturn aspects on the 10th, and from D10 Saturn-Ketu in the 12th pointing to behind-the-scenes, institutional, technical, or foreign-linked work rather than overt command. Timing-wise the current Saturn MD–Mercury AD (through Dec 2027) activates the 10th lord within a heavy Saturn frame: productive but demanding. Conclusion 'mixed': solid professional achievement and income likely, realized through persistent effort and less glamorous channels than the natal 10th-house promise alone would suggest."},"extracted":"{\n \"case_id\": \"career-synthesis-01\",\n \"domain\": \"career\",\n \"conclusion\": \"mixed\",\n \"confidence\": 0.72,\n \"selected_option_ids\": [],\n \"factors\": [\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Jupiter, the lagna lord and a single-lordship Raja Yoga graha (rules 1st and 4th kendras/trikonas), sits in the 10th house of career — a strong indicator of status and authority in profession.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Jupiter/house\", \"/yogas/0\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Jupiter is retrograde and in an enemy sign (Virgo) in the 10th, tempering the yoga — gains may come with delays, revisions of direction, or working under conditions not naturally aligned to the graha's nature.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\", \"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\", \"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"The 10th lord Mercury is placed in the 2nd house (wealth, speech) with Venus, indicating career tied to communication, finance, analysis, or commerce, and income derived from professional skill.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\", \"/placements/Mercury/house\", \"/placements/Venus/house\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Ketu aspects the 10th house (/aspects/Ketu includes 10) while Saturn also aspects it from the 12th via its 10th aspect — detachment, unconventional or technical/back-office work flavor, and pressure on public standing.\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/aspects/Ketu\", \"/placements/Saturn/house\", \"/aspects/Saturn\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"In D10, Saturn is in its own sign Capricorn in the 12th house (with Ketu), suggesting disciplined work executed behind the scenes, in foreign lands, institutions, or isolated settings rather than visible leadership.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"tool:varga#D10/placements/Saturn\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"D10 lagna Aquarius with Sun, Moon, and Venus all in the 2nd house of the D10 (Pisces), dispositor Jupiter placed in the D10 6th — earnings-oriented career with a service/problem-solving dimension; benefic cluster supports income through profession.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"tool:varga#D10/lagnaSign\", \"tool:varga#D10/placements/Sun\", \"tool:varga#D10/placements/Venus\", \"tool:varga#D10/placements/Jupiter\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Mercury in D10 sits in the 11th house (Sagittarius) — gains through intellect, trade, writing, consulting networks; consistent with Mercury as natal 10th lord.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"tool:varga#D10/placements/Mercury\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Current dasha context: Saturn mahadasha (2022–2041) with Mercury antardasha (Apr 2025 – Dec 2027). Saturn is a 2nd/3rd lord placed in the 12th natally — effortful period with expenditure themes; Mercury antardasha activates the 10th-lord karaka, favorable for career activity despite the Saturn overlay.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/dasha/current/mahadasha\", \"/dasha/current/antardasha\", \"/placements/Saturn/house\", \"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Adhi Yoga from the Moon (Venus, Mercury in 6th/7th/8th from Moon) supports overall prosperity and position, lending resilience to the career picture.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/1\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"contradictions\": [\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"S1\",\n   \"error_type\": \"overclaim\",\n   \"correction\": \"Jupiter in the 10th alone should not be read as guaranteed high office: it is retrograde, in an enemy sign, and receives Ketu's aspect, so the Raja Yoga delivers status with friction and delay rather than unimpeded authority.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\", \"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\", \"/aspects/Ketu\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"S2\",\n   \"error_type\": \"omission\",\n   \"correction\": \"The D10 must be weighed alongside D1: natal Jupiter-in-10th suggests visible authority, but D10 Saturn+Ketu in own-sign Capricorn in the 12th points to substantial behind-the-scenes, technical, institutional or foreign-land work. Both are true simultaneously — recognition earned through less-visible roles.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Jupiter/house\", \"tool:varga#D10/placements/Saturn\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"missing_information\": [\n  \"Exact birth-time rectification confidence (whole-sign lagna at Mula pada 3 assumed reliable)\",\n  \"Actual occupation/industry history to anchor the synthesis against lived events\",\n  \"Shadbala / vimshopaka strength figures for Jupiter and Mercury\"\n ],\n \"rationale\": \"Career indications are genuinely mixed but net constructive. The core engine is strong: lagna lord and single-lordship Raja Yoga graha Jupiter in the 10th (/placements/Jupiter/house, /yogas/0), and 10th lord Mercury well-placed in the 2nd with Venus linking profession directly to wealth and speech. Adhi Yoga adds baseline prosperity. Friction comes from Jupiter's retrogradation and enemy-sign placement plus Ketu/Saturn aspects on the 10th, and from D10 Saturn-Ketu in the 12th pointing to behind-the-scenes, institutional, technical, or foreign-linked work rather than overt command. Timing-wise the current Saturn MD–Mercury AD (through Dec 2027) activates the 10th lord within a heavy Saturn frame: productive but demanding. Conclusion 'mixed': solid professional achievement and income likely, realized through persistent effort and less glamorous channels than the natal 10th-house promise alone would suggest.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-synthesis-02","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-02","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.75,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Sasa Yoga: Saturn exalted in Libra in the 10th house — a Mahapurusha yoga directly strengthening career, status, and authority through disciplined, steady effort","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/yogas/0"]},{"claim":"Lagna lord Saturn placed in the 10th house links self to career; Dhanishta (Mars-ruled) lagna nakshatra adds drive","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/lagna/nakshatraLord"]},{"claim":"Raja Yoga via Venus ruling both the 10th kendra and 5th trikona — though Venus sits in the 12th, indicating career gains tied to foreign lands, institutions behind the scenes, or expenditure-heavy roles","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/yogas/1","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"claim":"10th lord Venus in 12th with Rahu suggests career connected to foreign settings, research/isolation, or service abroad; Rahu amplifies ambition but can bring instability","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Rahu/house"]},{"claim":"Jupiter vargottama and Vipareeta Raja Yoga (12th lord in 6th) — success emerging from adversarial/service environments; Jupiter aspects the 10th from the 6th, supporting careers in service, law, health, or advisory work","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargottama","/yogas/2","/aspects/Jupiter"]},{"claim":"D10 shows Sun in Taurus D10 lagna with Venus (D10 10th lord) in Aquarius in the D10 10th, dispositor Saturn in Cancer 3rd — a stable, Venus-flavored professional standing built on communication and persistent effort","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/0","/vargas/D10/placements/5","/vargas/D10/placements/6"]},{"claim":"D10 11th house holds Mercury, Jupiter, and Rahu in Pisces — strong gains/networks in later life through knowledge, advisory, or large organizations","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/3","/vargas/D10/placements/4","/vargas/D10/placements/7"]},{"claim":"Mars aspects the 10th house from the 3rd — competitive energy directed at career, courage/initiative (3rd) feeding public action","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/aspects/Mars"]},{"claim":"Current period: Rahu–Venus–Saturn mahadasha-antardasha-pratyantardasha. Rahu MD (12th natal, but yogakaraka-like via Venus antardasha as 10th/5th lord) plus Saturn PD exalted natally — a period where behind-the-scenes or foreign-linked career matters intensify under Saturn's discipline","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"omission","correction":"Venus's raja yoga is diluted by 12th placement — must not be read as straightforward rise; gains come with cost/expenditure or foreign displacement","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Sun in the 1st is in enemy sign (Capricorn), so self-expression in authority roles carries friction despite Sasa Yoga strength","evidence":["/placements/Sun/dignity","/placements/Sun/house"]}],"missing_information":["Specific profession field of the native (for finer D10 alignment)","Exact birth-time rectification confidence","Full dasha timeline beyond listed upcoming periods for late-life career assessment"],"rationale":"Career indications are strongly supportive at core: exalted Saturn in the 10th (Sasa Yoga) with lagna lord in the 10th gives exceptional professional backbone, reinforced by Jupiter's vargottama aspect on the 10th and a solid D10 (benefics in D10 11th, Venus in D10 10th). The main tempering factor is 10th lord Venus in the 12th — success channels through foreign lands, institutions, or behind-the-scenes work, with expenditure or relocation costs, and Rahu's current mahadasha amplifies both ambition and instability. Net reading: durable, high-standing career achieved through discipline and service-oriented fields, most fruitful when aligned with foreign/institutional/advisory contexts."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-synthesis-02\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.75,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Sasa Yoga: Saturn exalted in Libra in the 10th house — a Mahapurusha yoga directly strengthening career, status, and authority through disciplined, steady effort\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/yogas/0\"]},{\"claim\":\"Lagna lord Saturn placed in the 10th house links self to career; Dhanishta (Mars-ruled) lagna nakshatra adds drive\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/lagna/nakshatraLord\"]},{\"claim\":\"Raja Yoga via Venus ruling both the 10th kendra and 5th trikona — though Venus sits in the 12th, indicating career gains tied to foreign lands, institutions behind the scenes, or expenditure-heavy roles\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"10th lord Venus in 12th with Rahu suggests career connected to foreign settings, research/isolation, or service abroad; Rahu amplifies ambition but can bring instability\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter vargottama and Vipareeta Raja Yoga (12th lord in 6th) — success emerging from adversarial/service environments; Jupiter aspects the 10th from the 6th, supporting careers in service, law, health, or advisory work\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargottama\",\"/yogas/2\",\"/aspects/Jupiter\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 shows Sun in Taurus D10 lagna with Venus (D10 10th lord) in Aquarius in the D10 10th, dispositor Saturn in Cancer 3rd — a stable, Venus-flavored professional standing built on communication and persistent effort\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/0\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/5\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/6\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 11th house holds Mercury, Jupiter, and Rahu in Pisces — strong gains/networks in later life through knowledge, advisory, or large organizations\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/3\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/4\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/7\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars aspects the 10th house from the 3rd — competitive energy directed at career, courage/initiative (3rd) feeding public action\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Mars\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current period: Rahu–Venus–Saturn mahadasha-antardasha-pratyantardasha. Rahu MD (12th natal, but yogakaraka-like via Venus antardasha as 10th/5th lord) plus Saturn PD exalted natally — a period where behind-the-scenes or foreign-linked career matters intensify under Saturn's discipline\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current\"],\"evidence2\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"omission\",\"correction\":\"Venus's raja yoga is diluted by 12th placement — must not be read as straightforward rise; gains come with cost/expenditure or foreign displacement\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Sun in the 1st is in enemy sign (Capricorn), so self-expression in authority roles carries friction despite Sasa Yoga strength\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/dignity\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"Specific profession field of the native (for finer D10 alignment)\",\"Exact birth-time rectification confidence\",\"Full dasha timeline beyond listed upcoming periods for late-life career assessment\"],\"rationale\":\"Career indications are strongly supportive at core: exalted Saturn in the 10th (Sasa Yoga) with lagna lord in the 10th gives exceptional professional backbone, reinforced by Jupiter's vargottama aspect on the 10th and a solid D10 (benefics in D10 11th, Venus in D10 10th). The main tempering factor is 10th lord Venus in the 12th — success channels through foreign lands, institutions, or behind-the-scenes work, with expenditure or relocation costs, and Rahu's current mahadasha amplifies both ambition and instability. Net reading: durable, high-standing career achieved through discipline and service-oriented fields, most fruitful when aligned with foreign/institutional/advisory contexts.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-knowledge-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-knowledge-01","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"rationale":"The House1LordInHouse11 rule treats the ascendant lord placed in the 11th house (house of gains) as a positive indication for income and earning capacity. Option A matches this; B overclaims by guaranteeing enormous profits, and C contradicts the rule's supportive nature."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-knowledge-01\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"confidence\":0.9,\"rationale\":\"The House1LordInHouse11 rule treats the ascendant lord placed in the 11th house (house of gains) as a positive indication for income and earning capacity. Option A matches this; B overclaims by guaranteeing enormous profits, and C contradicts the rule's supportive nature.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-synthesis-03","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-03","domain":"career","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.6,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Lagna and 10th lord Mercury form a single-lordship Raja Yoga (Mercury rules both kendra 10 and trikona 1), a strong career indicator","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/1","/placements/Mercury/lordInHouse"]},{"claim":"Mercury sits in the 4th house (angular, supportive for status through home base, education, property-linked or advisory work) rather than the 10th itself","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house"]},{"claim":"Mercury is combust in the 4th alongside Sun (Budha-Aditya Yoga) — the yoga is present but the combustion weakens its expression per the chart's own note","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/combust","/yogas/0"]},{"claim":"Ketu occupies the 10th house while Rahu aspects it from the 4th — a classic indication of unconventional career paths, detachment from status, and fluctuating public role","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Ketu/house","/aspects/Rahu"]},{"claim":"Dashamsa shows Jupiter exalted-in-strength placement (Jupiter + Rahu in Aries in the 10th of D10) and Venus in the D10 lagna — dignified career significators suggesting eventual respect in profession","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/4","/vargas/D10/placements/5"]},{"claim":"Current period is Moon–Mars–Saturn; Mars is a Vipareeta Raja Yoga graha (8th lord in 6th) placed in the 6th, indicating gains through service, competition, or difficult-work contexts during this sub-period","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current","/yogas/2","/placements/Mars/house"]},{"claim":"Transiting Saturn sits on natal Moon in the 7th (sade sati zone per gochara reckoning, saturnFromMoon=1), a period traditionally associated with pressure on partnerships and public dealings that bear on career","effect":"challenging","evidence":["tool:transits_at#/transits/Saturn/inNatalHouse","/transits/saturnFromMoon"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Career indications are genuinely two-sided. The strongest structural asset is Mercury's dual rulership of the 1st and 10th (Raja Yoga), reinforced by a dignified D10 with Jupiter in the 10th of Dashamsa and Venus in its lagna. However, Mercury is combust and displaced to the 4th, Ketu occupies the natal 10th under Rahu's aspect, and the current Moon–Mars–Saturn sequence runs through dusthana-linked and Saturn-heavy periods coinciding with sade-sati-zone transit. The doctrine supports an unconventional, service-oriented career with real capability but uneven visibility and current-period pressure; no single reading justifies a definitively supportive or challenging verdict."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-synthesis-03\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.6,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Lagna and 10th lord Mercury form a single-lordship Raja Yoga (Mercury rules both kendra 10 and trikona 1), a strong career indicator\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\",\"/placements/Mercury/lordInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury sits in the 4th house (angular, supportive for status through home base, education, property-linked or advisory work) rather than the 10th itself\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury is combust in the 4th alongside Sun (Budha-Aditya Yoga) — the yoga is present but the combustion weakens its expression per the chart's own note\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/combust\",\"/yogas/0\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu occupies the 10th house while Rahu aspects it from the 4th — a classic indication of unconventional career paths, detachment from status, and fluctuating public role\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Ketu/house\",\"/aspects/Rahu\"]},{\"claim\":\"Dashamsa shows Jupiter exalted-in-strength placement (Jupiter + Rahu in Aries in the 10th of D10) and Venus in the D10 lagna — dignified career significators suggesting eventual respect in profession\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/4\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/5\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current period is Moon–Mars–Saturn; Mars is a Vipareeta Raja Yoga graha (8th lord in 6th) placed in the 6th, indicating gains through service, competition, or difficult-work contexts during this sub-period\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current\",\"/yogas/2\",\"/placements/Mars/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Transiting Saturn sits on natal Moon in the 7th (sade sati zone per gochara reckoning, saturnFromMoon=1), a period traditionally associated with pressure on partnerships and public dealings that bear on career\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"tool:transits_at#/transits/Saturn/inNatalHouse\",\"/transits/saturnFromMoon\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Career indications are genuinely two-sided. The strongest structural asset is Mercury's dual rulership of the 1st and 10th (Raja Yoga), reinforced by a dignified D10 with Jupiter in the 10th of Dashamsa and Venus in its lagna. However, Mercury is combust and displaced to the 4th, Ketu occupies the natal 10th under Rahu's aspect, and the current Moon–Mars–Saturn sequence runs through dusthana-linked and Saturn-heavy periods coinciding with sade-sati-zone transit. The doctrine supports an unconventional, service-oriented career with real capability but uneven visibility and current-period pressure; no single reading justifies a definitively supportive or challenging verdict.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-knowledge-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-knowledge-01","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"rationale":"The VedAstro rule House1LordInHouse11 describes the ascendant lord in the 11th house as an indication of gains and good earning capacity. Option A matches this supportive reading. Option B overclaims by guaranteeing 'enormous profits,' which no rule states as certain. Option C contradicts the rule's meaning, since the 11th is a house of gains, not loss."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-knowledge-01\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"confidence\":0.9,\"rationale\":\"The VedAstro rule House1LordInHouse11 describes the ascendant lord in the 11th house as an indication of gains and good earning capacity. Option A matches this supportive reading. Option B overclaims by guaranteeing 'enormous profits,' which no rule states as certain. Option C contradicts the rule's meaning, since the 11th is a house of gains, not loss.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-synthesis-03","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-03","domain":"career","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.55,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Mercury rules both the lagna and the 10th (Gemini career house) and is placed in the 4th kendra with the Sun, forming a Raja Yoga by single lordship of a kendra and a trikona — a genuine career/status combination.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/1","/placements/Mercury/house","/houses/9/lord"]},{"claim":"Budha-Aditya Yoga in the 4th supports intellectual/administrative standing, but Mercury is combust, which weakens the delivery of the result.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/yogas/0","/placements/Mercury/combust"]},{"claim":"Ketu occupies the 10th house natally; Ketu in career can give technical or detached work but also instability or lack of public visibility.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Ketu/house"]},{"claim":"Jupiter exalted in Cancer sits in the 11th house of gains, supporting income and fulfilment of desires through networks.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Mars as 8th lord in the 6th forms Vipareeta Raja Yoga — gains arising through service, competition, or adversity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/2"]},{"claim":"D10 shows Jupiter and Rahu together in the 10th from the D10 lagna, indicating ambition and expansion in profession; Venus in the D10 lagna adds refinement to public role.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/4","/vargas/D10/placements/5"]},{"claim":"Current period is Moon mahadasha / Mars antardasha (2025-10-07 to 2026-05-08). Mars carries the Vipareeta yoga, but Moon as 11th lord placed in the 7th gives mixed-to-favorable professional outcomes; the running pratyantardasha lord Saturn aspects the natal 10th-related houses via its 3rd/7th/10th aspects from house 2.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current","/placements/Mars/house","/houses/10/significations"]},{"claim":"Transit Saturn in Pisces sits on the natal Moon (sade sati position, saturnFromMoon = 1), a classic pressure period on mind and workload that can slow recognition even when effort is high.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["tool:transits_at#/saturnFromMoon"]},{"claim":"Transit Jupiter retrograde in Gemini over natal Ketu in the 10th suggests fluctuating rather than steadily rising career momentum at present.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/transits/contacts/4"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Exact career field or nature of employment of the subject","Specific date/event the question refers to","Divisional strength confirmation beyond D10 (no D24/ashtakavarga provided)","Whether the subject is self-employed vs in service"],"rationale":"The natal chart shows real career promise: Mercury's single lordship of lagna and 10th forms a Raja yoga, exalted Jupiter in the 11th supports gains, and Mars's Vipareeta Raja Yoga rewards effort through service and adversity — echoed in D10 by Jupiter-Rahu in the 10th and Venus in the D10 lagna. However, combustion of Mercury, Ketu in the 10th, transit Saturn conjunct the natal Moon (sade sati bandh), and a retrograde Jupiter over natal Ketu in the 10th all temper near-term results. The current Moon–Mars period is neither clearly favorable nor adverse for career. The overall indication is mixed: strong underlying career architecture with present-period friction."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-synthesis-03\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.55,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Mercury rules both the lagna and the 10th (Gemini career house) and is placed in the 4th kendra with the Sun, forming a Raja Yoga by single lordship of a kendra and a trikona — a genuine career/status combination.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/houses/9/lord\"]},{\"claim\":\"Budha-Aditya Yoga in the 4th supports intellectual/administrative standing, but Mercury is combust, which weakens the delivery of the result.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0\",\"/placements/Mercury/combust\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu occupies the 10th house natally; Ketu in career can give technical or detached work but also instability or lack of public visibility.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Ketu/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter exalted in Cancer sits in the 11th house of gains, supporting income and fulfilment of desires through networks.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars as 8th lord in the 6th forms Vipareeta Raja Yoga — gains arising through service, competition, or adversity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 shows Jupiter and Rahu together in the 10th from the D10 lagna, indicating ambition and expansion in profession; Venus in the D10 lagna adds refinement to public role.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/4\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/5\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current period is Moon mahadasha / Mars antardasha (2025-10-07 to 2026-05-08). Mars carries the Vipareeta yoga, but Moon as 11th lord placed in the 7th gives mixed-to-favorable professional outcomes; the running pratyantardasha lord Saturn aspects the natal 10th-related houses via its 3rd/7th/10th aspects from house 2.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Transit Saturn in Pisces sits on the natal Moon (sade sati position, saturnFromMoon = 1), a classic pressure period on mind and workload that can slow recognition even when effort is high.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"tool:transits_at#/saturnFromMoon\"]},{\"claim\":\"Transit Jupiter retrograde in Gemini over natal Ketu in the 10th suggests fluctuating rather than steadily rising career momentum at present.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/transits/contacts/4\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"Exact career field or nature of employment of the subject\",\"Specific date/event the question refers to\",\"Divisional strength confirmation beyond D10 (no D24/ashtakavarga provided)\",\"Whether the subject is self-employed vs in service\"],\"rationale\":\"The natal chart shows real career promise: Mercury's single lordship of lagna and 10th forms a Raja yoga, exalted Jupiter in the 11th supports gains, and Mars's Vipareeta Raja Yoga rewards effort through service and adversity — echoed in D10 by Jupiter-Rahu in the 10th and Venus in the D10 lagna. However, combustion of Mercury, Ketu in the 10th, transit Saturn conjunct the natal Moon (sade sati bandh), and a retrograde Jupiter over natal Ketu in the 10th all temper near-term results. The current Moon–Mars period is neither clearly favorable nor adverse for career. The overall indication is mixed: strong underlying career architecture with present-period friction.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-synthesis-03","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-03","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.65,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Mercury, lagna lord and sole 10th-lord (kendra-trikona raja yoga), placed in the 4th with the Sun forms Budha-Aditya Yoga — a strong career signature, though Mercury's combustion weakens it","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/0","/yogas/1","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/combust"]},{"claim":"10th house occupied by Ketu and aspected by Rahu (via its trine aspect on house 10) introduces instability, detachment or unconventional direction in career","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/9/occupants","/aspects/Rahu"]},{"claim":"Jupiter exalted in Cancer in the 11th house of gains aspects the career-relevant houses 3, 5 and 7 — supports gains through counsel, teaching or advisory work","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/house","/aspects/Jupiter","/houses/10/significations"]},{"claim":"D10 shows Jupiter with Rahu in the 10th of the dashamsa (Aries), Venus in D10 lagna — career tied to Jupiterian/Rahu-flavored roles; Venus dignified in own-sign Cancer in D10 lagna is a supporting factor","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements"]},{"claim":"Current dasha: Moon mahadasha (Moon in 7th, lord of 11th) with Mars antardasha — Mars as 8th-lord in the 6th gives Vipareeta Raja Yoga, favorable for gains from service/competition, though Mars also aspects the 1st and 12th houses","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/dasha/current","/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Mars/house","/yogas/2"]},{"claim":"Transits as of 2026-01-01: Saturn conjunct natal Moon in Pisces (7th) marks start of sade sati (saturnFromMoon = 1); transiting Jupiter retrograde conjunct Ketu over natal 10th — a period of pressure and reassessment rather than smooth expansion","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/transits/saturnFromMoon","tool:transits_at#/transiting/Saturn/conjunctNatal"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Specific career field or question being asked (job change, promotion, business, etc.)","Exact date for which the career outcome is sought","Divisional chart beyond D10 (e.g., no D60) to confirm inner strength of Mercury despite combustion"],"rationale":"The core career architecture is strong: Mercury rules both the 1st and 10th and sits with the Sun forming Budha-Aditya Yoga, while exalted Jupiter in the 11th supports gains. These are offset by Ketu in the 10th with Rahu's aspect and Mercury's combustion, so results are real but come with detachment, unconventional turns, or diluted recognition. The running Moon–Mars period carries Vipareeta Raja Yoga support, but the onset of sade sati with transiting Saturn on the natal Moon suggests a phase requiring patience rather than a clear green light. Overall indication is supportive-with-caveats; without knowing the specific question and target date, a more precise verdict cannot be drawn."},"extracted":"{\n \"case_id\": \"career-synthesis-03\",\n \"domain\": \"career\",\n \"conclusion\": \"supportive\",\n \"confidence\": 0.65,\n \"selected_option_ids\": [],\n \"factors\": [\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Mercury, lagna lord and sole 10th-lord (kendra-trikona raja yoga), placed in the 4th with the Sun forms Budha-Aditya Yoga — a strong career signature, though Mercury's combustion weakens it\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/0\", \"/yogas/1\", \"/placements/Mercury/house\", \"/placements/Mercury/combust\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"10th house occupied by Ketu and aspected by Rahu (via its trine aspect on house 10) introduces instability, detachment or unconventional direction in career\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/houses/9/occupants\", \"/aspects/Rahu\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Jupiter exalted in Cancer in the 11th house of gains aspects the career-relevant houses 3, 5 and 7 — supports gains through counsel, teaching or advisory work\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\", \"/placements/Jupiter/house\", \"/aspects/Jupiter\", \"/houses/10/significations\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"D10 shows Jupiter with Rahu in the 10th of the dashamsa (Aries), Venus in D10 lagna — career tied to Jupiterian/Rahu-flavored roles; Venus dignified in own-sign Cancer in D10 lagna is a supporting factor\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/vargas/D10/placements\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Current dasha: Moon mahadasha (Moon in 7th, lord of 11th) with Mars antardasha — Mars as 8th-lord in the 6th gives Vipareeta Raja Yoga, favorable for gains from service/competition, though Mars also aspects the 1st and 12th houses\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/dasha/current\", \"/placements/Moon/house\", \"/placements/Mars/house\", \"/yogas/2\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Transits as of 2026-01-01: Saturn conjunct natal Moon in Pisces (7th) marks start of sade sati (saturnFromMoon = 1); transiting Jupiter retrograde conjunct Ketu over natal 10th — a period of pressure and reassessment rather than smooth expansion\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/transits/saturnFromMoon\", \"tool:transits_at#/transiting/Saturn/conjunctNatal\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"contradictions\": [],\n \"missing_information\": [\n  \"Specific career field or question being asked (job change, promotion, business, etc.)\",\n  \"Exact date for which the career outcome is sought\",\n  \"Divisional chart beyond D10 (e.g., no D60) to confirm inner strength of Mercury despite combustion\"\n ],\n \"rationale\": \"The core career architecture is strong: Mercury rules both the 1st and 10th and sits with the Sun forming Budha-Aditya Yoga, while exalted Jupiter in the 11th supports gains. These are offset by Ketu in the 10th with Rahu's aspect and Mercury's combustion, so results are real but come with detachment, unconventional turns, or diluted recognition. The running Moon–Mars period carries Vipareeta Raja Yoga support, but the onset of sade sati with transiting Saturn on the natal Moon suggests a phase requiring patience rather than a clear green light. Overall indication is supportive-with-caveats; without knowing the specific question and target date, a more precise verdict cannot be drawn.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-application-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-01","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Ascendant lord Sun is placed in the 11th house of gains, alongside Venus (10th lord) forming a Raja yoga for gains — supportive of earning capacity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house","/yogas/4"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"'Guarantees enormous profits' is an absolute overclaim; the placement supports gains but does not guarantee outcomes.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house"]},{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"11th is the house of gains (labha); the ascendant lord there is not primarily a financial-loss indication. Loss indications would involve the 12th or dusthana lords, e.g., 8th lord Jupiter in the 12th (a Vipareeta Raja Yoga).","evidence":["/reference/houseSignifications/11","/yogas/5"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Statement A is directly established: the Leo lagna's lord Sun sits in Gemini, the 11th whole-sign house (/lagna/lordInHouse, /placements/Sun/house), and joins 10th-lord Venus in a Raja yoga of gains (/yogas/4), supporting earning capacity without guaranteeing magnitude. Statements B and C misstate the doctrine; only A applies, so the polarity of applicable statements is supportive."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-01\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.9,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Ascendant lord Sun is placed in the 11th house of gains, alongside Venus (10th lord) forming a Raja yoga for gains — supportive of earning capacity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/yogas/4\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"'Guarantees enormous profits' is an absolute overclaim; the placement supports gains but does not guarantee outcomes.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"11th is the house of gains (labha); the ascendant lord there is not primarily a financial-loss indication. Loss indications would involve the 12th or dusthana lords, e.g., 8th lord Jupiter in the 12th (a Vipareeta Raja Yoga).\",\"evidence\":[\"/reference/houseSignifications/11\",\"/yogas/5\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Statement A is directly established: the Leo lagna's lord Sun sits in Gemini, the 11th whole-sign house (/lagna/lordInHouse, /placements/Sun/house), and joins 10th-lord Venus in a Raja yoga of gains (/yogas/4), supporting earning capacity without guaranteeing magnitude. Statements B and C misstate the doctrine; only A applies, so the polarity of applicable statements is supportive.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-application-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-01","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Ascendant lord (Sun) placed in the 11th house of gains supports earning capacity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house"]},{"claim":"Sun in 11th is further reinforced by a Raja yoga with Venus (10th lord) conjunct there.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/4"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The lagna lord Sun occupies the 11th house (/placements/Sun/house), matching statement A's rule — supportive of gains, not guaranteed or loss-indicating. Statement B is an overclaim ('guarantees enormous profits' is never a valid reading), and statement C contradicts standard doctrine and the chart's gains-oriented 11th placement. Only A is established."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-01\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.9,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Ascendant lord (Sun) placed in the 11th house of gains supports earning capacity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Sun in 11th is further reinforced by a Raja yoga with Venus (10th lord) conjunct there.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/4\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The lagna lord Sun occupies the 11th house (/placements/Sun/house), matching statement A's rule — supportive of gains, not guaranteed or loss-indicating. Statement B is an overclaim ('guarantees enormous profits' is never a valid reading), and statement C contradicts standard doctrine and the chart's gains-oriented 11th placement. Only A is established.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-application-02","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-02","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The second lord Venus is placed in the first house, matching the configuration described in statement A.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"Statement A's reading (wealth via personal effort, intelligence, or learning) is a standard supportive interpretation of the 2nd lord in the 1st.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"No classical rule guarantees wealth from this placement alone; strength of Venus, aspects, and other factors matter.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The 2nd lord in the 1st is not primarily an inability-to-earn indication; it is generally read as supportive of self-earned wealth.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart shows the 2nd lord (Venus) in the 1st house (/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse = 1), which establishes statement A as applicable. Statement B overclaims by asserting a guarantee, and statement C contradicts standard doctrine, so only A is selected and the conclusion is supportive."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-02\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.9,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The second lord Venus is placed in the first house, matching the configuration described in statement A.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"Statement A's reading (wealth via personal effort, intelligence, or learning) is a standard supportive interpretation of the 2nd lord in the 1st.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"No classical rule guarantees wealth from this placement alone; strength of Venus, aspects, and other factors matter.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The 2nd lord in the 1st is not primarily an inability-to-earn indication; it is generally read as supportive of self-earned wealth.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart shows the 2nd lord (Venus) in the 1st house (/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse = 1), which establishes statement A as applicable. Statement B overclaims by asserting a guarantee, and statement C contradicts standard doctrine, so only A is selected and the conclusion is supportive.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-application-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-01","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.95,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The ascendant lord (Sun, lord of Leo lagna) occupies the 11th house of gains and income.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/sign","/placements/Sun/house"]},{"claim":"The 11th house also holds Venus (10th lord) with Sun, forming a raja yoga conjunction relevant to earning capacity — further supporting gains.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/yogas/4"]},{"claim":"Ketu also sits in the 11th, adding some mixed quality to the gains house, but this does not negate the supportive placement of the lagna lord there.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Ketu/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"No rule guarantees 'enormous profits'; the lagna lord in the 11th is a favorable indication for gains but does not guarantee magnitude of wealth. Also Ketu's presence in the 11th tempers an unqualified claim (/placements/Ketu/house).","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Ketu/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The 11th is a house of gains (labha), not loss; loss is signified by the 12th. The chart shows Sun in house 11 (/placements/Sun/house), so C is not established.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/reference/houseSignifications/11","/reference/houseSignifications/12"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Statement A is directly established: the chart's lagna is Leo ruled by the Sun (/lagna/sign), and the Sun is placed in the 11th house of gains (/placements/Sun/house), which classical doctrine treats as supportive of income and fulfilment of desires. Statement B overstates the guarantee of profit, and statement C inverts the significations of the 11th and 12th houses; neither is applicable. The only applicable listed statement is A, whose polarity is supportive."},"extracted":"{\n  \"case_id\": \"wealth-application-01\",\n  \"domain\": \"wealth\",\n  \"conclusion\": \"supportive\",\n  \"confidence\": 0.95,\n  \"selected_option_ids\": [\"A\"],\n  \"factors\": [\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"The ascendant lord (Sun, lord of Leo lagna) occupies the 11th house of gains and income.\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/lagna/sign\", \"/placements/Sun/house\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"The 11th house also holds Venus (10th lord) with Sun, forming a raja yoga conjunction relevant to earning capacity — further supporting gains.\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\", \"/yogas/4\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Ketu also sits in the 11th, adding some mixed quality to the gains house, but this does not negate the supportive placement of the lagna lord there.\",\n      \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Ketu/house\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"contradictions\": [\n    {\n      \"statement_id\": \"B\",\n      \"error_type\": \"overclaim\",\n      \"correction\": \"No rule guarantees 'enormous profits'; the lagna lord in the 11th is a favorable indication for gains but does not guarantee magnitude of wealth. Also Ketu's presence in the 11th tempers an unqualified claim (/placements/Ketu/house).\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Sun/house\", \"/placements/Ketu/house\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"statement_id\": \"C\",\n      \"error_type\": \"doctrinal\",\n      \"correction\": \"The 11th is a house of gains (labha), not loss; loss is signified by the 12th. The chart shows Sun in house 11 (/placements/Sun/house), so C is not established.\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Sun/house\", \"/reference/houseSignifications/11\", \"/reference/houseSignifications/12\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"missing_information\": [],\n  \"rationale\": \"Statement A is directly established: the chart's lagna is Leo ruled by the Sun (/lagna/sign), and the Sun is placed in the 11th house of gains (/placements/Sun/house), which classical doctrine treats as supportive of income and fulfilment of desires. Statement B overstates the guarantee of profit, and statement C inverts the significations of the 11th and 12th houses; neither is applicable. The only applicable listed statement is A, whose polarity is supportive.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-application-02","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-02","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The second house lord (Venus) is placed in the first house, matching the classical rule that the second lord in the first supports wealth earned through personal effort, intelligence, or learning.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"A placement indicates supportive potential for self-earned wealth; it does not guarantee wealth, as full chart strength, aspects, and dashas must be considered.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Second lord in the first is classically read as a dhana-favorable placement tied to self-effort, not as an inability-to-earn indication.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Chart facts show the second lord is Venus and it is placed in the first house (/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse = 1). This directly establishes statement A as applicable. Statement B overclaims by asserting a guarantee, which no single placement establishes. Statement C contradicts the classical reading of this placement. Therefore only A is selected and the conclusion polarity is supportive."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-02\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.85,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The second house lord (Venus) is placed in the first house, matching the classical rule that the second lord in the first supports wealth earned through personal effort, intelligence, or learning.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"A placement indicates supportive potential for self-earned wealth; it does not guarantee wealth, as full chart strength, aspects, and dashas must be considered.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Second lord in the first is classically read as a dhana-favorable placement tied to self-effort, not as an inability-to-earn indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Chart facts show the second lord is Venus and it is placed in the first house (/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse = 1). This directly establishes statement A as applicable. Statement B overclaims by asserting a guarantee, which no single placement establishes. Statement C contradicts the classical reading of this placement. Therefore only A is selected and the conclusion polarity is supportive.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-application-03","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-03","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Mars occupies the 2nd house (Pisces), a wealth/accumulation house","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/houses/1/occupants"]},{"claim":"2nd lord Jupiter is placed in the 8th, so accumulation is not unqualified — Mars here supports earning power but not guaranteed wealth","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Jupiter aspects the 2nd house, adding a benefic influence on wealth matters","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/aspects/Jupiter"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"No single placement guarantees wealth; Mars in the 2nd is at most supportive of earning capacity.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Mars in the 2nd is classically read as energetic earning and accumulation drive (Kubera-related readings aside), not necessarily an inability to accumulate.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Statement A is the balanced classical reading: Mars in /placements/Mars/house=2 supports earning drive and accumulation without guaranteeing wealth or implying inability. B is an overclaim and C contradicts standard doctrine, especially given the mixed signal from 2nd lord Jupiter in the 8th (/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse). Conclusion polarity follows statement A: supportive."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-03\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.85,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Mars occupies the 2nd house (Pisces), a wealth/accumulation house\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/houses/1/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"2nd lord Jupiter is placed in the 8th, so accumulation is not unqualified — Mars here supports earning power but not guaranteed wealth\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter aspects the 2nd house, adding a benefic influence on wealth matters\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Jupiter\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"No single placement guarantees wealth; Mars in the 2nd is at most supportive of earning capacity.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Mars in the 2nd is classically read as energetic earning and accumulation drive (Kubera-related readings aside), not necessarily an inability to accumulate.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Statement A is the balanced classical reading: Mars in /placements/Mars/house=2 supports earning drive and accumulation without guaranteeing wealth or implying inability. B is an overclaim and C contradicts standard doctrine, especially given the mixed signal from 2nd lord Jupiter in the 8th (/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse). Conclusion polarity follows statement A: supportive.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-application-03","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-03","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Mars occupies the 2nd house of wealth and accumulation","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/houses/2/occupants"]},{"claim":"Mars is in Pisces, a friend's sign, with the 2nd lord Jupiter aspecting its own house from the 8th","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Mars/sign","/placements/Mars/dignity","/houses/2/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Mars is a functional malefic for Aquarius lagna, so its presence in the 2nd supports earning capacity without guaranteeing wealth","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/lagna/lord"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"No placement 'guarantees' wealth; Mars in the 2nd at most supports earning power, and Mars here sits in a friend's sign as a natural malefic.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Nothing in the chart establishes a necessary inability to accumulate; Mars in the 2nd is conventionally read as supportive of accumulation, especially with Jupiter's aspect on the 2nd house.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/houses/2/aspectedBy"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"omission","correction":"Statement A is applicable, so D does not hold.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Statement A correctly reflects the chart: Mars occupies the 2nd house (/placements/Mars/house) of wealth, in a friendly sign, supporting earning and accumulation without any guarantee or necessity of poverty. Statements B and C are overclaims in both directions and are rejected; D fails because A applies."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-03\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.85,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Mars occupies the 2nd house of wealth and accumulation\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/houses/2/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars is in Pisces, a friend's sign, with the 2nd lord Jupiter aspecting its own house from the 8th\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/sign\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/houses/2/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars is a functional malefic for Aquarius lagna, so its presence in the 2nd supports earning capacity without guaranteeing wealth\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"No placement 'guarantees' wealth; Mars in the 2nd at most supports earning power, and Mars here sits in a friend's sign as a natural malefic.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Nothing in the chart establishes a necessary inability to accumulate; Mars in the 2nd is conventionally read as supportive of accumulation, especially with Jupiter's aspect on the 2nd house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/houses/2/aspectedBy\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"omission\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is applicable, so D does not hold.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Statement A correctly reflects the chart: Mars occupies the 2nd house (/placements/Mars/house) of wealth, in a friendly sign, supporting earning and accumulation without any guarantee or necessity of poverty. Statements B and C are overclaims in both directions and are rejected; D fails because A applies.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-application-03","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-03","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Mars occupies the second house (Pisces) in friendly dignity, supporting earning power and accumulation per classical doctrine, without implying guaranteed wealth or inability to accumulate.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/sign","/placements/Mars/dignity"]},{"claim":"The second lord Jupiter is placed in the eighth, a dusthana, which tempers accumulation and confirms Mars in the 2nd does not guarantee wealth.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"The second house is aspected by Jupiter (a benefic) and Rahu, adding mixed influence on wealth matters.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/2/aspectedBy"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Mars in the second supports earning capacity but does not guarantee wealth; here the 2nd lord sits in the 8th (/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse), so accumulation is not assured.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Classical doctrine treats Mars in the second as supportive of earnings, not as necessarily indicating inability to accumulate.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Statement A correctly states the classical treatment of Mars in the second house — supportive of earning/accumulation without guaranteeing wealth. The chart confirms applicability: /placements/Mars/house = 2 with friend's-sign dignity. B is an overclaim (the 2nd lord Jupiter is in the 8th, a dusthana), and C contradicts doctrine. Only A applies, so conclusion is supportive."},"extracted":"{\n \"case_id\": \"wealth-application-03\",\n \"domain\": \"wealth\",\n \"conclusion\": \"supportive\",\n \"confidence\": 0.85,\n \"selected_option_ids\": [\"A\"],\n \"factors\": [\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Mars occupies the second house (Pisces) in friendly dignity, supporting earning power and accumulation per classical doctrine, without implying guaranteed wealth or inability to accumulate.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mars/house\", \"/placements/Mars/sign\", \"/placements/Mars/dignity\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"The second lord Jupiter is placed in the eighth, a dusthana, which tempers accumulation and confirms Mars in the 2nd does not guarantee wealth.\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"The second house is aspected by Jupiter (a benefic) and Rahu, adding mixed influence on wealth matters.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/houses/2/aspectedBy\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"contradictions\": [\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"B\",\n   \"error_type\": \"overclaim\",\n   \"correction\": \"Mars in the second supports earning capacity but does not guarantee wealth; here the 2nd lord sits in the 8th (/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse), so accumulation is not assured.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mars/house\", \"/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"C\",\n   \"error_type\": \"doctrinal\",\n   \"correction\": \"Classical doctrine treats Mars in the second as supportive of earnings, not as necessarily indicating inability to accumulate.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mars/house\", \"/placements/Mars/dignity\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"missing_information\": [],\n \"rationale\": \"Statement A correctly states the classical treatment of Mars in the second house — supportive of earning/accumulation without guaranteeing wealth. The chart confirms applicability: /placements/Mars/house = 2 with friend's-sign dignity. B is an overclaim (the 2nd lord Jupiter is in the 8th, a dusthana), and C contradicts doctrine. Only A applies, so conclusion is supportive.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-application-02","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-02","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The second lord (Venus) is placed in the first house, matching the classical indication of wealth through personal effort, intelligence, or learning.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"A placement indicates supportive potential, not a guarantee of wealth; other factors (strength, aspects, dashas) must be weighed.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Second lord in the lagna is classically read as a dhana-supportive placement, not an inability-to-earn indication.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"missing_information":["Venus strength/dignity","aspects on Venus and the second house","current dasha"],"rationale":"Chart facts show the 2nd lord Venus in the 1st house (/houses/1/lord, /houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse), which supports statement A's reading of self-earned wealth. Statement B is an overclaim (no guarantee) and statement C contradicts the doctrine, so only A is selected and the conclusion is supportive."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-02\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.85,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The second lord (Venus) is placed in the first house, matching the classical indication of wealth through personal effort, intelligence, or learning.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"A placement indicates supportive potential, not a guarantee of wealth; other factors (strength, aspects, dashas) must be weighed.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Second lord in the lagna is classically read as a dhana-supportive placement, not an inability-to-earn indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"Venus strength/dignity\",\"aspects on Venus and the second house\",\"current dasha\"],\"rationale\":\"Chart facts show the 2nd lord Venus in the 1st house (/houses/1/lord, /houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse), which supports statement A's reading of self-earned wealth. Statement B is an overclaim (no guarantee) and statement C contradicts the doctrine, so only A is selected and the conclusion is supportive.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-application-04","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-04","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.8,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the 2nd house in Scorpio — outside its own signs Libra/Capricorn/Aquarius — supporting the stated rule of heavy effort for limited gain","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/sign","/placements/Saturn/dignity"]},{"claim":"Saturn is retrograde and in enemy sign in the 2nd, further weakening its capacity to deliver easy wealth","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/retrograde","/placements/Saturn/dignity"]},{"claim":"The 2nd house is crowded (Moon, Saturn, Rahu), adding pressure on wealth significations","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/1/occupants"]},{"claim":"Saturn also rules 4 and 5 and forms raja yogas (e.g., with Venus and Moon), so its 2nd-house presence does not imply unqualified poverty — only that rule B's 'always' framing fails","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Full dasha context for Saturn periods would be needed to time when this 2nd-house challenge manifests"],"rationale":"Statement A matches the chart exactly: /placements/Saturn/house = 2 and /placements/Saturn/sign = Scorpio, which is neither Libra, Capricorn, nor Aquarius; dignity is 'Enemy' (/placements/Saturn/dignity). Statements B and C use absolute language ('always', 'guarantees') not established by the stated rule or the chart — Saturn here is a yoga-forming lord of 4 and 5 (/yogas), so blanket struggle or poverty claims are doctrinally unsound. Only A applies, so conclusion polarity follows it: challenging."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-04\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"challenging\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies the 2nd house in Scorpio — outside its own signs Libra/Capricorn/Aquarius — supporting the stated rule of heavy effort for limited gain\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/sign\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn is retrograde and in enemy sign in the 2nd, further weakening its capacity to deliver easy wealth\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/retrograde\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 2nd house is crowded (Moon, Saturn, Rahu), adding pressure on wealth significations\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn also rules 4 and 5 and forms raja yogas (e.g., with Venus and Moon), so its 2nd-house presence does not imply unqualified poverty — only that rule B's 'always' framing fails\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"Full dasha context for Saturn periods would be needed to time when this 2nd-house challenge manifests\"],\"rationale\":\"Statement A matches the chart exactly: /placements/Saturn/house = 2 and /placements/Saturn/sign = Scorpio, which is neither Libra, Capricorn, nor Aquarius; dignity is 'Enemy' (/placements/Saturn/dignity). Statements B and C use absolute language ('always', 'guarantees') not established by the stated rule or the chart — Saturn here is a yoga-forming lord of 4 and 5 (/yogas), so blanket struggle or poverty claims are doctrinally unsound. Only A applies, so conclusion polarity follows it: challenging.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-application-04","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-04","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the 2nd house in Scorpio, in enemy sign, supporting the classical reading of hard work with constrained accumulation.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/sign","/placements/Saturn/dignity"]},{"claim":"The 2nd house also holds debilitated Moon and Rahu, compounding pressure on wealth significations.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Rahu/house"]},{"claim":"However, Saturn forms raja yogas (lord of 4 and 5; conjunct 10th lord Moon), so gains through effort are not absent.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/yogas/6","/yogas/8"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Sign and dignity condition the result; Saturn here is in an enemy sign, not universally struggling by rule alone.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/dignity"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"No rule guarantees poverty; the chart shows multiple raja yogas involving Saturn.","evidence":["/yogas/4","/yogas/8"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Statement A matches the chart: natal Saturn is in the 2nd house (/placements/Saturn/house) in Scorpio (/placements/Saturn/sign), i.e., outside its own signs Libra/Capricorn/Aquarius, and with enemy-sign dignity (/placements/Saturn/dignity) — the classic 'heavy effort for limited gain' indication for wealth. Statements B and C overstate the rule ('always', 'guarantees') and are contradicted by Saturn's yogic role (yogas listing Saturn as a raja yoga partner). Applicable statements are challenging in polarity, so conclusion is challenging."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-04\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"challenging\",\"confidence\":0.85,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies the 2nd house in Scorpio, in enemy sign, supporting the classical reading of hard work with constrained accumulation.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/sign\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 2nd house also holds debilitated Moon and Rahu, compounding pressure on wealth significations.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"However, Saturn forms raja yogas (lord of 4 and 5; conjunct 10th lord Moon), so gains through effort are not absent.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/6\",\"/yogas/8\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Sign and dignity condition the result; Saturn here is in an enemy sign, not universally struggling by rule alone.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"No rule guarantees poverty; the chart shows multiple raja yogas involving Saturn.\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/4\",\"/yogas/8\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Statement A matches the chart: natal Saturn is in the 2nd house (/placements/Saturn/house) in Scorpio (/placements/Saturn/sign), i.e., outside its own signs Libra/Capricorn/Aquarius, and with enemy-sign dignity (/placements/Saturn/dignity) — the classic 'heavy effort for limited gain' indication for wealth. Statements B and C overstate the rule ('always', 'guarantees') and are contradicted by Saturn's yogic role (yogas listing Saturn as a raja yoga partner). Applicable statements are challenging in polarity, so conclusion is challenging.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-application-04","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-04","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the second house in Scorpio (not Libra, Capricorn, or Aquarius), so the rule in statement A applies: a challenge involving heavy effort for limited gain.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/sign","/placements/Saturn/dignity"]},{"claim":"Saturn is retrograde and in an enemy sign in the 2nd, further coloring the wealth-house placement as strained rather than easy gain.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/retrograde","/placements/Saturn/dignity"]},{"claim":"The 2nd house also holds a debilitated Moon (10th lord) and Rahu, adding pressure on accumulated resources; however the Moon–Saturn conjunction forms a stated raja yoga, so struggle-with-gain rather than outright lack fits the chart.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/1/occupants","/yogas/8"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"'Always causes financial struggle regardless of sign' overreaches: classical treatment conditions Saturn-in-2nd results on sign, dignity, aspects, and yogas. Here Saturn's own-sign/kendra lordsips even form raja yogas (e.g., with Venus), so an unconditional negative reading is not established.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/yogas/2","/yogas/5"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"No classical rule states Saturn in the 2nd guarantees poverty; this contradicts the chart itself, which contains multiple raja yogas touching wealth significations.","evidence":["/yogas/8","/yogas/9"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Statement A is the only option whose stated condition is satisfied by the chart: Saturn sits in house 2 (/placements/Saturn/house) in Scorpio (/placements/Saturn/sign), which is none of Libra, Capricorn, or Aquarius — its own signs where the result would soften. Its 'Enemy' dignity (/placements/Saturn/dignity) reinforces the heavy-effort reading. Statements B and C are unconditional absolutes ('always', 'guarantees') that no standard doctrine supports and that the chart's raja yogas contradict. Since the only applicable listed statement carries challenging polarity for wealth, conclusion is 'challenging'."},"extracted":"{\n  \"case_id\": \"wealth-application-04\",\n  \"domain\": \"wealth\",\n  \"conclusion\": \"challenging\",\n  \"confidence\": 0.85,\n  \"selected_option_ids\": [\"A\"],\n  \"factors\": [\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Saturn occupies the second house in Scorpio (not Libra, Capricorn, or Aquarius), so the rule in statement A applies: a challenge involving heavy effort for limited gain.\",\n      \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Saturn/house\", \"/placements/Saturn/sign\", \"/placements/Saturn/dignity\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Saturn is retrograde and in an enemy sign in the 2nd, further coloring the wealth-house placement as strained rather than easy gain.\",\n      \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Saturn/retrograde\", \"/placements/Saturn/dignity\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"The 2nd house also holds a debilitated Moon (10th lord) and Rahu, adding pressure on accumulated resources; however the Moon–Saturn conjunction forms a stated raja yoga, so struggle-with-gain rather than outright lack fits the chart.\",\n      \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/houses/1/occupants\", \"/yogas/8\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"contradictions\": [\n    {\n      \"statement_id\": \"B\",\n      \"error_type\": \"overclaim\",\n      \"correction\": \"'Always causes financial struggle regardless of sign' overreaches: classical treatment conditions Saturn-in-2nd results on sign, dignity, aspects, and yogas. Here Saturn's own-sign/kendra lordsips even form raja yogas (e.g., with Venus), so an unconditional negative reading is not established.\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Saturn/house\", \"/yogas/2\", \"/yogas/5\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"statement_id\": \"C\",\n      \"error_type\": \"overclaim\",\n      \"correction\": \"No classical rule states Saturn in the 2nd guarantees poverty; this contradicts the chart itself, which contains multiple raja yogas touching wealth significations.\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/8\", \"/yogas/9\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"missing_information\": [],\n  \"rationale\": \"Statement A is the only option whose stated condition is satisfied by the chart: Saturn sits in house 2 (/placements/Saturn/house) in Scorpio (/placements/Saturn/sign), which is none of Libra, Capricorn, or Aquarius — its own signs where the result would soften. Its 'Enemy' dignity (/placements/Saturn/dignity) reinforces the heavy-effort reading. Statements B and C are unconditional absolutes ('always', 'guarantees') that no standard doctrine supports and that the chart's raja yogas contradict. Since the only applicable listed statement carries challenging polarity for wealth, conclusion is 'challenging'.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-contradiction-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":false,"error":"JSON Parse error: Expected '}'","extracted":"{\n \"case_id\": \"wealth-contradiction-01\",\n \"domain\": \"wealth\",\n \"conclusion\": \"mixed\",\n \"confidence\": 0.9,\n \"selected_option_ids\": [],\n \"factors\": [\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"S1 is doctrinally sound: Ketu in the 2nd (Taurus) is a malefic in the house of wealth/family and is reasonably read as a challenging financial indication involving loss or deception risk.\",\n   \"effect\": \"neutral\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Ketu/house\", \"/placements/Ketu/dignity\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"S2 is an error: no single placement 'guarantees' fraud; this is an overclaim beyond what Jyotish doctrine supports. Ketu debilitated in the 2nd suggests vulnerability/risk, not certainty of fraud — especially given offsetting wealth yogas like the Dhana Yoga (Saturn–Sun) and Gaja Kesari.\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/5\", \"/yogas/0\", \"/placements/Ketu/dignity\", \"/placements/Ketu/house\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"S3 is an error: Ketu occupies the 2nd house (Taurus), not the 3rd. The 3rd is empty with lord Mercury placed in the 8th; only Venus aspects the 3rd.\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Ketu/house\", \"/placements/Ketu/sign\", \"/houses/2/occupants\", \"/houses/3/occupants\", \"/houses/3/aspectedBy\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"contradictions\": [\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"S2\",\n   \"error_type\": \"overclaim\",\n   \"correction\": \"Ketu debilitated in the 2nd indicates a challenging financial indication — potential for loss, deception, or liability — but it does not guarantee fraud. Astrological placements indicate tendencies, not certainties, and here they are counterbalanced by Dhana and Raja yogas (Saturn–Sun conjunction as lords of 11/10 and 5).\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Ketu/house\", \"/placements/Ketu/dignity\", \"/yogas/5\", \"/yogas/4\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"S3\",\n   \"error_type\": \"factual\",\n   \"correction\": \"Ketu is in the 2nd house in Taurus (Mrigashira pada 1), not the 3rd house; the 3rd house (Gemini) has no occupants.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Ketu/house\", \"/placements/Ketu/sign\", \"/houses/2/occupants\", \"/houses/3/occupants\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"missing_information\": [],\n \"rationale\": \"S1 correctly states the standard reading of Ketu in the 2nd as a challenging financial indication. S2 overstates this into a guaranteed outcome, which no placement supports — particularly in a chart carrying multiple wealth yogas (Dhana Yoga via Saturn–Sun, Gaja Kesari, Adhi Yoga). S3 misplaces Ketu: chart facts show Ketu at Taurus 24°32'27\" in house 2, while house 3 is unoccupied.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-contradiction-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-contradiction-01","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Ketu in the 2nd (house of wealth/family) is a classical affliction to finances, indicating possible losses or deception-prone matters","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Ketu/house","/houses/1/significations"]},{"claim":"The affliction is moderated: 2nd lord Venus is well placed in the 9th and aspected by Jupiter, and the chart also carries Dhana Yoga (Saturn-11L with Sun-5L)","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/aspects/Venus","/yogas"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"No graha placement guarantees an outcome like fraud. Ketu in the 2nd is at most a risk indication for financial loss or deception-related matters; it does not guarantee fraud will occur. The 2nd lord Venus in the 9th aspected by Jupiter (/aspects/Jupiter includes 9) and the Dhana Yoga of Sun+Saturn (/yogas) offset the affliction.","evidence":["/placements/Ketu/house","/placements/Venus/house","/yogas"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Ketu occupies house 2 (Taurus), not house 3. It is the lord of the 3rd, Mercury, who sits in the 8th (/placements/Mercury/house). Ketu's aspects fall on houses 6, 8 and 10, not its occupancy.","evidence":["/placements/Ketu/house","/placements/Ketu/sign","/placements/Mercury/house","/aspects/Ketu"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is a fair doctrinal statement consistent with the chart: Ketu (debilitated per /placements/Ketu/dignity) sits in the 2nd house of wealth. S2 overstates this into a deterministic guarantee of fraud, which no single placement supports and which the chart's mitigating factors (Venus in 9th, Jupiter aspect on 9, Dhana and Adhi Yogas) contradict. S3 misstates Ketu's house — it is in the 2nd, not the 3rd."},"extracted":"{\n  \"case_id\": \"wealth-contradiction-01\",\n  \"domain\": \"wealth\",\n  \"conclusion\": \"mixed\",\n  \"confidence\": 0.9,\n  \"selected_option_ids\": [],\n  \"factors\": [\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Ketu in the 2nd (house of wealth/family) is a classical affliction to finances, indicating possible losses or deception-prone matters\",\n      \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Ketu/house\", \"/houses/1/significations\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"The affliction is moderated: 2nd lord Venus is well placed in the 9th and aspected by Jupiter, and the chart also carries Dhana Yoga (Saturn-11L with Sun-5L)\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Venus/house\", \"/aspects/Venus\", \"/yogas\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"contradictions\": [\n    {\n      \"statement_id\": \"S2\",\n      \"error_type\": \"overclaim\",\n      \"correction\": \"No graha placement guarantees an outcome like fraud. Ketu in the 2nd is at most a risk indication for financial loss or deception-related matters; it does not guarantee fraud will occur. The 2nd lord Venus in the 9th aspected by Jupiter (/aspects/Jupiter includes 9) and the Dhana Yoga of Sun+Saturn (/yogas) offset the affliction.\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Ketu/house\", \"/placements/Venus/house\", \"/yogas\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"statement_id\": \"S3\",\n      \"error_type\": \"factual\",\n      \"correction\": \"Ketu occupies house 2 (Taurus), not house 3. It is the lord of the 3rd, Mercury, who sits in the 8th (/placements/Mercury/house). Ketu's aspects fall on houses 6, 8 and 10, not its occupancy.\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Ketu/house\", \"/placements/Ketu/sign\", \"/placements/Mercury/house\", \"/aspects/Ketu\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"missing_information\": [],\n  \"rationale\": \"S1 is a fair doctrinal statement consistent with the chart: Ketu (debilitated per /placements/Ketu/dignity) sits in the 2nd house of wealth. S2 overstates this into a deterministic guarantee of fraud, which no single placement supports and which the chart's mitigating factors (Venus in 9th, Jupiter aspect on 9, Dhana and Adhi Yogas) contradict. S3 misstates Ketu's house — it is in the 2nd, not the 3rd.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-contradiction-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-contradiction-01","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.95,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Ketu in the 2nd is at most a challenging/afflictive indication (loss, deception, liability as tendencies), never a guarantee of fraud. Astrology indicates propensities with proportionate uncertainty, not certainties. Evidence: Ketu is debilitated and a malefic placed in house 2 (wealth/family/speech) — /placements/Ketu/house, /placements/Ketu/dignity.","evidence":["/placements/Ketu/house","/placements/Ketu/dignity"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Ketu occupies house 2 (Taurus, conjunct the exalted Moon), not house 3. House 3 (Gemini) has no occupants; it is only aspected by Venus. Evidence: /placements/Ketu/house = 2, /houses/2/occupants includes Ketu, /houses/3/occupants is empty.","evidence":["/placements/Ketu/house","/houses/2/occupants","/houses/3/occupants"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is doctrinally acceptable: Ketu (/placements/Ketu) sits in house 2, the house of wealth, family and speech (/houses/2/significations), debilitated in Taurus (/placements/Ketu/dignity), so treating it as a challenging financial indication involving possible loss or deception is proportionate. S2 overclaims certainty ('guarantees fraud'), which no chart placement supports. S3 misstates Ketu's house; chart facts place it in house 2, not 3."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-contradiction-01\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.95,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Ketu in the 2nd is at most a challenging/afflictive indication (loss, deception, liability as tendencies), never a guarantee of fraud. Astrology indicates propensities with proportionate uncertainty, not certainties. Evidence: Ketu is debilitated and a malefic placed in house 2 (wealth/family/speech) — /placements/Ketu/house, /placements/Ketu/dignity.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Ketu/house\",\"/placements/Ketu/dignity\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Ketu occupies house 2 (Taurus, conjunct the exalted Moon), not house 3. House 3 (Gemini) has no occupants; it is only aspected by Venus. Evidence: /placements/Ketu/house = 2, /houses/2/occupants includes Ketu, /houses/3/occupants is empty.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Ketu/house\",\"/houses/2/occupants\",\"/houses/3/occupants\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S1 is doctrinally acceptable: Ketu (/placements/Ketu) sits in house 2, the house of wealth, family and speech (/houses/2/significations), debilitated in Taurus (/placements/Ketu/dignity), so treating it as a challenging financial indication involving possible loss or deception is proportionate. S2 overclaims certainty ('guarantees fraud'), which no chart placement supports. S3 misstates Ketu's house; chart facts place it in house 2, not 3.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-contradiction-02","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-contradiction-02","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.95,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Jupiter is exalted and retrograde in house 11 (Cancer), the house of gains — a classically supportive placement for income and accumulation, though it receives Saturn's 11th-house aspect.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/sign","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/houses/11/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Jupiter does not 'guarantee' wealth: it is retrograde, aspected by exalted Saturn from the 2nd house, and 2nd-lord Venus sits in the 3rd rather than a strong wealth house.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/aspects/Saturn","/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"claim":"Jupiter actually occupies house 11, not house 12.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"No single graha placement guarantees riches. Jupiter's exaltation in the 11th strongly favors gains, but its retrograde motion and Saturn's aspect on the 11th temper and delay results; wealth indications must be read alongside the 2nd and 11th lords (Venus in the 3rd, Moon in the 7th).","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/houses/11/aspectedBy","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Jupiter occupies house 11 (Cancer, exalted), not house 12. The 12th house (Leo) is unoccupied.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/houses/12/occupants"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is accurate and consistent with /placements/Jupiter (exalted in Cancer, house 11) and /yogas context of gains. S2 overstates by converting a supportive indication into a guarantee, ignoring the retrogression flag at /placements/Jupiter/retrograde and Saturn's aspect recorded at /houses/11/aspectedBy. S3 contradicts the chart facts directly: /placements/Jupiter/house = 11, while /houses/12/occupants is empty."},"extracted":"{\n  \"case_id\": \"wealth-contradiction-02\",\n  \"domain\": \"wealth\",\n  \"conclusion\": \"mixed\",\n  \"confidence\": 0.95,\n  \"selected_option_ids\": [],\n  \"factors\": [\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Jupiter is exalted and retrograde in house 11 (Cancer), the house of gains — a classically supportive placement for income and accumulation, though it receives Saturn's 11th-house aspect.\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Jupiter/house\", \"/placements/Jupiter/sign\", \"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\", \"/houses/11/aspectedBy\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Jupiter does not 'guarantee' wealth: it is retrograde, aspected by exalted Saturn from the 2nd house, and 2nd-lord Venus sits in the 3rd rather than a strong wealth house.\",\n      \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\", \"/aspects/Saturn\", \"/placements/Venus/house\", \"/placements/Saturn/house\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Jupiter actually occupies house 11, not house 12.\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"contradictions\": [\n    {\n      \"statement_id\": \"S2\",\n      \"error_type\": \"overclaim\",\n      \"correction\": \"No single graha placement guarantees riches. Jupiter's exaltation in the 11th strongly favors gains, but its retrograde motion and Saturn's aspect on the 11th temper and delay results; wealth indications must be read alongside the 2nd and 11th lords (Venus in the 3rd, Moon in the 7th).\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\", \"/houses/11/aspectedBy\", \"/placements/Venus/house\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"statement_id\": \"S3\",\n      \"error_type\": \"factual\",\n      \"correction\": \"Jupiter occupies house 11 (Cancer, exalted), not house 12. The 12th house (Leo) is unoccupied.\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Jupiter/house\", \"/houses/12/occupants\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"missing_information\": [],\n  \"rationale\": \"S1 is accurate and consistent with /placements/Jupiter (exalted in Cancer, house 11) and /yogas context of gains. S2 overstates by converting a supportive indication into a guarantee, ignoring the retrogression flag at /placements/Jupiter/retrograde and Saturn's aspect recorded at /houses/11/aspectedBy. S3 contradicts the chart facts directly: /placements/Jupiter/house = 11, while /houses/12/occupants is empty.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-contradiction-02","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-contradiction-02","confidence":0,"selected_option_ids":[],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Jupiter in the 11th supports gains but guarantees nothing. In this chart Jupiter is retrograde (/placements/Jupiter/retrograde) and aspected by Saturn (/houses/10/aspectedBy includes Saturn via its 4th... specifically Saturn aspects house 11 per /aspects/Saturn), so results are moderated; dasha timing and other factors determine actual outcomes.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/houses/10/aspectedBy"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Jupiter does not occupy house 12; it is in Cancer in house 11, exalted (/placements/Jupiter/house, /placements/Jupiter/sign, /placements/Jupiter/dignity). House 12 has no occupants (/houses/11/occupants is empty for Leo).","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Audited three statements against chart facts. S1 is a fair doctrinal reading supported by the chart: Jupiter is exalted in Cancer in house 11 (/placements/Jupiter/house, /placements/Jupiter/dignity), and house 11 signifies gains and income (/reference/houseSignifications/11) — supportive of wealth, though Saturn's aspect on that house tempers it. S2 is erroneous as an overclaim: no single placement guarantees riches; Jupiter here is retrograde, aspected by Saturn from the 2nd, and wealth outcomes also depend on dashas — supportive indication only, never a guarantee. S3 is a factual error: Jupiter occupies house 11, not house 12 (/placements/Jupiter/house)."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-contradiction-02\",\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"confidence\":0.0,\"rationale\":\"Audited three statements against chart facts. S1 is a fair doctrinal reading supported by the chart: Jupiter is exalted in Cancer in house 11 (/placements/Jupiter/house, /placements/Jupiter/dignity), and house 11 signifies gains and income (/reference/houseSignifications/11) — supportive of wealth, though Saturn's aspect on that house tempers it. S2 is erroneous as an overclaim: no single placement guarantees riches; Jupiter here is retrograde, aspected by Saturn from the 2nd, and wealth outcomes also depend on dashas — supportive indication only, never a guarantee. S3 is a factual error: Jupiter occupies house 11, not house 12 (/placements/Jupiter/house).\",\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Jupiter in the 11th supports gains but guarantees nothing. In this chart Jupiter is retrograde (/placements/Jupiter/retrograde) and aspected by Saturn (/houses/10/aspectedBy includes Saturn via its 4th... specifically Saturn aspects house 11 per /aspects/Saturn), so results are moderated; dasha timing and other factors determine actual outcomes.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/houses/10/aspectedBy\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Jupiter does not occupy house 12; it is in Cancer in house 11, exalted (/placements/Jupiter/house, /placements/Jupiter/sign, /placements/Jupiter/dignity). House 12 has no occupants (/houses/11/occupants is empty for Leo).\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\"]}],\"missing_information\":[]}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-contradiction-02","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-contradiction-02","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.95,"selected_option_ids":["S2","S3"],"factors":[{"claim":"Jupiter is exalted in Cancer in the 11th house, a classical placement supportive of gains and accumulation.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/sign","/placements/Jupiter/dignity"]},{"claim":"However, Jupiter is retrograde and aspected by Saturn from the 2nd, so the gains indication is not unqualified.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/houses/10/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Saturn, also exalted, sits in the 2nd house of wealth, further supporting accumulation themes.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Jupiter in the 11th supports gains and fulfilment of desires, but no placement 'guarantees' riches. Here Jupiter's retrograde motion (/placements/Jupiter/retrograde) and Saturn's aspect on the 11th (/aspects/Saturn) qualify the result; wealth indications are supportive, not certain.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/aspects/Saturn"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Jupiter occupies house 11 (Cancer), not house 12. House 12 (Leo) has Sun as lord and no occupants (/houses/11/occupants).","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/houses/12/occupants","/placements/Jupiter/sign"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is accurate: natal Jupiter is exalted in Cancer in the 11th house of gains (/placements/Jupiter/house, /placements/Jupiter/dignity), a classically wealth-supportive placement. S2 commits an overclaim — astrological placements indicate tendencies, never guarantees, and here Jupiter's retrogradation and Saturn's aspect on the 11th temper the result. S3 is a factual error contradicted by /placements/Jupiter/house = 11."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-contradiction-02\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.95,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"S2\",\"S3\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Jupiter is exalted in Cancer in the 11th house, a classical placement supportive of gains and accumulation.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/sign\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"However, Jupiter is retrograde and aspected by Saturn from the 2nd, so the gains indication is not unqualified.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/houses/10/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn, also exalted, sits in the 2nd house of wealth, further supporting accumulation themes.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Jupiter in the 11th supports gains and fulfilment of desires, but no placement 'guarantees' riches. Here Jupiter's retrograde motion (/placements/Jupiter/retrograde) and Saturn's aspect on the 11th (/aspects/Saturn) qualify the result; wealth indications are supportive, not certain.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/aspects/Saturn\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Jupiter occupies house 11 (Cancer), not house 12. House 12 (Leo) has Sun as lord and no occupants (/houses/11/occupants).\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/houses/12/occupants\",\"/placements/Jupiter/sign\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S1 is accurate: natal Jupiter is exalted in Cancer in the 11th house of gains (/placements/Jupiter/house, /placements/Jupiter/dignity), a classically wealth-supportive placement. S2 commits an overclaim — astrological placements indicate tendencies, never guarantees, and here Jupiter's retrogradation and Saturn's aspect on the 11th temper the result. S3 is a factual error contradicted by /placements/Jupiter/house = 11.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-01","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.72,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Dhana Yoga: 2nd lord Jupiter conjunct lagna lord Saturn in the 11th house of gains","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/3","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"claim":"Second Dhana Yoga: 11th lord Jupiter conjunct lagna lord Saturn in the 11th itself, strengthening income and fulfilment of desire","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/4"]},{"claim":"Raja Yoga: Venus (4th & 9th lord, own sign) conjunct Mercury (5th lord) in the 9th — fortune and accumulated resources combine","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/0","/yogas/1","/placements/Venus/dignity","/houses/9/occupants"]},{"claim":"Adhi Yoga from the exalted Moon: benefics in 6th/7th/8th from Moon confer prosperity and comfort","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/5","/placements/Moon/dignity"]},{"claim":"Mars (10th lord, career-driven earning capacity) aspects the 11th house of gains, energising the Jupiter–Saturn cluster; but Mars is in enemy sign Gemini and aspects the 12th (expenditure)","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Mars/sign","/aspects/Mars","/placements/Mars/dignity"]},{"claim":"Lagna lord Saturn placed in the 11th supports steady gains, though Saturn is a natural malefic and only neutral in dignity","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Saturn/dignity"]},{"claim":"8th lord Mercury well-placed in the 9th with Venus adds inheritance/sudden-gain potential through dharmic channels","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/dignity"]},{"claim":"Current Mercury mahadasha (2018–2035) activates the Venus–Mercury raja yoga in the 9th; Moon antardasha (to Jul 2026) is a benefic exalted 6th lord in the 4th — service-linked gains with home focus","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/dasha/current"]},{"claim":"Transit note: transiting Rahu/Ketu axis sits on natal 1/7 axis and Saturn transits the 2nd house of wealth (Pisces), which can bring pressure on savings and family finances even amid supportive dasha","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/transits/asOf","/transits/contacts/7","/transits/contacts/6"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"omission","correction":"The chart shows strong dhana yogas, but the 2nd house itself is empty with its lord in the 11th — gains come via networks/income streams rather than stored accumulation, so wealth flows should be described as income-oriented rather than hoarding.","evidence":["/houses/2/occupants","/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Wealth potential is clearly supportive: two dhana yogas anchored by lagna lord Saturn with 2nd/11th lord Jupiter in the 11th, plus a strong Venus–Mercury raja yoga in the 9th and Adhi Yoga from an exalted Moon. The long Mercury mahadasha keeps these yogas active through 2035. Caveats: Mars's malefic aspect on the 12th and 11th cluster introduces expenditure leakage and volatility, and the current Saturn transit over the 2nd can strain accumulation near-term despite the dasha backdrop. Net: strong earning/gains orientation, moderate friction in retention."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-synthesis-01\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.72,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Dhana Yoga: 2nd lord Jupiter conjunct lagna lord Saturn in the 11th house of gains\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/3\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Second Dhana Yoga: 11th lord Jupiter conjunct lagna lord Saturn in the 11th itself, strengthening income and fulfilment of desire\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/4\"]},{\"claim\":\"Raja Yoga: Venus (4th & 9th lord, own sign) conjunct Mercury (5th lord) in the 9th — fortune and accumulated resources combine\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0\",\"/yogas/1\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/houses/9/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"Adhi Yoga from the exalted Moon: benefics in 6th/7th/8th from Moon confer prosperity and comfort\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/5\",\"/placements/Moon/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars (10th lord, career-driven earning capacity) aspects the 11th house of gains, energising the Jupiter–Saturn cluster; but Mars is in enemy sign Gemini and aspects the 12th (expenditure)\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/sign\",\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Lagna lord Saturn placed in the 11th supports steady gains, though Saturn is a natural malefic and only neutral in dignity\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"8th lord Mercury well-placed in the 9th with Venus adds inheritance/sudden-gain potential through dharmic channels\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current Mercury mahadasha (2018–2035) activates the Venus–Mercury raja yoga in the 9th; Moon antardasha (to Jul 2026) is a benefic exalted 6th lord in the 4th — service-linked gains with home focus\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current\"]},{\"claim\":\"Transit note: transiting Rahu/Ketu axis sits on natal 1/7 axis and Saturn transits the 2nd house of wealth (Pisces), which can bring pressure on savings and family finances even amid supportive dasha\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/transits/asOf\",\"/transits/contacts/7\",\"/transits/contacts/6\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"omission\",\"correction\":\"The chart shows strong dhana yogas, but the 2nd house itself is empty with its lord in the 11th — gains come via networks/income streams rather than stored accumulation, so wealth flows should be described as income-oriented rather than hoarding.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/2/occupants\",\"/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Wealth potential is clearly supportive: two dhana yogas anchored by lagna lord Saturn with 2nd/11th lord Jupiter in the 11th, plus a strong Venus–Mercury raja yoga in the 9th and Adhi Yoga from an exalted Moon. The long Mercury mahadasha keeps these yogas active through 2035. Caveats: Mars's malefic aspect on the 12th and 11th cluster introduces expenditure leakage and volatility, and the current Saturn transit over the 2nd can strain accumulation near-term despite the dasha backdrop. Net: strong earning/gains orientation, moderate friction in retention.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-01","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.75,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Strong Dhana Yoga: Jupiter (lord of 2 and 11) conjunct Saturn (lord of 1) in the 11th house of gains","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/3","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity"]},{"claim":"Jupiter in Moolatrikona in Sagittarius in its own 11th house — a powerful, self-reinforcing gains placement","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/sign","/placements/Jupiter/dignity"]},{"claim":"Raja Yoga: Venus rules both the 4th (kendra) and 9th (trikona), placed in its own sign Libra in the 9th with Mercury — wealth through fortune, property, higher learning","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/1","/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/dignity"]},{"claim":"Second Raja Yoga: Venus (4th lord) + Mercury (5th lord) conjunct in house 9 — a Lakshmi-type combination favoring accumulated resources","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/0"]},{"claim":"Mars–Saturn mutual aspect Raja Yoga: 10th lord Mars aspects 1st-lord-ruled houses; earnings tied to career action and disciplined effort","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/2"]},{"claim":"Adhi Yoga from the Moon (benefics Jupiter, Venus, Mercury in 6th/7th/8th from Moon) — prosperity and comfort per classical texts","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/5"]},{"claim":"Exalted Moon in the 4th aspects the 10th — inner contentment supports steady public standing and property comfort","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Moon/dignity","/aspects/Moon"]},{"claim":"2nd lord Jupiter's dispositor chain is clean (Jupiter in own sign), so savings/family wealth flows to gains; but Saturn's conjunction tempers the pace — gains come late and slowly","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Current dasha Mercury–Moon (to Jul 2026): Mercury is a Raja-yoga planet in the 9th; Moon exalted as 6th lord — income supportive though Moon's 6th lordship can bring service-related expenses","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current","/placements/Moon/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"omission","correction":"The strong Dhana Yogas are partially offset by Saturn's conjunction with Jupiter in the 11th — Saturn is neutral and delays/flattens gains rather than amplifying them; wealth builds gradually over the Mercury mahadasha (2018–2035) rather than suddenly.","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha","/placements/Saturn/dignity"]}],"missing_information":["Exact birth-time rectification confidence for whole-sign cusps","D2 (Hora) chart for finer wealth assessment","Specific financial events/timeline from the native"],"rationale":"Multiple classical Dhana and Raja Yogas converge on the 9th and 11th houses: Jupiter (2nd & 11th lord, Moolatrikona) conjunct Lagna lord Saturn in the 11th, plus Venus (4th+9th lord, own sign) with Mercury (5th lord) in the 9th, and Adhi Yoga from an exalted Moon. This indicates solid, well-supported wealth accumulation. The main tempering factor is Saturn's presence alongside Jupiter, indicating slow, disciplined growth rather than windfalls, consistent with the long Mercury mahadasha (2018–2035) that activates these yogas progressively."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-synthesis-01\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.75,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Strong Dhana Yoga: Jupiter (lord of 2 and 11) conjunct Saturn (lord of 1) in the 11th house of gains\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/3\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter in Moolatrikona in Sagittarius in its own 11th house — a powerful, self-reinforcing gains placement\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/sign\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Raja Yoga: Venus rules both the 4th (kendra) and 9th (trikona), placed in its own sign Libra in the 9th with Mercury — wealth through fortune, property, higher learning\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Second Raja Yoga: Venus (4th lord) + Mercury (5th lord) conjunct in house 9 — a Lakshmi-type combination favoring accumulated resources\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars–Saturn mutual aspect Raja Yoga: 10th lord Mars aspects 1st-lord-ruled houses; earnings tied to career action and disciplined effort\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"Adhi Yoga from the Moon (benefics Jupiter, Venus, Mercury in 6th/7th/8th from Moon) — prosperity and comfort per classical texts\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/5\"]},{\"claim\":\"Exalted Moon in the 4th aspects the 10th — inner contentment supports steady public standing and property comfort\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/dignity\",\"/aspects/Moon\"]},{\"claim\":\"2nd lord Jupiter's dispositor chain is clean (Jupiter in own sign), so savings/family wealth flows to gains; but Saturn's conjunction tempers the pace — gains come late and slowly\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current dasha Mercury–Moon (to Jul 2026): Mercury is a Raja-yoga planet in the 9th; Moon exalted as 6th lord — income supportive though Moon's 6th lordship can bring service-related expenses\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]}] ,\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"omission\",\"correction\":\"The strong Dhana Yogas are partially offset by Saturn's conjunction with Jupiter in the 11th — Saturn is neutral and delays/flattens gains rather than amplifying them; wealth builds gradually over the Mercury mahadasha (2018–2035) rather than suddenly.\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/mahadasha\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"Exact birth-time rectification confidence for whole-sign cusps\",\"D2 (Hora) chart for finer wealth assessment\",\"Specific financial events/timeline from the native\"],\"rationale\":\"Multiple classical Dhana and Raja Yogas converge on the 9th and 11th houses: Jupiter (2nd & 11th lord, Moolatrikona) conjunct Lagna lord Saturn in the 11th, plus Venus (4th+9th lord, own sign) with Mercury (5th lord) in the 9th, and Adhi Yoga from an exalted Moon. This indicates solid, well-supported wealth accumulation. The main tempering factor is Saturn's presence alongside Jupiter, indicating slow, disciplined growth rather than windfalls, consistent with the long Mercury mahadasha (2018–2035) that activates these yogas progressively.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-01","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.75,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Strong dhana yoga: Jupiter, lord of the 2nd, conjunct Saturn, lord of the 1st, in the 11th house of gains — a classic 2nd-lord + lagna-lord combination in the house of income.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/3","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Saturn/house","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/lagna/lordInHouse"]},{"claim":"Jupiter is in Moolatrikona in Sagittarius and occupies its own 11th house, strengthening both the 11th (gains) and its 2nd-house ownership.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/houses/10/sign"]},{"claim":"Raja yoga: Venus rules both the 4th (kendra) and 9th (trikona) and sits in its own sign Libra in the 9th — a powerful Lakshmi-type placement for fortune and assets.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/1","/placements/Venus/dignity","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"claim":"Additional raja yoga: Venus (4th lord) conjunct Mercury (5th lord) in the 9th supports wealth through education, intellect, speculation and property.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/0","/placements/Mercury/house"]},{"claim":"Mars (10th lord) aspects Saturn (1st lord), forming another raja yoga linking career/status with self-earned position.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/2","/aspects/Mars"]},{"claim":"Adhi Yoga from the Moon (benefics Jupiter, Venus, Mercury in 6th–8th from Moon) indicates prosperity and comfort per classical lunar combinations; Moon itself is exalted in the 4th (assets, home, vehicles).","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/5","/placements/Moon/dignity","/placements/Moon/house"]},{"claim":"The 11th house (gains) is aspected by Mars and Rahu, adding drive but also volatility, competition and sudden fluctuations to income streams.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/10/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Sun (7th lord) sits in the 8th house aspected by Saturn and Mars: partnership/business income can be unstable or tied to others' resources, inheritance matters are significant.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/houses/7/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Current Mercury mahadasha (2018–2035): Mercury is a 5th/8th lord placed in the 9th within the Venus–Mercury raja yoga — dasha lord participates directly in wealth yogas, favorably activating them.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha","/placements/Mercury/house","/yogas/0"]},{"claim":"Upcoming Mercury–Saturn antardasha (2032–2035) activates the Jupiter–Saturn dhana yoga again via the 11th house, though Saturn's neutral dignity tempers the pace.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/upcoming/3","/placements/Saturn/dignity"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Exact birth-time rectification confidence (lagna at only 0°19' Aquarius makes house cusps timing-sensitive)","Specific periods for major financial decisions/events to correlate against dasha timeline"],"rationale":"The chart carries multiple independent wealth combinations: a direct dhana yoga (Jupiter+Saturn in the 11th with Jupiter in Moolatrikona owning the 2nd and 11th), two raja yogas centered on Venus in own sign in the 9th, and Adhi Yoga from an exalted Moon. The long-running Mercury mahadasha places a participant of the Venus–Mercury yoga in charge until 2035. Offsetting factors are modest: 8th-house Sun as 7th lord complicates partnership income, and malefic aspects on the gains house add volatility, but these qualify rather than negate the overall supportive picture."},"extracted":"{\n \"case_id\": \"wealth-synthesis-01\",\n \"domain\": \"wealth\",\n \"conclusion\": \"supportive\",\n \"confidence\": 0.75,\n \"selected_option_ids\": [],\n \"factors\": [\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Strong dhana yoga: Jupiter, lord of the 2nd, conjunct Saturn, lord of the 1st, in the 11th house of gains — a classic 2nd-lord + lagna-lord combination in the house of income.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/3\", \"/placements/Jupiter/house\", \"/placements/Saturn/house\", \"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\", \"/lagna/lordInHouse\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Jupiter is in Moolatrikona in Sagittarius and occupies its own 11th house, strengthening both the 11th (gains) and its 2nd-house ownership.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\", \"/houses/10/sign\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Raja yoga: Venus rules both the 4th (kendra) and 9th (trikona) and sits in its own sign Libra in the 9th — a powerful Lakshmi-type placement for fortune and assets.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/1\", \"/placements/Venus/dignity\", \"/placements/Venus/house\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Additional raja yoga: Venus (4th lord) conjunct Mercury (5th lord) in the 9th supports wealth through education, intellect, speculation and property.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/0\", \"/placements/Mercury/house\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Mars (10th lord) aspects Saturn (1st lord), forming another raja yoga linking career/status with self-earned position.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/2\", \"/aspects/Mars\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Adhi Yoga from the Moon (benefics Jupiter, Venus, Mercury in 6th–8th from Moon) indicates prosperity and comfort per classical lunar combinations; Moon itself is exalted in the 4th (assets, home, vehicles).\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/5\", \"/placements/Moon/dignity\", \"/placements/Moon/house\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"The 11th house (gains) is aspected by Mars and Rahu, adding drive but also volatility, competition and sudden fluctuations to income streams.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/houses/10/aspectedBy\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Sun (7th lord) sits in the 8th house aspected by Saturn and Mars: partnership/business income can be unstable or tied to others' resources, inheritance matters are significant.\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Sun/house\", \"/houses/7/aspectedBy\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Current Mercury mahadasha (2018–2035): Mercury is a 5th/8th lord placed in the 9th within the Venus–Mercury raja yoga — dasha lord participates directly in wealth yogas, favorably activating them.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/dasha/current/mahadasha\", \"/placements/Mercury/house\", \"/yogas/0\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Upcoming Mercury–Saturn antardasha (2032–2035) activates the Jupiter–Saturn dhana yoga again via the 11th house, though Saturn's neutral dignity tempers the pace.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/dasha/upcoming/3\", \"/placements/Saturn/dignity\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"contradictions\": [],\n \"missing_information\": [\n  \"Exact birth-time rectification confidence (lagna at only 0°19' Aquarius makes house cusps timing-sensitive)\",\n  \"Specific periods for major financial decisions/events to correlate against dasha timeline\"\n ],\n \"rationale\": \"The chart carries multiple independent wealth combinations: a direct dhana yoga (Jupiter+Saturn in the 11th with Jupiter in Moolatrikona owning the 2nd and 11th), two raja yogas centered on Venus in own sign in the 9th, and Adhi Yoga from an exalted Moon. The long-running Mercury mahadasha places a participant of the Venus–Mercury yoga in charge until 2035. Offsetting factors are modest: 8th-house Sun as 7th lord complicates partnership income, and malefic aspects on the gains house add volatility, but these qualify rather than negate the overall supportive picture.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-knowledge-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-knowledge-01","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"rationale":"The House1LordInHouse11 rule treats the ascendant lord's placement in the 11th house (house of gains) as favorable for income and gains; it does not guarantee enormous profits nor indicate financial loss, so B and C are incorrect."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-knowledge-01\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"confidence\":0.9,\"rationale\":\"The House1LordInHouse11 rule treats the ascendant lord's placement in the 11th house (house of gains) as favorable for income and gains; it does not guarantee enormous profits nor indicate financial loss, so B and C are incorrect.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-02","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":false,"error":"✖ Invalid input: expected array, received undefined\n  → at selected_option_ids","extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-synthesis-02\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.7,\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Dhana Yoga: 11th lord Sun conjunct 9th lord Mercury in the lagna — a strong wealth combination linking gains and fortune to self-effort\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/2\",\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury is vargottama, reinforcing the Dhana yoga's durability\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargottama\"]},{\"claim\":\"Budha-Aditya yoga in the 1st supports intelligence and earning capacity, though Mercury's combustion tempers it\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0\",\"/placements/Mercury/combust\"]},{\"claim\":\"Raja Yoga from Saturn ruling both 4th (kendra) and 5th (trikona); Saturn sits in the 2nd house of accumulated wealth — yogakaraka in the wealth house\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn in the 2nd is in an enemy sign (Scorpio) and conjunct debilitated Rahu with Ketu aspecting — savings and family wealth face obstruction, volatility, and shared-resource complications\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Rahu/sign\",\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"Lagna lord Venus debilitated in the 12th — but forms Vipareeta Raja Yoga (8th lord in 12th), suggesting gains through adversity, foreign lands, or hidden sources; still, the dispositor of wealth is weak at birth\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/3\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter in the 11th house of gains (friendly Leo), aspected by Mars/Saturn but well placed for income and fulfilment of desires; Jupiter also aspects the 5th (speculation)\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current Rahu mahadasha until mid-2026: Rahu is debilitated natally and placed in the 2nd house with Saturn, indicating financial turbulence during this long period; Rahu–Mars antardasha (Mars rules the 7th/2nd lord) keeps pressure on money matters\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord\",\"/dasha/current/antardasha/lord\",\"/placements/Rahu/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter mahadasha begins 2026-07-31; Jupiter is a benefic placed in the 11th house of gains, promising a materially better phase\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/upcoming/0\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"Exact D1/D9 strength calculations (shadbala) for Venus and Saturn to weigh the Vipareeta yoga against debilitation\",\"Second-house navamsa confirmation of wealth durability\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart carries genuine Dhana and Raja yogas (11th+9th lords in lagna, vargottama Mercury, yogakaraka Saturn in the 2nd) pointing to real wealth capacity. These are offset by a debilitated lagna lord in the 12th, Saturn-Rahu affliction of the 2nd house, and a currently running debilitated-Rahu dasha. The mixed verdict reflects strong underlying potential currently under pressure, with the Jupiter mahadasha starting July 2026 indicating improvement.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-02","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-02","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.7,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Dhana yoga: Sun (11th lord of gains) conjunct Mercury (9th lord of fortune) in the lagna — a classic wealth combination, strengthened by Mercury being vargottama.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/2","/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Mercury/house","/vargottama"]},{"claim":"Budha-Aditya yoga in house 1 supports intelligence and earning capacity through self-effort, though Mercury's combustion tempers the result.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/yogas/0","/placements/Mercury/combust"]},{"claim":"Saturn forms a Raja yoga as single lord of kendra (4th) and trikona (5th), placed in the 2nd house of accumulated wealth — wealth via property/assets, but Saturn is in enemy sign Scorpio with debilitated Rahu, indicating slow, obstructed accumulation.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/yogas/1","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Rahu/house","/placements/Rahu/dignity"]},{"claim":"Vipareeta Raja Yoga: Venus, lord of the 8th (sudden events, inheritance), sits in the 12th — potential gains through inheritance or others' resources arising from loss/isolation contexts.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/3","/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/dignity"]},{"claim":"Lagna lord Venus debilitated in Virgo in the 12th house: weakened vitality of self-directed wealth; expenses, foreign connections, or isolation drain resources.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Venus/dignity","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"claim":"Jupiter in the 11th house of gains (friend's sign) supports income streams and fulfilment of desires, though at the very end of Leo (29°54') — late-degree, and it receives aspects from Mars and Saturn.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/formatted","/houses/10/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"2nd lord Mars placed in the 5th house links wealth to speculation/intelligence/creativity; Mars also aspects the 11th and 12th houses — gains mixed with expenditure.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mars/house","/aspects/Mars"]},{"claim":"Current dasha: Rahu–Mars–Saturn (Rahu MD until 2026-07-31). Rahu is debilitated in the 2nd house of wealth with Saturn — financial pressure, volatility, and unexpected obligations during this closing phase of Rahu mahadasha.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord","/dasha/current/antardasha/lord","/dasha/current/pratyantardasha/lord","/placements/Rahu/house"]},{"claim":"Upcoming Jupiter mahadasha from 2026-07-31: Jupiter is a benefic placed in the 11th house of gains and aspects the 5th house — an improvement in income and accumulation outlook relative to Rahu MD.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/dasha/upcoming/0","/placements/Jupiter/house","/aspects/Jupiter"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The dhana and Budha-Aditya yogas should not be read as unqualified wealth: Mercury is combust (/placements/Mercury/combust) and the dispositor chain runs through a debilitated lagna lord, so results manifest with delay and leakage rather than straightforward affluence.","evidence":["/yogas/0","/placements/Mercury/combust","/lagna/lordInHouse"]}],"missing_information":["Exact birth-time rectification confidence (whole-sign houses sensitive to time)","Ashtakavarga bindus for 2nd and 11th houses to grade wealth quantum","Specific life events/financial history for verification"],"rationale":"The natal promise of wealth is real but conditional: dhana yoga (Sun+Mercury in lagna), Saturn's kendra-trikona raja yoga landing in the 2nd house, and Jupiter in the 11th give genuine capacity for gains and asset-building. These are counterweighted by a debilitated lagna lord in the 12th (expenditure, leakage), combust Mercury, and a heavy Saturn-Rahu conjunction in the 2nd house making accumulation slow and subject to disruption. The present Rahu–Mars–Saturn period (through mid-2026) is the weakest stretch; the incoming Jupiter mahadasha from July 2026, with Jupiter natally in the 11th aspecting the 5th, indicates a materially improved financial phase thereafter. Overall verdict: mixed — solid long-term wealth structure with significant frictions and timing-dependent outcomes."},"extracted":"{\n  \"case_id\": \"wealth-synthesis-02\",\n  \"domain\": \"wealth\",\n  \"conclusion\": \"mixed\",\n  \"confidence\": 0.7,\n  \"selected_option_ids\": [],\n  \"factors\": [\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Dhana yoga: Sun (11th lord of gains) conjunct Mercury (9th lord of fortune) in the lagna — a classic wealth combination, strengthened by Mercury being vargottama.\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/2\", \"/placements/Sun/house\", \"/placements/Mercury/house\", \"/vargottama\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Budha-Aditya yoga in house 1 supports intelligence and earning capacity through self-effort, though Mercury's combustion tempers the result.\",\n      \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/0\", \"/placements/Mercury/combust\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Saturn forms a Raja yoga as single lord of kendra (4th) and trikona (5th), placed in the 2nd house of accumulated wealth — wealth via property/assets, but Saturn is in enemy sign Scorpio with debilitated Rahu, indicating slow, obstructed accumulation.\",\n      \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/1\", \"/placements/Saturn/house\", \"/placements/Saturn/dignity\", \"/placements/Rahu/house\", \"/placements/Rahu/dignity\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Vipareeta Raja Yoga: Venus, lord of the 8th (sudden events, inheritance), sits in the 12th — potential gains through inheritance or others' resources arising from loss/isolation contexts.\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/3\", \"/placements/Venus/house\", \"/placements/Venus/dignity\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Lagna lord Venus debilitated in Virgo in the 12th house: weakened vitality of self-directed wealth; expenses, foreign connections, or isolation drain resources.\",\n      \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/lagna/lordInHouse\", \"/placements/Venus/dignity\", \"/placements/Venus/house\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Jupiter in the 11th house of gains (friend's sign) supports income streams and fulfilment of desires, though at the very end of Leo (29°54') — late-degree, and it receives aspects from Mars and Saturn.\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Jupiter/house\", \"/placements/Jupiter/formatted\", \"/houses/10/aspectedBy\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"2nd lord Mars placed in the 5th house links wealth to speculation/intelligence/creativity; Mars also aspects the 11th and 12th houses — gains mixed with expenditure.\",\n      \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\", \"/placements/Mars/house\", \"/aspects/Mars\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Current dasha: Rahu–Mars–Saturn (Rahu MD until 2026-07-31). Rahu is debilitated in the 2nd house of wealth with Saturn — financial pressure, volatility, and unexpected obligations during this closing phase of Rahu mahadasha.\",\n      \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord\", \"/dasha/current/antardasha/lord\", \"/dasha/current/pratyantardasha/lord\", \"/placements/Rahu/house\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Upcoming Jupiter mahadasha from 2026-07-31: Jupiter is a benefic placed in the 11th house of gains and aspects the 5th house — an improvement in income and accumulation outlook relative to Rahu MD.\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/dasha/upcoming/0\", \"/placements/Jupiter/house\", \"/aspects/Jupiter\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"contradictions\": [\n    {\n      \"statement_id\": \"S1\",\n      \"error_type\": \"overclaim\",\n      \"correction\": \"The dhana and Budha-Aditya yogas should not be read as unqualified wealth: Mercury is combust (/placements/Mercury/combust) and the dispositor chain runs through a debilitated lagna lord, so results manifest with delay and leakage rather than straightforward affluence.\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/0\", \"/placements/Mercury/combust\", \"/lagna/lordInHouse\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"missing_information\": [\n    \"Exact birth-time rectification confidence (whole-sign houses sensitive to time)\",\n    \"Ashtakavarga bindus for 2nd and 11th houses to grade wealth quantum\",\n    \"Specific life events/financial history for verification\"\n  ],\n  \"rationale\": \"The natal promise of wealth is real but conditional: dhana yoga (Sun+Mercury in lagna), Saturn's kendra-trikona raja yoga landing in the 2nd house, and Jupiter in the 11th give genuine capacity for gains and asset-building. These are counterweighted by a debilitated lagna lord in the 12th (expenditure, leakage), combust Mercury, and a heavy Saturn-Rahu conjunction in the 2nd house making accumulation slow and subject to disruption. The present Rahu–Mars–Saturn period (through mid-2026) is the weakest stretch; the incoming Jupiter mahadasha from July 2026, with Jupiter natally in the 11th aspecting the 5th, indicates a materially improved financial phase thereafter. Overall verdict: mixed — solid long-term wealth structure with significant frictions and timing-dependent outcomes.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-03","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-03","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.7,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Second lord Saturn is exalted in Libra in the 10th house, forming Sasa Yoga — a strong indicator of status-linked wealth through career.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Saturn/house","/yogas"]},{"claim":"Venus rules both the 10th (kendra) and 5th (trikona), a single-lordship Raja Yoga pointing to gains via profession and purva punya.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas","/houses/9","/houses/4"]},{"claim":"Jupiter as 12th lord placed in the 6th forms Vipareeta Raja Yoga; it also aspects the 2nd and 10th houses, lending protective support to finances.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas","/placements/Jupiter/house","/aspects/Jupiter"]},{"claim":"Adhi Yoga from the Moon (benefics in 6th/7th/8th from Moon) supports overall prosperity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas"]},{"claim":"Mercury, karaka of commerce and accounts, sits in the 2nd house but is retrograde and combust, weakening the wealth-house occupant.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/combust","/placements/Mercury/retrograde"]},{"claim":"Venus, the Raja-yoga lord, occupies the 12th with Rahu, indicating expenditure, foreign links, and leakage alongside earning potential.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Rahu/house","/houses/11/significations"]},{"claim":"Current period is Rahu–Venus (to Dec 2026) with pratyantardasha Saturn: Rahu amplifies, but its dispositor Venus sits in the 12th with Rahu natal, so financial flows are amplified in both directions.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current","/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Rahu/house"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["No specific option set was provided to select from","Navamsa dignity of the 2nd/11th lords beyond sign placements already given (Saturn and Jupiter share D9 11th house — noted, but no explicit varga-strength judgment supplied)","Question specifics (e.g., investment timing vs. income growth) are not stated"],"rationale":"The chart carries genuinely strong wealth-supportive architecture: an exalted second lord in the kendra of career (Sasa Yoga, /placements/Saturn/house, /placements/Saturn/dignity), a Venus Raja Yoga linking 5th and 10th, Vipareeta Raja Yoga via Jupiter, and Adhi Yoga from the Moon. Against this stand real weaknesses: combust-retrograde Mercury occupying the 2nd itself, and the Raja-yoga lord Venus placed in the 12th with Rahu, which doctrine reads as expenditure and dissipation tempering gains. The current Rahu–Venus mahadasha–antardasha activates both sides at once. The represented evidence supports 'mixed' rather than a forced positive or negative verdict; no doctrinal basis exists here to guarantee financial outcomes."},"extracted":"{\n  \"case_id\": \"wealth-synthesis-03\",\n  \"domain\": \"wealth\",\n  \"conclusion\": \"mixed\",\n  \"confidence\": 0.7,\n  \"selected_option_ids\": [],\n  \"factors\": [\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Second lord Saturn is exalted in Libra in the 10th house, forming Sasa Yoga — a strong indicator of status-linked wealth through career.\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\", \"/placements/Saturn/house\", \"/yogas\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Venus rules both the 10th (kendra) and 5th (trikona), a single-lordship Raja Yoga pointing to gains via profession and purva punya.\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/yogas\", \"/houses/9\", \"/houses/4\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Jupiter as 12th lord placed in the 6th forms Vipareeta Raja Yoga; it also aspects the 2nd and 10th houses, lending protective support to finances.\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/yogas\", \"/placements/Jupiter/house\", \"/aspects/Jupiter\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Adhi Yoga from the Moon (benefics in 6th/7th/8th from Moon) supports overall prosperity.\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/yogas\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Mercury, karaka of commerce and accounts, sits in the 2nd house but is retrograde and combust, weakening the wealth-house occupant.\",\n      \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mercury/house\", \"/placements/Mercury/combust\", \"/placements/Mercury/retrograde\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Venus, the Raja-yoga lord, occupies the 12th with Rahu, indicating expenditure, foreign links, and leakage alongside earning potential.\",\n      \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Venus/house\", \"/placements/Rahu/house\", \"/houses/11/significations\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Current period is Rahu–Venus (to Dec 2026) with pratyantardasha Saturn: Rahu amplifies, but its dispositor Venus sits in the 12th with Rahu natal, so financial flows are amplified in both directions.\",\n      \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/dasha/current\", \"/placements/Venus/house\", \"/placements/Rahu/house\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"contradictions\": [],\n  \"missing_information\": [\n    \"No specific option set was provided to select from\",\n    \"Navamsa dignity of the 2nd/11th lords beyond sign placements already given (Saturn and Jupiter share D9 11th house — noted, but no explicit varga-strength judgment supplied)\",\n    \"Question specifics (e.g., investment timing vs. income growth) are not stated\"\n  ],\n  \"rationale\": \"The chart carries genuinely strong wealth-supportive architecture: an exalted second lord in the kendra of career (Sasa Yoga, /placements/Saturn/house, /placements/Saturn/dignity), a Venus Raja Yoga linking 5th and 10th, Vipareeta Raja Yoga via Jupiter, and Adhi Yoga from the Moon. Against this stand real weaknesses: combust-retrograde Mercury occupying the 2nd itself, and the Raja-yoga lord Venus placed in the 12th with Rahu, which doctrine reads as expenditure and dissipation tempering gains. The current Rahu–Venus mahadasha–antardasha activates both sides at once. The represented evidence supports 'mixed' rather than a forced positive or negative verdict; no doctrinal basis exists here to guarantee financial outcomes.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-03","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-03","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.6,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Sasa Yoga: Saturn exalted in Libra in the 10th (a kendra) — a strong Mahapurusha yoga supporting career status and earned wealth through profession.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/0","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity"]},{"claim":"Raja Yoga from Venus ruling both the 10th (kendra) and 5th (trikona) — a wealth-and-status combination, though Venus itself sits in the 12th, weakening delivery of its results.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/yogas/1","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"claim":"Vipareeta Raja Yoga: Jupiter as 12th lord placed in the 6th — gains arising after difficulty or through others' losses/debt resolution; classically supportive under adversity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/2","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Adhi Yoga from the Moon (benefics in 6/7/8 from Moon) — comfort and prosperity indications.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/3"]},{"claim":"The 2nd house of accumulated wealth holds Mercury retrograde and combust, with lord Saturn in the 10th — savings fluctuate and depend heavily on career; combust retrograde Mercury suggests irregularity in speech/financial dealings.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/retrograde","/placements/Mercury/combust"]},{"claim":"11th house of gains is empty with Mars as its lord in the 3rd — gains come through self-effort and initiative rather than passive income; no strong affliction but no amplification either.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/houses/10","/placements/Mars/house"]},{"claim":"12th house contains Venus (5th/10th lord) with Rahu — significant expenditure, foreign-land or speculative outflows tied to status-seeking; Venus in Mula nakshatra adds volatility.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Rahu/house","/placements/Venus/nakshatra"]},{"claim":"Current Rahu mahadasha / Venus antardasha (2023-12 to 2026-12): Rahu sits in the natal 12th with Venus; this period emphasizes expenditure and foreign/unconventional financial channels, while Venus's yogakaraka-like lordship can still deliver career-linked gains.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord","/dasha/current/antardasha/lord","/placements/Rahu/house","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"claim":"Transiting Rahu conjuncts natal Mercury in the 2nd house (as of 2026-01-01), pressuring wealth accumulation, family finances, and speech-related contracts during the current period.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["tool:/transits_at#0"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"omission","correction":"A reading of 'great wealth' cannot rest on Sasa or Adhi Yoga alone while ignoring the combust retrograde Mercury in the 2nd and Venus-Rahu in the 12th, which materially qualify accumulation.","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/combust","/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Rahu/house"]},{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Vipareeta Raja Yoga does not guarantee windfalls; it indicates rise through adverse circumstances, and Jupiter is also retrograde and in enemy sign, weakening the yoga.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart shows genuine strength for career-derived status and prosperity (exalted Saturn Sasa Yoga in the 10th, Venus kendra-trikona Raja Yoga, Adhi Yoga from the Moon, Vipareeta Raja Yoga). However, direct accumulation is qualified: the 2nd house Mercury is retrograde and combust, the 11th is unoccupied, and the 5th/10th lord Venus sits in the 12th with Rahu — indicating high expenditure and leakage alongside earning power. The current Rahu-Venus period (through Dec 2026) mirrors this duality, with transiting Rahu on natal Mercury in the 2nd adding near-term pressure. Net indication: mixed — strong professional standing and gains-through-effort, but inconsistent savings and elevated expenses; no certain outcome should be stated."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-synthesis-03\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.6,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Sasa Yoga: Saturn exalted in Libra in the 10th (a kendra) — a strong Mahapurusha yoga supporting career status and earned wealth through profession.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Raja Yoga from Venus ruling both the 10th (kendra) and 5th (trikona) — a wealth-and-status combination, though Venus itself sits in the 12th, weakening delivery of its results.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Vipareeta Raja Yoga: Jupiter as 12th lord placed in the 6th — gains arising after difficulty or through others' losses/debt resolution; classically supportive under adversity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/2\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Adhi Yoga from the Moon (benefics in 6/7/8 from Moon) — comfort and prosperity indications.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/3\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 2nd house of accumulated wealth holds Mercury retrograde and combust, with lord Saturn in the 10th — savings fluctuate and depend heavily on career; combust retrograde Mercury suggests irregularity in speech/financial dealings.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/retrograde\",\"/placements/Mercury/combust\"]},{\"claim\":\"11th house of gains is empty with Mars as its lord in the 3rd — gains come through self-effort and initiative rather than passive income; no strong affliction but no amplification either.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10\",\"/placements/Mars/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"12th house contains Venus (5th/10th lord) with Rahu — significant expenditure, foreign-land or speculative outflows tied to status-seeking; Venus in Mula nakshatra adds volatility.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/placements/Venus/nakshatra\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current Rahu mahadasha / Venus antardasha (2023-12 to 2026-12): Rahu sits in the natal 12th with Venus; this period emphasizes expenditure and foreign/unconventional financial channels, while Venus's yogakaraka-like lordship can still deliver career-linked gains.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord\",\"/dasha/current/antardasha/lord\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Transiting Rahu conjuncts natal Mercury in the 2nd house (as of 2026-01-01), pressuring wealth accumulation, family finances, and speech-related contracts during the current period.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"tool:/transits_at#0\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"omission\",\"correction\":\"A reading of 'great wealth' cannot rest on Sasa or Adhi Yoga alone while ignoring the combust retrograde Mercury in the 2nd and Venus-Rahu in the 12th, which materially qualify accumulation.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/combust\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Vipareeta Raja Yoga does not guarantee windfalls; it indicates rise through adverse circumstances, and Jupiter is also retrograde and in enemy sign, weakening the yoga.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart shows genuine strength for career-derived status and prosperity (exalted Saturn Sasa Yoga in the 10th, Venus kendra-trikona Raja Yoga, Adhi Yoga from the Moon, Vipareeta Raja Yoga). However, direct accumulation is qualified: the 2nd house Mercury is retrograde and combust, the 11th is unoccupied, and the 5th/10th lord Venus sits in the 12th with Rahu — indicating high expenditure and leakage alongside earning power. The current Rahu-Venus period (through Dec 2026) mirrors this duality, with transiting Rahu on natal Mercury in the 2nd adding near-term pressure. Net indication: mixed — strong professional standing and gains-through-effort, but inconsistent savings and elevated expenses; no certain outcome should be stated.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-02","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-02","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.7,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Strong Dhana Yoga: Sun (11th lord) conjunct Mercury (9th lord) in the 1st house links gains and fortune to self-effort, with Mercury vargottama strengthening the yoga.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/2","/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Mercury/house","/vargottama"]},{"claim":"Budha-Aditya Yoga in the lagna supports intellect-driven earning, though Mercury's combustion tempers its expression.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/yogas/0","/placements/Mercury/combust"]},{"claim":"Raja Yoga via Saturn ruling both 4th (kendra) and 5th (trikona); Saturn in the 2nd house of accumulated wealth can convert this into assets/savings, but Saturn is in enemy sign Scorpio and sits with debilitated Rahu, indicating gains through persistence with volatility and delays.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/yogas/1","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Rahu/house","/placements/Rahu/dignity"]},{"claim":"2nd lord Mars in the 5th (trikona) aspected by Jupiter from the 11th connects earnings to intelligence/speculation and gives a dhana link between houses 2, 5, and 11.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mars/house","/aspects/Jupiter","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Vipareeta Raja Yoga: Venus, 8th lord, in the 12th — sudden/other people's money themes can turn favorable after disruption; Venus is debilitated, so results are modest and tied to expenditure/foreign/isolation matters.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/yogas/3","/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/dignity"]},{"claim":"Lagna lord Venus in the 12th and debilitated weakens personal retention of resources; income tends to leak into expenses, foreign connections, or isolation-related costs.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Venus/dignity","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"claim":"Ketu debilitated in the 8th (Taurus, sign of Venus) with the 8th also aspected by Mars, Saturn, and Rahu indicates instability around inheritance/joint finances and sudden fluctuations in shared resources.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Ketu/sign","/placements/Ketu/dignity","/houses/7/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Current Rahu mahadasha (to 2026-07-31): Rahu is debilitated in the 2nd house of wealth, so this long period likely brought aggressive but unstable financial pursuits; Rahu–Mars antardasha (Mars = 2nd lord in 5th) keeps focus on earning through initiative/speculation.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord","/placements/Rahu/dignity","/placements/Rahu/house","/dasha/current/antardasha"]},{"claim":"From 2026-07-31, Jupiter mahadasha begins; natal Jupiter is benefic in the 11th (gains), friend-sign dignity, aspecting the 5th where the 2nd lord sits — a materially more supportive period for income and fulfilment of desires, though Jupiter at ~29°54' Leo is at the very end of the sign (sandhi), weakening it somewhat.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/dasha/upcoming/0","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/degreeInSign"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"omission","correction":"The Dhana Yoga (Sun+Mercury in 1st) should not be read as unqualifiedly strong: Sun is debilitated in Libra and Mercury combust, so both participants of the yoga are compromised; the yoga operates with reduced force despite Mercury's vargottama status.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/dignity","/placements/Mercury/combust","/yogas/0","/vargottama"]},{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn's Raja Yoga does not automatically mean wealth: Saturn is in an enemy sign in the 2nd alongside a debilitated Rahu, so the yoga manifests only after effort, delay, and with fluctuation.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Rahu/dignity"]}],"missing_information":["Exact birth-time rectification confidence (affects lagna degree and house cusps under non-whole-sign systems)","Divisional charts D2 (hora) for wealth-specific assessment","Ashtakavarga bindus for the 2nd and 11th houses to quantify gain strength"],"rationale":"The chart carries genuine wealth yogas — Dhana Yoga (9th + 11th lords in lagna), a kendra-trikona Raja Yoga through Saturn, and 2nd-lord-in-trikona with 11th-house Jupiter's aspect — but every participant is weakened: Sun debilitated, Mercury combust (though vargottama), Saturn in enemy sign with debilitated Rahu in the 2nd, and lagna lord Venus debilitated in the 12th. Net reading: capacity to earn through intellect and persistent effort, but chronic leakage of funds and volatility in savings and joint finances. The tail end of the Rahu mahadasha (Rahu debilitated in the 2nd) fits an unsettled financial phase; the incoming Jupiter mahadasha from mid-2026, with natal Jupiter dignified in the 11th aspecting the 2nd lord, indicates a more supportive earning cycle — with proportionate uncertainty, not certainty."},"extracted":"{\n  \"case_id\": \"wealth-synthesis-02\",\n  \"domain\": \"wealth\",\n  \"conclusion\": \"mixed\",\n  \"confidence\": 0.7,\n  \"selected_option_ids\": [],\n  \"factors\": [\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Strong Dhana Yoga: Sun (11th lord) conjunct Mercury (9th lord) in the 1st house links gains and fortune to self-effort, with Mercury vargottama strengthening the yoga.\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/2\", \"/placements/Sun/house\", \"/placements/Mercury/house\", \"/vargottama\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Budha-Aditya Yoga in the lagna supports intellect-driven earning, though Mercury's combustion tempers its expression.\",\n      \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/0\", \"/placements/Mercury/combust\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Raja Yoga via Saturn ruling both 4th (kendra) and 5th (trikona); Saturn in the 2nd house of accumulated wealth can convert this into assets/savings, but Saturn is in enemy sign Scorpio and sits with debilitated Rahu, indicating gains through persistence with volatility and delays.\",\n      \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/1\", \"/placements/Saturn/house\", \"/placements/Saturn/dignity\", \"/placements/Rahu/house\", \"/placements/Rahu/dignity\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"2nd lord Mars in the 5th (trikona) aspected by Jupiter from the 11th connects earnings to intelligence/speculation and gives a dhana link between houses 2, 5, and 11.\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\", \"/placements/Mars/house\", \"/aspects/Jupiter\", \"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Vipareeta Raja Yoga: Venus, 8th lord, in the 12th — sudden/other people's money themes can turn favorable after disruption; Venus is debilitated, so results are modest and tied to expenditure/foreign/isolation matters.\",\n      \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/3\", \"/placements/Venus/house\", \"/placements/Venus/dignity\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Lagna lord Venus in the 12th and debilitated weakens personal retention of resources; income tends to leak into expenses, foreign connections, or isolation-related costs.\",\n      \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/lagna/lordInHouse\", \"/placements/Venus/dignity\", \"/placements/Venus/house\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Ketu debilitated in the 8th (Taurus, sign of Venus) with the 8th also aspected by Mars, Saturn, and Rahu indicates instability around inheritance/joint finances and sudden fluctuations in shared resources.\",\n      \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Ketu/sign\", \"/placements/Ketu/dignity\", \"/houses/7/aspectedBy\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Current Rahu mahadasha (to 2026-07-31): Rahu is debilitated in the 2nd house of wealth, so this long period likely brought aggressive but unstable financial pursuits; Rahu–Mars antardasha (Mars = 2nd lord in 5th) keeps focus on earning through initiative/speculation.\",\n      \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord\", \"/placements/Rahu/dignity\", \"/placements/Rahu/house\", \"/dasha/current/antardasha\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"From 2026-07-31, Jupiter mahadasha begins; natal Jupiter is benefic in the 11th (gains), friend-sign dignity, aspecting the 5th where the 2nd lord sits — a materially more supportive period for income and fulfilment of desires, though Jupiter at ~29°54' Leo is at the very end of the sign (sandhi), weakening it somewhat.\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/dasha/upcoming/0\", \"/placements/Jupiter/house\", \"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\", \"/placements/Jupiter/degreeInSign\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"contradictions\": [\n    {\n      \"statement_id\": \"S1\",\n      \"error_type\": \"omission\",\n      \"correction\": \"The Dhana Yoga (Sun+Mercury in 1st) should not be read as unqualifiedly strong: Sun is debilitated in Libra and Mercury combust, so both participants of the yoga are compromised; the yoga operates with reduced force despite Mercury's vargottama status.\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Sun/dignity\", \"/placements/Mercury/combust\", \"/yogas/0\", \"/vargottama\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"statement_id\": \"S2\",\n      \"error_type\": \"overclaim\",\n      \"correction\": \"Saturn's Raja Yoga does not automatically mean wealth: Saturn is in an enemy sign in the 2nd alongside a debilitated Rahu, so the yoga manifests only after effort, delay, and with fluctuation.\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\", \"/placements/Rahu/dignity\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"missing_information\": [\n    \"Exact birth-time rectification confidence (affects lagna degree and house cusps under non-whole-sign systems)\",\n    \"Divisional charts D2 (hora) for wealth-specific assessment\",\n    \"Ashtakavarga bindus for the 2nd and 11th houses to quantify gain strength\"\n  ],\n  \"rationale\": \"The chart carries genuine wealth yogas — Dhana Yoga (9th + 11th lords in lagna), a kendra-trikona Raja Yoga through Saturn, and 2nd-lord-in-trikona with 11th-house Jupiter's aspect — but every participant is weakened: Sun debilitated, Mercury combust (though vargottama), Saturn in enemy sign with debilitated Rahu in the 2nd, and lagna lord Venus debilitated in the 12th. Net reading: capacity to earn through intellect and persistent effort, but chronic leakage of funds and volatility in savings and joint finances. The tail end of the Rahu mahadasha (Rahu debilitated in the 2nd) fits an unsettled financial phase; the incoming Jupiter mahadasha from mid-2026, with natal Jupiter dignified in the 11th aspecting the 2nd lord, indicates a more supportive earning cycle — with proportionate uncertainty, not certainty.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-application-01-paraphrase","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-01-paraphrase","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the seventh house but rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh house; per the stated rule this is a challenging indication for marital happiness.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/houses/1/sign","/houses/7/sign","/houses/7/lord"]},{"claim":"Saturn's exaltation in Libra (Sasa Yoga) mitigates the indication, so it remains an adverse marker rather than a deterministic outcome.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/dignity","/yogas"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"A single placement does not guarantee divorce; Saturn's exaltation in Libra in the 7th (Sasa Yoga) actually strengthens the significator of marriage.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/dignity","/yogas"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The exception cannot apply when its condition (Saturn ruling the ascendant or seventh) is unmet — here Saturn rules houses 10 and 11 only.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/houses/10/lord","/houses/11/lord"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"omission","correction":"Statement A is established by the rule and chart, so D is false.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Chart facts show Saturn placed in house 7 (/placements/Saturn/house) with Libra as the 7th sign ruled by Venus (/houses/7/lord) and Aries ascendant ruled by Mars (/lagna/lordInHouse). Saturn rules Capricorn (10th) and Aquarius (11th) (/houses/10/lord, /houses/11/lord), i.e., neither the ascendant nor the seventh, so option A correctly states the challenging indication. B is a deterministic overclaim contradicted by Saturn's exaltation (Sasa Yoga), C misstates the rule's scope, hence D fails."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.9,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies the seventh house but rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh house; per the stated rule this is a challenging indication for marital happiness.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/houses/1/sign\",\"/houses/7/sign\",\"/houses/7/lord\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn's exaltation in Libra (Sasa Yoga) mitigates the indication, so it remains an adverse marker rather than a deterministic outcome.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/yogas\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"A single placement does not guarantee divorce; Saturn's exaltation in Libra in the 7th (Sasa Yoga) actually strengthens the significator of marriage.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/yogas\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The exception cannot apply when its condition (Saturn ruling the ascendant or seventh) is unmet — here Saturn rules houses 10 and 11 only.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/11/lord\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"omission\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established by the rule and chart, so D is false.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Chart facts show Saturn placed in house 7 (/placements/Saturn/house) with Libra as the 7th sign ruled by Venus (/houses/7/lord) and Aries ascendant ruled by Mars (/lagna/lordInHouse). Saturn rules Capricorn (10th) and Aquarius (11th) (/houses/10/lord, /houses/11/lord), i.e., neither the ascendant nor the seventh, so option A correctly states the challenging indication. B is a deterministic overclaim contradicted by Saturn's exaltation (Sasa Yoga), C misstates the rule's scope, hence D fails.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-03","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-03","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.6,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Sasa Yoga: exalted Saturn in the 10th (kendra) grants career-based authority and sustained earning power","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/yogas/0"]},{"claim":"The 2nd lord (Saturn) is placed in the 10th, linking accumulated wealth directly to profession","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/10"]},{"claim":"Raja Yoga from a single-lord Venus ruling both the 10th (kendra) and 5th (trikona)","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"Adhi Yoga — benefics in the 6th, 7th or 8th from the Moon — classically indicates prosperity","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/3"]},{"claim":"Vipareeta Raja Yoga: Jupiter as 12th lord in the 6th can convert losses/debt into gains after difficulty","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/2","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Venus, the yoga-forming wealth lord, occupies the 12th house of loss/expenditure conjunct Rahu — earnings leak through expense, foreign/isolation matters, and unconventional channels","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Rahu/house","/houses/12/significations"]},{"claim":"Mercury in the 2nd house is retrograde and combust, weakening the karaka of commerce and the 9th lord's fortune-signification in the house of accumulated resources","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/retrograde","/placements/Mercury/combust"]},{"claim":"Current dasha is Rahu–Venus–Saturn (from 2025-11-09): Rahu sits with wealth-lord Venus in the 12th while Saturn is exalted in the 10th — gains through career are supported but expenditure runs high simultaneously","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current","/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity"]},{"claim":"Transit Saturn aspects the natal 12th (where Venus-Rahu sit) from the 3rd house, adding pressure on expenses during this window","effect":"challenging","evidence":["tool:transits_at#/transits/saturnFromMoon"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Adhi Yoga and Sasa Yoga indicate capacity for prosperity, not guaranteed wealth; the 12th-house Venus-Rahu placement materially qualifies any strong-wealth claim","evidence":["/yogas/3","/placements/Venus/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Strong career-linked wealth architecture (exalted 10th-house Saturn forming Sasa Yoga, 2nd lord in the 10th, Venus kendradi-pati Raja Yoga, Adhi Yoga) is offset by the wealth-yoga lord Venus sitting in the 12th with Rahu and a weakened combust-retrograde Mercury in the 2nd. The current Rahu–Venus–Saturn period activates both the gainful 10th and the loss-giving 12th at once. Net indication: solid earning capacity through profession with persistent leakage through expenditure — a genuinely mixed picture rather than a clean verdict."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-synthesis-03\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.6,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Sasa Yoga: exalted Saturn in the 10th (kendra) grants career-based authority and sustained earning power\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/yogas/0\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 2nd lord (Saturn) is placed in the 10th, linking accumulated wealth directly to profession\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/10\"]},{\"claim\":\"Raja Yoga from a single-lord Venus ruling both the 10th (kendra) and 5th (trikona)\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"Adhi Yoga — benefics in the 6th, 7th or 8th from the Moon — classically indicates prosperity\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/3\"]},{\"claim\":\"Vipareeta Raja Yoga: Jupiter as 12th lord in the 6th can convert losses/debt into gains after difficulty\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/2\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus, the yoga-forming wealth lord, occupies the 12th house of loss/expenditure conjunct Rahu — earnings leak through expense, foreign/isolation matters, and unconventional channels\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/houses/12/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury in the 2nd house is retrograde and combust, weakening the karaka of commerce and the 9th lord's fortune-signification in the house of accumulated resources\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/retrograde\",\"/placements/Mercury/combust\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current dasha is Rahu–Venus–Saturn (from 2025-11-09): Rahu sits with wealth-lord Venus in the 12th while Saturn is exalted in the 10th — gains through career are supported but expenditure runs high simultaneously\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Transit Saturn aspects the natal 12th (where Venus-Rahu sit) from the 3rd house, adding pressure on expenses during this window\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"tool:transits_at#/transits/saturnFromMoon\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Adhi Yoga and Sasa Yoga indicate capacity for prosperity, not guaranteed wealth; the 12th-house Venus-Rahu placement materially qualifies any strong-wealth claim\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/3\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Strong career-linked wealth architecture (exalted 10th-house Saturn forming Sasa Yoga, 2nd lord in the 10th, Venus kendradi-pati Raja Yoga, Adhi Yoga) is offset by the wealth-yoga lord Venus sitting in the 12th with Rahu and a weakened combust-retrograde Mercury in the 2nd. The current Rahu–Venus–Saturn period activates both the gainful 10th and the loss-giving 12th at once. Net indication: solid earning capacity through profession with persistent leakage through expenditure — a genuinely mixed picture rather than a clean verdict.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-application-01-paraphrase","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":false,"error":"✖ Invalid input: expected array, received undefined\n  → at contradictions[1].evidence","extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"challenging\",\"confidence\":0.9,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies the seventh house (Libra), which signifies spouse and partnership.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/houses/6/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"For this Aries lagna, Saturn rules the 10th and 11th houses (Capricorn, Aquarius) — neither the ascendant nor the seventh.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/11/lord\"]},{\"claim\":\"Since Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh, no ownership exception applies; its placement in the seventh is treated as a challenging indication for marital happiness.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mitigating context exists but does not negate the indication: Saturn is exalted in Libra forming Sasa Yoga, and Venus, lord of the seventh, sits in the lagna aspecting its own house.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/yogas/1\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/aspects/Venus\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"No astrological placement 'guarantees' divorce. Saturn in the seventh is at most an indication of delay, seriousness, or friction in marriage, here softened by exaltation (Sasa Yoga).\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"This directly contradicts statement A's stated rule: the exception applies only when Saturn rules the ascendant or the seventh, which it does not here (/houses/9/lord, /houses/10/lord).\"}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart facts show Saturn placed in the seventh house (/placements/Saturn/house) while ruling Capricorn and Aquarius, i.e., the 10th and 11th, not the lagna or seventh (/houses/10/lord, /houses/11/lord). Under the stated rule, the ownership exception therefore does not apply, making option A correct as a challenging (not deterministic) indication. Option B is an overclaim no rule supports, and option C misstates the exception. Exaltation and Sasa Yoga plus the seventh lord Venus in the lagna provide mitigating support but do not change the polarity of the listed indications.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-application-01-paraphrase","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-01-paraphrase","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the seventh house and is a functional neutral/malefic here ruling houses 10 and 11, not the ascendant or the seventh; by the stated rule this counts as a challenging indication for marital happiness.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/10/lord"]},{"claim":"However, Saturn is exalted in Libra forming Sasa Yoga in a kendra, which mitigates the harshness of the placement.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/dignity","/yogas/1"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"No astrological placement 'guarantees' divorce; Saturn exalted in the seventh (Sasa Yoga) can indicate delay, maturity, or stability in marriage rather than dissolution.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/yogas/1"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The exception does not apply when Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh; here Saturn rules the 10th and 11th (/houses/10/lord), so the challenging reading of A stands.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/houses/10/lord"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Option A correctly states the rule: Saturn sits in house 7 (/placements/Saturn/house) while its lordships are Capricorn (10th) and Aquarius (11th) (/houses/10/lord), not Aries lagna or Libra seventh, so the challenging designation applies. Option B is an overclaim no rule supports, and option C misstates the exception's scope. The exaltation/Sasa Yoga is a mitigating factor but does not negate the listed indication."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.85,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies the seventh house and is a functional neutral/malefic here ruling houses 10 and 11, not the ascendant or the seventh; by the stated rule this counts as a challenging indication for marital happiness.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/10/lord\"]},{\"claim\":\"However, Saturn is exalted in Libra forming Sasa Yoga in a kendra, which mitigates the harshness of the placement.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/yogas/1\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"No astrological placement 'guarantees' divorce; Saturn exalted in the seventh (Sasa Yoga) can indicate delay, maturity, or stability in marriage rather than dissolution.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The exception does not apply when Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh; here Saturn rules the 10th and 11th (/houses/10/lord), so the challenging reading of A stands.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/houses/10/lord\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Option A correctly states the rule: Saturn sits in house 7 (/placements/Saturn/house) while its lordships are Capricorn (10th) and Aquarius (11th) (/houses/10/lord), not Aries lagna or Libra seventh, so the challenging designation applies. Option B is an overclaim no rule supports, and option C misstates the exception's scope. The exaltation/Sasa Yoga is a mitigating factor but does not negate the listed indication.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-application-01-evidence-order","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-01-evidence-order","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the seventh house (Libra) — a classic placement scrutinized for marital happiness.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/houses/6/occupants"]},{"claim":"Saturn rules Capricorn (10th) and Aquarius (11th), so it rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh; per rule A it is treated as a challenging indication for marriage.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/sign","/houses/9/lord","/houses/0/lord"]},{"claim":"Mitigating: Saturn is exalted in Libra and forms Sasa Yoga in a kendra, softening but not negating the challenge.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/dignity","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"Seventh lord Venus placed in the ascendant with mutual aspect to the seventh supports the marriage significator.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the seventh does not guarantee divorce; classical doctrine treats it as an affliction whose outcome depends on dignity, aspects, and dasha context.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/yogas/1"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The exception applies precisely when Saturn DOES rule the ascendant or seventh; here Saturn rules neither (/houses/9/lord = Saturn for 10th... i.e., lords of houses 1 and 7 are Mars and Venus), so no exception arises.","evidence":["/houses/0/lord","/houses/6/lord"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Statement A matches the chart exactly: natal Saturn sits in house 7 (/placements/Saturn/house) while ruling houses 10 and 11, not the 1st or 7th, so the stated rule renders it a challenging indication. Statement B is an overclaim (exaltation and Sasa Yoga mitigate). Statement C misstates the exception's condition. The applicable listed statements are negative-polarity, so conclusion = challenging."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"challenging\",\"confidence\":0.85,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies the seventh house (Libra) — a classic placement scrutinized for marital happiness.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/houses/6/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn rules Capricorn (10th) and Aquarius (11th), so it rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh; per rule A it is treated as a challenging indication for marriage.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/sign\",\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/0/lord\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mitigating: Saturn is exalted in Libra and forms Sasa Yoga in a kendra, softening but not negating the challenge.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"Seventh lord Venus placed in the ascendant with mutual aspect to the seventh supports the marriage significator.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn in the seventh does not guarantee divorce; classical doctrine treats it as an affliction whose outcome depends on dignity, aspects, and dasha context.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The exception applies precisely when Saturn DOES rule the ascendant or seventh; here Saturn rules neither (/houses/9/lord = Saturn for 10th... i.e., lords of houses 1 and 7 are Mars and Venus), so no exception arises.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/0/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Statement A matches the chart exactly: natal Saturn sits in house 7 (/placements/Saturn/house) while ruling houses 10 and 11, not the 1st or 7th, so the stated rule renders it a challenging indication. Statement B is an overclaim (exaltation and Sasa Yoga mitigate). Statement C misstates the exception's condition. The applicable listed statements are negative-polarity, so conclusion = challenging.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-application-01-evidence-order","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-01-evidence-order","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the seventh house of marriage","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/houses/6"]},{"claim":"Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh: lagna is Aries ruled by Mars, and the seventh is Libra ruled by Venus; Saturn rules houses 10-11","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/houses/6/lord","/houses/9/lord","/placements/Saturn/sign"]},{"claim":"Therefore the exception for Saturn-as-lagna-or-seventh-lord does not apply, and Saturn's presence in the seventh stands as a challenging indication for marital happiness per statement A","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"claim":"Statement B (guarantees divorce) is an overclaim — no rule guarantees divorce; Saturn here is also exalted forming Sasa Yoga, a mitigating dignity","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/dignity","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"Statement C is factually wrong: the exception requires Saturn to rule the ascendant or seventh, which it does not here","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/houses/6/lord"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart has Saturn in house 7 (/placements/Saturn/house), but its lordships are Capricorn (10) and Aquarius (11) (/houses/9/lord, /houses/10/lord) — not the Aries lagna or Libra seventh. So statement A's condition holds and Saturn-in-the-seventh is a challenging indication for marriage; B overclaims a guaranteed outcome (and ignores Saturn's exaltation/Sasa Yoga); C misstates the exception. Only A is applicable, giving a challenging polarity."},"extracted":"{\n \"case_id\": \"marriage-application-01-evidence-order\",\n \"domain\": \"marriage\",\n \"conclusion\": \"challenging\",\n \"confidence\": 0.85,\n \"selected_option_ids\": [\"A\"],\n \"factors\": [\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Saturn occupies the seventh house of marriage\",\n   \"effect\": \"neutral\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Saturn/house\", \"/houses/6\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh: lagna is Aries ruled by Mars, and the seventh is Libra ruled by Venus; Saturn rules houses 10-11\",\n   \"effect\": \"neutral\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/lagna/lord\", \"/houses/6/lord\", \"/houses/9/lord\", \"/placements/Saturn/sign\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Therefore the exception for Saturn-as-lagna-or-seventh-lord does not apply, and Saturn's presence in the seventh stands as a challenging indication for marital happiness per statement A\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Statement B (guarantees divorce) is an overclaim — no rule guarantees divorce; Saturn here is also exalted forming Sasa Yoga, a mitigating dignity\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\", \"/yogas/1\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Statement C is factually wrong: the exception requires Saturn to rule the ascendant or seventh, which it does not here\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/lagna/lord\", \"/houses/6/lord\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"contradictions\": [],\n \"missing_information\": [],\n \"rationale\": \"The chart has Saturn in house 7 (/placements/Saturn/house), but its lordships are Capricorn (10) and Aquarius (11) (/houses/9/lord, /houses/10/lord) — not the Aries lagna or Libra seventh. So statement A's condition holds and Saturn-in-the-seventh is a challenging indication for marriage; B overclaims a guaranteed outcome (and ignores Saturn's exaltation/Sasa Yoga); C misstates the exception. Only A is applicable, giving a challenging polarity.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-application-01-evidence-order","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-01-evidence-order","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.75,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the seventh house but rules neither the ascendant (Aries/Mars) nor the seventh (Libra/Venus) — its lordships are the 10th and 11th.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/houses/6/lord","/houses/9/lord","/houses/0/sign","/houses/6/sign"]},{"claim":"Under the stated rule, Saturn in the 7th without lordship of the 1st or 7th is a challenging indication for marital happiness; this matches option A.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"claim":"The exception clause cannot apply here since Saturn does not rule the lagna or 7th, so option C fails on this chart.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/houses/6/lord","/houses/9/lord"]},{"claim":"Option B's guarantee of divorce is an overclaim no classical rule supports; Saturn is also dignified (exalted) forming Sasa Yoga in a kendra, which softens any reading.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/dignity","/yogas"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"No rule guarantees divorce from Saturn's presence in the 7th; indications are probabilistic, not deterministic.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The exception to Saturn-in-7th challenging marital happiness applies only when Saturn rules the ascendant or seventh; here it rules the 10th and 11th.","evidence":["/houses/6/lord","/houses/9/lord"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Saturn sits in the natal 7th (/placements/Saturn/house) but lords the 10th and 11th houses (/houses/9/lord), not the 1st or 7th. Therefore statement A's rule fires: Saturn in the 7th without lordship of the ascendant or seventh is a challenging indication for marriage. Statement B overclaims certainty, and statement C misstates the exception's condition. Only A is applicable, so the conclusion takes its polarity: challenging. Note mitigating context (exalted Saturn, Sasa Yoga) that tempers but does not negate the listed rule."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"challenging\",\"confidence\":0.75,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies the seventh house but rules neither the ascendant (Aries/Mars) nor the seventh (Libra/Venus) — its lordships are the 10th and 11th.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/0/sign\",\"/houses/6/sign\"]},{\"claim\":\"Under the stated rule, Saturn in the 7th without lordship of the 1st or 7th is a challenging indication for marital happiness; this matches option A.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"The exception clause cannot apply here since Saturn does not rule the lagna or 7th, so option C fails on this chart.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/houses/9/lord\"]},{\"claim\":\"Option B's guarantee of divorce is an overclaim no classical rule supports; Saturn is also dignified (exalted) forming Sasa Yoga in a kendra, which softens any reading.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/yogas\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"No rule guarantees divorce from Saturn's presence in the 7th; indications are probabilistic, not deterministic.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The exception to Saturn-in-7th challenging marital happiness applies only when Saturn rules the ascendant or seventh; here it rules the 10th and 11th.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/houses/9/lord\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Saturn sits in the natal 7th (/placements/Saturn/house) but lords the 10th and 11th houses (/houses/9/lord), not the 1st or 7th. Therefore statement A's rule fires: Saturn in the 7th without lordship of the ascendant or seventh is a challenging indication for marriage. Statement B overclaims certainty, and statement C misstates the exception's condition. Only A is applicable, so the conclusion takes its polarity: challenging. Note mitigating context (exalted Saturn, Sasa Yoga) that tempers but does not negate the listed rule.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-01-paraphrase","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-01-paraphrase","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.6,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"7th lord Mercury placed in the 8th house separates the marriage karaka house from its lord, indicating turbulence, secrecy, or sudden disruptions in partnership","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"Mars sits in the 7th house in an enemy sign, giving Mangal-type friction, assertiveness and conflict potential with the spouse","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity"]},{"claim":"Sun also occupies the 7th, and Ketu aspects the 7th house — ego dominance and detachment colouring the partnership","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/aspects/Ketu"]},{"claim":"Venus (natural marriage karaka) is at the very end of Aries in the 5th, neutral in dignity and ruled by the afflicted Mars, so its capacity to bless marriage is diluted","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Venus/dignity","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"claim":"Raja yoga between 1st lord Jupiter and 7th/10th lord Mercury (mutual aspect) links self and spouse houses, supporting a significant committed union","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/1","/yogas/2"]},{"claim":"In D9, Venus is well-placed in Sagittarius in the 5th under Jupiter's dispositorship, strengthening inner marital harmony despite D1 afflictions","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/5"]},{"claim":"Jupiter transits the natal 7th conjunct natal Sun and Mars as of early 2026, activating the marriage house during Ketu–Mercury dasha (Mercury being the 7th lord)","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/dasha/current"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"factual","correction":"Mercury rules both the 7th (Gemini) and 10th; it is placed in the 8th house Cancer, not in the 7th.","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house"]}],"missing_information":["Navamsa 7th house occupants and its lord's strength for fuller D9 assessment","Upapada lagna not provided in chart facts","Exact timing windows would require checking dasha-antardasha periods of Venus/Mercury via timeline tools"],"rationale":"Marriage indications are genuinely mixed. Supporting: Raja yogas linking 1st lord Jupiter with 7th lord Mercury (/yogas), a strong exalted Saturn aspecting structure, and D9 Venus in a friendly sign (/vargas/D9). Challenging: combust Mars and Sun in the 7th (/placements/Sun/house, /placements/Mars/house), 7th lord Mercury debilitated-context in the 8th (/placements/Mercury/house), Ketu's aspect on the 7th, and natal Moon debilitated in the 12th suggesting emotional withdrawal (/placements/Moon). Current Venus mahadasha beginning 2026-07-29 (/dasha/upcoming/0) is a plausible activation window given Venus's role as karaka, but its D1 weakness tempers expectations."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-synthesis-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.6,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"7th lord Mercury placed in the 8th house separates the marriage karaka house from its lord, indicating turbulence, secrecy, or sudden disruptions in partnership\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars sits in the 7th house in an enemy sign, giving Mangal-type friction, assertiveness and conflict potential with the spouse\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Sun also occupies the 7th, and Ketu aspects the 7th house — ego dominance and detachment colouring the partnership\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/aspects/Ketu\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus (natural marriage karaka) is at the very end of Aries in the 5th, neutral in dignity and ruled by the afflicted Mars, so its capacity to bless marriage is diluted\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Raja yoga between 1st lord Jupiter and 7th/10th lord Mercury (mutual aspect) links self and spouse houses, supporting a significant committed union\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\",\"/yogas/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"In D9, Venus is well-placed in Sagittarius in the 5th under Jupiter's dispositorship, strengthening inner marital harmony despite D1 afflictions\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/5\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter transits the natal 7th conjunct natal Sun and Mars as of early 2026, activating the marriage house during Ketu–Mercury dasha (Mercury being the 7th lord)\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current\"],\"missing_information\":[],\"contradictions\":[],\"rationale\":\"The 7th house carries both promise and strain: raja yogas connecting lagna lord Jupiter with 7th lord Mercury and a dignified D9 Venus support a real marriage prospect, while Sun+Mars occupancy of the 7th, the 7th lord's placement in the 8th, Ketu's aspect, and a weak-end Venus indicate conflict, delay or disruption. Overall indication is mixed rather than clearly supportive.\"}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Mercury rules both the 7th (Gemini) and 10th; it is placed in the 8th house Cancer, not in the 7th.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"Navamsa 7th house occupants and its lord's strength for fuller D9 assessment\",\"Upapada lagna not provided in chart facts\",\"Exact timing windows would require checking dasha-antardasha periods of Venus/Mercury via timeline tools\"],\"rationale\":\"Marriage indications are genuinely mixed. Supporting: Raja yogas linking 1st lord Jupiter with 7th lord Mercury (/yogas), a strong exalted Saturn aspecting structure, and D9 Venus in a friendly sign (/vargas/D9). Challenging: combust Mars and Sun in the 7th (/placements/Sun/house, /placements/Mars/house), 7th lord Mercury debilitated-context in the 8th (/placements/Mercury/house), Ketu's aspect on the 7th, and natal Moon debilitated in the 12th suggesting emotional withdrawal (/placements/Moon). Current Venus mahadasha beginning 2026-07-29 (/dasha/upcoming/0) is a plausible activation window given Venus's role as karaka, but its D1 weakness tempers expectations.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-01-paraphrase","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":false,"error":"✖ Invalid option: expected one of \"factual\"|\"doctrinal\"|\"overclaim\"|\"omission\"\n  → at contradictions[0].error_type","extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-synthesis-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.6,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"7th house is heavily occupied and afflicted: Sun (lord of 9) and combust Mars sit in Gemini in the 7th, with Mars in enemy sign and Ketu aspecting the house — classic indicators of friction, ego clashes, or a dominating/dynamic spouse dynamic.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/combust\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"7th lord Mercury is placed in the 8th house in an enemy sign — the karaka of partnership falls into a dusthana, suggesting delays, secrecy, turbulence, or transformation through marriage.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/dignity\",\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus, karaka of marriage and lagna nakshatra lord (Purva Ashadha), sits in the 5th with Rahu — romantic inclination and love-marriage potential, but Rahu's conjunction can bring unconventional choices or infatuation-driven decisions.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/nakshatraLord\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Raja yoga between Mercury (7th lord) and Jupiter (1st lord) by mutual aspect links self and partnership; Jupiter also aspects the 10th from the 2nd, lending eventual dignity to married life despite a rocky start.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\",\"/yogas/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"Debilitated retrograde Jupiter (natural karaka of husband/wisdom) in the 2nd house of family weakens family harmony significations, though its retrogression and the single-lordship raja yoga (4th+1st lord) partially restore strength.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/yogas/0\"]},{\"claim\":\"D9 lagna Leo with Moon and Mercury in D9 lagna shows emotional engagement with the partner; however Mars in D9 8th and Jupiter in D9 12th indicate inner strain around intimacy and shared resources.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements\"],\"note\":\"\"}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"\",\"error_type\":\"\",\"correction\":\"\",\"evidence\":[]}],\"missing_information\":[\"Exact marriage timing cannot be fixed without checking dasha antardasha sequence against the client's actual marital history; no event dates are supplied.\",\"Upapada lagna / Jaimini marriage factors are not present in the facts.\",\"D9 navamsa dignity of individual grahas (exaltation/debilitation within D9) is not listed.\"],\"rationale\":\"Marriage indications are genuinely two-sided. The supporting side: a mutual-aspect raja yoga joining the 1st lord Jupiter and 7th lord Mercury ties personal identity to partnership constructively; Venus as marriage karaka is unafflicted by combustion in D1 and placed in the 5th (romance) though conjunct Rahu; the native's lagna nakshatra lord is Venus itself, making relationship themes central to life direction. The challenging side dominates structurally: the 7th holds Sun plus a combust, enemy-sign Mars and receives Ketu's aspect, pointing to conflict and heat in partnership; the 7th lord Mercury occupies the 8th (dusthana) in an enemy sign, indicating delay and turbulence; and the natural karaka of the spouse, Jupiter, is debilitated retrograde in the 2nd (family). The Vipareeta Raja Yoga (8th lord Moon in 12th) may convert some adversity into resilience after initial difficulty. Overall verdict: mixed — marriage is indicated and eventually stabilizing, but early friction, delays, or an unconventional path are strongly suggested. Timing would require correlating Venus/Jupiter/Rahu periods with biographical events.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-01-paraphrase","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-01-paraphrase","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.6,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"7th lord Mercury is placed in the 8th house, a dusthana, weakening the significations of partnership and suggesting turbulence or secrecy in marriage","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/houses/7/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"Mars sits in the 7th house with the Sun; Mars in the 7th is a classical mangal-dosha-type affliction and its enemy dignity plus combustion further strain marital harmony","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Mars/combust","/houses/7/occupants"]},{"claim":"Ketu aspects the 7th house, adding detachment or karmic distance to partnerships","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Ketu"]},{"claim":"A Raja Yoga forms between Mercury (lord of 7) and Jupiter (lagna lord) through mutual aspect, indicating that partnership can still elevate status despite the difficult placement","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"Jupiter, lagna lord and karaka of wisdom, aspects the 8th and via mutual aspect supports Mercury, offering protective grace to the 7th-lord axis","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/yogas/1","/yogas/2"]},{"claim":"Venus, karaka of marriage, is a benefic placed in the 5th (a trikona) ruling 6 and 11, linking romance to gains, though at the very last degree of Aries (gandanta-like edge) and aspected by Saturn and Ketu's house","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/degreeInSign","/houses/5/occupants","/houses/5/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"In D9, Venus is well placed in Sagittarius in the 5th from the Navamsa lagna, supporting inner strength of the marriage karaka","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/5"]},{"claim":"D9 lagna lord Sun sits in the D9 7th house in Saturn's sign, and Mars occupies the D9 8th — spouse-related matters carry weight but also friction","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/0","/vargas/D9/placements/2"]},{"claim":"Current Ketu–Mercury dasha runs to mid-2026 with Venus mahadasha starting 2026-07-29; Venus as marriage karaka and 11th lord suggests relationship matters become more prominent after mid-2026","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/dasha/current","/dasha/upcoming/0"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart shows a genuinely mixed marriage picture: heavy affliction of the 7th house itself (Sun+Mars occupation, Ketu aspect, 7th lord in the 8th) is counterbalanced by Raja Yoga links between the 1st, 7th and 10th lords, a decently placed Venus, and reasonable Venus placement in D9. The upcoming Venus mahadasha (from July 2026) makes this domain more active. No death/medical predictions made; indications are probabilistic, not certain."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-synthesis-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.6,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"7th lord Mercury is placed in the 8th house, a dusthana, weakening the significations of partnership and suggesting turbulence or secrecy in marriage\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/houses/7/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars sits in the 7th house with the Sun; Mars in the 7th is a classical mangal-dosha-type affliction and its enemy dignity plus combustion further strain marital harmony\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/placements/Mars/combust\",\"/houses/7/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu aspects the 7th house, adding detachment or karmic distance to partnerships\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Ketu\"]},{\"claim\":\"A Raja Yoga forms between Mercury (lord of 7) and Jupiter (lagna lord) through mutual aspect, indicating that partnership can still elevate status despite the difficult placement\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter, lagna lord and karaka of wisdom, aspects the 8th and via mutual aspect supports Mercury, offering protective grace to the 7th-lord axis\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/yogas/1\",\"/yogas/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus, karaka of marriage, is a benefic placed in the 5th (a trikona) ruling 6 and 11, linking romance to gains, though at the very last degree of Aries (gandanta-like edge) and aspected by Saturn and Ketu's house\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Venus/degreeInSign\",\"/houses/5/occupants\",\"/houses/5/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"In D9, Venus is well placed in Sagittarius in the 5th from the Navamsa lagna, supporting inner strength of the marriage karaka\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/5\"]},{\"claim\":\"D9 lagna lord Sun sits in the D9 7th house in Saturn's sign, and Mars occupies the D9 8th — spouse-related matters carry weight but also friction\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/0\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current Ketu–Mercury dasha runs to mid-2026 with Venus mahadasha starting 2026-07-29; Venus as marriage karaka and 11th lord suggests relationship matters become more prominent after mid-2026\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current\",\"/dasha/upcoming/0\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart shows a genuinely mixed marriage picture: heavy affliction of the 7th house itself (Sun+Mars occupation, Ketu aspect, 7th lord in the 8th) is counterbalanced by Raja Yoga links between the 1st, 7th and 10th lords, a decently placed Venus, and reasonable Venus placement in D9. The upcoming Venus mahadasha (from July 2026) makes this domain more active. No death/medical predictions made; indications are probabilistic, not certain.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-application-02-counterfactual","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-02-counterfactual","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"rationale":"The chart places Saturn in the eighth house (/placements/Saturn/house = 8), not the seventh. Statements A, B, and C all concern Saturn in the seventh, so none of them applies to this chart; D is correct. Conclusion polarity cannot be set from the listed statements since none is applicable."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-02-counterfactual\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"confidence\":0.9,\"rationale\":\"The chart places Saturn in the eighth house (/placements/Saturn/house = 8), not the seventh. Statements A, B, and C all concern Saturn in the seventh, so none of them applies to this chart; D is correct. Conclusion polarity cannot be set from the listed statements since none is applicable.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-01-evidence-order","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-01-evidence-order","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.65,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"7th house Gemini occupied by Sun and Mars; Mars is combust and in enemy sign — marital significators under pressure","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/combust","/placements/Sun/house"]},{"claim":"Venus (karaka of marriage) placed in the 5th with Rahu, at 29°12' — late-degree placement and Rahu conjunction add instability to romance","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/degreeInSign","/placements/Rahu/house"]},{"claim":"Mercury, lord of the 7th, sits in the 8th — spouse-significator house lord in a dusthana","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house"]},{"claim":"Raja Yoga: Mercury (lord of 7) mutually aspects Jupiter (lord of 1), giving partnership a dignified, supportive dimension","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"D9 lagna Leo with Moon and Mercury in D9 lagna; Venus strong in D9 (Sagittarius, dispositor Jupiter) supports inner strength of the marriage karaka","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D9/lagnaSign","/vargas/D9/placements/5"]},{"claim":"Ketu aspects the natal 7th house, adding detachment or karmic coloring to partnership","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Ketu/3","/houses/6/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Current Ketu–Mercury dasha (until 2026-07-29): antardasha lord Mercury is the 7th lord but sits in the 8th — relationship matters activated through a dusthana lens","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord","/dasha/current/antardasha/lord","/placements/Mercury/house"]},{"claim":"Transit Jupiter retrograde conjunct natal Sun and Mars in the natal 7th house (as of 2026-01-01), aspecting houses 4, 7, 8 — benefic activation of the marriage axis despite retrogression","effect":"supporting","evidence":["tool:transits_at#0/inNatalHouse","tool:transits_at#0/transiting"]},{"claim":"Upcoming Venus mahadasha from 2026-07-29 (Venus–Venus first): Venus is the marriage karaka and 6th/11th lord placed in the 5th — a period that typically brings relationship developments, though Venus's Rahu conjunction colors it","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/dasha/upcoming/0","/placements/Venus"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Mars in the 7th is often read as Kuja/Mangal-type affliction, but its combustion and enemy dignity already limit it; it should not be treated as an outright denial of marriage, only as friction.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/combust"]},{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"omission","correction":"A synthesis must weigh the supporting D9 Venus and Mercury–Jupiter Raja Yoga against the challenging 7th-lord-in-8th; neither alone determines outcome.","evidence":["/yogas/1"]}],"missing_information":["Exact navamsa strength/bala calculations for Venus and Mercury beyond dignity shown","Whether the native is currently married or seeking marriage (context for timing interpretation)","Specific pratyantardasha-level timing within the upcoming Venus mahadasha for event windows"],"rationale":"The chart shows a genuinely mixed marriage picture. Challenging factors: Sun+combust Mars in the 7th, 7th lord Mercury in the 8th, Venus conjunct Rahu at a very late degree in Aries, and Ketu's aspect on the 7th — indicating friction, karmic coloring, and delays or intensity in partnership. Supporting factors: Mercury–Jupiter mutual-aspect Raja Yoga linking the 1st and 7th lords, Venus well-placed in D9 Sagittarius, transit Jupiter activating the natal 7th in early 2026, and the Venus mahadasha beginning July 2026 which should foreground relationship matters. Net reading: marriage/partnership themes are strongly activated around the Ketu→Venus dasha transition (mid-2026 onward), but the union carries inherent tension requiring conscious management; outcome quality depends on how the Venus periods unfold rather than being fixed as either clearly favorable or adverse."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-synthesis-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.65,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"7th house Gemini occupied by Sun and Mars; Mars is combust and in enemy sign — marital significators under pressure\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/combust\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus (karaka of marriage) placed in the 5th with Rahu, at 29°12' — late-degree placement and Rahu conjunction add instability to romance\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Venus/degreeInSign\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury, lord of the 7th, sits in the 8th — spouse-significator house lord in a dusthana\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Raja Yoga: Mercury (lord of 7) mutually aspects Jupiter (lord of 1), giving partnership a dignified, supportive dimension\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"D9 lagna Leo with Moon and Mercury in D9 lagna; Venus strong in D9 (Sagittarius, dispositor Jupiter) supports inner strength of the marriage karaka\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/lagnaSign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu aspects the natal 7th house, adding detachment or karmic coloring to partnership\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Ketu/3\",\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current Ketu–Mercury dasha (until 2026-07-29): antardasha lord Mercury is the 7th lord but sits in the 8th — relationship matters activated through a dusthana lens\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord\",\"/dasha/current/antardasha/lord\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Transit Jupiter retrograde conjunct natal Sun and Mars in the natal 7th house (as of 2026-01-01), aspecting houses 4, 7, 8 — benefic activation of the marriage axis despite retrogression\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"tool:transits_at#0/inNatalHouse\",\"tool:transits_at#0/transiting\"]},{\"claim\":\"Upcoming Venus mahadasha from 2026-07-29 (Venus–Venus first): Venus is the marriage karaka and 6th/11th lord placed in the 5th — a period that typically brings relationship developments, though Venus's Rahu conjunction colors it\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/upcoming/0\",\"/placements/Venus\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Mars in the 7th is often read as Kuja/Mangal-type affliction, but its combustion and enemy dignity already limit it; it should not be treated as an outright denial of marriage, only as friction.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/combust\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"omission\",\"correction\":\"A synthesis must weigh the supporting D9 Venus and Mercury–Jupiter Raja Yoga against the challenging 7th-lord-in-8th; neither alone determines outcome.\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"Exact navamsa strength/bala calculations for Venus and Mercury beyond dignity shown\",\"Whether the native is currently married or seeking marriage (context for timing interpretation)\",\"Specific pratyantardasha-level timing within the upcoming Venus mahadasha for event windows\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart shows a genuinely mixed marriage picture. Challenging factors: Sun+combust Mars in the 7th, 7th lord Mercury in the 8th, Venus conjunct Rahu at a very late degree in Aries, and Ketu's aspect on the 7th — indicating friction, karmic coloring, and delays or intensity in partnership. Supporting factors: Mercury–Jupiter mutual-aspect Raja Yoga linking the 1st and 7th lords, Venus well-placed in D9 Sagittarius, transit Jupiter activating the natal 7th in early 2026, and the Venus mahadasha beginning July 2026 which should foreground relationship matters. Net reading: marriage/partnership themes are strongly activated around the Ketu→Venus dasha transition (mid-2026 onward), but the union carries inherent tension requiring conscious management; outcome quality depends on how the Venus periods unfold rather than being fixed as either clearly favorable or adverse.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-application-02-counterfactual","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-02-counterfactual","confidence":0.95,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"rationale":"The chart places Saturn in the 8th house (/placements/Saturn/house), not the seventh. Statements A-C all concern Saturn in the seventh house, so none is applicable to this chart; D is correct."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-02-counterfactual\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"confidence\":0.95,\"rationale\":\"The chart places Saturn in the 8th house (/placements/Saturn/house), not the seventh. Statements A-C all concern Saturn in the seventh house, so none is applicable to this chart; D is correct.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-01-evidence-order","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-01-evidence-order","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.7,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"7th house is occupied by Sun and Mars, with Mars combust — a heated, ego-charged 7th house that strains partnership harmony.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/6/occupants","/placements/Mars/combust","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Sun/house"]},{"claim":"7th lord Mercury sits in the 8th house and also rules the 10th — the marriage significator tied to dusthana themes of sudden change and transformation; Mercury in Cancer is also in enemy sign.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/dignity","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"Ketu aspects the 7th house, adding detachment or unconventional coloring to partnership.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Ketu"]},{"claim":"Venus (marriage karaka) placed in the 5th house of romance, though conjunct Rahu, which can amplify desire but add karmic/unusual elements to love matters.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Rahu/sign","/houses/4/occupants"]},{"claim":"Raja yoga between Mercury (lord of 7) and Jupiter (lord of 1) via mutual aspect links self and spouse houses — a strong supporting factor for eventual committed partnership.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas"]},{"claim":"Navamsa lagna Leo with Moon there; Venus dignified in Sagittarius D9 5th house — inner strength of the Venus karaka is good despite natal 'Neutral' dignity; Sun in D9 7th repeats the solar emphasis on spouse.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements","/vargas/D9/lagnaSign"]},{"claim":"Vipareeta Raja Yoga (Moon as 8th lord in 12th) offers resilience through crises but does not directly ease the 7th-house friction.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/yogas","/placements/Moon/house"]},{"claim":"Timing: current Ketu mahadasha (to 2026-07-29) is generally detachment-flavored; the incoming Venus mahadasha from mid-2026 (Venus–Venus to Nov 2029) activates the natural marriage karaka sitting in the romantic 5th — a favorable window for marriage or deepened partnership.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/dasha/current","/dasha/upcoming"]},{"claim":"Transits as of 2026-01-01: Jupiter transiting natal 7th (Gemini) conjunct natal Sun and Mars while aspecting natal 1st — benefic transit over the marriage house supports union attempts now; Saturn from Pisces (natal 4th) aspects houses 7 and 10, adding pressure/delay flavor.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["tool:transits_at#transits/contacts/4/inNatalHouse","/transits/contacts/6/aspectingNatalHouses"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"omission","correction":"A reading focusing only on Sun+Mars in the 7th would conclude a difficult marriage outright; it must be reconciled with the Mercury–Jupiter raja yoga linking lords of 1 and 7, and the strong Venus antardasha window ahead, yielding a mixed rather than challenging conclusion.","evidence":["/yogas","/dasha/upcoming"]}],"missing_information":["Exact birth-date confirmation of marital status/history to calibrate timing claims","Navamsa 7th lord strength assessment beyond raw placements (not provided)","Upapada lagna (Jaimini) not available in facts"],"rationale":"The 7th house carries clear affliction: Sun and Mars occupy it (Mars combust), its lord Mercury sits in the 8th in an enemy sign, and Ketu aspects it — all pointing to friction, ego clashes, or delay in partnership. This is materially offset by (a) the mutual-aspect raja yoga between Mercury (7th lord) and Jupiter (lagna lord), (b) Venus the karaka well-placed in the 5th, and (c) dignity of Venus in D9. Timing favors movement once Venus mahadasha begins 2026-07-29, reinforced by Jupiter's transit through the natal 7th in early 2026. Net judgment: mixed — marriage/partnership indications are real and supported by dasha and yoga, but quality requires managing heat and instability inherent in the 7th house."},"extracted":"{\n \"case_id\": \"marriage-synthesis-01-evidence-order\",\n \"domain\": \"marriage\",\n \"conclusion\": \"mixed\",\n \"confidence\": 0.7,\n \"selected_option_ids\": [],\n \"factors\": [\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"7th house is occupied by Sun and Mars, with Mars combust — a heated, ego-charged 7th house that strains partnership harmony.\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/houses/6/occupants\", \"/placements/Mars/combust\", \"/placements/Mars/house\", \"/placements/Sun/house\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"7th lord Mercury sits in the 8th house and also rules the 10th — the marriage significator tied to dusthana themes of sudden change and transformation; Mercury in Cancer is also in enemy sign.\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mercury/house\", \"/placements/Mercury/dignity\", \"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\", \"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Ketu aspects the 7th house, adding detachment or unconventional coloring to partnership.\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/aspects/Ketu\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Venus (marriage karaka) placed in the 5th house of romance, though conjunct Rahu, which can amplify desire but add karmic/unusual elements to love matters.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Venus/house\", \"/placements/Rahu/sign\", \"/houses/4/occupants\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Raja yoga between Mercury (lord of 7) and Jupiter (lord of 1) via mutual aspect links self and spouse houses — a strong supporting factor for eventual committed partnership.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/yogas\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Navamsa lagna Leo with Moon there; Venus dignified in Sagittarius D9 5th house — inner strength of the Venus karaka is good despite natal 'Neutral' dignity; Sun in D9 7th repeats the solar emphasis on spouse.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/vargas/D9/placements\", \"/vargas/D9/lagnaSign\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Vipareeta Raja Yoga (Moon as 8th lord in 12th) offers resilience through crises but does not directly ease the 7th-house friction.\",\n   \"effect\": \"neutral\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/yogas\", \"/placements/Moon/house\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Timing: current Ketu mahadasha (to 2026-07-29) is generally detachment-flavored; the incoming Venus mahadasha from mid-2026 (Venus–Venus to Nov 2029) activates the natural marriage karaka sitting in the romantic 5th — a favorable window for marriage or deepened partnership.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/dasha/current\", \"/dasha/upcoming\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Transits as of 2026-01-01: Jupiter transiting natal 7th (Gemini) conjunct natal Sun and Mars while aspecting natal 1st — benefic transit over the marriage house supports union attempts now; Saturn from Pisces (natal 4th) aspects houses 7 and 10, adding pressure/delay flavor.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"tool:transits_at#transits/contacts/4/inNatalHouse\", \"/transits/contacts/6/aspectingNatalHouses\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"contradictions\": [\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"S1\",\n   \"error_type\": \"omission\",\n   \"correction\": \"A reading focusing only on Sun+Mars in the 7th would conclude a difficult marriage outright; it must be reconciled with the Mercury–Jupiter raja yoga linking lords of 1 and 7, and the strong Venus antardasha window ahead, yielding a mixed rather than challenging conclusion.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/yogas\", \"/dasha/upcoming\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"missing_information\": [\n  \"Exact birth-date confirmation of marital status/history to calibrate timing claims\",\n  \"Navamsa 7th lord strength assessment beyond raw placements (not provided)\",\n  \"Upapada lagna (Jaimini) not available in facts\"\n ],\n \"rationale\": \"The 7th house carries clear affliction: Sun and Mars occupy it (Mars combust), its lord Mercury sits in the 8th in an enemy sign, and Ketu aspects it — all pointing to friction, ego clashes, or delay in partnership. This is materially offset by (a) the mutual-aspect raja yoga between Mercury (7th lord) and Jupiter (lagna lord), (b) Venus the karaka well-placed in the 5th, and (c) dignity of Venus in D9. Timing favors movement once Venus mahadasha begins 2026-07-29, reinforced by Jupiter's transit through the natal 7th in early 2026. Net judgment: mixed — marriage/partnership indications are real and supported by dasha and yoga, but quality requires managing heat and instability inherent in the 7th house.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-application-01-paraphrase","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-01-paraphrase","domain":"health","conclusion":"insufficient","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"factors":[{"claim":"Second lord Venus is placed in the ninth house (Sagittarius), in neutral dignity","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/sign","/placements/Venus/dignity"]},{"claim":"A single placement of the 2nd lord in the 9th does not, by itself, support a claim of early-life weak health improving later, nor uniformly poor health throughout life","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house"]},{"claim":"No chart rule diagnoses a specific illness; health indications would require assessment of lagna, its lord, 6th/8th houses and their occupants (e.g., /houses/8/occupants)","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/houses/6/significations","/houses/8/significations"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Options A and B both assert health trajectories ('weaker early/better later' or 'uniformly poor throughout') supposedly flowing from the second lord's placement in the ninth. While the placement itself is factual — Venus is lord of house 2 and sits in house 9 (/placements/Venus/house) — no such time-differentiated or lifelong health rule follows from it as stated, so neither A nor B is established. Option C is doctrinally incorrect on principle: Jyotish placements indicate tendencies, not specific illness diagnoses, and this evaluation must not diagnose medical conditions. Therefore none of A–C holds, making D the only defensible selection."},"extracted":"{\n \"case_id\":\"health-application-01-paraphrase\",\n \"domain\":\"health\",\n \"conclusion\":\"insufficient\",\n \"confidence\":0.85,\n \"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\n \"factors\":[\n  {\n   \"claim\":\"Second lord Venus is placed in the ninth house (Sagittarius), in neutral dignity\",\n   \"effect\":\"neutral\",\n   \"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Venus/sign\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\":\"A single placement of the 2nd lord in the 9th does not, by itself, support a claim of early-life weak health improving later, nor uniformly poor health throughout life\",\n   \"effect\":\"neutral\",\n   \"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\":\"No chart rule diagnoses a specific illness; health indications would require assessment of lagna, its lord, 6th/8th houses and their occupants (e.g., /houses/8/occupants)\",\n   \"effect\":\"neutral\",\n   \"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/significations\",\"/houses/8/significations\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"contradictions\":[],\n \"missing_information\":[],\n \"rationale\":\"Options A and B both assert health trajectories ('weaker early/better later' or 'uniformly poor throughout') supposedly flowing from the second lord's placement in the ninth. While the placement itself is factual — Venus is lord of house 2 and sits in house 9 (/placements/Venus/house) — no such time-differentiated or lifelong health rule follows from it as stated, so neither A nor B is established. Option C is doctrinally incorrect on principle: Jyotish placements indicate tendencies, not specific illness diagnoses, and this evaluation must not diagnose medical conditions. Therefore none of A–C holds, making D the only defensible selection.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-application-01-paraphrase","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-01-paraphrase","domain":"health","conclusion":"insufficient","confidence":0.7,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"factors":[{"claim":"The second lord is Venus in the ninth house, a trikona — this placement itself is generally considered auspicious and gives no inherent indication of uniformly poor health.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"Statement A asserts an early-poor/later-better timeline for health, but no such temporal split is derivable from the placement /placements/Venus/house = 9 or from any stated doctrine in the chart facts.","effect":"mixed","evidence":[]},{"claim":"Statement B's claim of uniformly poor health contradicts Venus being a natural benefic occupying a trikona (house 9), aspected by its own dispositor Jupiter (/aspects/Jupiter includes house 9).","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/vargas/D9/placements"]},{"claim":"Statement C claims diagnostic power for a specific illness; no classical rule of 'second lord in ninth' diagnoses named diseases, and the chart facts contain no such attribution.","effect":"challenging","evidence":[]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"A benefic second lord in a trikona cannot support a blanket reading of lifelong poor health.","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/houses/9/significations"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"House-placement rules indicate areas of life affected, not specific medical diagnoses.","evidence":["/reference/houseSignifications"]}],"missing_information":["The exact textual source and wording of the 'stated rule' linking second lord in the ninth to health timing, needed to validate option A","Birth-time rectification quality and any actual health history to corroborate any timing claim"],"rationale":"Venus (lord of 2) sits in house 9, a trikona, aspected by Jupiter — an ordinarily favorable configuration. Nothing in the chart facts establishes an early-vs-late deterioration/improvement pattern (A), a verdict of lifelong ill health (B, contradicted by the dignified benefic placement), or disease-diagnostic power (C). Without the source text of the rule itself, none of A–C can be confirmed from the computed evidence, so D applies."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"insufficient\",\"confidence\":0.7,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The second lord is Venus in the ninth house, a trikona — this placement itself is generally considered auspicious and gives no inherent indication of uniformly poor health.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"Statement A asserts an early-poor/later-better timeline for health, but no such temporal split is derivable from the placement /placements/Venus/house = 9 or from any stated doctrine in the chart facts.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[]},{\"claim\":\"Statement B's claim of uniformly poor health contradicts Venus being a natural benefic occupying a trikona (house 9), aspected by its own dispositor Jupiter (/aspects/Jupiter includes house 9).\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements\"]},{\"claim\":\"Statement C claims diagnostic power for a specific illness; no classical rule of 'second lord in ninth' diagnoses named diseases, and the chart facts contain no such attribution.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"A benefic second lord in a trikona cannot support a blanket reading of lifelong poor health.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"House-placement rules indicate areas of life affected, not specific medical diagnoses.\",\"evidence\":[\"/reference/houseSignifications\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"The exact textual source and wording of the 'stated rule' linking second lord in the ninth to health timing, needed to validate option A\",\"Birth-time rectification quality and any actual health history to corroborate any timing claim\"],\"rationale\":\"Venus (lord of 2) sits in house 9, a trikona, aspected by Jupiter — an ordinarily favorable configuration. Nothing in the chart facts establishes an early-vs-late deterioration/improvement pattern (A), a verdict of lifelong ill health (B, contradicted by the dignified benefic placement), or disease-diagnostic power (C). Without the source text of the rule itself, none of A–C can be confirmed from the computed evidence, so D applies.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-01-evidence-order","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-01-evidence-order","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.6,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"7th house occupied by Sun and combust Mars — malefic occupation of the spouse bhava, Mars combustion weakens the karaka of marital drive and indicates friction/assertion issues in partnership","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/6","/placements/Mars/combust"]},{"claim":"7th lord Mercury placed in the 8th (dusthana) — the karaka-of-spouse-house lord falls into a house of sudden events and transformation, indicating instability or delay themes in marriage","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/houses/7/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"Ketu aspects the 7th house — nodal influence adds detachment or unconventional coloring to partnership","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Ketu","/houses/6/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Raja Yoga between Mercury (lord 7 and 10) and Jupiter (lagna lord) by mutual aspect — a strong mitigating factor linking self and partnership, capable of elevating marriage once formed","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/1","/yogas/2"]},{"claim":"Venus (natural karaka of marriage) in the 5th with Rahu, aspecting the 11th — romance-oriented placement with amplification/desire via Rahu; Venus aspects gains, supporting fulfillment of relationship desires but Rahu adds volatility","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/houses/4/aspectedBy","/aspects/Venus"]},{"claim":"D9 shows Venus in the 5th of Navamsa (Sagittarius, dispositor Jupiter strong in own-sign context) — inner strength of the marriage karaka is good despite D1 complications","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/5"]},{"claim":"D9 lagna Leo with Moon in D9 lagna and Saturn in D9 11th (Gemini) — emotional investment in the marriage sphere is present; Saturn's role suggests maturity/late-blooming tone","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/1","/vargas/D9/placements/2","/vargas/D9/placements/6"]},{"claim":"Current dasha is Ketu MD–Mercury AD (to 2026-07-29); Ketu is the graha aspecting the 7th natally, while antardasha lord Mercury is the 7th lord in the 8th — an activating but turbulent period for marital matters","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord","/dasha/current/antardasha/lord"]},{"claim":"Venus–Venus mahadasha begins 2026-07-29 (/dasha/upcoming/0) — Venus as mahadasha lord, being the natural marriage karaka placed in the 5th, marks a distinctly more favorable window for marriage than the closing Ketu period","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/dasha/upcoming/0"]},{"claim":"Transit Jupiter retrograde sits in the natal 7th conjunct natal Sun and Mars (as-of 2026-01-01) — benefic transit through the spouse bhava supports marriage-related developments near this window, though retrogression suggests revisiting/reworking arrangements","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/transits/contacts/4"]},{"claim":"Vipareeta Raja Yoga (8th lord Moon in the 12th) — converts a dusthana weakness into resilience; sudden disruptions tend to resolve without lasting damage","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/3","/placements/Moon/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Malefic occupation of the 7th (Sun + combust Mars) does not deny marriage; it colors its quality. The Mercury–Jupiter Raja Yoga and dignified D9 Venus counterbalance it.","evidence":["/yogas/1","/vargas/D9/placements/5"]},{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"omission","correction":"Any synthesis omitting the dasha sequence is incomplete: Ketu MD ends mid-2026 and Venus MD (karaka of marriage) runs through 2039, materially changing the outlook across time.","evidence":["/dasha/upcoming/0"]}],"missing_information":["Exact timing question (already-married vs. seeking marriage) not specified","Navamsa 7th lord condition and upapada lagna not provided in chart facts","Dignity of Venus in D9 relative to combustion/affliction in navamsa-specific terms"],"rationale":"Marriage indications are genuinely mixed. The D1 7th house carries real afflictions: Sun and combust Mars occupy it (/houses/6/occupants, /placements/Mars/combust), its lord Mercury sits in the 8th (/placements/Mercury/house), and Ketu aspects it (/aspects/Ketu). Against this stand a Mercury–Jupiter mutual-aspect Raja Yoga directly involving the 7th lord (/yogas/1), Venus the marriage karaka well-placed in the 5th with good D9 strength (/vargas/D9/placements/5), and a Vipareeta Raja Yoga buffering dusthana damage (/yogas/3). Timing favors improvement after Ketu MD closes on 2026-07-29, when Venus–Venus begins (/dasha/upcoming/0), reinforced by transit Jupiter currently in the natal 7th (/transits/contacts/4). Net: marriage/partnership matters are achievable and likely to stabilize from late 2026 onward, but with friction, unconventional elements, and a need for deliberate management during the current Ketu–Mercury window."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-synthesis-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.6,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"7th house occupied by Sun and combust Mars — malefic occupation of the spouse bhava, Mars combustion weakens the karaka of marital drive and indicates friction/assertion issues in partnership\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6\",\"/placements/Mars/combust\"]},{\"claim\":\"7th lord Mercury placed in the 8th (dusthana) — the karaka-of-spouse-house lord falls into a house of sudden events and transformation, indicating instability or delay themes in marriage\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/houses/7/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu aspects the 7th house — nodal influence adds detachment or unconventional coloring to partnership\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Ketu\",\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"Raja Yoga between Mercury (lord 7 and 10) and Jupiter (lagna lord) by mutual aspect — a strong mitigating factor linking self and partnership, capable of elevating marriage once formed\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\",\"/yogas/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus (natural karaka of marriage) in the 5th with Rahu, aspecting the 11th — romance-oriented placement with amplification/desire via Rahu; Venus aspects gains, supporting fulfillment of relationship desires but Rahu adds volatility\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/houses/4/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Venus\"]},{\"claim\":\"D9 shows Venus in the 5th of Navamsa (Sagittarius, dispositor Jupiter strong in own-sign context) — inner strength of the marriage karaka is good despite D1 complications\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/5\"]},{\"claim\":\"D9 lagna Leo with Moon in D9 lagna and Saturn in D9 11th (Gemini) — emotional investment in the marriage sphere is present; Saturn's role suggests maturity/late-blooming tone\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/1\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/2\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/6\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current dasha is Ketu MD–Mercury AD (to 2026-07-29); Ketu is the graha aspecting the 7th natally, while antardasha lord Mercury is the 7th lord in the 8th — an activating but turbulent period for marital matters\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord\",\"/dasha/current/antardasha/lord\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus–Venus mahadasha begins 2026-07-29 (/dasha/upcoming/0) — Venus as mahadasha lord, being the natural marriage karaka placed in the 5th, marks a distinctly more favorable window for marriage than the closing Ketu period\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/upcoming/0\"]},{\"claim\":\"Transit Jupiter retrograde sits in the natal 7th conjunct natal Sun and Mars (as-of 2026-01-01) — benefic transit through the spouse bhava supports marriage-related developments near this window, though retrogression suggests revisiting/reworking arrangements\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/transits/contacts/4\"]},{\"claim\":\"Vipareeta Raja Yoga (8th lord Moon in the 12th) — converts a dusthana weakness into resilience; sudden disruptions tend to resolve without lasting damage\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/3\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Malefic occupation of the 7th (Sun + combust Mars) does not deny marriage; it colors its quality. The Mercury–Jupiter Raja Yoga and dignified D9 Venus counterbalance it.\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"omission\",\"correction\":\"Any synthesis omitting the dasha sequence is incomplete: Ketu MD ends mid-2026 and Venus MD (karaka of marriage) runs through 2039, materially changing the outlook across time.\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/upcoming/0\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"Exact timing question (already-married vs. seeking marriage) not specified\",\"Navamsa 7th lord condition and upapada lagna not provided in chart facts\",\"Dignity of Venus in D9 relative to combustion/affliction in navamsa-specific terms\"],\"rationale\":\"Marriage indications are genuinely mixed. The D1 7th house carries real afflictions: Sun and combust Mars occupy it (/houses/6/occupants, /placements/Mars/combust), its lord Mercury sits in the 8th (/placements/Mercury/house), and Ketu aspects it (/aspects/Ketu). Against this stand a Mercury–Jupiter mutual-aspect Raja Yoga directly involving the 7th lord (/yogas/1), Venus the marriage karaka well-placed in the 5th with good D9 strength (/vargas/D9/placements/5), and a Vipareeta Raja Yoga buffering dusthana damage (/yogas/3). Timing favors improvement after Ketu MD closes on 2026-07-29, when Venus–Venus begins (/dasha/upcoming/0), reinforced by transit Jupiter currently in the natal 7th (/transits/contacts/4). Net: marriage/partnership matters are achievable and likely to stabilize from late 2026 onward, but with friction, unconventional elements, and a need for deliberate management during the current Ketu–Mercury window.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-application-01-paraphrase","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-01-paraphrase","confidence":0.85,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"rationale":"In this chart the 2nd lord is Venus, placed in the 9th house (/placements/Venus/house = 9; /houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse confirms Venus rules Taurus, the 2nd). However, the placement of the 2nd lord in the 9th is not a recognized standalone diagnostic rule for health timing or for diagnosing illness. Option B's claim of uniformly poor health contradicts even option A's own premise and has no doctrinal basis here. Option C overclaims: no Jyotish rule 'diagnoses' a specific illness, and the chart facts list no disease-specific evidence tied to this placement. Option A asserts a time-graded health outcome that the stated rule does not establish either. Therefore none of A–C is supported by the stated rule combined with this chart."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-01-paraphrase\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"confidence\":0.85,\"rationale\":\"In this chart the 2nd lord is Venus, placed in the 9th house (/placements/Venus/house = 9; /houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse confirms Venus rules Taurus, the 2nd). However, the placement of the 2nd lord in the 9th is not a recognized standalone diagnostic rule for health timing or for diagnosing illness. Option B's claim of uniformly poor health contradicts even option A's own premise and has no doctrinal basis here. Option C overclaims: no Jyotish rule 'diagnoses' a specific illness, and the chart facts list no disease-specific evidence tied to this placement. Option A asserts a time-graded health outcome that the stated rule does not establish either. Therefore none of A–C is supported by the stated rule combined with this chart.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"marriage-application-02-counterfactual","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-02-counterfactual","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"insufficient","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the eighth house, not the seventh, so statements about Saturn in the seventh are not applicable to this chart.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"A","error_type":"omission","correction":"Statement A presumes Saturn in the seventh; the chart shows Saturn in the eighth house, so the rule does not apply as stated.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"omission","correction":"Same premise error: Saturn is not in the seventh house in this chart.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Besides the house mismatch, no classical rule establishes that Saturn necessarily ends a marriage; such certainty is an overclaim regardless of placement.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The only computed fact is /placements/Saturn/house = 8. Since Saturn is in the eighth rather than the seventh house, statements A-C do not apply to this chart; D is selected and the conclusion is insufficient for a marriage polarity assessment from the listed statements alone."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-02-counterfactual\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"insufficient\",\"confidence\":0.9,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies the eighth house, not the seventh, so statements about Saturn in the seventh are not applicable to this chart.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"A\",\"error_type\":\"omission\",\"correction\":\"Statement A presumes Saturn in the seventh; the chart shows Saturn in the eighth house, so the rule does not apply as stated.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"omission\",\"correction\":\"Same premise error: Saturn is not in the seventh house in this chart.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Besides the house mismatch, no classical rule establishes that Saturn necessarily ends a marriage; such certainty is an overclaim regardless of placement.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The only computed fact is /placements/Saturn/house = 8. Since Saturn is in the eighth rather than the seventh house, statements A-C do not apply to this chart; D is selected and the conclusion is insufficient for a marriage polarity assessment from the listed statements alone.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-application-01-evidence-order","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-01-evidence-order","domain":"health","conclusion":"insufficient","confidence":0.7,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"factors":[],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"A single house placement (2nd lord Venus in the 9th) does not establish a temporal trajectory of health (early-poor/late-good) nor a uniform lifelong condition, and no Jyotish rule of this kind diagnoses a specific illness.","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart fact is only that Venus, lord of the 2nd (Taurus), occupies the 9th (Sagittarius) (/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse = 9; /placements/Venus/house = 9). Statement A asserts a specific early-vs-late health trajectory, statement B a uniformly poor lifelong health, and statement C a diagnostic power for specific illness — none of these follow from the stated placement rule alone; such rules indicate general tendencies at most, never disease diagnosis. Hence A–C are not established and option D applies. With no applicable affirmative statement, no supportive/challenging polarity can be set from the listed options."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"insufficient\",\"confidence\":0.7,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"factors\":[],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"A single house placement (2nd lord Venus in the 9th) does not establish a temporal trajectory of health (early-poor/late-good) nor a uniform lifelong condition, and no Jyotish rule of this kind diagnoses a specific illness.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart fact is only that Venus, lord of the 2nd (Taurus), occupies the 9th (Sagittarius) (/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse = 9; /placements/Venus/house = 9). Statement A asserts a specific early-vs-late health trajectory, statement B a uniformly poor lifelong health, and statement C a diagnostic power for specific illness — none of these follow from the stated placement rule alone; such rules indicate general tendencies at most, never disease diagnosis. Hence A–C are not established and option D applies. With no applicable affirmative statement, no supportive/challenging polarity can be set from the listed options.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-application-01-evidence-order","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-01-evidence-order","domain":"health","conclusion":"insufficient","confidence":0.8,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"factors":[{"claim":"The second lord (Venus) is placed in the ninth house, but the stated rule does not support any specific health timeline or diagnosis.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"claim":"Statement B is contradicted: the chart shows supportive yogas (Gaja Kesari, Adhi Yoga, Raja/Dhana yogas) that would not be consistent with 'uniformly poor health'.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/yogas"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"A","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Nothing in the rule 'second lord in the ninth' establishes an early-weak/later-better health trajectory; the second house concerns wealth/family/speech and its lord's placement alone does not yield this timeline.","evidence":["/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"'Uniformly poor health' is not a standard reading of second-lord-in-ninth; benefic Venus (/placements/Venus/isBenefic) in the 9th trine is generally benign for this claim.","evidence":["/placements/Venus"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"House/lord placements do not diagnose specific illnesses; Jyotish rules of this kind indicate general areas of vulnerability at most.","evidence":[]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Venus, lord of the 2nd, sits in the 9th (/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse = 9). None of statements A–C follows from that placement: A invents an unsupported time trend, B overstates it as uniformly poor health despite the chart's strong benefic yogas, and C wrongly treats the rule as diagnostic of a specific illness. Therefore only option D applies."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"insufficient\",\"confidence\":0.8,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The second lord (Venus) is placed in the ninth house, but the stated rule does not support any specific health timeline or diagnosis.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Statement B is contradicted: the chart shows supportive yogas (Gaja Kesari, Adhi Yoga, Raja/Dhana yogas) that would not be consistent with 'uniformly poor health'.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"A\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Nothing in the rule 'second lord in the ninth' establishes an early-weak/later-better health trajectory; the second house concerns wealth/family/speech and its lord's placement alone does not yield this timeline.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"'Uniformly poor health' is not a standard reading of second-lord-in-ninth; benefic Venus (/placements/Venus/isBenefic) in the 9th trine is generally benign for this claim.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"House/lord placements do not diagnose specific illnesses; Jyotish rules of this kind indicate general areas of vulnerability at most.\",\"evidence\":[]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Venus, lord of the 2nd, sits in the 9th (/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse = 9). None of statements A–C follows from that placement: A invents an unsupported time trend, B overstates it as uniformly poor health despite the chart's strong benefic yogas, and C wrongly treats the rule as diagnostic of a specific illness. Therefore only option D applies.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-application-01-evidence-order","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-01-evidence-order","domain":"health","conclusion":"insufficient","confidence":0.7,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"factors":[{"claim":"The second house relates to food/intake and family resources rather than being the primary health significator; the 6th/8th houses and lagna are the main health axes here.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/reference/houseSignifications/2","/reference/houseSignifications/6","/reference/houseSignifications/1"]},{"claim":"Venus (lord of the 2nd, Taurus) sits in the 9th in Sagittarius, unafflicted and non-combust — a benefic in a trikona, which at most gives a mildly supportive indication for vitality, with no time-phased or diagnostic content.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/sign","/placements/Venus/dignity","/placements/Venus/combust"]},{"claim":"Statement A's 'weaker early / better later' trajectory is not derivable from a static natal placement alone without dasha sequencing tied to that specific rule.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord"]},{"claim":"Statements B (uniformly poor health) and C (diagnosing a specific illness) are contradicted by both the chart and the scope of any such placement rule.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Jupiter/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"A second-lord-in-ninth placement does not by itself establish a time-graded health pattern; that requires additional reasoning (e.g., dasha activation) beyond the stated rule.","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"No single placement rule establishes uniformly poor health throughout life; the chart also contains supportive factors such as exalted Moon and Gaja Kesari Yoga.","evidence":["/placements/Moon/dignity"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Jyotish rules indicate tendencies and domains of vulnerability; they do not diagnose specific illnesses.","evidence":["/reference/houseSignifications/6"]}],"missing_information":["Exact wording/source of the 'stated rule' being evaluated"],"rationale":"The chart fact relevant to all three statements is Venus, lord of the 2nd (/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse), placed in the 9th (/placements/Venus/house). Statement A asserts a temporal trajectory (poor early health, improving later) that cannot be read off a single static placement; it would require dasha-linked argumentation not supplied by the stated rule. Statement B ('uniformly poor health') is even stronger and equally unsupported, and is further undercut by chart strengths like the exalted Moon in Taurus (/placements/Moon/dignity) and Gaja Kesari Yoga (/yogas/0). Statement C overclaims diagnostic power for what is an indicative rule. Since A, B, and C each fail on evidence-order grounds, option D applies, and the conclusion polarity is insufficient."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"insufficient\",\"confidence\":0.7,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The second house relates to food/intake and family resources rather than being the primary health significator; the 6th/8th houses and lagna are the main health axes here.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/reference/houseSignifications/2\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/6\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus (lord of the 2nd, Taurus) sits in the 9th in Sagittarius, unafflicted and non-combust — a benefic in a trikona, which at most gives a mildly supportive indication for vitality, with no time-phased or diagnostic content.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Venus/sign\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/placements/Venus/combust\"]},{\"claim\":\"Statement A's 'weaker early / better later' trajectory is not derivable from a static natal placement alone without dasha sequencing tied to that specific rule.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord\"]},{\"claim\":\"Statements B (uniformly poor health) and C (diagnosing a specific illness) are contradicted by both the chart and the scope of any such placement rule.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"A second-lord-in-ninth placement does not by itself establish a time-graded health pattern; that requires additional reasoning (e.g., dasha activation) beyond the stated rule.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"No single placement rule establishes uniformly poor health throughout life; the chart also contains supportive factors such as exalted Moon and Gaja Kesari Yoga.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/dignity\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Jyotish rules indicate tendencies and domains of vulnerability; they do not diagnose specific illnesses.\",\"evidence\":[\"/reference/houseSignifications/6\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"Exact wording/source of the 'stated rule' being evaluated\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart fact relevant to all three statements is Venus, lord of the 2nd (/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse), placed in the 9th (/placements/Venus/house). Statement A asserts a temporal trajectory (poor early health, improving later) that cannot be read off a single static placement; it would require dasha-linked argumentation not supplied by the stated rule. Statement B ('uniformly poor health') is even stronger and equally unsupported, and is further undercut by chart strengths like the exalted Moon in Taurus (/placements/Moon/dignity) and Gaja Kesari Yoga (/yogas/0). Statement C overclaims diagnostic power for what is an indicative rule. Since A, B, and C each fail on evidence-order grounds, option D applies, and the conclusion polarity is insufficient.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-synthesis-01-paraphrase","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-01-paraphrase","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.55,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Lagna lord Saturn is strong by placement in the 11th (a house of gains) and forms a Dhana/Raja yoga with Mars there, giving underlying stamina and recuperative resilience.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Mars/house","/yogas/4"]},{"claim":"Budha-Aditya Yoga in the lagna supports vitality, mental alertness and self-possession.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Mercury/house","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"Jupiter aspects the 2nd and 4th houses from the 8th; Gaja Kesari Yoga from the Moon lends emotional stability and protection to diet/family and home life.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/aspects/Jupiter","/yogas/0"]},{"claim":"The Moon, a benefic and significator of fluids/mind, sits in the 2nd but is combust — indicating sensitivity of mind/emotional health and possible issues around diet or speech.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/combust"]},{"claim":"Saturn in enemy sign Scorpio in the 11th casts its aspect onto the lagna itself, weighing on the body and general vitality over time.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/dignity","/houses/10/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Mars aspects the 6th house of disease while Rahu/Ketu axis afflicts the 5th (and Ketu aspects the 11th), pointing to episodic acute complaints and vulnerability around digestion/acidity-type Mars-Saturn-Scorpio signatures.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Mars","/placements/Rahu/house","/placements/Ketu/house"]},{"claim":"Current dasha Mercury–Jupiter–Venus: Jupiter as 12th lord placed in the 8th (Vipareeta position) can bring periods of low energy or hospital-type experiences even when outcomes ultimately turn favourable.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current","/yogas/5"]},{"claim":"Transit Saturn conjunct natal Venus in Pisces and transiting Ketu on natal Jupiter in the 8th suggest a phase requiring extra care with chronic/slow-developing matters; however gochara Saturn is at 12 from the Moon, i.e., sade sati has concluded, easing long-term pressure.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["tool:transits_at#transits/contacts/6","tool:transits_at#transits/contacts/8","/transits/saturnFromMoon"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart shows a resilient constitutional base (lagna lord strong in the 11th, Budha-Aditya in lagna) offset by a combust Moon, Saturn's aspect on the lagna, and malefic influence on the 5th/6th axis. The present Mercury–Jupiter–Venus dasha with Jupiter as 12th-lord-in-8th, combined with transit Ketu over natal Jupiter, argues for caution rather than alarm. Overall reading: mixed, with supportive fundamentals."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-synthesis-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.55,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Lagna lord Saturn is strong by placement in the 11th (a house of gains) and forms a Dhana/Raja yoga with Mars there, giving underlying stamina and recuperative resilience.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/yogas/4\"]},{\"claim\":\"Budha-Aditya Yoga in the lagna supports vitality, mental alertness and self-possession.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter aspects the 2nd and 4th houses from the 8th; Gaja Kesari Yoga from the Moon lends emotional stability and protection to diet/family and home life.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Jupiter\",\"/yogas/0\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Moon, a benefic and significator of fluids/mind, sits in the 2nd but is combust — indicating sensitivity of mind/emotional health and possible issues around diet or speech.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/combust\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn in enemy sign Scorpio in the 11th casts its aspect onto the lagna itself, weighing on the body and general vitality over time.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/houses/10/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars aspects the 6th house of disease while Rahu/Ketu axis afflicts the 5th (and Ketu aspects the 11th), pointing to episodic acute complaints and vulnerability around digestion/acidity-type Mars-Saturn-Scorpio signatures.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/placements/Ketu/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current dasha Mercury–Jupiter–Venus: Jupiter as 12th lord placed in the 8th (Vipareeta position) can bring periods of low energy or hospital-type experiences even when outcomes ultimately turn favourable.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current\",\"/yogas/5\"]},{\"claim\":\"Transit Saturn conjunct natal Venus in Pisces and transiting Ketu on natal Jupiter in the 8th suggest a phase requiring extra care with chronic/slow-developing matters; however gochara Saturn is at 12 from the Moon, i.e., sade sati has concluded, easing long-term pressure.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"tool:transits_at#transits/contacts/6\",\"tool:transits_at#transits/contacts/8\",\"/transits/saturnFromMoon\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart shows a resilient constitutional base (lagna lord strong in the 11th, Budha-Aditya in lagna) offset by a combust Moon, Saturn's aspect on the lagna, and malefic influence on the 5th/6th axis. The present Mercury–Jupiter–Venus dasha with Jupiter as 12th-lord-in-8th, combined with transit Ketu over natal Jupiter, argues for caution rather than alarm. Overall reading: mixed, with supportive fundamentals.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-synthesis-01-evidence-order","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-01-evidence-order","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.6,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Lagna lord Saturn is placed in the 11th (a good upachaya) but in an enemy sign, so vitality is workable yet not robust; self/body house lord away from the 1st weakens constitutional strength.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/houses/0/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"Saturn and Ketu both aspect the 1st house (self/body), a classically draining influence on stamina and overall resilience.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Saturn","/aspects/Ketu","/houses/0/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"The Moon — significator of the mind and fluids — is combust and at only 0°04' in Aquarius in the 2nd; a weakened Chandra typically flags mental restlessness, anxiety, or dietary irregularity.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Moon/combust","/placements/Moon/formatted","/placements/Moon/house"]},{"claim":"6th lord Mercury sits in the 1st with the Sun (Budha-Aditya Yoga), which gives intellect and recovery capacity, but a dusthana lord on the lagna keeps disease matters personally close.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse","/yogas/1","/placements/Mercury/house"]},{"claim":"Jupiter forms Vipareeta Raja Yoga as 12th lord in the 8th; this can convert chronic/sudden health vulnerabilities into resilience over time, though it marks the native's life with health-related transformation.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/5","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Mars aspects the 6th house of disease from the 11th; Mars-Saturn conjunction in the 11th can indicate injuries, inflammation, or joint/blood-related strain surfacing through overexertion.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Mars","/yogas/2","/houses/10/occupants"]},{"claim":"Currently running Mercury–Jupiter dasha (to Nov 2026); Jupiter is a benefic placed in the 8th and retrograde — periods of its sub-lordship often bring health check-ups or latent chronic matters to attention rather than acute crises.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha/path","/dasha/current/antardasha/path","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde"]},{"claim":"Transit Rahu is conjunct natal Moon in the natal 2nd and transiting Ketu conjunct natal Jupiter in the 8th (as of 2026-01-01), suggesting heightened stress sensitivity and need for disciplined routine now; Saturn transit from Moon = 2 places the native in sade sati, adding fatigue and pressure.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/transits/contacts/7/conjunctNatal","/transits/contacts/8/inNatalHouse","/transits/saturnFromMoon"]},{"claim":"Upcoming Mercury–Saturn antardasha (Nov 2026–Jul 2029): Saturn is lagna lord in enemy sign; a Saturn sub-period under a neutral benefic mahadasha usually demands routine care, joints/bones attention, but is not inherently disease-giving for a lagna lord.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/dasha/upcoming/0"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["D30 (Trimshamsha) chart for detailed disease analysis","Exact afflictions to the 6th house cusp / arudha considerations","Current age-specific medical history to calibrate indications"],"rationale":"Health indicators are genuinely two-sided. Supporting: Budha-Aditya Yoga on the lagna, lagna lord in an upachaya, and Vipareeta Raja Yoga via Jupiter. Challenging: Saturn+Ketu aspecting the lagna, combust Moon at the very edge of Aquarius, Mars-Saturn conjunction, and current sade-sati with Rahu on the natal Moon. Net reading: adequate underlying constitution with vulnerability around stress, digestion/diet (combust Moon in 2nd — food), and joints/fatigue (Saturn), requiring disciplined routine especially through the Mercury–Saturn period from late 2026. No prediction of specific disease is made."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-synthesis-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.6,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Lagna lord Saturn is placed in the 11th (a good upachaya) but in an enemy sign, so vitality is workable yet not robust; self/body house lord away from the 1st weakens constitutional strength.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/houses/0/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn and Ketu both aspect the 1st house (self/body), a classically draining influence on stamina and overall resilience.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Saturn\",\"/aspects/Ketu\",\"/houses/0/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Moon — significator of the mind and fluids — is combust and at only 0°04' in Aquarius in the 2nd; a weakened Chandra typically flags mental restlessness, anxiety, or dietary irregularity.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/combust\",\"/placements/Moon/formatted\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"6th lord Mercury sits in the 1st with the Sun (Budha-Aditya Yoga), which gives intellect and recovery capacity, but a dusthana lord on the lagna keeps disease matters personally close.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/yogas/1\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter forms Vipareeta Raja Yoga as 12th lord in the 8th; this can convert chronic/sudden health vulnerabilities into resilience over time, though it marks the native's life with health-related transformation.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/5\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars aspects the 6th house of disease from the 11th; Mars-Saturn conjunction in the 11th can indicate injuries, inflammation, or joint/blood-related strain surfacing through overexertion.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/yogas/2\",\"/houses/10/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"Currently running Mercury–Jupiter dasha (to Nov 2026); Jupiter is a benefic placed in the 8th and retrograde — periods of its sub-lordship often bring health check-ups or latent chronic matters to attention rather than acute crises.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/path\",\"/dasha/current/antardasha/path\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\"]},{\"claim\":\"Transit Rahu is conjunct natal Moon in the natal 2nd and transiting Ketu conjunct natal Jupiter in the 8th (as of 2026-01-01), suggesting heightened stress sensitivity and need for disciplined routine now; Saturn transit from Moon = 2 places the native in sade sati, adding fatigue and pressure.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/transits/contacts/7/conjunctNatal\",\"/transits/contacts/8/inNatalHouse\",\"/transits/saturnFromMoon\"]},{\"claim\":\"Upcoming Mercury–Saturn antardasha (Nov 2026–Jul 2029): Saturn is lagna lord in enemy sign; a Saturn sub-period under a neutral benefic mahadasha usually demands routine care, joints/bones attention, but is not inherently disease-giving for a lagna lord.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/upcoming/0\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"D30 (Trimshamsha) chart for detailed disease analysis\",\"Exact afflictions to the 6th house cusp / arudha considerations\",\"Current age-specific medical history to calibrate indications\"],\"rationale\":\"Health indicators are genuinely two-sided. Supporting: Budha-Aditya Yoga on the lagna, lagna lord in an upachaya, and Vipareeta Raja Yoga via Jupiter. Challenging: Saturn+Ketu aspecting the lagna, combust Moon at the very edge of Aquarius, Mars-Saturn conjunction, and current sade-sati with Rahu on the natal Moon. Net reading: adequate underlying constitution with vulnerability around stress, digestion/diet (combust Moon in 2nd — food), and joints/fatigue (Saturn), requiring disciplined routine especially through the Mercury–Saturn period from late 2026. No prediction of specific disease is made.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-synthesis-01-paraphrase","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-01-paraphrase","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.55,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Lagna is Capricorn with lagna lord Saturn placed in the 11th (a house of gains), giving the native resilience and strong recuperative grounding; Saturn aspects its own sign Capricorn/1st house, strengthening the body's framework.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/sign","/placements/Saturn/house","/houses/0/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Budha-Aditya Yoga (Sun + Mercury) in the 1st house supports vitality of intellect and nervous coordination, though Sun in an enemy sign slightly dilutes it.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Sun/dignity","/yogas"]},{"claim":"Gaja Kesari Yoga (Jupiter in 7th from Moon) offers protective grace and recovery capacity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas"]},{"claim":"Mars in own sign Scorpio in the 11th gives robust constitution and stamina.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Mars/house"]},{"claim":"The natal Moon, significator of mind and fluids, is combust in the 2nd house — a classic indication of emotional stress affecting physical well-being (diet, sleep, speech-related issues).","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Moon/combust","/placements/Moon/house"]},{"claim":"Saturn sits in an enemy sign in the 11th with Rahu (debilitated) alongside Mars — a Mars-Saturn-Rahu cluster that can indicate chronic joint, circulatory, or toxin-accumulation tendencies; Saturn also aspects the 1st, 5th, and 8th houses, weighing on vitality and longevity matters.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/sign","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Rahu/house","/placements/Rahu/dignity","/aspects/Saturn"]},{"claim":"Jupiter (12th lord) retrograde in the 8th house forms Vipareeta Raja Yoga — protective against chronic disease per doctrine, but the 8th placement itself flags sudden health events and hidden conditions.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/yogas"]},{"claim":"5th house (well-being via purva punya) is occupied by debilitated Ketu and aspected by Mars, Saturn, and Rahu — indicating weakened natural immunity reserves and possible issues connected to children/stomach region.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Ketu/house","/placements/Ketu/dignity","/houses/4/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Currently running Mercury–Jupiter antardasha with Jupiter in the 8th house natally: this sub-period can surface latent or chronic matters requiring attention.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord","/dasha/current/antardasha/lord","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Transit Saturn in Pisces conjuncts natal Venus (3rd house) and aspects the 9th and 12th; transit Ketu sits on natal Jupiter in the 8th while transit Rahu conjoins the natal Moon — a period of heightened sensitivity, anxiety, and vulnerability to sudden ailments around early 2026.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/transits/asOf","/transits/contacts"]},{"claim":"Gochara Saturn from Moon stands at 2 (Aquarius Moon), placing the native inside sade sati — fatigue, low morale, and slow recovery are typical indications during this window.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/transits/saturnFromMoon"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Exact current health complaints or medical history of the subject","Divisional charts beyond D7/D9/D10 (no specific health varga available)","Birth-time rectification confirmation given lagna at only ~0°29' Capricorn"],"rationale":"The chart shows a fundamentally sturdy frame — Capricorn lagna with its lord in the 11th, Mars in own sign, Budha-Aditya in the 1st, and Gaja Kesari protection — but layered with genuine vulnerabilities: a combust Moon (mind-body link), a heavy Mars–Saturn–Rahu load in the 11th with Saturn aspecting the lagna, debilitated nodes, and Jupiter in the 8th. The present Mercury–Jupiter dasha coincides with sade sati, transit Ketu on natal Jupiter in the 8th, and transit Rahu on the natal Moon, so the near-term window (2026) reads as more sensitive than the baseline chart itself. Overall verdict: mixed — sound underlying constitution under periodic stress, warranting routine care rather than alarm. These are astrological indications only, not medical advice or diagnosis."},"extracted":"{\n \"case_id\": \"health-synthesis-01-paraphrase\",\n \"domain\": \"health\",\n \"conclusion\": \"mixed\",\n \"confidence\": 0.55,\n \"selected_option_ids\": [],\n \"factors\": [\n  {\"claim\": \"Lagna is Capricorn with lagna lord Saturn placed in the 11th (a house of gains), giving the native resilience and strong recuperative grounding; Saturn aspects its own sign Capricorn/1st house, strengthening the body's framework.\", \"effect\": \"supporting\", \"evidence\": [\"/lagna/sign\", \"/placements/Saturn/house\", \"/houses/0/aspectedBy\"]},\n  {\"claim\": \"Budha-Aditya Yoga (Sun + Mercury) in the 1st house supports vitality of intellect and nervous coordination, though Sun in an enemy sign slightly dilutes it.\", \"effect\": \"supporting\", \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Sun/house\", \"/placements/Mercury/house\", \"/placements/Sun/dignity\", \"/yogas\"]},\n  {\"claim\": \"Gaja Kesari Yoga (Jupiter in 7th from Moon) offers protective grace and recovery capacity.\", \"effect\": \"supporting\", \"evidence\": [\"/yogas\"]},\n  {\"claim\": \"Mars in own sign Scorpio in the 11th gives robust constitution and stamina.\", \"effect\": \"supporting\", \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mars/dignity\", \"/placements/Mars/house\"]},\n  {\"claim\": \"The natal Moon, significator of mind and fluids, is combust in the 2nd house — a classic indication of emotional stress affecting physical well-being (diet, sleep, speech-related issues).\", \"effect\": \"challenging\", \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Moon/combust\", \"/placements/Moon/house\"]},\n  {\"claim\": \"Saturn sits in an enemy sign in the 11th with Rahu (debilitated) alongside Mars — a Mars-Saturn-Rahu cluster that can indicate chronic joint, circulatory, or toxin-accumulation tendencies; Saturn also aspects the 1st, 5th, and 8th houses, weighing on vitality and longevity matters.\", \"effect\": \"challenging\", \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Saturn/sign\", \"/placements/Saturn/dignity\", \"/placements/Rahu/house\", \"/placements/Rahu/dignity\", \"/aspects/Saturn\"]},\n  {\"claim\": \"Jupiter (12th lord) retrograde in the 8th house forms Vipareeta Raja Yoga — protective against chronic disease per doctrine, but the 8th placement itself flags sudden health events and hidden conditions.\", \"effect\": \"mixed\", \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Jupiter/house\", \"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\", \"/yogas\"]},\n  {\"claim\": \"5th house (well-being via purva punya) is occupied by debilitated Ketu and aspected by Mars, Saturn, and Rahu — indicating weakened natural immunity reserves and possible issues connected to children/stomach region.\", \"effect\": \"challenging\", \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Ketu/house\", \"/placements/Ketu/dignity\", \"/houses/4/aspectedBy\"]},\n  {\"claim\": \"Currently running Mercury–Jupiter antardasha with Jupiter in the 8th house natally: this sub-period can surface latent or chronic matters requiring attention.\", \"effect\": \"mixed\", \"evidence\": [\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord\", \"/dasha/current/antardasha/lord\", \"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},\n  {\"claim\": \"Transit Saturn in Pisces conjuncts natal Venus (3rd house) and aspects the 9th and 12th; transit Ketu sits on natal Jupiter in the 8th while transit Rahu conjoins the natal Moon — a period of heightened sensitivity, anxiety, and vulnerability to sudden ailments around early 2026.\", \"effect\": \"challenging\", \"evidence\": [\"/transits/asOf\", \"/transits/contacts\"]},\n  {\"claim\": \"Gochara Saturn from Moon stands at 2 (Aquarius Moon), placing the native inside sade sati — fatigue, low morale, and slow recovery are typical indications during this window.\", \"effect\": \"challenging\", \"evidence\": [\"/transits/saturnFromMoon\"]}\n ],\n \"contradictions\": [],\n \"missing_information\": [\n  \"Exact current health complaints or medical history of the subject\",\n  \"Divisional charts beyond D7/D9/D10 (no specific health varga available)\",\n  \"Birth-time rectification confirmation given lagna at only ~0°29' Capricorn\"\n ],\n \"rationale\": \"The chart shows a fundamentally sturdy frame — Capricorn lagna with its lord in the 11th, Mars in own sign, Budha-Aditya in the 1st, and Gaja Kesari protection — but layered with genuine vulnerabilities: a combust Moon (mind-body link), a heavy Mars–Saturn–Rahu load in the 11th with Saturn aspecting the lagna, debilitated nodes, and Jupiter in the 8th. The present Mercury–Jupiter dasha coincides with sade sati, transit Ketu on natal Jupiter in the 8th, and transit Rahu on the natal Moon, so the near-term window (2026) reads as more sensitive than the baseline chart itself. Overall verdict: mixed — sound underlying constitution under periodic stress, warranting routine care rather than alarm. These are astrological indications only, not medical advice or diagnosis.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-application-02-counterfactual","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-02-counterfactual","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"rationale":"The chart facts show the second lord (Mercury) placed in the twelfth house (/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse = 12), not the eleventh. Statements A, B, and C all concern a second-lord-in-eleventh placement, which is not present in this chart. Therefore none of A–C is established by the stated rule and chart, and D applies."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-02-counterfactual\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"confidence\":0.9,\"rationale\":\"The chart facts show the second lord (Mercury) placed in the twelfth house (/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse = 12), not the eleventh. Statements A, B, and C all concern a second-lord-in-eleventh placement, which is not present in this chart. Therefore none of A–C is established by the stated rule and chart, and D applies.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-application-02-counterfactual","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-02-counterfactual","domain":"health","conclusion":"insufficient","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"factors":[{"claim":"The second lord is Mercury and it is placed in the twelfth house, not the eleventh.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/houses/2/lord","/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"A","error_type":"factual","correction":"The second lord (Mercury) is in the twelfth house, not the eleventh, so statement A does not apply to this chart.","evidence":["/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"No placement guarantees lifelong illness; moreover the second lord is in the twelfth, not the eleventh.","evidence":["/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated rule concerns second lord in the eleventh as a challenging indication, not strong vitality; and the placement here is in the twelfth.","evidence":["/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart shows the second lord Mercury placed in the twelfth house (/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse = 12), so none of statements A-C about a second lord in the eleventh applies. Therefore D is selected and no health polarity can be established from these statements."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-02-counterfactual\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"insufficient\",\"confidence\":0.9,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The second lord is Mercury and it is placed in the twelfth house, not the eleventh.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/2/lord\",\"/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"A\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"The second lord (Mercury) is in the twelfth house, not the eleventh, so statement A does not apply to this chart.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"No placement guarantees lifelong illness; moreover the second lord is in the twelfth, not the eleventh.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule concerns second lord in the eleventh as a challenging indication, not strong vitality; and the placement here is in the twelfth.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart shows the second lord Mercury placed in the twelfth house (/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse = 12), so none of statements A-C about a second lord in the eleventh applies. Therefore D is selected and no health polarity can be established from these statements.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-synthesis-01-evidence-order","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-01-evidence-order","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.55,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Lagna lord Saturn is strong by own-sign Mars association in the 11th (Dhana/Raja yoga), supporting vitality and recovery capacity, though Saturn is in 'Enemy' dignity and Saturn aspects the lagna itself (/aspects/Saturn includes house 1), a classic pressure on the body.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/houses/0/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"6th lord Mercury sits in the lagna with the Sun (Budha-Aditya), placing a dusthana lord on the self — disease/service matters are tied to the body; Mercury's 7th-house aspect touches the 7th (partnerships).","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"8th house holds retrograde Jupiter (lord of 12) — Vipareeta Raja Yoga offers protection from chronic/sudden harm, but Jupiter also aspects the 2nd, 4th and 12th houses, linking Moon (mind/fluids) to 8th-house transformation themes.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/yogas/5","/aspects/Jupiter"]},{"claim":"Moon is combust and at 0° Aquarius in the 2nd, aspected only toward the 8th; a combust, sandhi-degree Moon weakens emotional resilience and digestion-related significations.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Moon/combust","/placements/Moon/formatted","/aspects/Moon"]},{"claim":"Mars aspects the 6th house of disease directly (/aspects/Mars), and Ketu debilitated in the 5th receives Mars and Saturn aspects — stress-prone, inflammatory indications around diet/speculation.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Mars","/houses/4/aspectedBy","/placements/Ketu/dignity"]},{"claim":"Current dasha: Mercury mahadasha (2012–2029) — Mercury as 6th lord in lagna keeps health/service themes active; Jupiter antardasha until 2026-11-19 is a natural benefic period offering mitigation.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha/path","/dasha/current/antardasha/path"]},{"claim":"Transits as of 2026-01-01: sade sati phase (Saturn 2nd from Moon per /transits/saturnFromMoon = 2), Rahu transiting natal Moon in the 2nd, and a heavy Sagittarius stellium (Sun, Mars, Venus, Mercury) in the 12th of loss/hospitalization — an elevated-stress transit window for body and mind.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/transits/saturnFromMoon","tool:transits_at#/transits/contacts"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart shows genuine protective architecture (Vipareeta Raja Yoga via Jupiter in the 8th; strong lagna-lord/lagna pairing in Dhana-Raja yoga; benefic Jupiter antardasha now) set against structural vulnerabilities (6th lord in lagna, combust sandhi Moon linked to the 8th, Mars aspect on the 6th, debilitated Ketu in the 5th). The current transit picture — late sade sati, Rahu over the natal Moon, and a 12th-house stellium — tilts the near term toward elevated fatigue/stress load rather than acute crisis, but this is probabilistic indication, not diagnosis or prediction."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-synthesis-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.55,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Lagna lord Saturn is strong by own-sign Mars association in the 11th (Dhana/Raja yoga), supporting vitality and recovery capacity, though Saturn is in 'Enemy' dignity and Saturn aspects the lagna itself (/aspects/Saturn includes house 1), a classic pressure on the body.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/houses/0/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"6th lord Mercury sits in the lagna with the Sun (Budha-Aditya), placing a dusthana lord on the self — disease/service matters are tied to the body; Mercury's 7th-house aspect touches the 7th (partnerships).\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"8th house holds retrograde Jupiter (lord of 12) — Vipareeta Raja Yoga offers protection from chronic/sudden harm, but Jupiter also aspects the 2nd, 4th and 12th houses, linking Moon (mind/fluids) to 8th-house transformation themes.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/yogas/5\",\"/aspects/Jupiter\"]},{\"claim\":\"Moon is combust and at 0° Aquarius in the 2nd, aspected only toward the 8th; a combust, sandhi-degree Moon weakens emotional resilience and digestion-related significations.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/combust\",\"/placements/Moon/formatted\",\"/aspects/Moon\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars aspects the 6th house of disease directly (/aspects/Mars), and Ketu debilitated in the 5th receives Mars and Saturn aspects — stress-prone, inflammatory indications around diet/speculation.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/houses/4/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Ketu/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current dasha: Mercury mahadasha (2012–2029) — Mercury as 6th lord in lagna keeps health/service themes active; Jupiter antardasha until 2026-11-19 is a natural benefic period offering mitigation.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/path\",\"/dasha/current/antardasha/path\"]},{\"claim\":\"Transits as of 2026-01-01: sade sati phase (Saturn 2nd from Moon per /transits/saturnFromMoon = 2), Rahu transiting natal Moon in the 2nd, and a heavy Sagittarius stellium (Sun, Mars, Venus, Mercury) in the 12th of loss/hospitalization — an elevated-stress transit window for body and mind.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/transits/saturnFromMoon\",\"tool:transits_at#/transits/contacts\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart shows genuine protective architecture (Vipareeta Raja Yoga via Jupiter in the 8th; strong lagna-lord/lagna pairing in Dhana-Raja yoga; benefic Jupiter antardasha now) set against structural vulnerabilities (6th lord in lagna, combust sandhi Moon linked to the 8th, Mars aspect on the 6th, debilitated Ketu in the 5th). The current transit picture — late sade sati, Rahu over the natal Moon, and a 12th-house stellium — tilts the near term toward elevated fatigue/stress load rather than acute crisis, but this is probabilistic indication, not diagnosis or prediction.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-application-02-counterfactual","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-02-counterfactual","confidence":0.95,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"rationale":"The chart facts show the second lord is Mercury placed in the 12th house (/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse = 12), not the 11th. Therefore statements A, B, and C, which all concern a second lord in the eleventh, are not applicable to this chart. Statement D is correct: none of A–C is established by the stated rule and chart."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-02-counterfactual\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"confidence\":0.95,\"rationale\":\"The chart facts show the second lord is Mercury placed in the 12th house (/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse = 12), not the 11th. Therefore statements A, B, and C, which all concern a second lord in the eleventh, are not applicable to this chart. Statement D is correct: none of A–C is established by the stated rule and chart.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-synthesis-01-paraphrase","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-01-paraphrase","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.6,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Lagna is early Capricorn with Saturn as lagna lord placed in the 11th in its own-sign Mars's territory — the native's vitality is tied to Saturn, whose condition is mixed (Enemy dignity, but conjunct its friend Mars and forming a Raja/Dhana yoga), suggesting durable constitution with chronic, Saturnian slow-burn issues.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/lagna/sign","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity"]},{"claim":"Sun (natural significator of vitality) sits in the 1st house in Enemy dignity at 29° Capricorn — self and body are strongly identified, but vitality runs hot-and-cold under a hostile dispositor.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/dignity"]},{"claim":"Budha-Aditya yoga in the lagna gives resilience of mind-body coordination and recovery capacity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"The Moon, karaka of fluids and mind, is combust in the 2nd and aspected by Mars and Jupiter — emotional/nervous strain and dietary/speech-related sensitivities are indicated.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Moon/combust","/placements/Moon/house","/houses/1/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"6th house (disease) Gemini is empty with lord Mercury strong in the lagna — good placement: disease capacity is handled by a well-placed lagna occupant, supporting recovery from acute illness.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/5/occupants","/placements/Mercury/house"]},{"claim":"However Mercury rules the 6th from the 1st: health matters stay close to the body/self; daily-routine discipline is the lever for health outcomes.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"8th house Leo holds retrograde Jupiter and is aspected by natal Saturn and Moon — chronic or hard-to-diagnose tendencies, plus Vipareeta Raja Yoga (12th lord in 8th), which classically converts adversity into eventual relief.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/houses/7/aspectedBy","/yogas/5"]},{"claim":"Current dasha context: Mercury mahadasha (2012–2029) with Jupiter antardasha until Nov 2026 — Jupiter is 12th lord in the 8th natally, so this period can bring hospitalization-type or isolation-flavored episodes even while ultimately protective (Vipareeta pattern).","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha","/dasha/current/antardasha","/placements/Jupiter/house","/dasha/upcoming/0"]},{"claim":"Transits as of 2026-01-01: transiting Rahu conjunct natal Moon (mind, sleep, anxiety) and transiting Ketu over natal Jupiter in the 8th; transiting Saturn conjunct natal Venus in the 3rd aspecting houses 5/9/12 — a period of mental restlessness, disturbed sleep, and low-grade depletion rather than acute danger.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["tool:/transits_at#0","/transits/contacts/7/conjunctNatal","/transits/contacts/6/conjunctNatal"]},{"claim":"Gochara check: Saturn is 2 signs from the natal Moon (sade sati phase) and Jupiter 5 from the Moon — sade sati typically raises fatigue, joint/knee complaints, and mental heaviness; Jupiter's position offers some protection.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/transits/saturnFromMoon","/transits/jupiterFromMoon"]},{"claim":"Upcoming Mercury–Saturn antardasha (Nov 2026–Jul 2029): Saturn is lagna lord in Enemy sign in the 11th — likely a demanding stretch where routine, joints, and stamina need deliberate care; not an indication of catastrophic outcome.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/upcoming/0","/placements/Saturn/dignity"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Vipareeta Raja Yoga does not guarantee immunity to illness; it indicates eventual resolution/benefit emerging from difficulty, with uncertainty about timing and severity.","evidence":["/yogas/5"]},{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"omission","correction":"Any health synthesis must note this is astrological indication only, not medical diagnosis; no birth-time rectification data or medical history is available to confirm patterns.","evidence":[]}],"missing_information":["Exact nature of any existing health conditions or symptoms (chart alone cannot diagnose)","Whether birth time is rectified (lagna at 0°29' Capricorn is near a cusp-sensitive point, raising sensitivity of all house assignments)","Divisional charts beyond D9/D10/D7 relevant to specific health assessment (D60)"],"rationale":"The chart shows a fundamentally resilient frame — Budha-Aditya in the lagna, empty well-disposed 6th, and a protective Vipareeta Raja Yoga through Jupiter in the 8th — offset by a combust Moon, hostile-dignity Sun as vitality karaka, and heavy Saturnian influence on the body via lagna lordship. Current-period overlays (Mercury–Jupiter dasha touching the 8th/12th axis, sade sati, Rahu on natal Moon, Ketu on natal Jupiter in the 8th) point to fatigue, sleep/anxiety strain, and possible medical attention during late 2024–2026, with the Mercury–Saturn antardasha (Nov 2026–mid 2029) demanding disciplined routine rather than signaling crisis. Conclusion: mixed, with proportionate uncertainty and no medical claims."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-synthesis-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.6,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Lagna is early Capricorn with Saturn as lagna lord placed in the 11th in its own-sign Mars's territory — the native's vitality is tied to Saturn, whose condition is mixed (Enemy dignity, but conjunct its friend Mars and forming a Raja/Dhana yoga), suggesting durable constitution with chronic, Saturnian slow-burn issues.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/sign\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Sun (natural significator of vitality) sits in the 1st house in Enemy dignity at 29° Capricorn — self and body are strongly identified, but vitality runs hot-and-cold under a hostile dispositor.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Sun/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Budha-Aditya yoga in the lagna gives resilience of mind-body coordination and recovery capacity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Moon, karaka of fluids and mind, is combust in the 2nd and aspected by Mars and Jupiter — emotional/nervous strain and dietary/speech-related sensitivities are indicated.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/combust\",\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"6th house (disease) Gemini is empty with lord Mercury strong in the lagna — good placement: disease capacity is handled by a well-placed lagna occupant, supporting recovery from acute illness.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/occupants\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"However Mercury rules the 6th from the 1st: health matters stay close to the body/self; daily-routine discipline is the lever for health outcomes.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"8th house Leo holds retrograde Jupiter and is aspected by natal Saturn and Moon — chronic or hard-to-diagnose tendencies, plus Vipareeta Raja Yoga (12th lord in 8th), which classically converts adversity into eventual relief.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/houses/7/aspectedBy\",\"/yogas/5\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current dasha context: Mercury mahadasha (2012–2029) with Jupiter antardasha until Nov 2026 — Jupiter is 12th lord in the 8th natally, so this period can bring hospitalization-type or isolation-flavored episodes even while ultimately protective (Vipareeta pattern).\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/mahadasha\",\"/dasha/current/antardasha\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/dasha/upcoming/0\"]},{\"claim\":\"Transits as of 2026-01-01: transiting Rahu conjunct natal Moon (mind, sleep, anxiety) and transiting Ketu over natal Jupiter in the 8th; transiting Saturn conjunct natal Venus in the 3rd aspecting houses 5/9/12 — a period of mental restlessness, disturbed sleep, and low-grade depletion rather than acute danger.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"tool:/transits_at#0\",\"/transits/contacts/7/conjunctNatal\",\"/transits/contacts/6/conjunctNatal\"]},{\"claim\":\"Gochara check: Saturn is 2 signs from the natal Moon (sade sati phase) and Jupiter 5 from the Moon — sade sati typically raises fatigue, joint/knee complaints, and mental heaviness; Jupiter's position offers some protection.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/transits/saturnFromMoon\",\"/transits/jupiterFromMoon\"]},{\"claim\":\"Upcoming Mercury–Saturn antardasha (Nov 2026–Jul 2029): Saturn is lagna lord in Enemy sign in the 11th — likely a demanding stretch where routine, joints, and stamina need deliberate care; not an indication of catastrophic outcome.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/upcoming/0\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Vipareeta Raja Yoga does not guarantee immunity to illness; it indicates eventual resolution/benefit emerging from difficulty, with uncertainty about timing and severity.\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/5\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"omission\",\"correction\":\"Any health synthesis must note this is astrological indication only, not medical diagnosis; no birth-time rectification data or medical history is available to confirm patterns.\",\"evidence\":[]}],\"missing_information\":[\"Exact nature of any existing health conditions or symptoms (chart alone cannot diagnose)\",\"Whether birth time is rectified (lagna at 0°29' Capricorn is near a cusp-sensitive point, raising sensitivity of all house assignments)\",\"Divisional charts beyond D9/D10/D7 relevant to specific health assessment (D60)\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart shows a fundamentally resilient frame — Budha-Aditya in the lagna, empty well-disposed 6th, and a protective Vipareeta Raja Yoga through Jupiter in the 8th — offset by a combust Moon, hostile-dignity Sun as vitality karaka, and heavy Saturnian influence on the body via lagna lordship. Current-period overlays (Mercury–Jupiter dasha touching the 8th/12th axis, sade sati, Rahu on natal Moon, Ketu on natal Jupiter in the 8th) point to fatigue, sleep/anxiety strain, and possible medical attention during late 2024–2026, with the Mercury–Saturn antardasha (Nov 2026–mid 2029) demanding disciplined routine rather than signaling crisis. Conclusion: mixed, with proportionate uncertainty and no medical claims.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-application-01-paraphrase","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-01-paraphrase","domain":"career","confidence":0.95,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The ascendant lord (Moon) occupies the tenth house, which is classically treated as supportive of professional success/specialization.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house"]},{"claim":"This placement does not guarantee any specific profession; no option or rule establishes a particular vocation.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/houses/9"]}],"rationale":"Option A applies: /lagna/lordInHouse = 10 and /placements/Moon/house = 10 show the Cancer-lagna lord Moon in the 10th, a standard supportive indication for career standing — not a career-loss indication, so B fails; and no rule or chart fact guarantees a specific profession, so C fails; D therefore also fails."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"confidence\":0.95,\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The ascendant lord (Moon) occupies the tenth house, which is classically treated as supportive of professional success/specialization.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"This placement does not guarantee any specific profession; no option or rule establishes a particular vocation.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9\"]}],\"rationale\":\"Option A applies: /lagna/lordInHouse = 10 and /placements/Moon/house = 10 show the Cancer-lagna lord Moon in the 10th, a standard supportive indication for career standing — not a career-loss indication, so B fails; and no rule or chart fact guarantees a specific profession, so C fails; D therefore also fails.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-application-01-paraphrase","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-01-paraphrase","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"rationale":"The chart facts state the lagna lord Moon is placed in house 10 (/lagna/lordInHouse = 10, /placements/Moon/house = 10), and the 10th signifies career, status, authority, and public standing (/houses/9/significations). Classical treatment of the ascendant lord in a kendra, especially the 10th, supports professional success/specialization — so A applies. B contradicts the standard reading of this placement (no rule or chart evidence frames it as career loss). C overclaims: no single placement guarantees a specific profession; the D10 shows Sun/Mercury/Moon in Leo in its own 10th (/vargas/D10/placements) but that indicates strength of career significations, not a fixed profession. Hence only A is established."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-01-paraphrase\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"confidence\":0.9,\"rationale\":\"The chart facts state the lagna lord Moon is placed in house 10 (/lagna/lordInHouse = 10, /placements/Moon/house = 10), and the 10th signifies career, status, authority, and public standing (/houses/9/significations). Classical treatment of the ascendant lord in a kendra, especially the 10th, supports professional success/specialization — so A applies. B contradicts the standard reading of this placement (no rule or chart evidence frames it as career loss). C overclaims: no single placement guarantees a specific profession; the D10 shows Sun/Mercury/Moon in Leo in its own 10th (/vargas/D10/placements) but that indicates strength of career significations, not a fixed profession. Hence only A is established.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"health-synthesis-01-evidence-order","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-01-evidence-order","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.55,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Lagna lord Saturn placed in the 11th with Mars and Rahu; lagna itself is aspected by natal Saturn and debilitated Ketu, indicating a constitution that holds up under strain but is vulnerable to chronic, slow-developing issues (Saturn) and sudden/acute episodes (Mars-Rahu).","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/1/aspectedBy","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Rahu/house"]},{"claim":"The 6th house of disease is unoccupied but its lord Mercury sits in the 1st (lagna), tying disease matters directly to the body/self; Mercury also aspects the 7th. A 6th lord in the 1st classically links health sensitivity to the native's own vitality.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/aspects/Mercury"]},{"claim":"Jupiter, a natural benefic, occupies the 8th (chronic matters, longevity) retrograde, forming Vipareeta Raja Yoga — one dusthana lord fallen into another — which traditionally converts adversity into resilience; it also aspects the 12th (hospitalization/isolation), softening those significations.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/yogas/5","/aspects/Jupiter"]},{"claim":"Moon (2nd house, combust per /placements/Moon/combust) aspects the 8th; an afflicted Moon aspecting the 8th points to mind-body linkage, sleep/fluid-related vulnerability, and stress-driven flare-ups.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Moon","/aspects/Moon"]},{"claim":"Current period: Mercury mahadasha (Mercury is 6th lord of disease sitting in the 1st), Jupiter antardasha (Jupiter in the 8th house natally) until Nov 2026 — a dasha sequence that activates both the disease axis and the chronic/8th-house axis simultaneously.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord","/dasha/current/antardasha/to","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Transits as of 2026-01-01: Saturn from Moon = 2 (within sade sati range 12-1-2), and Rahu transiting natal house 2 conjunct natal Moon while Ketu transits natal house 8 conjunct natal Jupiter — nodal transit over the Moon and across the 2/8 axis raises stress, diet, and sudden-event sensitivity.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/transits/saturnFromMoon","tool:transits_at#/contacts/7","tool:transits_at#/contacts/8"]},{"claim":"Mitigating: transiting Jupiter is retrograde in the natal 6th (house of disease) aspecting houses 10 and 12 — benefic presence on the 6th can indicate recovery capacity and successful management rather than pure affliction.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["tool:transits_at#/contacts/4","/transits/contacts/4/inNatalHouse"]},{"claim":"Upcoming Ketu mahadasha begins Dec 2029 after Mercury–Saturn ends Jul 2029; Saturn antardasha over a natal Saturn-Mars-Rahu conjunction in the 11th suggests a demanding stretch for stamina in 2026–2029, though not deterministically adverse.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/upcoming/0","/placements/Saturn/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Vipareeta Raja Yoga via Jupiter in the 8th does not guarantee immunity to illness; it indicates resilience and favorable outcomes from adversity, so it should temper but not override the challenging 6th-lord-in-lagna indication.","evidence":["/yogas/5","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"missing_information":["Exact divisional strength of the 6th/8th lords in relevant vargas (D3/D7/D9/D12 do not bear directly on health; D60 would help)","Natal planetary strengths (shadbala/vimsopaka) not provided","Actual medical history or symptoms of the subject"],"rationale":"The chart shows a mixed health picture: genuine vulnerabilities (6th lord Mercury in the 1st; Moon combust aspecting the 8th; Mars-Saturn-Rahu pressure on the lagna lord in the 11th; active Mercury-Jupiter dasha running through the disease and 8th-house axes; sade sati-range Saturn plus Rahu/Ketu transiting the natal Moon and 8th) are counterweighted by protective factors (Jupiter's Vipareeta Raja Yoga in the 8th, benefic Jupiter transiting the 6th). Overall conclusion: mixed — heightened sensitivity and stress-linked flare-ups likely during 2026–2029, but with real recovery and management capacity; no deterministic illness prediction should be made."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-synthesis-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.55,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Lagna lord Saturn placed in the 11th with Mars and Rahu; lagna itself is aspected by natal Saturn and debilitated Ketu, indicating a constitution that holds up under strain but is vulnerable to chronic, slow-developing issues (Saturn) and sudden/acute episodes (Mars-Rahu).\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 6th house of disease is unoccupied but its lord Mercury sits in the 1st (lagna), tying disease matters directly to the body/self; Mercury also aspects the 7th. A 6th lord in the 1st classically links health sensitivity to the native's own vitality.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/aspects/Mercury\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter, a natural benefic, occupies the 8th (chronic matters, longevity) retrograde, forming Vipareeta Raja Yoga — one dusthana lord fallen into another — which traditionally converts adversity into resilience; it also aspects the 12th (hospitalization/isolation), softening those significations.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/yogas/5\",\"/aspects/Jupiter\"]},{\"claim\":\"Moon (2nd house, combust per /placements/Moon/combust) aspects the 8th; an afflicted Moon aspecting the 8th points to mind-body linkage, sleep/fluid-related vulnerability, and stress-driven flare-ups.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon\",\"/aspects/Moon\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current period: Mercury mahadasha (Mercury is 6th lord of disease sitting in the 1st), Jupiter antardasha (Jupiter in the 8th house natally) until Nov 2026 — a dasha sequence that activates both the disease axis and the chronic/8th-house axis simultaneously.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord\",\"/dasha/current/antardasha/to\",\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Transits as of 2026-01-01: Saturn from Moon = 2 (within sade sati range 12-1-2), and Rahu transiting natal house 2 conjunct natal Moon while Ketu transits natal house 8 conjunct natal Jupiter — nodal transit over the Moon and across the 2/8 axis raises stress, diet, and sudden-event sensitivity.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/transits/saturnFromMoon\",\"tool:transits_at#/contacts/7\",\"tool:transits_at#/contacts/8\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mitigating: transiting Jupiter is retrograde in the natal 6th (house of disease) aspecting houses 10 and 12 — benefic presence on the 6th can indicate recovery capacity and successful management rather than pure affliction.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"tool:transits_at#/contacts/4\",\"/transits/contacts/4/inNatalHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"Upcoming Ketu mahadasha begins Dec 2029 after Mercury–Saturn ends Jul 2029; Saturn antardasha over a natal Saturn-Mars-Rahu conjunction in the 11th suggests a demanding stretch for stamina in 2026–2029, though not deterministically adverse.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/upcoming/0\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Vipareeta Raja Yoga via Jupiter in the 8th does not guarantee immunity to illness; it indicates resilience and favorable outcomes from adversity, so it should temper but not override the challenging 6th-lord-in-lagna indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/5\",\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"Exact divisional strength of the 6th/8th lords in relevant vargas (D3/D7/D9/D12 do not bear directly on health; D60 would help)\",\"Natal planetary strengths (shadbala/vimsopaka) not provided\",\"Actual medical history or symptoms of the subject\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart shows a mixed health picture: genuine vulnerabilities (6th lord Mercury in the 1st; Moon combust aspecting the 8th; Mars-Saturn-Rahu pressure on the lagna lord in the 11th; active Mercury-Jupiter dasha running through the disease and 8th-house axes; sade sati-range Saturn plus Rahu/Ketu transiting the natal Moon and 8th) are counterweighted by protective factors (Jupiter's Vipareeta Raja Yoga in the 8th, benefic Jupiter transiting the 6th). Overall conclusion: mixed — heightened sensitivity and stress-linked flare-ups likely during 2026–2029, but with real recovery and management capacity; no deterministic illness prediction should be made.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-application-01-evidence-order","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-01-evidence-order","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Ascendant lord (Moon) is placed in the 10th house of career, a kendra, which classically supports professional standing and direction.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/sign","/houses/10/occupants"]},{"claim":"The 10th is aspected by no malefic occupants and the lagna lord there does not constitute a loss indication; no chart evidence supports statement B.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/houses/10"]},{"claim":"While the placement supports career success in principle, it does not specify or guarantee any particular profession — no rule establishes that (statement C not established).","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/houses/10/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Lagna lord in the 10th supports career strength generally but cannot guarantee a specific profession from this placement alone.","evidence":["/houses/10/significations"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Option A is directly supported: the Cancer lagna's lord Moon sits in the 10th house (Aries) per /placements/Mouse... i.e., /placements/Moon/house = 10, and the 10th carries career significations (/houses/10/significations). Statement B contradicts standard doctrine and finds no support here. Statement C overclaims specificity, so it is rejected. Only A applies, giving a supportive polarity."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.9,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Ascendant lord (Moon) is placed in the 10th house of career, a kendra, which classically supports professional standing and direction.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/sign\",\"/houses/10/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 10th is aspected by no malefic occupants and the lagna lord there does not constitute a loss indication; no chart evidence supports statement B.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10\"]},{\"claim\":\"While the placement supports career success in principle, it does not specify or guarantee any particular profession — no rule establishes that (statement C not established).\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Lagna lord in the 10th supports career strength generally but cannot guarantee a specific profession from this placement alone.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/significations\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Option A is directly supported: the Cancer lagna's lord Moon sits in the 10th house (Aries) per /placements/Mouse... i.e., /placements/Moon/house = 10, and the 10th carries career significations (/houses/10/significations). Statement B contradicts standard doctrine and finds no support here. Statement C overclaims specificity, so it is rejected. Only A applies, giving a supportive polarity.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-application-01-paraphrase","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-01-paraphrase","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Ascendant lord (Moon, lord of Cancer lagna) placed in the 10th house of career — a classical supportive indication for professional standing and specialization","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house"]},{"claim":"The 10th-house placement does not fix or guarantee any specific profession; the chart indicates strength of career significations, not a particular vocation","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house"]},{"claim":"No chart evidence supports treating lagna lord in the 10th as primarily career-loss; the 10th is a kendra of action and status","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/9/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Lagna lord in the 10th is classically read as strengthening career and public standing, not as a loss indication.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Placement in the 10th supports professional success generally but cannot determine a specific profession from this evidence alone.","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"omission","correction":"Option A IS established by the stated rule and the chart (Moon as Cancer lagna lord in Aries, the 10th whole-sign house).","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart facts show Cancer lagna whose lord is Moon (/lagna/lord), and /lagna/lordInHouse = 10 with Moon in the 10th house (/placements/Moon/house = 10). This establishes option A. Option B contradicts standard doctrine and has no chart support; option C overclaims specificity, which no single placement guarantees; therefore D is also false."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.9,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Ascendant lord (Moon, lord of Cancer lagna) placed in the 10th house of career — a classical supportive indication for professional standing and specialization\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 10th-house placement does not fix or guarantee any specific profession; the chart indicates strength of career significations, not a particular vocation\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"No chart evidence supports treating lagna lord in the 10th as primarily career-loss; the 10th is a kendra of action and status\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Lagna lord in the 10th is classically read as strengthening career and public standing, not as a loss indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Placement in the 10th supports professional success generally but cannot determine a specific profession from this evidence alone.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"omission\",\"correction\":\"Option A IS established by the stated rule and the chart (Moon as Cancer lagna lord in Aries, the 10th whole-sign house).\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart facts show Cancer lagna whose lord is Moon (/lagna/lord), and /lagna/lordInHouse = 10 with Moon in the 10th house (/placements/Moon/house = 10). This establishes option A. Option B contradicts standard doctrine and has no chart support; option C overclaims specificity, which no single placement guarantees; therefore D is also false.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-application-01-evidence-order","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-01-evidence-order","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The ascendant lord (Moon, lord of Cancer lagna) is placed in the 10th house of career/status in Aries, which classical doctrine treats as a strong support for professional success and specialization.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/sign","/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/sign"]},{"claim":"The 10th lord Mars is placed in the 9th with a mutual-aspect Raja Yoga between Mars (10th lord) and Jupiter (9th lord), reinforcing the career-supportive reading rather than contradicting it.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse","/yogas/2","/yogas/3/name"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Ascendant lord in the 10th is a kendra placement of the lagna lord, classically read as strength for self and career, not primarily a career-loss indication. No chart evidence supports a loss reading here.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The placement indicates career strength/success potential but does not guarantee any specific profession; specific profession requires further factors (D10, dasha context) and is never 'guaranteed' by one placement.","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/vargas/D10"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Statement A is directly established: the chart shows Cancer lagna with its lord Moon in the 10th house (/lagna/lord = Moon, /lagna/lordInHouse = 10, /placements/Moon/house = 10), a kendra placement traditionally supportive of professional success. Statement B reverses standard doctrine without support, and statement C overclaims certainty; neither is applicable. The polarity of the applicable statement (A) is positive, so conclusion is supportive."},"extracted":"{\n \"case_id\": \"career-application-01-evidence-order\",\n \"domain\": \"career\",\n \"conclusion\": \"supportive\",\n \"confidence\": 0.9,\n \"selected_option_ids\": [\"A\"],\n \"factors\": [\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"The ascendant lord (Moon, lord of Cancer lagna) is placed in the 10th house of career/status in Aries, which classical doctrine treats as a strong support for professional success and specialization.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/lagna/sign\", \"/lagna/lord\", \"/lagna/lordInHouse\", \"/placements/Moon/house\", \"/placements/Moon/sign\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"The 10th lord Mars is placed in the 9th with a mutual-aspect Raja Yoga between Mars (10th lord) and Jupiter (9th lord), reinforcing the career-supportive reading rather than contradicting it.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\", \"/yogas/2\", \"/yogas/3/name\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"contradictions\": [\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"B\",\n   \"error_type\": \"doctrinal\",\n   \"correction\": \"Ascendant lord in the 10th is a kendra placement of the lagna lord, classically read as strength for self and career, not primarily a career-loss indication. No chart evidence supports a loss reading here.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/lagna/lordInHouse\", \"/placements/Moon/house\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"C\",\n   \"error_type\": \"overclaim\",\n   \"correction\": \"The placement indicates career strength/success potential but does not guarantee any specific profession; specific profession requires further factors (D10, dasha context) and is never 'guaranteed' by one placement.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Moon/house\", \"/vargas/D10\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"missing_information\": [],\n \"rationale\": \"Statement A is directly established: the chart shows Cancer lagna with its lord Moon in the 10th house (/lagna/lord = Moon, /lagna/lordInHouse = 10, /placements/Moon/house = 10), a kendra placement traditionally supportive of professional success. Statement B reverses standard doctrine without support, and statement C overclaims certainty; neither is applicable. The polarity of the applicable statement (A) is positive, so conclusion is supportive.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-application-01-evidence-order","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-01-evidence-order","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The ascendant lord Moon is placed in the 10th house of career, a kendra, which the classical rule treats as supportive of professional success and standing.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/sign","/lagna/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"Lagnesh in the 10th is not a career-loss indication; statement B contradicts standard doctrine.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house"]},{"claim":"No rule or chart evidence guarantees a specific profession from this placement alone; the D10 shows supporting structure (Sun, Mercury, Moon in Leo 10th of D10) but no specific-profession guarantee follows from A.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S-B","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Ascendant lord in the tenth is a strength for career, not primarily a loss indication.","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/houses/10/significations"]},{"statement_id":"S-C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The placement supports professional success generally but does not guarantee a particular profession.","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only statement A is established: /lagna/lord is Moon, and /placements/Moon/house = 10 (Aries), with the Moon also aspecting the 4th — lagnesh in the 10th kendra is classically read as supportive of professional success/specialization. B is doctrinally wrong, and C overclaims; neither is applicable. The conclusion polarity therefore follows A: supportive. Supporting context: Jupiter (lord of 9) aspects the 10th per /aspects/Jupiter, forming a Raja Yoga with Mars (/yogas index 2)."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.9,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The ascendant lord Moon is placed in the 10th house of career, a kendra, which the classical rule treats as supportive of professional success and standing.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/sign\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"Lagnesh in the 10th is not a career-loss indication; statement B contradicts standard doctrine.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"No rule or chart evidence guarantees a specific profession from this placement alone; the D10 shows supporting structure (Sun, Mercury, Moon in Leo 10th of D10) but no specific-profession guarantee follows from A.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S-B\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Ascendant lord in the tenth is a strength for career, not primarily a loss indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S-C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The placement supports professional success generally but does not guarantee a particular profession.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only statement A is established: /lagna/lord is Moon, and /placements/Moon/house = 10 (Aries), with the Moon also aspecting the 4th — lagnesh in the 10th kendra is classically read as supportive of professional success/specialization. B is doctrinally wrong, and C overclaims; neither is applicable. The conclusion polarity therefore follows A: supportive. Supporting context: Jupiter (lord of 9) aspects the 10th per /aspects/Jupiter, forming a Raja Yoga with Mars (/yogas index 2).\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-synthesis-01-paraphrase","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-01-paraphrase","domain":"career","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.6,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Jupiter, the lagna lord and a single-lordship Raja Yoga (rules 1st and 4th kendras/trikonas), sits in the 10th house of career — a strong career anchor.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/yogas/0"]},{"claim":"10th lord Mercury is well placed in the 2nd house (wealth/speech) with benefic Venus, linking career to finance, communication and earning capacity; Mercury–Venus in 2nd also supports Adhi Yoga from the Moon.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"Current Saturn mahadasha with Saturn aspecting natal house 10 (Saturn's 3rd aspect from Scorpio/12th), giving disciplined but heavy career pressure during 2022–2041.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current","/aspects/Saturn"]},{"claim":"Ketu aspects the 10th house, adding detachment or unconventional shifts in career direction.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Ketu"]},{"claim":"Natal Saturn sits in the 12th in enemy sign with debilitated Rahu — its dasha periods may bring expenditure, foreign relocation, or behind-the-scenes roles rather than visible authority.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Rahu/house","/placements/Rahu/dignity"]},{"claim":"In D10, Saturn and Ketu occupy the 12th (own-sign Saturn) while Sun-Moon-Venus cluster in the 2nd and Jupiter-Rahu sit in the 6th — career success comes through service and steady accumulation rather than positional power.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements"]},{"claim":"Transit Saturn in Pisces (natal 4th) aspects natal house 10 as of Jan 2026, coinciding with Saturn–Mercury antardasha (Mercury being 10th lord), pointing to an active, work-focused phase through late 2027.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["tool:transits_at#0/transits/contacts/6","/dasha/current/antardasha"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart shows genuine career strength: lagna lord Jupiter's placement in the 10th with a kendra-trikona Raja Yoga, plus 10th lord Mercury joining Venus in the wealth house. However, the current long Saturn dasha draws energy from a 12th-house Saturn afflicted by debilitated Rahu, and Ketu's aspect on the 10th suggests phases of detachment or redirection. Net indication is a capable professional life with meaningful output, tempered by periodic withdrawal, foreign/isolation themes, and less appetite for overt authority during Saturn's dasha."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-synthesis-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.6,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Jupiter, the lagna lord and a single-lordship Raja Yoga (rules 1st and 4th kendras/trikonas), sits in the 10th house of career — a strong career anchor.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/yogas/0\"]},{\"claim\":\"10th lord Mercury is well placed in the 2nd house (wealth/speech) with benefic Venus, linking career to finance, communication and earning capacity; Mercury–Venus in 2nd also supports Adhi Yoga from the Moon.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current Saturn mahadasha with Saturn aspecting natal house 10 (Saturn's 3rd aspect from Scorpio/12th), giving disciplined but heavy career pressure during 2022–2041.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current\",\"/aspects/Saturn\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu aspects the 10th house, adding detachment or unconventional shifts in career direction.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Ketu\"]},{\"claim\":\"Natal Saturn sits in the 12th in enemy sign with debilitated Rahu — its dasha periods may bring expenditure, foreign relocation, or behind-the-scenes roles rather than visible authority.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"In D10, Saturn and Ketu occupy the 12th (own-sign Saturn) while Sun-Moon-Venus cluster in the 2nd and Jupiter-Rahu sit in the 6th — career success comes through service and steady accumulation rather than positional power.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements\"]},{\"claim\":\"Transit Saturn in Pisces (natal 4th) aspects natal house 10 as of Jan 2026, coinciding with Saturn–Mercury antardasha (Mercury being 10th lord), pointing to an active, work-focused phase through late 2027.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"tool:transits_at#0/transits/contacts/6\",\"/dasha/current/antardasha\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart shows genuine career strength: lagna lord Jupiter's placement in the 10th with a kendra-trikona Raja Yoga, plus 10th lord Mercury joining Venus in the wealth house. However, the current long Saturn dasha draws energy from a 12th-house Saturn afflicted by debilitated Rahu, and Ketu's aspect on the 10th suggests phases of detachment or redirection. Net indication is a capable professional life with meaningful output, tempered by periodic withdrawal, foreign/isolation themes, and less appetite for overt authority during Saturn's dasha.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-application-02-counterfactual","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-02-counterfactual","confidence":0.95,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"rationale":"The chart facts show the tenth lord is Mars and it is placed in the 2nd house (/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse = 2), not the first. Statements A–C all presuppose the tenth lord in the first, which this chart does not establish; therefore none of them applies, and D is selected."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-02-counterfactual\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"confidence\":0.95,\"rationale\":\"The chart facts show the tenth lord is Mars and it is placed in the 2nd house (/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse = 2), not the first. Statements A–C all presuppose the tenth lord in the first, which this chart does not establish; therefore none of them applies, and D is selected.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-application-02-counterfactual","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-02-counterfactual","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"rationale":"The chart facts show the tenth lord is Mars and it is placed in the 2nd house (/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse = 2), not the first. Therefore none of statements A–C (which all concern the tenth lord in the first) is established by this chart; D applies. Conclusion polarity is set from the applicable listed statement only: D is neutral/none-applicable, so no supportive or challenging career indication can be claimed from these rules."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-02-counterfactual\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"confidence\":0.9,\"rationale\":\"The chart facts show the tenth lord is Mars and it is placed in the 2nd house (/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse = 2), not the first. Therefore none of statements A–C (which all concern the tenth lord in the first) is established by this chart; D applies. Conclusion polarity is set from the applicable listed statement only: D is neutral/none-applicable, so no supportive or challenging career indication can be claimed from these rules.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-synthesis-01-paraphrase","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-01-paraphrase","domain":"career","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.6,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Jupiter (Lagna lord) in the 10th house is a strong career anchor, forming a single-lordship Raja Yoga (rules 4th kendra and 1st trikona), indicating status and authority through dharmic work.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/yogas/0"]},{"claim":"10th lord Mercury placed in the 2nd house links career to wealth, speech, finance and communication; Mercury with Venus there supports earning through skilled articulation.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"claim":"Adhi Yoga from the Moon (Venus, Mercury benefics in 6th/7th/8th from Moon) indicates a comfortable, respected life overall.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"Mars strong in own sign Aries in the 5th aspects the 11th house of gains, supporting initiative-driven income.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/aspects/Mars"]},{"claim":"Jupiter is retrograde and in enemy sign Virgo in the 10th — dignity weakness tempers the Raja Yoga's full expression.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde"]},{"claim":"Ketu aspects the 10th house, adding detachment or discontinuity to public standing.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/10/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Saturn, 2nd/3rd lord, sits in the 12th (enemy sign) with debilitated Rahu — income linked to expenditure, foreign settings, or behind-the-scenes work; Saturn also aspects the 9th and 2nd.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Rahu/dignity","/aspects/Saturn"]},{"claim":"Current Saturn mahadasha / Mercury antardasha: Saturn dasha lord in the 12th colors the period with effort and isolation themes, though Mercury antardasha (10th lord) activates career matters through 2027.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current"]},{"claim":"D10: Jupiter exalted-equivalent in Cancer in D10 6th, Saturn own-sign Capricorn in D10 12th, Sun-Moon-Venus cluster in Pisces 2nd — service-oriented, disciplined career with steady resource flow but a 12th-house Saturn suggesting foreign/institutional settings.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Exact career field/profession of the subject for corroboration"],"rationale":"The chart shows genuine career strength — Lagna lord Jupiter in the 10th with a Raja Yoga, 10th lord Mercury in the wealth house, and Adhi Yoga — but dignity weaknesses (Jupiter enemy-sign retrograde, Saturn enemy-sign in the 12th with debilitated Rahu, Ketu aspecting the 10th) prevent an unambiguously supportive reading. The current Saturn–Mercury period keeps career themes active but colored by Saturn's 12th-house placement."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-synthesis-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.6,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Jupiter (Lagna lord) in the 10th house is a strong career anchor, forming a single-lordship Raja Yoga (rules 4th kendra and 1st trikona), indicating status and authority through dharmic work.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/yogas/0\"]},{\"claim\":\"10th lord Mercury placed in the 2nd house links career to wealth, speech, finance and communication; Mercury with Venus there supports earning through skilled articulation.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Adhi Yoga from the Moon (Venus, Mercury benefics in 6th/7th/8th from Moon) indicates a comfortable, respected life overall.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars strong in own sign Aries in the 5th aspects the 11th house of gains, supporting initiative-driven income.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/aspects/Mars\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter is retrograde and in enemy sign Virgo in the 10th — dignity weakness tempers the Raja Yoga's full expression.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu aspects the 10th house, adding detachment or discontinuity to public standing.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn, 2nd/3rd lord, sits in the 12th (enemy sign) with debilitated Rahu — income linked to expenditure, foreign settings, or behind-the-scenes work; Saturn also aspects the 9th and 2nd.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/dignity\",\"/aspects/Saturn\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current Saturn mahadasha / Mercury antardasha: Saturn dasha lord in the 12th colors the period with effort and isolation themes, though Mercury antardasha (10th lord) activates career matters through 2027.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10: Jupiter exalted-equivalent in Cancer in D10 6th, Saturn own-sign Capricorn in D10 12th, Sun-Moon-Venus cluster in Pisces 2nd — service-oriented, disciplined career with steady resource flow but a 12th-house Saturn suggesting foreign/institutional settings.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"Exact career field/profession of the subject for corroboration\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart shows genuine career strength — Lagna lord Jupiter in the 10th with a Raja Yoga, 10th lord Mercury in the wealth house, and Adhi Yoga — but dignity weaknesses (Jupiter enemy-sign retrograde, Saturn enemy-sign in the 12th with debilitated Rahu, Ketu aspecting the 10th) prevent an unambiguously supportive reading. The current Saturn–Mercury period keeps career themes active but colored by Saturn's 12th-house placement.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-application-02-counterfactual","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-02-counterfactual","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"rationale":"The chart facts show the tenth lord is Mars and it is placed in the 2nd house (/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse = 2), not in the first. Therefore none of statements A–C (which all concern the tenth lord in the first) are established by this chart. Statement D applies."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-02-counterfactual\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"confidence\":0.9,\"rationale\":\"The chart facts show the tenth lord is Mars and it is placed in the 2nd house (/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse = 2), not in the first. Therefore none of statements A–C (which all concern the tenth lord in the first) are established by this chart. Statement D applies.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-synthesis-01-paraphrase","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-01-paraphrase","domain":"career","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.7,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Lagna lord Jupiter placed in the 10th house of career, forming a Raja Yoga (Jupiter rules both the kendra 4th and trikona 1st), is a major career-supporting combination for status and authority.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house","/yogas/0"]},{"claim":"However, Jupiter is retrograde and in an enemy sign (Virgo) in the natal chart, so career gains come with friction, delays, or a sense of under-recognition.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/placements/Jupiter/dignity"]},{"claim":"The D10 dashamsa lagna is Aquarius ruled by Saturn, and Saturn sits in its own sign Capricorn in D10's 12th — indicating disciplined, behind-the-scenes or institutional work rather than public limelight.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/lagnaSign","/vargas/D10/placements/6"]},{"claim":"In D1, the 10th lord Mercury occupies the 2nd house with Venus (11th lord) — linking career to finance, speech, commerce, and income generation; this Venus–Mercury pairing in the 2nd also supports Adhi Yoga from the Moon.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Venus/house","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"Ketu aspects the 10th house (from the 6th), which can bring detachment from conventional status, sudden shifts in professional direction, or technical/specialized inclinations.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Ketu","/placements/Ketu/house"]},{"claim":"The current Saturn mahadasha (2022–2041) runs Saturn, which natally sits in the 12th in enemy sign Scorpio conjunct Rahu — the dasha lord's weak placement suggests heavy workload, expenditure, foreign/isolated postings, or working without proportional recognition during much of this period.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Rahu/house"]},{"claim":"The running Saturn–Mercury antardasha (2025-04-04 to 2027-12-13) activates the 10th-lord Mercury in the 2nd, a comparatively favorable window within the Saturn dasha for work tied to communication, accounts, advisory or commercial roles, and income.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/dasha/current/antardasha","/placements/Mercury/house"]},{"claim":"Transit Jupiter in Gemini aspects the natal 11th house of gains while transiting Saturn in Pisces aspects the natal 10th house, indicating steady effort toward gains around the reference date, though Saturn's aspect on the 6th and 10th keeps pressure on service and duty.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["tool:transits_at#/0","/transits/contacts/6"]},{"claim":"Mars strong in its own sign Aries in the 5th aspects the 11th and 12th houses, giving drive, initiative, and capacity for gains through self-directed effort, but also impulsive spending or risk-taking that can offset gains.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Mars/dignity","/aspects/Mars"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Exact nature of the native's profession/industry (needed for concrete role-level synthesis)","Full birth-time rectification confirmation given sensitivity of house cusps in Whole Sign system"],"rationale":"Career fundamentals are genuinely strong: lagna lord Jupiter in the 10th forms a single-lordship Raja Yoga (/yogas/0), and the 10th lord Mercury joins the 11th lord Venus in the wealth house, tying profession to income. But both key grahas are compromised — Jupiter retrograde in an enemy sign, Mercury neutral — and the long-running Saturn dasha draws on a Saturn placed in the 12th with Rahu in an enemy sign, coloring the period with workload, expense, and delayed recognition. The current Saturn–Mercury antardasha is the most workable stretch in the near term. Net indication: mixed, with capability and status potential tempered by the Saturn dasha's grind."},"extracted":"{\n \"case_id\": \"career-synthesis-01-paraphrase\",\n \"domain\": \"career\",\n \"conclusion\": \"mixed\",\n \"confidence\": 0.7,\n \"selected_option_ids\": [],\n \"factors\": [\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Lagna lord Jupiter placed in the 10th house of career, forming a Raja Yoga (Jupiter rules both the kendra 4th and trikona 1st), is a major career-supporting combination for status and authority.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/lagna/lordInHouse\", \"/placements/Jupiter/house\", \"/yogas/0\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"However, Jupiter is retrograde and in an enemy sign (Virgo) in the natal chart, so career gains come with friction, delays, or a sense of under-recognition.\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\", \"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"The D10 dashamsa lagna is Aquarius ruled by Saturn, and Saturn sits in its own sign Capricorn in D10's 12th — indicating disciplined, behind-the-scenes or institutional work rather than public limelight.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/vargas/D10/lagnaSign\", \"/vargas/D10/placements/6\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"In D1, the 10th lord Mercury occupies the 2nd house with Venus (11th lord) — linking career to finance, speech, commerce, and income generation; this Venus–Mercury pairing in the 2nd also supports Adhi Yoga from the Moon.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mercury/house\", \"/placements/Venus/house\", \"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\", \"/yogas/1\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Ketu aspects the 10th house (from the 6th), which can bring detachment from conventional status, sudden shifts in professional direction, or technical/specialized inclinations.\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/aspects/Ketu\", \"/placements/Ketu/house\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"The current Saturn mahadasha (2022–2041) runs Saturn, which natally sits in the 12th in enemy sign Scorpio conjunct Rahu — the dasha lord's weak placement suggests heavy workload, expenditure, foreign/isolated postings, or working without proportional recognition during much of this period.\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/dasha/current/mahadasha\", \"/placements/Saturn/house\", \"/placements/Saturn/dignity\", \"/placements/Rahu/house\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"The running Saturn–Mercury antardasha (2025-04-04 to 2027-12-13) activates the 10th-lord Mercury in the 2nd, a comparatively favorable window within the Saturn dasha for work tied to communication, accounts, advisory or commercial roles, and income.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/dasha/current/antardasha\", \"/placements/Mercury/house\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Transit Jupiter in Gemini aspects the natal 11th house of gains while transiting Saturn in Pisces aspects the natal 10th house, indicating steady effort toward gains around the reference date, though Saturn's aspect on the 6th and 10th keeps pressure on service and duty.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"tool:transits_at#/0\", \"/transits/contacts/6\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Mars strong in its own sign Aries in the 5th aspects the 11th and 12th houses, giving drive, initiative, and capacity for gains through self-directed effort, but also impulsive spending or risk-taking that can offset gains.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Mars/dignity\", \"/aspects/Mars\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"contradictions\": [],\n \"missing_information\": [\n  \"Exact nature of the native's profession/industry (needed for concrete role-level synthesis)\",\n  \"Full birth-time rectification confirmation given sensitivity of house cusps in Whole Sign system\"\n ],\n \"rationale\": \"Career fundamentals are genuinely strong: lagna lord Jupiter in the 10th forms a single-lordship Raja Yoga (/yogas/0), and the 10th lord Mercury joins the 11th lord Venus in the wealth house, tying profession to income. But both key grahas are compromised — Jupiter retrograde in an enemy sign, Mercury neutral — and the long-running Saturn dasha draws on a Saturn placed in the 12th with Rahu in an enemy sign, coloring the period with workload, expense, and delayed recognition. The current Saturn–Mercury antardasha is the most workable stretch in the near term. Net indication: mixed, with capability and status potential tempered by the Saturn dasha's grind.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-application-01-paraphrase","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-01-paraphrase","confidence":0.95,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"rationale":"The chart shows the lagna lord Sun placed in the 11th house of gains (/lagna/lordInHouse = 11, /placements/Sun/house = 11, with Venus lord of the 10th also there forming a raja yoga per /yogas[4]). Statement A correctly states this is treated as supportive of gains and earning capacity — a proportionate reading consistent with the 11th house signifying 'gains, income, fulfilment of desire' (/reference/houseSignifications/11). Statement B overclaims: classical placement supports gains but never guarantees 'enormous profits,' especially with Ketu also in the 11th and Kemadruma Yoga present (/yogas[0]). Statement C contradicts the standard signification of the 11th as a house of gains; nothing in the rule or chart establishes it as primarily a loss indication. Hence only A applies."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-01-paraphrase\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"confidence\":0.95,\"rationale\":\"The chart shows the lagna lord Sun placed in the 11th house of gains (/lagna/lordInHouse = 11, /placements/Sun/house = 11, with Venus lord of the 10th also there forming a raja yoga per /yogas[4]). Statement A correctly states this is treated as supportive of gains and earning capacity — a proportionate reading consistent with the 11th house signifying 'gains, income, fulfilment of desire' (/reference/houseSignifications/11). Statement B overclaims: classical placement supports gains but never guarantees 'enormous profits,' especially with Ketu also in the 11th and Kemadruma Yoga present (/yogas[0]). Statement C contradicts the standard signification of the 11th as a house of gains; nothing in the rule or chart establishes it as primarily a loss indication. Hence only A applies.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-synthesis-01-evidence-order","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-01-evidence-order","domain":"career","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.6,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Lagna lord Jupiter in the 10th house of career is a strong anchor for professional life and public standing.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/lagna/lordInHouse"]},{"claim":"Jupiter forms a Raja Yoga by ruling both a kendra (4) and a trikona (1), supporting status and authority.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/0"]},{"claim":"10th lord Mercury placed in the 2nd house links career to wealth, speech and accumulated resources; Mercury also participates in Adhi Yoga with Venus.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"Ketu aspects the 10th house, introducing detachment or unconventional elements in career direction.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/aspects/Ketu"]},{"claim":"Natal Saturn (current mahadasha lord 2022–2041) sits in the 12th house in enemy sign, suggesting periods of expenditure, foreign connections or reduced visibility during Saturn dasha.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/dasha/current/mahadasha"]},{"claim":"Current antardasha lord Mercury is well-placed in the 2nd with Venus and in own-sign Virgo in D10's 11th (gains from profession).","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/vargas/D10/placements/3"]},{"claim":"D10 lagna lord Saturn in its own sign Capricorn in the D10 12th suggests career involving behind-the-scenes work, institutions, or foreign settings, with strong but self-contained discipline.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/lagnaSign","/vargas/D10/placements/6"]},{"claim":"D10 Jupiter in Cancer (6th) with Rahu indicates service-oriented work environments and possible workplace friction or competition.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/4","/vargas/D10/placements/7"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"A Raja Yoga from single lordship supports potential for status but does not guarantee it; it must be weighed against Saturn dasha running through the 12th house.","evidence":["/yogas/0","/dasha/current/mahadasha"]}],"missing_information":["Navamsa (D9) strength of Jupiter and Mercury for fuller career assessment","Exact pratyantardasha sequencing within Saturn–Mercury beyond current period"],"rationale":"The chart shows genuine career strength: lagna lord in the 10th (/placements/Jupiter/house), a Raja Yoga (/yogas/0), and 10th lord Mercury linked to the wealth house (/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse). However, the long-running Saturn mahadasha places the spotlight on 12th-house themes (/placements/Saturn/house), tempering visibility and gains. Overall indication is mixed-to-supportive: solid professional foundation with periodic phases of lower profile or higher expenditure."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-synthesis-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.6,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Lagna lord Jupiter in the 10th house of career is a strong anchor for professional life and public standing.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter forms a Raja Yoga by ruling both a kendra (4) and a trikona (1), supporting status and authority.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0\"]},{\"claim\":\"10th lord Mercury placed in the 2nd house links career to wealth, speech and accumulated resources; Mercury also participates in Adhi Yoga with Venus.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu aspects the 10th house, introducing detachment or unconventional elements in career direction.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Ketu\"]},{\"claim\":\"Natal Saturn (current mahadasha lord 2022–2041) sits in the 12th house in enemy sign, suggesting periods of expenditure, foreign connections or reduced visibility during Saturn dasha.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/dasha/current/mahadasha\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current antardasha lord Mercury is well-placed in the 2nd with Venus and in own-sign Virgo in D10's 11th (gains from profession).\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/3\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 lagna lord Saturn in its own sign Capricorn in the D10 12th suggests career involving behind-the-scenes work, institutions, or foreign settings, with strong but self-contained discipline.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/lagnaSign\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/6\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Jupiter in Cancer (6th) with Rahu indicates service-oriented work environments and possible workplace friction or competition.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/4\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/7\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"A Raja Yoga from single lordship supports potential for status but does not guarantee it; it must be weighed against Saturn dasha running through the 12th house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0\",\"/dasha/current/mahadasha\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"Navamsa (D9) strength of Jupiter and Mercury for fuller career assessment\",\"Exact pratyantardasha sequencing within Saturn–Mercury beyond current period\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart shows genuine career strength: lagna lord in the 10th (/placements/Jupiter/house), a Raja Yoga (/yogas/0), and 10th lord Mercury linked to the wealth house (/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse). However, the long-running Saturn mahadasha places the spotlight on 12th-house themes (/placements/Saturn/house), tempering visibility and gains. Overall indication is mixed-to-supportive: solid professional foundation with periodic phases of lower profile or higher expenditure.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-synthesis-01-evidence-order","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-01-evidence-order","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.7,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Lagna lord Jupiter placed in the 10th house of career is a strong central indicator: the self's ruler sits in the karma bhava, tying identity to profession and public standing.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/lagna/lordInHouse"]},{"claim":"Jupiter forms a Raja Yoga by single lordship of both a kendra (4th) and trikona (1st), and this yoga-lord occupies the 10th — amplifying authority and status potential.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/0","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Jupiter is retrograde and in 'Enemy' dignity in Virgo (10th): the yoga functions but with internal revision, delays, or unconventional expression of authority.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/houses/9/sign"]},{"claim":"Mercury, the 7th and 10th lord, is placed in the 2nd house with Venus — career lord linked to wealth/speech house, suggesting income through communication, trade, advisory or analytical skill.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"claim":"Venus–Mercury form Adhi Yoga (benefics in 6th/7th/8th from Moon), supporting gains and comfort through professional activity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"Ketu aspects the 10th house, introducing detachment, sudden shifts of direction, or technical/occult flavor in career.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/aspects/Ketu","/houses/9/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Saturn (current mahadasha lord) is placed in the 12th with Rahu — dasha lord in a dusthana suggests the Saturn period (2022–2041) carries themes of foreign settings, institutions, behind-the-scenes work, expenditure, or isolation alongside duty.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha","/placements/Saturn/house","/houses/11/occupants"]},{"claim":"D10 shows lagna Aquarius with Saturn (its dispositor chain via Ketu/Saturn in Capricorn 12th) and Sun+Moon+Venus clustered in the D10 2nd (Pisces) — earnings-oriented career; Mercury in D10 11th supports gains through intellect/networks.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements","/vargas/D10/lagnaSign"]},{"claim":"Transit context (asOf 2026-01-01): Jupiter retrograde transiting natal 7th aspecting natal 7th; Saturn transiting Pisces (natal 4th) aspecting houses 1, 6, 10 — transit Saturn directly touches the 10th, indicating pressure/restructuring phase on career during its current run.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/transits/contacts/4","/transits/contacts/6/aspectingNatalHouses"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"A Raja Yoga in the 10th does not guarantee uninterrupted rise: Jupiter's retrograde motion, Enemy dignity, and Ketu's aspect on the 10th temper the promise with delays and redirection. The correct reading is strong career orientation realized unevenly.","evidence":["/yogas/0","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/aspects/Ketu"]},{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"omission","correction":"Any synthesis must weigh that the running Saturn mahadasha lord sits in the 12th with debilitated Rahu; ignoring this would overstate the favorable 10th-house picture for the 2022–2041 span.","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Rahu/dignity"]}],"missing_information":["Exact antardasha-level career events (promotions, job changes) would require correlating specific past dates with dasha_timeline results","No birth-time rectification status; lagna degree sensitivity affects whole-sign assignments near boundaries","Upapada/amatyakaraka (Jaimini) analysis not present in chart facts"],"rationale":"The chart's core career signature is strong: lagna lord Jupiter in the 10th carrying a kendra-trikona Raja Yoga (/yogas/0, /placements/Jupiter/house), reinforced by 10th lord Mercury in the wealth house with Venus (/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse) and Adhi Yoga (/yogas/1). Qualifications are Jupiter's retrogression and Enemy dignity, Ketu's aspect on the 10th, and above all the current Saturn mahadasha whose lord occupies the 12th with Rahu — pointing to a long period where career progress routes through foreign/institutional/behind-the-scenes channels and demands patience. Transit Saturn currently aspecting the natal 10th confirms an active restructuring phase. Net assessment: fundamentally supportive career promise, expressed with delays, detours, and non-linear growth during the Saturn dasha."},"extracted":"{\n \"case_id\": \"career-synthesis-01-evidence-order\",\n \"domain\": \"career\",\n \"conclusion\": \"supportive\",\n \"confidence\": 0.7,\n \"selected_option_ids\": [],\n \"factors\": [\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Lagna lord Jupiter placed in the 10th house of career is a strong central indicator: the self's ruler sits in the karma bhava, tying identity to profession and public standing.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Jupiter/house\", \"/lagna/lordInHouse\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Jupiter forms a Raja Yoga by single lordship of both a kendra (4th) and trikona (1st), and this yoga-lord occupies the 10th — amplifying authority and status potential.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/0\", \"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Jupiter is retrograde and in 'Enemy' dignity in Virgo (10th): the yoga functions but with internal revision, delays, or unconventional expression of authority.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\", \"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\", \"/houses/9/sign\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Mercury, the 7th and 10th lord, is placed in the 2nd house with Venus — career lord linked to wealth/speech house, suggesting income through communication, trade, advisory or analytical skill.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\", \"/placements/Mercury/house\", \"/placements/Venus/house\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Venus–Mercury form Adhi Yoga (benefics in 6th/7th/8th from Moon), supporting gains and comfort through professional activity.\",\n   \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/1\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Ketu aspects the 10th house, introducing detachment, sudden shifts of direction, or technical/occult flavor in career.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/aspects/Ketu\", \"/houses/9/aspectedBy\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Saturn (current mahadasha lord) is placed in the 12th with Rahu — dasha lord in a dusthana suggests the Saturn period (2022–2041) carries themes of foreign settings, institutions, behind-the-scenes work, expenditure, or isolation alongside duty.\",\n   \"effect\": \"challenging\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/dasha/current/mahadasha\", \"/placements/Saturn/house\", \"/houses/11/occupants\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"D10 shows lagna Aquarius with Saturn (its dispositor chain via Ketu/Saturn in Capricorn 12th) and Sun+Moon+Venus clustered in the D10 2nd (Pisces) — earnings-oriented career; Mercury in D10 11th supports gains through intellect/networks.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/vargas/D10/placements\", \"/vargas/D10/lagnaSign\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"claim\": \"Transit context (asOf 2026-01-01): Jupiter retrograde transiting natal 7th aspecting natal 7th; Saturn transiting Pisces (natal 4th) aspecting houses 1, 6, 10 — transit Saturn directly touches the 10th, indicating pressure/restructuring phase on career during its current run.\",\n   \"effect\": \"mixed\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/transits/contacts/4\", \"/transits/contacts/6/aspectingNatalHouses\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"contradictions\": [\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"S1\",\n   \"error_type\": \"overclaim\",\n   \"correction\": \"A Raja Yoga in the 10th does not guarantee uninterrupted rise: Jupiter's retrograde motion, Enemy dignity, and Ketu's aspect on the 10th temper the promise with delays and redirection. The correct reading is strong career orientation realized unevenly.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/yogas/0\", \"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\", \"/aspects/Ketu\"]\n  },\n  {\n   \"statement_id\": \"S2\",\n   \"error_type\": \"omission\",\n   \"correction\": \"Any synthesis must weigh that the running Saturn mahadasha lord sits in the 12th with debilitated Rahu; ignoring this would overstate the favorable 10th-house picture for the 2022–2041 span.\",\n   \"evidence\": [\"/dasha/current/mahadasha\", \"/placements/Saturn/house\", \"/placements/Rahu/dignity\"]\n  }\n ],\n \"missing_information\": [\n  \"Exact antardasha-level career events (promotions, job changes) would require correlating specific past dates with dasha_timeline results\",\n  \"No birth-time rectification status; lagna degree sensitivity affects whole-sign assignments near boundaries\",\n  \"Upapada/amatyakaraka (Jaimini) analysis not present in chart facts\"\n ],\n \"rationale\": \"The chart's core career signature is strong: lagna lord Jupiter in the 10th carrying a kendra-trikona Raja Yoga (/yogas/0, /placements/Jupiter/house), reinforced by 10th lord Mercury in the wealth house with Venus (/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse) and Adhi Yoga (/yogas/1). Qualifications are Jupiter's retrogression and Enemy dignity, Ketu's aspect on the 10th, and above all the current Saturn mahadasha whose lord occupies the 12th with Rahu — pointing to a long period where career progress routes through foreign/institutional/behind-the-scenes channels and demands patience. Transit Saturn currently aspecting the natal 10th confirms an active restructuring phase. Net assessment: fundamentally supportive career promise, expressed with delays, detours, and non-linear growth during the Saturn dasha.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-application-01-paraphrase","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-01-paraphrase","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The ascendant lord (Sun, lord of Leo lagna) is placed in the 11th house of gains, which classically supports earning capacity and fulfilment of desires.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house","/houses/10"]},{"claim":"Statement B overclaims: placement in the 11th supports gains but does not guarantee enormous profits; the Sun is neutral in dignity and the 11th also contains Ketu, a shadowy graha that can dilute results.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Sun/dignity","/houses/10/occupants"]},{"claim":"Statement C contradicts the classical reading: the 11th house signifies gains and income, not financial loss; loss houses are 6, 8, 12.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/10/significations","/reference/dusthanas"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only option A follows from the stated rule and the chart: /lagna/lordInHouse shows the ascendant lord Sun in the 11th house (/placements/Sun/house), whose significations are 'gains, income... fulfilment of desire' (/houses/10/significations). This supports gains without guaranteeing them (ruling out B) and certainly does not indicate loss (ruling out C). D fails since A is established."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.9,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The ascendant lord (Sun, lord of Leo lagna) is placed in the 11th house of gains, which classically supports earning capacity and fulfilment of desires.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/10\"]},{\"claim\":\"Statement B overclaims: placement in the 11th supports gains but does not guarantee enormous profits; the Sun is neutral in dignity and the 11th also contains Ketu, a shadowy graha that can dilute results.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/dignity\",\"/houses/10/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"Statement C contradicts the classical reading: the 11th house signifies gains and income, not financial loss; loss houses are 6, 8, 12.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/significations\",\"/reference/dusthanas\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only option A follows from the stated rule and the chart: /lagna/lordInHouse shows the ascendant lord Sun in the 11th house (/placements/Sun/house), whose significations are 'gains, income... fulfilment of desire' (/houses/10/significations). This supports gains without guaranteeing them (ruling out B) and certainly does not indicate loss (ruling out C). D fails since A is established.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"career-synthesis-01-evidence-order","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-01-evidence-order","domain":"career","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.65,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Lagna lord Jupiter placed in the 10th house of career links self and life-direction directly to profession — a strong anchor for career significance.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9/occupants","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Jupiter forms a Raja Yoga by ruling both a kendra (4th) and trikona (1st), and this yogakaraka-quality planet sits in the 10th, supporting status and authority.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/0","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Jupiter is retrograde and in Enemy dignity in Virgo (/placements/Jupiter/dignity), so the 10th-house placement delivers with friction — delays, revisions, or working under conditions not fully one's own.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde"]},{"claim":"Mercury, lord of the 7th and 10th (career and public dealings), is placed in the 2nd house of wealth and speech — career tied to communication, commerce, finance, and income generation.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house"]},{"claim":"Ketu aspects the 10th house (/aspects/Ketu includes 10; /houses/9/aspectedBy), introducing detachment, unconventional paths, or periodic loss of interest in conventional authority structures.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/9/aspectedBy","/aspects/Ketu"]},{"claim":"D10 shows Saturn in own sign Capricorn in the D10 12th with Ketu — behind-the-scenes work, institutions, foreign or isolated settings, and disciplined but low-visibility roles; dispositor Saturn is natal 2nd/3rd lord in the 12th natally.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/6","/vargas/D10/lagnaSign","/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"claim":"D10 Jupiter in the 6th (Cancer) conjunct Rahu suggests service-oriented, competitive, possibly conflict-laden professional environments; Mercury in D10 11th (Sagittarius) supports gains through networks, analysis, trade.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/4","/vargas/D10/placements/3"]},{"claim":"Adhi Yoga from the Moon (benefics Venus and Mercury in 6th/7th/8th from Moon) supports overall rise, comfort and respect over the life course.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"Current Saturn mahadasha (2022–2041) runs Saturn–Mercury antardasha to Dec 2027: Saturn is 12th-house occupant and 2nd/3rd lord, Mercury is 10th lord — dasha lords connect career (Mercury) with expenditure/foreign/isolation themes (Saturn in 12th), indicating productive but demanding years.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current","/placements/Saturn/house","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"Saturn–Venus antardasha (Jan 2029 – Mar 2032) follows: Venus is 6th and 11th lord in the 2nd, supporting gains/income consolidation within service contexts.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/dasha/upcoming/1","/placements/Venus/house","/houses/5/lord"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"A 10th-house lagna lord does not guarantee eminence on its own; here it is tempered by Jupiter's enemy dignity, retrogression, and Ketu's aspect on the 10th, so the correct reading is 'strong career orientation with friction', not assured high office.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/houses/9/aspectedBy"]},{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Saturn's D10 12th-house placement should not be read as career failure; the 12th of the Dashamsa indicates work behind the scenes, in foreign lands, research, or institutional/isolation settings — Saturn being in own sign Capricorn there actually gives steady, disciplined output in such domains.","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/6","/vargas/D10/lagnaSign"]}],"missing_information":["Exact D10 ascendant lord strength / D10 10th house occupants are inferable from placements but no explicit D10 10th-lord analysis was supplied","No shadbala or vimshopaka strength scores to weigh Jupiter vs Saturn quantitatively","No birth-time rectification confirmation for a 3:33 AM lagna"],"rationale":"The chart shows a career-centred life: lagna lord Jupiter in the 10th forming a single-lordship Raja Yoga, with 10th lord Mercury in the wealth/speech house pointing to communication-, trade- or finance-linked work, reinforced by Adhi Yoga for eventual rise. These strengths are offset by Jupiter's retrograde enemy-dignity placement, Ketu's aspect on the 10th, and a D10 pattern (Saturn-Ketu in Capricorn 12th, Jupiter-Rahu in 6th) indicating behind-the-scenes, service-heavy or institutionally constrained roles rather than visible authority. The running Saturn mahadasha with Mercury antardasha (to Dec 2027) ties career activity to Saturn's 12th-house themes — demanding, lower-visibility, possibly foreign-connected — followed by the Venus antardasha (2029–2032) favouring income consolidation via Venus as 11th lord. Net assessment: mixed — solid career orientation and long-term rise, delivered through less glamorous channels than the 10th-house emphasis alone would suggest."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-synthesis-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.65,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Lagna lord Jupiter placed in the 10th house of career links self and life-direction directly to profession — a strong anchor for career significance.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/occupants\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter forms a Raja Yoga by ruling both a kendra (4th) and trikona (1st), and this yogakaraka-quality planet sits in the 10th, supporting status and authority.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter is retrograde and in Enemy dignity in Virgo (/placements/Jupiter/dignity), so the 10th-house placement delivers with friction — delays, revisions, or working under conditions not fully one's own.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury, lord of the 7th and 10th (career and public dealings), is placed in the 2nd house of wealth and speech — career tied to communication, commerce, finance, and income generation.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu aspects the 10th house (/aspects/Ketu includes 10; /houses/9/aspectedBy), introducing detachment, unconventional paths, or periodic loss of interest in conventional authority structures.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Ketu\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 shows Saturn in own sign Capricorn in the D10 12th with Ketu — behind-the-scenes work, institutions, foreign or isolated settings, and disciplined but low-visibility roles; dispositor Saturn is natal 2nd/3rd lord in the 12th natally.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/6\",\"/vargas/D10/lagnaSign\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Jupiter in the 6th (Cancer) conjunct Rahu suggests service-oriented, competitive, possibly conflict-laden professional environments; Mercury in D10 11th (Sagittarius) supports gains through networks, analysis, trade.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/4\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/3\"]},{\"claim\":\"Adhi Yoga from the Moon (benefics Venus and Mercury in 6th/7th/8th from Moon) supports overall rise, comfort and respect over the life course.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current Saturn mahadasha (2022–2041) runs Saturn–Mercury antardasha to Dec 2027: Saturn is 12th-house occupant and 2nd/3rd lord, Mercury is 10th lord — dasha lords connect career (Mercury) with expenditure/foreign/isolation themes (Saturn in 12th), indicating productive but demanding years.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn–Venus antardasha (Jan 2029 – Mar 2032) follows: Venus is 6th and 11th lord in the 2nd, supporting gains/income consolidation within service contexts.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/upcoming/1\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/houses/5/lord\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"A 10th-house lagna lord does not guarantee eminence on its own; here it is tempered by Jupiter's enemy dignity, retrogression, and Ketu's aspect on the 10th, so the correct reading is 'strong career orientation with friction', not assured high office.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/houses/9/aspectedBy\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Saturn's D10 12th-house placement should not be read as career failure; the 12th of the Dashamsa indicates work behind the scenes, in foreign lands, research, or institutional/isolation settings — Saturn being in own sign Capricorn there actually gives steady, disciplined output in such domains.\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/6\",\"/vargas/D10/lagnaSign\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"Exact D10 ascendant lord strength / D10 10th house occupants are inferable from placements but no explicit D10 10th-lord analysis was supplied\",\"No shadbala or vimshopaka strength scores to weigh Jupiter vs Saturn quantitatively\",\"No birth-time rectification confirmation for a 3:33 AM lagna\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart shows a career-centred life: lagna lord Jupiter in the 10th forming a single-lordship Raja Yoga, with 10th lord Mercury in the wealth/speech house pointing to communication-, trade- or finance-linked work, reinforced by Adhi Yoga for eventual rise. These strengths are offset by Jupiter's retrograde enemy-dignity placement, Ketu's aspect on the 10th, and a D10 pattern (Saturn-Ketu in Capricorn 12th, Jupiter-Rahu in 6th) indicating behind-the-scenes, service-heavy or institutionally constrained roles rather than visible authority. The running Saturn mahadasha with Mercury antardasha (to Dec 2027) ties career activity to Saturn's 12th-house themes — demanding, lower-visibility, possibly foreign-connected — followed by the Venus antardasha (2029–2032) favouring income consolidation via Venus as 11th lord. Net assessment: mixed — solid career orientation and long-term rise, delivered through less glamorous channels than the 10th-house emphasis alone would suggest.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-application-01-evidence-order","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":false,"error":"✖ Invalid input: expected number, received undefined\n  → at confidence","extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The ascendant lord (Sun) occupies the eleventh house of gains, which classical doctrine treats as supportive of earning capacity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Supporting context for gains: Venus, lord of the 10th, is also in the 11th with the Sun (Raja Yoga conjunction), and Mercury (2nd lord) sits in the 10th with its lord in the 11th — a strong income/career axis.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/4\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"'Guarantees enormous profits' overstates the rule; placement indicates supportive potential, not guaranteed magnitude of wealth. Ketu also sits in the 11th with these grahas and Kemadruma afflicts the Moon, tempering the indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Ketu/house\",\"/yogas/0\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"The ascendant lord in the 11th is not primarily a financial-loss indication; the 11th signifies gains (/houses/10/significations). Loss houses are the dusthanas (6, 8, 12), where the lagna lord does not sit.\",\"evidence\":[\"/reference/dusthanas\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Statement A correctly applies: the lagna lord Sun is placed in the 11th house of gains (/placements/Sun/house), classically read as favorable for earnings. B is an overclaim (no guarantee of magnitude), and C contradicts standard house significations. Hence only A applies and the polarity is supportive.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-application-01-paraphrase","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-01-paraphrase","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.95,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Ascendant lord Sun placed in the eleventh house of gains supports earning capacity and income (option A).","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house","/houses/10/significations"]},{"claim":"The ascendant lord's placement in the 11th does not guarantee enormous profits — a single placement cannot guarantee magnitude of outcome (option B is an overclaim).","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house"]},{"claim":"The same placement is not a financial-loss indication; the 11th signifies gains and fulfilment of desire (option C is contrary to chart facts).","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/reference/houseSignifications/11"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Lagna lord in the 11th supports gains but guarantees nothing about magnitude; other factors (e.g., Kemadruma Yoga from the Moon) temper the picture.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/yogas"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"factual","correction":"The 11th is the house of gains; lagna lord there is read as supportive of income, not loss.","evidence":["/reference/houseSignifications/11","/lagna/lordInHouse"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only option A is established by the chart: the Leo lagna's lord Sun sits in Gemini in the 11th house (/lagna/lordInHouse, /placements/Sun/house), the house of gains, alongside Venus (lord of 10) forming a raja yoga for income. Option B overclaims certainty/magnitude not warranted by any rule or chart fact, and option C contradicts the standard signification of the 11th house."},"extracted":"{\n  \"case_id\": \"wealth-application-01-paraphrase\",\n  \"domain\": \"wealth\",\n  \"conclusion\": \"supportive\",\n  \"confidence\": 0.95,\n  \"selected_option_ids\": [\"A\"],\n  \"factors\": [\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"Ascendant lord Sun placed in the eleventh house of gains supports earning capacity and income (option A).\",\n      \"effect\": \"supporting\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/lagna/lordInHouse\", \"/placements/Sun/house\", \"/houses/10/significations\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"The ascendant lord's placement in the 11th does not guarantee enormous profits — a single placement cannot guarantee magnitude of outcome (option B is an overclaim).\",\n      \"effect\": \"neutral\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Sun/house\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"claim\": \"The same placement is not a financial-loss indication; the 11th signifies gains and fulfilment of desire (option C is contrary to chart facts).\",\n      \"effect\": \"neutral\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/reference/houseSignifications/11\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"contradictions\": [\n    {\n      \"statement_id\": \"B\",\n      \"error_type\": \"overclaim\",\n      \"correction\": \"Lagna lord in the 11th supports gains but guarantees nothing about magnitude; other factors (e.g., Kemadruma Yoga from the Moon) temper the picture.\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/placements/Sun/house\", \"/yogas\"]\n    },\n    {\n      \"statement_id\": \"C\",\n      \"error_type\": \"factual\",\n      \"correction\": \"The 11th is the house of gains; lagna lord there is read as supportive of income, not loss.\",\n      \"evidence\": [\"/reference/houseSignifications/11\", \"/lagna/lordInHouse\"]\n    }\n  ],\n  \"missing_information\": [],\n  \"rationale\": \"Only option A is established by the chart: the Leo lagna's lord Sun sits in Gemini in the 11th house (/lagna/lordInHouse, /placements/Sun/house), the house of gains, alongside Venus (lord of 10) forming a raja yoga for income. Option B overclaims certainty/magnitude not warranted by any rule or chart fact, and option C contradicts the standard signification of the 11th house.\"\n}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-application-01-evidence-order","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-01-evidence-order","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The ascendant lord (Sun) is placed in the 11th house of gains, supporting earning capacity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house","/houses/10/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Placement in the 11th supports gains but does not guarantee enormous profits; no rule guarantees magnitude of wealth from this placement alone.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The 11th is a house of gains and income, not primarily a financial-loss indication; the loss house is the 12th.","evidence":["/houses/10/significations","/reference/houseSignifications"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Statement A is established: the lagna lord Sun occupies the natal 11th (gains/income), a classically supportive placement for earnings. Statement B overclaims certainty/magnitude; statement C contradicts standard signification of the 11th. Only A applies, so conclusion polarity is supportive."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.9,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The ascendant lord (Sun) is placed in the 11th house of gains, supporting earning capacity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Placement in the 11th supports gains but does not guarantee enormous profits; no rule guarantees magnitude of wealth from this placement alone.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The 11th is a house of gains and income, not primarily a financial-loss indication; the loss house is the 12th.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/significations\",\"/reference/houseSignifications\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Statement A is established: the lagna lord Sun occupies the natal 11th (gains/income), a classically supportive placement for earnings. Statement B overclaims certainty/magnitude; statement C contradicts standard signification of the 11th. Only A applies, so conclusion polarity is supportive.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-application-01-evidence-order","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-01-evidence-order","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The ascendant lord (Sun, Leo lagna) is placed in the 11th house of gains and income, a classically supportive placement for earning capacity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house","/houses/10"]},{"claim":"Supporting the gains theme, Mercury (2nd lord of wealth) sits in the 11th, linking wealth to income networks; Venus (10th lord) also joins Sun in the 11th forming a raja-yoga conjunction relevant to status-based gains.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Venus/house","/yogas/4"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"'Guarantees enormous profits' is an absolute outcome claim; classical rules indicate support for gains, not guaranteed magnitude. The 11th also holds Ketu with the Sun-Venus conjunction aspected by Rahu/Moon, so gains indications are mixed in quality, not guaranteed.","evidence":["/placements/Ketu/house","/aspects/Rahu","/aspects/Moon"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"There is no doctrinal basis for treating the ascendant lord in the 11th as primarily a financial-loss indication; the 11th signifies gains (/reference/houseSignifications/11).","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/reference/houseSignifications/11"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only statement A is established: the lagna lord Sun occupies the natal 11th house of gains, which is traditionally read as supportive of earning capacity. Statement B overclaims by guaranteeing outcomes, and statement C contradicts standard doctrine. Hence conclusion polarity follows the single applicable statement A: supportive."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.9,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The ascendant lord (Sun, Leo lagna) is placed in the 11th house of gains and income, a classically supportive placement for earning capacity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/10\"]},{\"claim\":\"Supporting the gains theme, Mercury (2nd lord of wealth) sits in the 11th, linking wealth to income networks; Venus (10th lord) also joins Sun in the 11th forming a raja-yoga conjunction relevant to status-based gains.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/yogas/4\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"'Guarantees enormous profits' is an absolute outcome claim; classical rules indicate support for gains, not guaranteed magnitude. The 11th also holds Ketu with the Sun-Venus conjunction aspected by Rahu/Moon, so gains indications are mixed in quality, not guaranteed.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Ketu/house\",\"/aspects/Rahu\",\"/aspects/Moon\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"There is no doctrinal basis for treating the ascendant lord in the 11th as primarily a financial-loss indication; the 11th signifies gains (/reference/houseSignifications/11).\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/11\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only statement A is established: the lagna lord Sun occupies the natal 11th house of gains, which is traditionally read as supportive of earning capacity. Statement B overclaims by guaranteeing outcomes, and statement C contradicts standard doctrine. Hence conclusion polarity follows the single applicable statement A: supportive.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-01-paraphrase","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-01-paraphrase","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.75,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Strong Dhana Yogas: Jupiter (lord of 2 and 11) conjunct Saturn (lagna lord) in the 11th house of gains, with Jupiter in Moolatrikona in its own sign","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/3","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Raja Yoga: Venus rules both the 4th (kendra) and 9th (trikona) and sits in its own sign Libra in the 9th, conjunct Mercury — a classic wealth-and-fortune combination","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/0","/yogas/1","/placements/Venus/dignity","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"claim":"Adhi Yoga from the Moon — benefics Jupiter, Venus, Mercury in the 6th/7th/8th from an exalted Moon — indicates prosperity and comfort","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/5","/placements/Moon/dignity"]},{"claim":"Exalted Moon in the 4th aspects the 10th, supporting steady income through career/public standing","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/aspects/Moon"]},{"claim":"Current Mercury mahadasha (2018–2035) runs a yogakaraka-type benefic placed in the 9th Raja Yoga conjunction, favorable for gains; Mercury–Jupiter period (2030–2032) activates the Dhana Yoga directly","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord","/placements/Mercury/house","/dasha/upcoming/2"]},{"claim":"2nd lord Jupiter well-placed but the 8th house (Sun there) is aspected by Mars and Saturn, indicating sudden expenses or transformation-linked financial events","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/houses/7/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Mars in enemy sign in the 5th (speculation) aspects the 11th and 12th — caution against speculative losses and elevated expenditure","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Mars/house","/aspects/Mars"]},{"claim":"Mercury–Mars antardasha (2026–2027) brings a malefic in enemy dignity into play during the gains-oriented mahadasha, suggesting volatile income phases","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/dasha/upcoming/0","/placements/Mars/dignity"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart carries unusually strong wealth combinations: two Dhana Yogas via Jupiter-Saturn in the 11th, a kendra-trikona Raja Yoga through Venus in its own 9th with Mercury, and Adhi Yoga on an exalted Moon. The main cautions come from Mars (enemy sign, aspecting 11th/12th) affecting speculation and expenditure, and 8th-house afflictions to the Sun. Overall conclusion is supportive, with volatility expected around the Mercury–Mars antardasha and stronger consolidation likely in Mercury–Jupiter (2030–2032)."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-synthesis-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.75,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Strong Dhana Yogas: Jupiter (lord of 2 and 11) conjunct Saturn (lagna lord) in the 11th house of gains, with Jupiter in Moolatrikona in its own sign\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/3\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Raja Yoga: Venus rules both the 4th (kendra) and 9th (trikona) and sits in its own sign Libra in the 9th, conjunct Mercury — a classic wealth-and-fortune combination\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0\",\"/yogas/1\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Adhi Yoga from the Moon — benefics Jupiter, Venus, Mercury in the 6th/7th/8th from an exalted Moon — indicates prosperity and comfort\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/5\",\"/placements/Moon/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Exalted Moon in the 4th aspects the 10th, supporting steady income through career/public standing\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/aspects/Moon\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current Mercury mahadasha (2018–2035) runs a yogakaraka-type benefic placed in the 9th Raja Yoga conjunction, favorable for gains; Mercury–Jupiter period (2030–2032) activates the Dhana Yoga directly\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/dasha/upcoming/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"2nd lord Jupiter well-placed but the 8th house (Sun there) is aspected by Mars and Saturn, indicating sudden expenses or transformation-linked financial events\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/7/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars in enemy sign in the 5th (speculation) aspects the 11th and 12th — caution against speculative losses and elevated expenditure\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/aspects/Mars\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury–Mars antardasha (2026–2027) brings a malefic in enemy dignity into play during the gains-oriented mahadasha, suggesting volatile income phases\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/upcoming/0\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart carries unusually strong wealth combinations: two Dhana Yogas via Jupiter-Saturn in the 11th, a kendra-trikona Raja Yoga through Venus in its own 9th with Mercury, and Adhi Yoga on an exalted Moon. The main cautions come from Mars (enemy sign, aspecting 11th/12th) affecting speculation and expenditure, and 8th-house afflictions to the Sun. Overall conclusion is supportive, with volatility expected around the Mercury–Mars antardasha and stronger consolidation likely in Mercury–Jupiter (2030–2032).\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-01-paraphrase","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":false,"error":"✖ Invalid input: expected string, received undefined\n  → at rationale","extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-synthesis-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.7,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Strong dhana yogas: Jupiter (lord of 2 and 11) conjunct Saturn (lagna lord) in the 11th house of gains, directly linking wealth, income and self.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/3\",\"/yogas/4\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Raja yoga from Venus ruling both 4th (kendra) and 9th (trikona) as a single lord, placed in its own sign Libra in the 9th with Mercury — a powerful lakshmi-flavored fortune combination.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus–Mercury conjunction in house 9 forms a Raja yoga (4th lord + 5th lord), supporting fortune, learning-based income and accumulated resources.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0\"]},{\"claim\":\"Adhi Yoga — benefics Jupiter, Venus, Mercury in 6th/7th/8th from the Moon — classically indicates prosperity and comfort.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/5\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars–Saturn mutual aspect (10th lord + lagna lord) is a raja yoga supporting career-driven earnings.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/2\",\"/aspects/Saturn\"]},{\"claim\":\"Exalted Moon in the 4th aspecting the 10th supports contentment, property and stable livelihood.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/dignity\",\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/aspects/Moon\"]},{\"claim\":\"2nd lord Jupiter in Moolatrikona in the 11th is strong for savings and fulfilment of desires.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/houses/11/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Sun in the 8th (a dusthana) aspected by Mars and Saturn can bring sudden disruptions to shared resources or inheritance matters.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/8/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars, a malefic in enemy sign Gemini in the 5th, aspects houses 8, 11 and 12, adding volatility and expenditure pressure on gains and losses.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/aspects/Mars\"]},{\"claim\":\"Rahu in the 7th (trade/partnerships) in enemy Leo suggests instability or unconventional dealings in partnership-based income.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current Mercury mahadasha (2018–2035): Mercury rules the 5th and 8th and sits in the 9th with Venus — largely fortunate for wealth, though its 8th lordship ties gains to sudden events; Moon antardasha (to Jul 2026) has exalted Moon ruling the 6th, mixed for finances.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord\",\"tool:dasha_at#0/natalPlacementsOfTheseLords\"],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart shows genuinely strong wealth combinations — multiple dhana and raja yogas anchored on the 11th-house Jupiter-Saturn conjunction and the Venus-Mercury pair in the 9th — offset by dusthana placements (Sun in 8th), a malefic Mars influencing gains/losses houses, and Rahu in the 7th affecting partnerships. Net reading: solid earning capacity and accumulation potential with periodic volatility, especially through partnerships and sudden events. Confidence moderate because no birth-time rectification or divisional confirmation beyond D1/D9 was applied.\"}]}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-01-paraphrase","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-01-paraphrase","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.7,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Strong Dhana Yogas: Jupiter (lord of 2 and 11) conjunct Saturn (lagna lord) in the 11th house of gains, with Jupiter in Moolatrikona in its own sign","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/3","/yogas/4","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Raja Yoga: Venus rules both the 4th (kendra) and 9th (trikona) and sits in its own sign Libra in the 9th — a Lakshmi-sthana placement favoring fortune and accumulated wealth","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/1","/placements/Venus/sign","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"claim":"Additional Raja Yoga: Venus (4th lord) conjunct Mercury (5th lord) in house 9 links kendra-trikona lords for prosperity","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/0"]},{"claim":"Adhi Yoga from the Moon — benefics Jupiter, Venus and Mercury occupy the 6th, 7th or 8th from the exalted Moon — classically indicates comfort and affluence","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/5","/placements/Moon/dignity"]},{"claim":"Mars–Saturn Raja Yoga (10th lord and lagna lord mutual aspect) supports earning capacity through career/status","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/2","/houses/9/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Current Mercury mahadasha activates the 2nd-lord/8th-lord Mercury placed in the 9th with Venus — dasha lord is well-placed for wealth during 2018–2035","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/dignity"]},{"claim":"Mercury–Moon antardasha (2025-02 to 2026-07): Moon is exalted in the 4th as 6th lord; gains are likely but with expenses tied to home/family matters","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current/antardasha","/placements/Moon/house","/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"Upcoming Mercury–Rahu (2027–2030): Rahu sits in the 7th in enemy dignity; partnerships and contracts could bring volatile or irregular financial outcomes","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/dasha/upcoming/2","/placements/Rahu/dignity","/placements/Rahu/house"]},{"claim":"Sun in the 8th (as 7th lord) suggests income via spouse/partnership channels may involve sudden events or inheritance rather than steady flow; the 8th also receives aspects of Mars and Saturn","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/houses/7/aspectedBy","/houses/8/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Lagna lord Saturn in the 11th supports gains but Saturn is neutral and Mars (a malefic) also aspects the 11th — gains may come slowly or after effort","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/houses/10/aspectedBy"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart carries multiple classical wealth yogas centered on the 9th and 11th houses: a strong Dhana Yoga (Jupiter-Saturn in the 11th), two Raja Yogas involving Venus and one linking Mars-Saturn, plus Adhi Yoga from an exalted Moon. The running Mercury mahadasha places a dignified 2nd/8th lord in the 9th at the helm, which favors wealth accumulation through 2035. Challenges are moderate rather than structural: Rahu in the 7th threatens volatility in the Mercury-Rahu antardasha (2027–2030), the Sun's 8th-house placement makes partnership-linked income uneven, and Mars' aspect on the 11th implies effortful rather than effortless gains. Overall conclusion: supportive, with timing-dependent fluctuations."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-synthesis-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.7,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Strong Dhana Yogas: Jupiter (lord of 2 and 11) conjunct Saturn (lagna lord) in the 11th house of gains, with Jupiter in Moolatrikona in its own sign\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/3\",\"/yogas/4\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Raja Yoga: Venus rules both the 4th (kendra) and 9th (trikona) and sits in its own sign Libra in the 9th — a Lakshmi-sthana placement favoring fortune and accumulated wealth\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\",\"/placements/Venus/sign\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Additional Raja Yoga: Venus (4th lord) conjunct Mercury (5th lord) in house 9 links kendra-trikona lords for prosperity\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0\"]},{\"claim\":\"Adhi Yoga from the Moon — benefics Jupiter, Venus and Mercury occupy the 6th, 7th or 8th from the exalted Moon — classically indicates comfort and affluence\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/5\",\"/placements/Moon/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars–Saturn Raja Yoga (10th lord and lagna lord mutual aspect) supports earning capacity through career/status\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/2\",\"/houses/9/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current Mercury mahadasha activates the 2nd-lord/8th-lord Mercury placed in the 9th with Venus — dasha lord is well-placed for wealth during 2018–2035\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury–Moon antardasha (2025-02 to 2026-07): Moon is exalted in the 4th as 6th lord; gains are likely but with expenses tied to home/family matters\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/antardasha\",\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"Upcoming Mercury–Rahu (2027–2030): Rahu sits in the 7th in enemy dignity; partnerships and contracts could bring volatile or irregular financial outcomes\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/upcoming/2\",\"/placements/Rahu/dignity\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Sun in the 8th (as 7th lord) suggests income via spouse/partnership channels may involve sudden events or inheritance rather than steady flow; the 8th also receives aspects of Mars and Saturn\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/7/aspectedBy\",\"/houses/8/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"Lagna lord Saturn in the 11th supports gains but Saturn is neutral and Mars (a malefic) also aspects the 11th — gains may come slowly or after effort\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/houses/10/aspectedBy\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart carries multiple classical wealth yogas centered on the 9th and 11th houses: a strong Dhana Yoga (Jupiter-Saturn in the 11th), two Raja Yogas involving Venus and one linking Mars-Saturn, plus Adhi Yoga from an exalted Moon. The running Mercury mahadasha places a dignified 2nd/8th lord in the 9th at the helm, which favors wealth accumulation through 2035. Challenges are moderate rather than structural: Rahu in the 7th threatens volatility in the Mercury-Rahu antardasha (2027–2030), the Sun's 8th-house placement makes partnership-linked income uneven, and Mars' aspect on the 11th implies effortful rather than effortless gains. Overall conclusion: supportive, with timing-dependent fluctuations.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-application-02-counterfactual","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-02-counterfactual","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"rationale":"The chart facts show the FIRST lord (Venus) placed in the SECOND house (/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse = 2), not the second lord in the first. Statements A-C all concern the second lord in the first, which is not what this chart shows; therefore none of A-C is established by the stated rule and chart."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-02-counterfactual\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"confidence\":0.9,\"rationale\":\"The chart facts show the FIRST lord (Venus) placed in the SECOND house (/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse = 2), not the second lord in the first. Statements A-C all concern the second lord in the first, which is not what this chart shows; therefore none of A-C is established by the stated rule and chart.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-01-evidence-order","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-01-evidence-order","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.72,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Strong dhana yoga: Jupiter (lord of both 2nd and 11th) conjunct lagna-lord Saturn in the 11th house of gains — gains tied directly to self-effort and sustained accumulation.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/3","/yogas/4","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"claim":"11th lord Jupiter placed in its own sign/house (Sagittarius, moolatrikona) strengthens income networks and fulfilment of desires.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"Raja yoga of Venus (4th & 9th lord) conjunct Mercury (5th lord) in the 9th house of fortune — luck, dharma-linked prosperity, and the current mahadasha lord (Mercury) sits inside this yoga, activating it through 2035.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/0","/yogas/1","/dasha/current/mahadasha","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"claim":"Exalted Moon in the 4th aspecting the 10th supports property/assets and stable career-based earnings; Adhi Yoga (benefics 6th/7th/8th from Moon) indicates comfort and wealth.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Moon/dignity","/aspects/Moon","/yogas/5"]},{"claim":"Mars (10th lord) aspects the 11th and 12th houses — energetic pursuit of gains but also pressure toward expenditure and impulsive financial decisions.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/aspects/Mars","/houses/11/significations","/houses/12/significations"]},{"claim":"Sun in the 8th (a dusthana) as 7th lord suggests partnership/contract-related volatility affecting finances; Rahu in the 7th reinforces irregularity in partnerships/trade.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Rahu/house"]},{"claim":"Timing: Mercury mahadasha (2018–2035) runs the fortune-yoga lord; current Mercury–Moon antardasha (to 2026-07-29) links income to assets/home; subsequent Mercury–Rahu (from 2027-07-27) and Mercury–Saturn (2032–2035) periods bring higher-gain but more volatile phases given Rahu/Saturn placements.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha","/dasha/upcoming"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"omission","correction":"The strong dhana yogas are partially offset by dusthana placement of the 7th lord (Sun in 8th) and Mars's aspect on the 12th; a synthesis citing only the yogas would overstate unqualified prosperity.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/aspects/Mars"]}],"missing_information":["Navamsa dignity confirmation for Jupiter and Saturn beyond D9 sign listing (D9 shows Jupiter in Taurus/8th, Saturn in Virgo/12th — vargottama status not flagged)","Exact degrees of any applying/separating conjunction between Jupiter and Saturn within the 11th (both present at /placements/Jupiter and /placements/Saturn)","Second-house occupancy/aspects detail relevant to savings flow (house 2 empty, only Sun's aspect noted)"],"rationale":"Wealth indications are net supportive: a direct 2nd/11th-lord + lagna-lord dhana yoga in the 11th, an activated Venus–Mercury raja yoga in the 9th whose lord rules the running Mercury mahadasha, and an exalted Moon supporting asset base. Offsets are partnership volatility (Sun in 8th as 7th lord, Rahu in 7th) and Mars aspects on 11th/12th indicating gain-expenditure swings. Conclusion: supportive overall, with volatility around Mercury–Rahu (2027–2030) and Mercury–Saturn (2032–2035) sub-periods."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-synthesis-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.72,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Strong dhana yoga: Jupiter (lord of both 2nd and 11th) conjunct lagna-lord Saturn in the 11th house of gains — gains tied directly to self-effort and sustained accumulation.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/3\",\"/yogas/4\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"11th lord Jupiter placed in its own sign/house (Sagittarius, moolatrikona) strengthens income networks and fulfilment of desires.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"Raja yoga of Venus (4th & 9th lord) conjunct Mercury (5th lord) in the 9th house of fortune — luck, dharma-linked prosperity, and the current mahadasha lord (Mercury) sits inside this yoga, activating it through 2035.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0\",\"/yogas/1\",\"/dasha/current/mahadasha\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Exalted Moon in the 4th aspecting the 10th supports property/assets and stable career-based earnings; Adhi Yoga (benefics 6th/7th/8th from Moon) indicates comfort and wealth.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/dignity\",\"/aspects/Moon\",\"/yogas/5\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars (10th lord) aspects the 11th and 12th houses — energetic pursuit of gains but also pressure toward expenditure and impulsive financial decisions.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/houses/11/significations\",\"/houses/12/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Sun in the 8th (a dusthana) as 7th lord suggests partnership/contract-related volatility affecting finances; Rahu in the 7th reinforces irregularity in partnerships/trade.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Timing: Mercury mahadasha (2018–2035) runs the fortune-yoga lord; current Mercury–Moon antardasha (to 2026-07-29) links income to assets/home; subsequent Mercury–Rahu (from 2027-07-27) and Mercury–Saturn (2032–2035) periods bring higher-gain but more volatile phases given Rahu/Saturn placements.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/mahadasha\",\"/dasha/upcoming\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"omission\",\"correction\":\"The strong dhana yogas are partially offset by dusthana placement of the 7th lord (Sun in 8th) and Mars's aspect on the 12th; a synthesis citing only the yogas would overstate unqualified prosperity.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/aspects/Mars\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"Navamsa dignity confirmation for Jupiter and Saturn beyond D9 sign listing (D9 shows Jupiter in Taurus/8th, Saturn in Virgo/12th — vargottama status not flagged)\",\"Exact degrees of any applying/separating conjunction between Jupiter and Saturn within the 11th (both present at /placements/Jupiter and /placements/Saturn)\",\"Second-house occupancy/aspects detail relevant to savings flow (house 2 empty, only Sun's aspect noted)\"],\"rationale\":\"Wealth indications are net supportive: a direct 2nd/11th-lord + lagna-lord dhana yoga in the 11th, an activated Venus–Mercury raja yoga in the 9th whose lord rules the running Mercury mahadasha, and an exalted Moon supporting asset base. Offsets are partnership volatility (Sun in 8th as 7th lord, Rahu in 7th) and Mars aspects on 11th/12th indicating gain-expenditure swings. Conclusion: supportive overall, with volatility around Mercury–Rahu (2027–2030) and Mercury–Saturn (2032–2035) sub-periods.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-01-evidence-order","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-01-evidence-order","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.72,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Dhana Yoga: Jupiter (2nd & 11th lord) conjunct lagna lord Saturn in the 11th house of gains — a strong, doubly-validated wealth combination in its own house","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/3","/yogas/4","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"claim":"Jupiter is in Moolatrikona (Sagittarius), strengthening the dhana yoga; Jupiter aspects the 5th (speculation) and 7th (trade)","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/aspects/Jupiter"]},{"claim":"Raja Yoga: Venus (4th & 9th lord) and Mercury (5th lord) conjunct in the 9th house of fortune — Venus in own sign Libra, indicating wealth via dharma, higher learning, fortune","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/0","/placements/Venus/dignity","/houses/9"]},{"claim":"Adhi Yoga — Jupiter, Venus, Mercury in 6th/7th/8th from Moon — a classical prosperity combination","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/5"]},{"claim":"Current Mercury mahadasha (2018–2035) runs a 9th-lord dasha lord placed with yogakaraka-like Venus in the 9th; Mercury–Jupiter antardasha (2030–2032) activates the Dhana yoga directly","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha","/dasha/upcoming/2"]},{"claim":"Transit Jupiter retrograde in natal 5th (Gemini) aspecting houses 1, 9, 11 supports gains flows as of reference date","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/transits/contacts/4"]},{"claim":"Mars, karaka of drive but placed in enemy sign in the 5th (speculation) and aspecting 8th, 11th, 12th, can bring speculative losses and expenditure pressure on gains","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mars/dignity","/aspects/Mars"]},{"claim":"Saturn (lagna lord) in Purva Ashadha under Venus nakshatra is neutral in dignity and hemmed by Mars/Rahu influences on the 11th (Mars aspects 11th, Rahu aspects 11th), tempering gain stability","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/dignity","/houses/11/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"12th lord Saturn placed in 11th links income to expenditure channels; gains may flow through foreign/isolation-related or service contexts","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/12/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"omission","correction":"The strong Dhana yogas are partially offset by malefic influence on the 11th house (Mars and Rahu aspects per /houses/11/aspectedBy); a synthesis citing only yogas would overstate the promise.","evidence":["/houses/11/aspectedBy","/placements/Mars/dignity"]}],"missing_information":["Exact strength/vimshopaka bala values for Jupiter and Saturn","Natal Moon sign gochara confirmation of sade sati status beyond snapshot (currently SaturnFromMoon = 11, so no sade sati)","Arudha and argala computations not provided"],"rationale":"Wealth indications are strongly supportive at their core: a double-anchored Dhana Yoga (Jupiter as 2nd+11th lord conjunct lagna lord Saturn in the 11th itself, /yogas/3,/yogas/4) plus a Raja Yoga of Venus+Mercury in the fortunate 9th (/yogas/0) and Adhi Yoga (/yogas/5). The running Mercury mahadasha (a 9th-house occupant and 5th lord, /dasha/current/mahadasha) keeps these combinations active through 2035, with Mercury–Jupiter (2030–2032) the peak activation window (/dasha/upcoming/2). Friction points: Mars in enemy dignity in the 5th aspecting the 11th introduces speculation/expenditure risk (/placements/Mars/dignity,/aspects/Mars), and 12th lordship of Saturn ties income streams to outflow channels. Net reading: supportive, with discipline needed around speculative ventures and expense management."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-synthesis-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.72,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Dhana Yoga: Jupiter (2nd & 11th lord) conjunct lagna lord Saturn in the 11th house of gains — a strong, doubly-validated wealth combination in its own house\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/3\",\"/yogas/4\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter is in Moolatrikona (Sagittarius), strengthening the dhana yoga; Jupiter aspects the 5th (speculation) and 7th (trade)\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/aspects/Jupiter\"]},{\"claim\":\"Raja Yoga: Venus (4th & 9th lord) and Mercury (5th lord) conjunct in the 9th house of fortune — Venus in own sign Libra, indicating wealth via dharma, higher learning, fortune\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/houses/9\"]},{\"claim\":\"Adhi Yoga — Jupiter, Venus, Mercury in 6th/7th/8th from Moon — a classical prosperity combination\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/5\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current Mercury mahadasha (2018–2035) runs a 9th-lord dasha lord placed with yogakaraka-like Venus in the 9th; Mercury–Jupiter antardasha (2030–2032) activates the Dhana yoga directly\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/mahadasha\",\"/dasha/upcoming/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"Transit Jupiter retrograde in natal 5th (Gemini) aspecting houses 1, 9, 11 supports gains flows as of reference date\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/transits/contacts/4\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars, karaka of drive but placed in enemy sign in the 5th (speculation) and aspecting 8th, 11th, 12th, can bring speculative losses and expenditure pressure on gains\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/aspects/Mars\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn (lagna lord) in Purva Ashadha under Venus nakshatra is neutral in dignity and hemmed by Mars/Rahu influences on the 11th (Mars aspects 11th, Rahu aspects 11th), tempering gain stability\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/houses/11/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"12th lord Saturn placed in 11th links income to expenditure channels; gains may flow through foreign/isolation-related or service contexts\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/12/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"omission\",\"correction\":\"The strong Dhana yogas are partially offset by malefic influence on the 11th house (Mars and Rahu aspects per /houses/11/aspectedBy); a synthesis citing only yogas would overstate the promise.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/11/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"Exact strength/vimshopaka bala values for Jupiter and Saturn\",\"Natal Moon sign gochara confirmation of sade sati status beyond snapshot (currently SaturnFromMoon = 11, so no sade sati)\",\"Arudha and argala computations not provided\"],\"rationale\":\"Wealth indications are strongly supportive at their core: a double-anchored Dhana Yoga (Jupiter as 2nd+11th lord conjunct lagna lord Saturn in the 11th itself, /yogas/3,/yogas/4) plus a Raja Yoga of Venus+Mercury in the fortunate 9th (/yogas/0) and Adhi Yoga (/yogas/5). The running Mercury mahadasha (a 9th-house occupant and 5th lord, /dasha/current/mahadasha) keeps these combinations active through 2035, with Mercury–Jupiter (2030–2032) the peak activation window (/dasha/upcoming/2). Friction points: Mars in enemy dignity in the 5th aspecting the 11th introduces speculation/expenditure risk (/placements/Mars/dignity,/aspects/Mars), and 12th lordship of Saturn ties income streams to outflow channels. Net reading: supportive, with discipline needed around speculative ventures and expense management.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-application-02-counterfactual","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-02-counterfactual","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"rationale":"The chart facts show the first lord (Venus) placed in the second house (/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse = 2), which is the reverse of the configuration described in statements A-C (second lord in the first). No chart fact establishes a second-lord-in-first placement, so none of A-C is applicable; D is selected."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-02-counterfactual\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"confidence\":0.9,\"rationale\":\"The chart facts show the first lord (Venus) placed in the second house (/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse = 2), which is the reverse of the configuration described in statements A-C (second lord in the first). No chart fact establishes a second-lord-in-first placement, so none of A-C is applicable; D is selected.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-01-evidence-order","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-01-evidence-order","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.75,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Dhana Yoga: Jupiter (2nd and 11th lord) conjunct Saturn in the 11th house of gains — a direct, double wealth combination placed in the house it signifies","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/3","/yogas/4","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"claim":"Jupiter is in Moolatrikona (Sagittarius), strengthening the Dhana Yoga; Saturn is the lagna lord disposited by Jupiter, tying self to gains","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"Raja Yoga: Venus (4th and 9th lord) conjunct Mercury (5th lord) in the 9th — fortune through trine lords, supporting prosperity via dharma, higher learning, luck","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/0","/placements/Venus/sign","/placements/Mercury/house"]},{"claim":"Venus in own sign Libra in the 9th is strong; Mercury in Swati (Rahu's nakshatra) links wealth to Rahu-flavoured/networked means","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Venus/dignity","/placements/Mercury/nakshatraLord"]},{"claim":"Adhi Yoga from Moon: benefics Jupiter, Venus, Mercury occupy the 6th/7th/8th from natal Moon — a classical prosperity/lordliness yoga","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/5"]},{"claim":"Moon exalted in Taurus in the 4th aspects the 10th — comfort, property, and career-linked affluence","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Moon/dignity","/aspects/Moon","/houses/9/significations"]},{"claim":"Mars (10th lord) in enemy sign Gemini in the 5th, aspecting houses 8, 11 and 12 — earnings come with effort, speculation risk, expenditure and exposure to sudden/8th-house matters; Mars also aspects the Dhana Yoga cluster in the 11th, energising but agitating it","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Mars/house","/aspects/Mars"]},{"claim":"Sun (7th lord) debilitated-adjacent placement in Virgo in the 8th — partnership/trade income can be unstable or tied to others' resources, inheritance, or transformation events","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/dignity","/houses/7/significations"]},{"claim":"Rahu in the 7th aspected by transiting nodes; Ketu on lagna — partnership dealings need care, though this is more trade than accumulation per se","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/placements/Rahu/house","/placements/Ketu/house"]},{"claim":"Current Mercury mahadasha (to Jan 2035): Mercury is a 5th-lord Raja-Yoga partner in the 9th in Swati — dasha of a wealth-supportive graha. Mercury–Moon (to Jul 2026), then Mercury–Mars (mixed, Mars is 10th lord in enemy sign), Mercury–Rahu (2027–2030, volatile gains), Mercury–Jupiter (2030–2032, peak for the Dhana Yoga since Jupiter is its key planet), Mercury–Saturn (2032–2035)","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha","/dasha/upcoming","/placements/Mercury/house"]},{"claim":"Transits as of 2026-01-01: transit Jupiter retrograde in natal 5th conjunct natal Mars, aspecting natal 1st/9th/11th — supports the gains axis; transit Saturn in Pisces in natal 2nd (wealth house) aspects natal 4/8/11 — consolidating pressure on finances with discipline required","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/transits/contacts/4","/transits/contacts/6"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"omission","correction":"A synthesis citing only the Dhana Yogas would overstate ease; Mars's 12th-house aspect and Sun in the 8th indicate leakage and dependency on others' money that must be reconciled against the strong yogas.","evidence":["/aspects/Mars","/placements/Sun/house"]}],"missing_information":["Navamsa strength of Jupiter/Saturn relative to D1 (D9 shows Jupiter in 8th of navamsa, Venus in 8th — some inner weakening of yoga planets worth weighing)","Ashtakavarga bindus for houses 2 and 11 to grade promise magnitude","Specific question timeframe (accumulation vs income vs inheritance)"],"rationale":"Wealth promise is genuinely strong: a double Dhana Yoga (2nd+11th lord Jupiter with lagna lord Saturn in the 11th), a Venus–Mercury Raja Yoga in the 9th with Venus in own sign, exalted Moon aspecting the 10th, and Adhi Yoga from the Moon. The current Mercury mahadasha runs a Raja-Yoga partner well-placed in the 9th until early 2035, with Mercury–Jupiter (2030–2032) the strongest sub-period for gains. Offsetting factors are Mars (10th lord) in an enemy sign aspecting the 12th, and Sun (7th lord) in the 8th — indicating effortful earnings, expenditure leaks, and instability in trade/partnership income rather than weak overall capacity. Net reading: supportive, with volatility around partnerships and speculative ventures."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-synthesis-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.75,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Dhana Yoga: Jupiter (2nd and 11th lord) conjunct Saturn in the 11th house of gains — a direct, double wealth combination placed in the house it signifies\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/3\",\"/yogas/4\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter is in Moolatrikona (Sagittarius), strengthening the Dhana Yoga; Saturn is the lagna lord disposited by Jupiter, tying self to gains\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"Raja Yoga: Venus (4th and 9th lord) conjunct Mercury (5th lord) in the 9th — fortune through trine lords, supporting prosperity via dharma, higher learning, luck\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0\",\"/placements/Venus/sign\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus in own sign Libra in the 9th is strong; Mercury in Swati (Rahu's nakshatra) links wealth to Rahu-flavoured/networked means\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/placements/Mercury/nakshatraLord\"]},{\"claim\":\"Adhi Yoga from Moon: benefics Jupiter, Venus, Mercury occupy the 6th/7th/8th from natal Moon — a classical prosperity/lordliness yoga\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/5\"]},{\"claim\":\"Moon exalted in Taurus in the 4th aspects the 10th — comfort, property, and career-linked affluence\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/dignity\",\"/aspects/Moon\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars (10th lord) in enemy sign Gemini in the 5th, aspecting houses 8, 11 and 12 — earnings come with effort, speculation risk, expenditure and exposure to sudden/8th-house matters; Mars also aspects the Dhana Yoga cluster in the 11th, energising but agitating it\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/aspects/Mars\"]},{\"claim\":\"Sun (7th lord) debilitated-adjacent placement in Virgo in the 8th — partnership/trade income can be unstable or tied to others' resources, inheritance, or transformation events\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Sun/dignity\",\"/houses/7/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Rahu in the 7th aspected by transiting nodes; Ketu on lagna — partnership dealings need care, though this is more trade than accumulation per se\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/placements/Ketu/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Current Mercury mahadasha (to Jan 2035): Mercury is a 5th-lord Raja-Yoga partner in the 9th in Swati — dasha of a wealth-supportive graha. Mercury–Moon (to Jul 2026), then Mercury–Mars (mixed, Mars is 10th lord in enemy sign), Mercury–Rahu (2027–2030, volatile gains), Mercury–Jupiter (2030–2032, peak for the Dhana Yoga since Jupiter is its key planet), Mercury–Saturn (2032–2035)\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/mahadasha\",\"/dasha/upcoming\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Transits as of 2026-01-01: transit Jupiter retrograde in natal 5th conjunct natal Mars, aspecting natal 1st/9th/11th — supports the gains axis; transit Saturn in Pisces in natal 2nd (wealth house) aspects natal 4/8/11 — consolidating pressure on finances with discipline required\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/transits/contacts/4\",\"/transits/contacts/6\"],\"note\":\"Saturn transiting 2nd is not sade-sati (saturnFromMoon=11).\"}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"omission\",\"correction\":\"A synthesis citing only the Dhana Yogas would overstate ease; Mars's 12th-house aspect and Sun in the 8th indicate leakage and dependency on others' money that must be reconciled against the strong yogas.\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"Navamsa strength of Jupiter/Saturn relative to D1 (D9 shows Jupiter in 8th of navamsa, Venus in 8th — some inner weakening of yoga planets worth weighing)\",\"Ashtakavarga bindus for houses 2 and 11 to grade promise magnitude\",\"Specific question timeframe (accumulation vs income vs inheritance)\"],\"rationale\":\"Wealth promise is genuinely strong: a double Dhana Yoga (2nd+11th lord Jupiter with lagna lord Saturn in the 11th), a Venus–Mercury Raja Yoga in the 9th with Venus in own sign, exalted Moon aspecting the 10th, and Adhi Yoga from the Moon. The current Mercury mahadasha runs a Raja-Yoga partner well-placed in the 9th until early 2035, with Mercury–Jupiter (2030–2032) the strongest sub-period for gains. Offsetting factors are Mars (10th lord) in an enemy sign aspecting the 12th, and Sun (7th lord) in the 8th — indicating effortful earnings, expenditure leaks, and instability in trade/partnership income rather than weak overall capacity. Net reading: supportive, with volatility around partnerships and speculative ventures.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"ox-alpha","caseId":"wealth-application-02-counterfactual","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-02-counterfactual","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"rationale":"The chart facts show the FIRST lord (Venus) placed in the SECOND house (/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse), not the second lord in the first. Statements A-C all concern a 'second lord in the first' configuration, which is not present; therefore none is established, and D applies."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-02-counterfactual\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"confidence\":0.9,\"rationale\":\"The chart facts show the FIRST lord (Venus) placed in the SECOND house (/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse), not the second lord in the first. Statements A-C all concern a 'second lord in the first' configuration, which is not present; therefore none is established, and D applies.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"pilot-cheap-20260824-c6"}